Originally posted by nixa37
How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.
There will be exploits REGARDLESS of what is done -- its a game, and people will continue to crunch numbers and figure out what gives them the best odds of success.
While I agree with you that letting people choose their majors and minors would basically end up with cookie cutter majors and minors, opening up all SA's and allowing players to choose their trees would end up with less cookie cutter builds and more specialization among players.
You can still have the 4 SA's involved in the archetype -- the 2 with the bonus, and the 2 with the negative, must be at the start of the trees, for example. But for the final 3 on the tree, you allow players to make their own choices -- maybe the 3 and 4 spots on the tree come from a certain group of SA's, and the 5-spot (which costs more) has a different group of SA's.
And you can have these parts of the tree appear after certain level achievements ala player development, learning new skills, etc.
To me, while this update is interesting, it lacks the punch of allowing true build creativity and as long as the trees remain static, cookie cutters will reign.
How do people not get that complete control leads to overpowered builds that will be exploited? The new system forces you to weigh the pros and cons of the different archetypes and then come up with a plan on how you are going to take advantage of the ALGs you choose to build your player efficiently. With complete choice you don't have to weigh pros and cons at certain positions because the its obvious what the best combination of majors would be. As many people have mentioned, almost every HB would have majors of speed, agility, strength, and carrying. Almost every OL would have blocking, strength, and agility. Almost every DL would have strength, speed, and agility. With this system, since you can't have the best possible combination, you have to choose what you want to emphasize in your final build and choose an archetype that will help you achieve your build goals.
There will be exploits REGARDLESS of what is done -- its a game, and people will continue to crunch numbers and figure out what gives them the best odds of success.
While I agree with you that letting people choose their majors and minors would basically end up with cookie cutter majors and minors, opening up all SA's and allowing players to choose their trees would end up with less cookie cutter builds and more specialization among players.
You can still have the 4 SA's involved in the archetype -- the 2 with the bonus, and the 2 with the negative, must be at the start of the trees, for example. But for the final 3 on the tree, you allow players to make their own choices -- maybe the 3 and 4 spots on the tree come from a certain group of SA's, and the 5-spot (which costs more) has a different group of SA's.
And you can have these parts of the tree appear after certain level achievements ala player development, learning new skills, etc.
To me, while this update is interesting, it lacks the punch of allowing true build creativity and as long as the trees remain static, cookie cutters will reign.






























