User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.


There will be exploits REGARDLESS of what is done -- its a game, and people will continue to crunch numbers and figure out what gives them the best odds of success.

While I agree with you that letting people choose their majors and minors would basically end up with cookie cutter majors and minors, opening up all SA's and allowing players to choose their trees would end up with less cookie cutter builds and more specialization among players.

You can still have the 4 SA's involved in the archetype -- the 2 with the bonus, and the 2 with the negative, must be at the start of the trees, for example. But for the final 3 on the tree, you allow players to make their own choices -- maybe the 3 and 4 spots on the tree come from a certain group of SA's, and the 5-spot (which costs more) has a different group of SA's.

And you can have these parts of the tree appear after certain level achievements ala player development, learning new skills, etc.

To me, while this update is interesting, it lacks the punch of allowing true build creativity and as long as the trees remain static, cookie cutters will reign.
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
I just don't believe this change "breaks" a player who has already been made.

I'm not smart enough to show that with actual math - but I don't believe the fact that your majors/minors (ie - auto level gains) change when you're ~level 14 - will break your player...

Depending on your build plan - it just isn't going to have an enormous impact.



The difference (as explained by a few) is that the s12-s14 created player is getting points put into meaningless attributes for his first season (e.g. a HB getting points put into throwing) ... whereas, the S15 player will not.

Thus, eventually the s12-s14 built players will definitely have a mark against them (i.e. considered "bad" builds ... not efficient).
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by nixa37

How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.


There will be exploits REGARDLESS of what is done -- its a game, and people will continue to crunch numbers and figure out what gives them the best odds of success.

While I agree with you that letting people choose their majors and minors would basically end up with cookie cutter majors and minors, opening up all SA's and allowing players to choose their trees would end up with less cookie cutter builds and more specialization among players.

You can still have the 4 SA's involved in the archetype -- the 2 with the bonus, and the 2 with the negative, must be at the start of the trees, for example. But for the final 3 on the tree, you allow players to make their own choices -- maybe the 3 and 4 spots on the tree come from a certain group of SA's, and the 5-spot (which costs more) has a different group of SA's.

And you can have these parts of the tree appear after certain level achievements ala player development, learning new skills, etc.

To me, while this update is interesting, it lacks the punch of allowing true build creativity and as long as the trees remain static, cookie cutters will reign.


Pretty much what I was saying , building my own player means just that. It we are only allowed to do what's there then that's all EVERYONE is going to do , nothing changes imo.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
Pretty much what I was saying , building my own player means just that. If we are only allowed to do what's there then that's all EVERYONE is going to do , nothing changes imo.


Yep...the static trees are probably the most frustrating part of player building (outside of FB's not getting gains in SPD and other amusing things like that)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
what would be the advantage of 2 seasons notice instead of 1 season notice? (this change is slated to go into effect in ~40 days)



I understand people get uncomfortable with change - especially when they have dollars invested (in the form of flex) - but I think once the details of this are fully absorbed by everyone - the vast majority of people will be pleased with the change - and the vast, vast majority will feel like they've gotten a very fair shake here.


I am definitely giving my gut reaction here, I am not going to pretend that I am not, lol. I guess the advantage would be an extra season to decide what to do when the system is implemented...and beyond that, why wouldn't they give us an extra season. I think I have earned that as a consumer, I mean, I've been here since season 2 and this is probably one of the biggest changes I've seen. I think the motivation for LESS THAN 40 days of notice is money driven, b/c no one is going to build players if there is a whole new feature coming out.

It is what it is, it just bums me out--seriously, 8 new players, all between 3-4 seasons old...
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by F8n4tune

Pretty much what I was saying , building my own player means just that. If we are only allowed to do what's there then that's all EVERYONE is going to do , nothing changes imo.


Yep...the static trees are probably the most frustrating part of player building (outside of FB's not getting gains in SPD and other amusing things like that)


While I understand what everyone is saying I just don't get how no one see's this point ? This is just a different colored shirt , more dressy but the same shirt none the less. It will still be , you build this and win because that's what everyone else is doing , that's not a change. I'm just unclear on why this is any different to what we have been doing for 14 seasons besides the better ALG's ?
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sborats

The difference (as explained by a few) is that the s12-s14 created player is getting points put into meaningless attributes for his first season (e.g. a HB getting points put into throwing) ... whereas, the S15 player will not.

Thus, eventually the s12-s14 built players will definitely have a mark against them (i.e. considered "bad" builds ... not efficient).


I see your point - and again - would love to know the actual numbers here (what are we talking about? a handful of points in throwing? instead of agility?)

Yes - those S12-S14 players will no longer be built perfect; optimal; etc (compared with S15 builds)...

but they will have a large level advantage over S15 players.

So - compare a S12 player to a S15 player after season 25 - and yes - there will be differences...

But compare them in Season 20 - and the S12 player will still play a significant role in the game - be needed - be wanted - be good - etc - etc - etc
 
reginator
offline
Link
 
Has anyone explained why Special Team only players are limited to FB, TE, and defensive players?

I assume its because those players all cost 200 flex and OL guys only cost 100 and if given that choice everyone would just stack their ST with only OL guys. I'd prefer another explanation though rather than to assume its just about $$$$.

Getting the speed or tackling autolevel gains on a center thats already been created to play STO would be really nice. If all the other players can suddenly get the attribute gains of a center why can't a center also be entitled to some of the autolevel gains of defensive player?
 
Link
 
3-4 points becomes significant at a later level. Building players is an art that people try to do as efficiently as possible. A lot of people don't want to be at ANY disadvantage even if its a small one just because they built their player a season or two before.

Is this change really worth it when the same thing is already naturally accomplished by AEQ and how you train and place your SPs?
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
3-4 points becomes significant at a later level. Building players is an art that people try to do as efficiently as possible. A lot of people don't want to be at ANY disadvantage even if its a small one just because they built their player a season or two before.

Is this change really worth it when the same thing is already naturally accomplished by AEQ and how you train and place your SPs?


sure - 3-4 points might be significant at a later level - but for the people wanting to compare a S15 player to a 12 player...IN SEASON 20....those 3-4 points will make no difference. The S12 player will have 3 more seasons of VA points lined up (and access to an extra equipment upgrade)
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
While I understand what everyone is saying I just don't get how no one see's this point ? This is just a different colored shirt , more dressy but the same shirt none the less. It will still be , you build this and win because that's what everyone else is doing , that's not a change. I'm just unclear on why this is any different to what we have been doing for 14 seasons besides the better ALG's ?


How naive are you guys? Do you really think there won't be a "best way" to build with completely customizable SA trees if there's a best way to build based on the new ALG's? Do you really think that not allowing player's to choose the most dominant combination of majors/minors (and therefore forcing them to decide which are the most important majors and minors for what they want to do) is going to lead to less diversity in builds? Do you really believe there will be one best archetype and one best way to build that archetype for each position? Regardless of how said player will be used?

For the love of God, there won't even necessarily be a best way to build any particular archetype, let alone a most dominant archetype at every single position.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
How naive are you guys? Do you really think there won't be a "best way" to build with completely customizable SA trees if there's a best way to build based on the new ALG's? Do you really think that not allowing player's to choose the most dominant combination of majors/minors (and therefore forcing them to decide which are the most important majors and minors for what they want to do) is going to lead to less diversity in builds? Do you really believe there will be one best archetype and one best way to build that archetype for each position? Regardless of how said player will be used?

For the love of God, there won't even necessarily be a best way to build any particular archetype, let alone a most dominant archetype at every single position.


So...what is your argument?
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
3-4 points becomes significant at a later level. Building players is an art that people try to do as efficiently as possible. A lot of people don't want to be at ANY disadvantage even if its a small one just because they built their player a season or two before.

Is this change really worth it when the same thing is already naturally accomplished by AEQ and how you train and place your SPs?


You do realize that building your guy earlier, and therefore having more SP, VA, equipment upgrades, etc. also gives you an advantage right? An advantage that one could argue is actually greater at most positions then having different ALGs for your first 10-11 levels.

Also, the same thing is most definitely not accomplished by AEQ, how you train, and how you place your SPs. The reason for this is every player at a given position has the same ALGs, so there is really only a single way to efficiently build with those ALGs. By offering different ALG options for each position we don't pigeonhole someone that wants to build efficiently into only focusing on what the current ALGs just happen to be.
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
So...what is your argument?


There is no best way to build a player, there is only the most efficient ways to build a player. Currently we are pigeonholed into a specific set of ALGs for each position, so there is essentially only one way to efficiently build each player, with the only real difference being in what majors you decide to cap when. By allowing us to choose among different ALGs at each position, we can now build players at the same position, equally efficiently, but with different attributes being capped early because of the different majors. This will allow for large differences in player builds at later levels.

As for my argument against complete customization, it basically comes down to the fact that you can't have the best possible combination of majors and minors at any single position with the system we're currently discussing. Therefore people are forced to weigh pros and cons of different archetypes and decide how they want to build. If we could just choose anything we wanted you'd end up with the vast majority of people just choosing the best possible combo of majors and minors and working from there. That isn't possible in this system.

EDIT: forgot to mention that you just decided to side step my questions and basically ask me to rephrase the same thing I said a page ago. Seriously though, I'd like you to think hard and answer the questions I asked because I think it will give you a better idea of where I'm coming from and make it easier to understand why you believe what you believe.

Oh, and as for complete SA customization, you'd have to be naive to think there won't be best possible SA setups dependent upon what archetype you choose and how you choose to build. I see how someone could value that extra customization, but I simply don't believe it will lead to nearly the diversity in build you guys think (nowhere near the difference archetypes will make) and it completely alters the fundamental setup of player building (and makes older players far more useless) while the current option keeps the fundamentals essentially the same, while only changing the actual value of the ALGs at any given position.
 
Eagle0415
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
Originally posted by Eagle0415

Catch22

Personally i feel there are agents out there like myself that just spent a lot of money in creating a entire team this season. And i feel i am now gonna be punished with retiring all my players to restart this over. Meaning i lose 10% of flex that i did not plan on losing for at least 10 seasons. I feel i should be allowed to retire my players with full return to do this as my players will hit the 40 days in a season i doubt i will win anything.

Eagle0415


solution: don't boost...don't buy custom; don't lose any flex, gain 300 almost the price of the team for the season


Solution you speak of does not do a thing for me. Reason being is i already spent the flex on CE so why should i have to take the hit on 49 players all my own thats a huge cost to me over 4400 flex which i don't feel i should have to give up because we keep changing the way the game is done. And i am not disagreeing this isnt a good move i just dont feel i should have to lose so much in flex to me its like i am being forced to donate close to 40.00 to the game owners and truthfully get nothing in return
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.