User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
burn_209
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
I REALLY hope when Im up there meeting the big man he doesnt say the Mormons were right. I was hoping to drink Jack Daniels with Frank Sinatra and if the Mormons are right thats out the window.


Yea I always wanted to meet Frank Sinatra haha
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by cheese12

The mass executions of Muslims back in the crusades narrow minded.

Things happen during times of war. The so-called "crusades" were in many ways a reaction to the spread of Islam. Were you to study the history of the spread of Islam, you would find that it was spread by the sword and not by convincing oration. That doesn't make everything that the "Christians" did ok--again, it merely provides as a broader context for what took place.


false. the arabian expansion was more or less complete by 750CE... the first crusade was over three centuries later. further, the impetus of the crusades was to defend byzantium from the turks, not the arabs.

a few other points:
- war crimes are war crimes... the vast majority of the victims of the jerusalem massacre were unarmed civilians who hadn't participated in battle (including women, children, etc).
- the crusades were "so-called" because that's what the crusaders called them.
- were you to study history, you would find that most of the reportage about muslim conversion was grossly exaggerated by christian authors. further, the vast majority of the lands were not converted at all... the arabs were vastly outnumbered and didn't push it.
- and yes, there were some fanatical tribes that went a bit too far. i'm not defending that, but keep in mind that every major religion has had its share of such fanatics... and it doesn't work for christians to disavow their fanatics as non-christian but then pretend that muslim fanatics are somehow constitutive of islam.
- interesting that you used "by the sword" reminds me of matthew 10:34

by and large, i would say that the arab expansion was far more peaceful than, say, the catholic (i.e. nicean/chalcedonian) conquest of the arian christians of northern europe... good ol' charlemagne certainly did a number on saxony.
 
Link
 
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.

I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:

1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.

And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".

In summary, your disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.

Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:38:48
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by cheese12

The Muslims were killed in their own land...

And they obtained "their own land" through...public auction? A late night real estate course on how to buy it with no money down?

They acquired it by the sword.


so... which way do you want it? are you saying they converted people or not? can't have it both ways...
 
burn_209
offline
Link
 
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by burn_209
I feel that you should not force your religion and say that if you dont believe in god you are going to hell. Only god has the ability to determine who goes to hevean or hell. Its not for us to make that assumption. Now like I said earlier I believe that no one is wrong and no one is right when it comes to religion because no one TRUELY KNOWS. I believe in god but I dont not TRUELY know what is on the other side yet because I have not passed on. I'm Catholic and when I die and meet God and he says the Mormons were right. Do I think that I'm going to hell? NO. Because all the different fractions of christianity are all based around the same principals and ideas with just a couple minor tweaks here and there.



I'm rushed for time, but suffice it to say that some of the "tweaks" could be classified as more than merely "minor".
 
burn_209
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I'm going to be leaving soon and will be out for much (all?) of the weekend. But before I go, I'd like to leave the atheists with one thought--and please feel free to consider this thought without any pretense that I've triple-dog-dared you to reply, because I'm not doing that at all.

I find it rather amusing that those that claim to have so many problems with Christianity RACE to see who among them can do the best job defending Islam. It is a FACT that in Islamic-governed countries that:

1) Most don't allow women to vote;
2) Most don't allow women to run for office;
3) Many don't allow women to drive;
4) Most don't allow non-Muslims to vote;
5) Most don't allow non-Muslims to run for office;
6) Homosexuality is a serious legal offense;
7) The freedom to assemble is not guaranteed;
8) Freedom of speech is not guaranteed;
9) Speaking ill of Islam or Mohammed is a serious legal offense;
10) Freedom of the press is not guaranteed.

And yet those 10 issues are not nearly the issue in countries where the government/governed are predominately "Christian".

In summary, you're disgust for Christianity you have no problem expressing--but you almost embrace a religion (Islam) that has demonstrated in Islamic-governed country after Islamic-governed country that you as an atheist would be treated HORRIFICALLY were you to take your beliefs and attempt to live them there.

Perhaps some perspective is in order. If your atheism causes you to be alarmed with certain aspects of Christianity, perhaps those same alarm bells should sound when the topic of Islam appears. You could then claim, at the least, consistency in regard to what troubles you with religion and its intrusion into your secular life.


WOW thats a hell of a point.
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
I swear to fuck I saw what that guy just wrote on Bill O'Reilly last week.

On the topic of which - how does he get away with the stuff he comes out with? If he said that stuff over here hed be off the airwaves in about five minutes. Ohh my bad his networks an arm of the Republican party.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by cheese12
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by cheese12

Islam is one of the most peaceful religons in the world.

Sorry, but you couldn't be more wrong.

Oh shit buddy oh shit you ever read the Qur'an buddy? It's a really peaceful religion same as christianity in many ways, yes they've done some bad things in the past just as the christians have but the fundamentals of both religions are the same

The quran is chock full of hateful charges--charges that have never been trumped by a "New Testament" that rewrites the earlier passages. You can pretend otherwise, but it doesn't change the facts any.


maybe i should quote matthew 10:34 again. here are the words of jesus:
"Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword."

now. i realize that there are a ton of ways to interpret that verse... and christians have been wildly successful at positioning that verse as non-violent. but: you must grant that muslims are thus allowed to do the exact same with their so-called "hateful charges".

just because you might be a self-styled expert on how to interpret the bible doesn't mean you automatically know how to correspondingly interpret the qur'an.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by burn_209
There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.



Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"
 
kenja
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by JocularFX

Originally posted by colonelghost


Originally posted by atom871



Originally posted by Darkus Black




The baby Jesus knows the good that people do and will not send the decent people to hell because they choose a different path. Luckily for me I do not believe in hell either - one of the joys of being a true atheist. You should all try it.



I tried it for seventeen years, most of my adult life. It's broken, wrong and leads to a lot of unnecessary pain. Repent and believe now brother.


I will never believe in any religious text because science keeps making you look foolish.


you don't technically have to believe in any religious text. Its just stories that help you go through life I guess... Its like a story with morale that relates to everyday living.



Parables are impossible for atheists to understand.



Thats why Catholics go to church and when the Priest have their time to talk, they break the Parables/Gospel down, so the congregation could understand and follow/obey.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

No, you've helped me establish that nothing about "The Crusades" was as shocking as folks wish to pretend that it was. Thanks.


doesn't make it right. like hume said, you can't derive an "ought" from an "is". and if we're making sweeping moral statements here, it's all within our purview.

further, how can you possibly excuse christian atrocities as not shocking while at the same time condemning muslims for the past actions of some islamic arabs?
 
burn_209
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by burn_209

There are different type of Muslims. All the terrorists and Al'Queda are Muslim FUNDAMENTALISTS. They believe the Q'ran Word for Word no exeptions. The regular muslims are as normal as me and you.



Go read my list again (10 issues found in any Islamic-governed country) and give me the exception to that list. When you give up and can't find one (others have tried), ask yourself "Why would such a allegedly peaceful religion have not a single place on the globe where women are treated as equals, where the right to assembly, speech and press is absolute, where the right to question Mohammed and Islam exists, and where folks can decide for themselves whom they may have sex with?"


Because it is what they believe in and that is what it says in the Q'uran. Like I said I'm catholic but especially in the middle east most governments are ruled by fundamentalists
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
I think youll find that the nation of Kosovo in eastern europe is a predominantly Islamic state where all of those things either exist already or will exist when they elect their first proper parliament. Albania should be there soon as well actually.
Last edited Aug 8, 2008 16:42:06
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


No, you've helped me establish that nothing about "The Crusades" was as shocking as folks wish to pretend that it was. Thanks.


doesn't make it right. like hume said, you can't derive an "ought" from an "is". and if we're making sweeping moral statements here, it's all within our purview.

further, how can you possibly excuse christian atrocities as not shocking while at the same time condemning muslims for the past actions of some islamic arabs?


I would never attempt to "justify" them--I was speaking merely of historical perspective.

Further, the state of life in the year 2008 for folks living in Islamic-governed countries contrasts sharply with those of secular and/or "Christian" countries in the year 2008. I think that's telling in many ways--much more so than what did or didn't take place 800 years ago.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.