User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
For those against full respecs in a BETA GAME, can I ask why? If our goal is to BETA TEST the game, why would it make any sense at all to deny the testers the periodic use of this fundamental testing tool?

It's almost like you guys are complaining because it will make it harder for you to win games. Which is odd, because this is a BETA GAME, and the goal is to test the game, not to win games.

Right?
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.


Exactly...I truly doubt GLB will ever be "live" without the BETA tag...This game will be ever changing and that is why they have left the BETA tag on.


For those of you that want full respecs I think you should start to pick your battles a bit better. Obviously you are not going to get a full respec...so instead of wasting time arguing about it over and over try to get a 80-90% respec or something a bit less drastic than a 100% respec and maybe Bort and the others will work with you.

You have to find some sort of middle ground. You knew it was a BETA when you decided to spend cash on it. They never made an agreement to allow any respecs. At this point if they allow you anything more than the FPs for retiring they have already done more than they agreed to...

Do I like that idea? No. But it is the way the world works. Bort has spent your money on servers and up keep costs and cannot afford to give you 100% respecs because then you will not need to pay him for a long time. If he gives you a 80-90% respec then he has a better shot at getting more cash out of you sooner...


I don't like that idea either but he is in business to make money. Sure he wants to make a great game people love to play but he also has to keep the lights on and electricity going into the servers or there will be no GLB.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.


I think someone wasn't following along with thread.

I was attempting to show the inconsistency of the "STOP COMPLAINING, BECAUSE WE ARE BETA TESTING" crowd, which is also the "OMG!!! NO FULL RESPECS!!!!" crowd.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
For those of you that want full respecs I think you should start to pick your battles a bit better. Obviously you are not going to get a full respec...so instead of wasting time arguing about it over and over try to get a 80-90% respec or something a bit less drastic than a 100% respec and maybe Bort and the others will work with you.


I don't need any respecs, since I'm not spending any time trying to test the game. I'm trying to win games, and my roster is built for that already.

The issue is what Bort can do to really make a push towards stability and growth. He's going about it in the wrong way. My guess is that his methodology worked fine in January. But now, with thousands of leagues and many thousands of paying customers, it is no longer practical.

I've tried to patiently explain a simple method for Bort to correct this, but it's fallen on deaf or ignorant ears. Use testers to test, and let the paying players play. It's not complicated.

I would be more than happy to help Bort actually test his game. But not with the team that we are paying $200 every 45 days for.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.


So when something isn't working and you fix it, do you screw over those dedicated players who paid you money to conform to the old rules? Or do you graciously allow them to change along with the game?
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9

I would be more than happy to help Bort actually test his game. But not with the team that we are paying $200 every 45 days for.


It only costs like $4 to pay for a team each month...
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by Zadith

For those of you that want full respecs I think you should start to pick your battles a bit better. Obviously you are not going to get a full respec...so instead of wasting time arguing about it over and over try to get a 80-90% respec or something a bit less drastic than a 100% respec and maybe Bort and the others will work with you.


I don't need any respecs, since I'm not spending any time trying to test the game. I'm trying to win games, and my roster is built for that already.

The issue is what Bort can do to really make a push towards stability and growth. He's going about it in the wrong way. My guess is that his methodology worked fine in January. But now, with thousands of leagues and many thousands of paying customers, it is no longer practical.

I've tried to patiently explain a simple method for Bort to correct this, but it's fallen on deaf or ignorant ears. Use testers to test, and let the paying players play. It's not complicated.

I would be more than happy to help Bort actually test his game. But not with the team that we are paying $200 every 45 days for.




I have to agree with you there. That is why I have been trying to play devil's advocate here. I agree with you that those offering up good suggestions are for the most part, being completely ignored.

I think it would help if they had some mods that did not openly join in on the flame posts that naturally follow suggestion threads on these forums.

I have seen mods openly call people idiots or tell them their idea was worthless when really all that was needed was a few changes to the original idea and then the suggest was actually a worthwhile investment.

Perhaps they need Mods that do nothing but watch the suggestion forum and help keep useless posts deleted and flamers out of that forum...

I do not know what the selection process for mods is but perhaps it needs to be reworked. Are the mods just friends of Borts? I know many of them do their jobs well but some do not do them as well as they should..


Back in January running GLB as a very casual business was fine. However now they have thousands of players and many of them are paying customers. GLB needs to make a move from less casual and more into a real business if they plan to stick around. And part of that is treating their customers better and providing better tech and customer support. Both with fresh updates and bug fixes and professional Mods that have separate accounts to play on.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 12:06:53
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greenday4537
Originally posted by RunningMn9


I would be more than happy to help Bort actually test his game. But not with the team that we are paying $200 every 45 days for.


It only costs like $4 to pay for a team each month...


See my 'fun with math' notes:

Originally posted by

Now, we know not everyone is boosting. But lets look at the income potential.

Offense: 4xOT, 4xG, 2xC, 2xQB, 2xHB, 2xFB, 2xTE, 6xWR = 24 players.
Defense: 4xDT, 4xDE, 7xLB, 7xCB, 2xFS, 2xSS = 26 Players
ST: 1xK, 1xP = 2 Players

52 Player Roster.

FP's to boost those folks each season (not including buying custom equipment, paying for the team every two seasons, etc) @30,000

Cost in $ for 30,000 FP's = $180.00

@ 130 leagues * two conferences * 16 teams = 4160 teams.

4160 teams boosting 100% = $748,800.00 every 45 days or so.

Even at 25% boosting, thats $187,000 every 45 days or so, not counting custom equipment and team ownership fees and friendly game fees and various other things that are being made to eat up FP's.

This isn't a 'Beta' game anymore.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.


So when something isn't working and you fix it, do you screw over those dedicated players who paid you money to conform to the old rules? Or do you graciously allow them to change along with the game?


It's not screwing, it's revenge for game exploitation. The game wasn't meant to have defenses that have a higher number in their Level than they do in Tackling, wasn't meant to have 90 speed run by everybody forever, wasn't meant to have 80 strength make you an unstoppable blocker...the list goes on.

If you built the right way for the game then you're fine NOW. If you build based on flaws in the sim equations, you get what you deserve: a handful of time where you're really good, and then the flaw is corrected and you're shown to be a one-hit wonder.
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
alot of good points in this thread
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Originally posted by Greenday4537

Originally posted by RunningMn9



I would be more than happy to help Bort actually test his game. But not with the team that we are paying $200 every 45 days for.


It only costs like $4 to pay for a team each month...


See my 'fun with math' notes:

Originally posted by




Now, we know not everyone is boosting. But lets look at the income potential.

Offense: 4xOT, 4xG, 2xC, 2xQB, 2xHB, 2xFB, 2xTE, 6xWR = 24 players.
Defense: 4xDT, 4xDE, 7xLB, 7xCB, 2xFS, 2xSS = 26 Players
ST: 1xK, 1xP = 2 Players

52 Player Roster.

FP's to boost those folks each season (not including buying custom equipment, paying for the team every two seasons, etc) @30,000

Cost in $ for 30,000 FP's = $180.00

@ 130 leagues * two conferences * 16 teams = 4160 teams.

4160 teams boosting 100% = $748,800.00 every 45 days or so.

Even at 25% boosting, thats $187,000 every 45 days or so, not counting custom equipment and team ownership fees and friendly game fees and various other things that are being made to eat up FP's.

This isn't a 'Beta' game anymore.


+1

Last edited Aug 14, 2008 13:37:10
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Fun with math:
How much of that money was required to be spent?
5000 teams * $8.50 per team for the 1000 flex = $42,500 over the entire life of the game thus far.

Nobody made you boost. Nobody made you buy custom equipment. Nobody made people extend team ownership, or buy flex to get more players. People CHOSE to do it, and just because they did doesn't change the status of this game.

Can you go to a store that's half-built, give the contractor building the joint $200k and seriously expect them to declare the store open for business, disregarding the fact that the store isn't done...just because you paid them a lot of money towards the building?
 
Mike544612
offline
Link
 
Im just glad I didnt listen to anybody and built my players to help my team win. And when they arent on that team anymore I try and find a team that needs my niche. Just like in business find your niche. Seems that alot of people forget that Football is the ultimate team game. You need everyone to give 100%. Who cares about player stats, builds, cash. What matters is that little Icon at the top of your screen that says Champ Whatever Leauge Season Whatever. Thats the only thing that matters.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 13:42:42
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by Jose Bagg


Wrong. This is beta, but it is a functional and competitive beta. Many users pay money to "test" this game. If it was true beta, we would all play for free and get to respec all we want. Then when the game went live, we would all have to pay to play. The game is only Beta because it is not perfect yet and the Beta tag gives them something to point at when people complain about the game not working.


So when something isn't working and you fix it, do you screw over those dedicated players who paid you money to conform to the old rules? Or do you graciously allow them to change along with the game?


It's not screwing, it's revenge for game exploitation. The game wasn't meant to have defenses that have a higher number in their Level than they do in Tackling, wasn't meant to have 90 speed run by everybody forever, wasn't meant to have 80 strength make you an unstoppable blocker...the list goes on.

If you built the right way for the game then you're fine NOW. If you build based on flaws in the sim equations, you get what you deserve: a handful of time where you're really good, and then the flaw is corrected and you're shown to be a one-hit wonder.


Thanks Bort, but revenge on customers isn't exactly good business. If someone were smart it wouldn't be too hard to run this game out of business with a better product for far less money.

Think about it. Bort is changing this game and not letting his beta testers change along with it without spending even more money.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.