Originally posted by chronoaug The problem is that once again Bort (and in this case Catch22) are trying to make a bunch of rules to fix a sort of exploit. It's almost impossible to do that and also still allow paying customers freedom and also competitive players a chance to better their odds of winning. What Bort and Catch22 should be doing instead is addressing the reasons people have to go to such drastic lengths to do these "exploits" (farm teams, cash teams, mergers, etc...) and fix those instead.
Part of it is Bort swallowing pride and admitting he made a mistake in season 1 with the money and equipment system. That he intended to make money more useful and that he never actually did the math and figured out how money would look in the game after 15 seasons of teams with various records and then throw in decline into the mix. He fucked up and now backtracks and blatantly lies to the customers by saying this was intended. Obviously it wasn't which is why all the media revenue was just tacked on (something people had to take advantage of by moving to a pro league then gutting because the system is terrible). This isn't an added wrinkle or strategy, it's just stress and pain in the ass and one of the reasons there's such a drastic separation between good and bad teams.
2 things would eliminate such a need for farm teams and cash teams and honestly wouldn't affect the game at all or the delicate sim
1- One extra season of plateau: You wouldn't need as many farm teams, teams wouldn't gut as much because they wouldn't have to recruit 30+ players every offseason (which becomes impossible for middle of the road teams), teams wouldn't need to merge, and 1season really wouldn't effect the power balance and all that kinda stuff.
If anything it would create more parity because the best teams won't be the ones with a ton of farm teams and merger participants who can afford to have all dots in their peak seasons lvl 68-73 who can just bring in a whole wave of 30-40 more peak dominant dots. They have a huge advantage over normal teams who have a mixture of dots between lvl 57-73 on their team in order to battle plateau/decline so they only have to recruit 15 people a season.
2- Get rid of money all together: Honestly, why not? Everybody is a paying customer so it's unfair that someone on a good but not elite team will not be able to be on the same playing field as player on a team who gets home playoff games. It's not a strategy like bort claims. The only strategy is to win more and get more home playoff games. That hardly sounds like a strategy. Bort originally wanted more fun stuff to do with team and player money but never got around to it because he was busy with the sim. I understand that so just swallow your pride, cut your losses and bring back money when you actually think it through.
The reason people are stressing, making cash teams, farm teams, etc... isn't fun. They don't enjoy doing that. It's also not part of the "strategy of the game" and even Bort never intended that. It's just a side effect of a game creator who never really thought things further than a season or two ahead and now a lot of problems are happening as a result.
Originally posted by MonkeyMan Originally posted by PierreThomas
Hey Bort and Catch, do you know why people slow build?
They slow build because BORT, not the players, came up with the idea of auto leveling gains which benefits players to build a set way in order to maximize points. Your customers don't want to pay $10 a year to have a player that is better than average in a high league next January. Unfortunately you Bort set the game up this way.
Do you know why teams merge?
They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging. Team owners don't want to start a team build it up for 10 seasons with loyal agents they become friends with and then combine their baby with another team just to cut loose half the agents that got them to the spot they were at but they just realize it becomes a necessity.
Do you know why people shell out 400 flex a season to own a farm team or cash team?
They set up farm teams because Bort made equipment too expensive and didn't have the foresight to see that the way equipment is set up a team has to have home field advantage in the playoffs just about every season. Teams that don't get this can't fully upgrade equipment and can't lure free agents to the team and in the teams 10th season they may be being punished for something that happened in season 5. This sets up unbalanced play and teams quickly scramble to find other ways to level the playing field. This game isn't the NFL but you can blow smoke up everyone's ass and try to claim it isn't based on professional football because the last time I checked college players don't have contracts. Every NFL team is on an equal playing field with finances every season. In fact, the teams that spend less and lose one season typically have more to spend the next. This system is so bad it is like it was created with one too many chromosomes.
This new rule isn't going to keep teams and agents from abusing cash, you are just simply making it harder and more time consuming which in the end is the reason people are leaving the game faster than they are coming in.
I would have loved this rule 8 seasons ago when the first collusion was going on instead of waiting 8 seasons to put your foot down and going back trying to penalize teams that are no longer competitive.
So the next time I get a player stuck on a bad team owner that promises equipment but doesn't deliver and when he becomes available he needs about 6.8 million to get equipment fully upgraded and he can't find a way to get that taken care of guess what I'm going to do? Retire him
Guess what is going to happen with the cash teams that are out there you are collecting 400 flex a season on? Sold back.
There is nothing worse in this game than slow building a player up for 8 seasons to finally have him ready to compete at a high level just to have the sim change completely away from the vision of your player. We now can't afford to switch equipment and your customer has thrown $40-100 down the drain because of your poor foresight. What should we do with these players? Would you suggest retiring them or the agent just losing interest in the game and quitting because these are the only two options you leave the agent with.
This announcement is going to cause chaos. I know that my teams little move this season caused plenty of crying but we didn't steal money from my team before leaving, we spent it all trying to get fully equipped for the playoffs before even deciding it. Sad that a USA Pro team that has won multiple trophies along the way with an elaborate farm system and took a season off to rent players off for max cash raising over $75 million still wasn't fully equipped but it just goes to show how fucked up the financial part of this game is.
So what are you going to be doing about the teams that dropped down and started over with huge bank accounts prior to this announcement that will have a massive advantage on everyone else when they reach the top levels of the game in a few seasons?
Think before you act for christ's sake!
Ultimately do you know why I rented off my entire team in season 9? Do you know why I merged with the Blaze? Do you know why we've set up such an elaborate farm system? We did this to try and level the playing field with teams that used the playoff ticket sale glitch back in season 3 to create hundreds of millions in additional revenue. I raised hell about this yet you ignored it allowing them to keep the money and giving them a HUGE financial advantage season after season. Are you going to penalize them too if any of them are still around and haven't quit the game by now?
Amazing post... I couldnt havesaid it better myself.. as always... great post PT.. you.. hopefully are revolutionizing GLB the way it should be
+1 Pierre always seems to hit the nail right on the head!
So you’ll spend all this time going through every fucking team in the game to see who gave away equip money that’s terribly over priced but you won’t go through all the teams in the preseason and manually move teams around to leagues they should be in to make the game better? OK that makes sense…
Originally posted by Sean Payton I suggested this before or something similar, but I don't think it ever grew legs. Every team from every level of football has an equipment room. The same should be here in GLB.
Each team should have an equipment room and the team owns the regular equipment. As the team gets better and can upgrade the equipment then the equipment gets upgraded. When the player signs with the team he can then "use" that equipment while he is on the team. Having an equipment room would allow teams to change from game to game if they have multiple sets of EQ. The EQ would be upgraded by the same levels so a piece can be upgraded to LVL64, but if the player is LVL48 and has it equipped it would only be worth +7 just like LVL48 EQ.
AEQ should probably just stay with the player since it was rolled for that particular player. A team can pay for this player to upgrade his AEQ if they want, like an incentive for that player to sign, etc.
This is just a rough idea, but I think y'all get the point. The EQ should just stay with the team and the players move from team to team with only their AEQ.
BTW, I also like the idea of Captain's EQ that was suggested on a previous page.
Originally posted by chronoaug The problem is that once again Bort (and in this case Catch22) are trying to make a bunch of rules to fix a sort of exploit. It's almost impossible to do that and also still allow paying customers freedom and also competitive players a chance to better their odds of winning. What Bort and Catch22 should be doing instead is addressing the reasons people have to go to such drastic lengths to do these "exploits" (farm teams, cash teams, mergers, etc...) and fix those instead.
Part of it is Bort swallowing pride and admitting he made a mistake in season 1 with the money and equipment system. That he intended to make money more useful and that he never actually did the math and figured out how money would look in the game after 15 seasons of teams with various records and then throw in decline into the mix. He fucked up and now backtracks and blatantly lies to the customers by saying this was intended. Obviously it wasn't which is why all the media revenue was just tacked on (something people had to take advantage of by moving to a pro league then gutting because the system is terrible). This isn't an added wrinkle or strategy, it's just stress and pain in the ass and one of the reasons there's such a drastic separation between good and bad teams.
2 things would eliminate such a need for farm teams and cash teams and honestly wouldn't affect the game at all or the delicate sim
1- One extra season of plateau: You wouldn't need as many farm teams, teams wouldn't gut as much because they wouldn't have to recruit 30+ players every offseason (which becomes impossible for middle of the road teams), teams wouldn't need to merge, and 1season really wouldn't effect the power balance and all that kinda stuff.
If anything it would create more parity because the best teams won't be the ones with a ton of farm teams and merger participants who can afford to have all dots in their peak seasons lvl 68-73 who can just bring in a whole wave of 30-40 more peak dominant dots. They have a huge advantage over normal teams who have a mixture of dots between lvl 57-73 on their team in order to battle plateau/decline so they only have to recruit 15 people a season.
2- Get rid of money all together: Honestly, why not? Everybody is a paying customer so it's unfair that someone on a good but not elite team will not be able to be on the same playing field as player on a team who gets home playoff games. It's not a strategy like bort claims. The only strategy is to win more and get more home playoff games. That hardly sounds like a strategy. Bort originally wanted more fun stuff to do with team and player money but never got around to it because he was busy with the sim. I understand that so just swallow your pride, cut your losses and bring back money when you actually think it through.
The reason people are stressing, making cash teams, farm teams, etc... isn't fun. They don't enjoy doing that. It's also not part of the "strategy of the game" and even Bort never intended that. It's just a side effect of a game creator who never really thought things further than a season or two ahead and now a lot of problems are happening as a result.
Good post! I like the idea of no money, i am here for football strategy and to control a team of dots through a good game plan. Money is just a part of the game that takes away from the experience that i am after, if winning is based on who can afford equipment and not who can out game plan the other guy then what is the point.
would a thread really be a thread without a jdbolick facepalm? Ball lick, your whole life is a facepalm... pretty sure that instead of cuddling afterwards, on the night of your conception your parents both rolled away from each other and facepalmed...
Originally posted by jktooley would a thread really be a thread without a jdbolick facepalm? Ball lick, your whole life is a facepalm... pretty sure that instead of cuddling afterwards, on the night of your conception your parents both rolled away from each other and facepalmed...
Damn don't get him started, I actually was awaiting him quoting pierres post as he picked apart how silly hazy has been in all of this... Stay focused jd, ignore tooley until you get what needs addressing outta tha way