Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg
Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg
QUESTIONS:
1) How long has this bug been known for?
2) Why is the changelog language vague and cryptic?
3) Why has there been no public apology and thank you to the discoverers of the issue?
3a) We haven't been getting what we've paid for, apparently. A bug is a bug, sh!t happens. But be forthcoming.
4) What players were affected? Should I expect different performance out of my players now?
5) Didn't I pay for a game where I have complete control over my players, teams, and strategies?
6) Why did it take so long for this issue to be addressed? Surely those behind the scenes could see the broken strings when those of us on the other side of the curtain noticed player performance issues for a long time AND pointed it out.
Originally posted by Jed
1) When Deathblade showed him the evidence yesterday, he seemed to not know of it being a bug till that point.
2) Because it's not necessarily a change which will fix anything, so he didn't want to focus attention on what it might solve, only what happened and what it might do.
3) Have you ever seen this for any bug fix, ever?
3a) Beta. You've been getting exactly what you paid for.
4) Don't know yet. Won't really know till the exact problem is definitively nailed down and fixed, which we won't know much more about until tomorrow's games (since the players who were used as testing to show this problem don't play till tomorrow)
5) There's been die rolls and randomness built into the sim since day 1. So if anything that varies even slightly from your stats vs the opponents' stats means you don't have completely control, then that's not something new. So no, you didn't.
6) Because it got lost in the sea of "WAAAAAAAAH MY PLAYER SUCKS AND IT'S NOT MY FAULT" that goes on around here. It took more solid evidence to pick that out of the crowd. Obviously, it wasn't noticed until now since nothing was even being looked at as a fix until now.
Well thank you for responding.
1) Fair enough.
2) Why wouldn't this change be tested on test servers if you don't know what it's going to do? No testing at all went into it?
2a) Your response isn't really a reason as to why the language isn't clear
3) Honestly, how the fuck can you call this a Beta? Beta testers don't pay to use software. It cannot be a Beta if you are charging your beta testers. I realize it's difficult to prepare for every situation and fix every bug, but "it's beta" is a cop-out. When you say "you're getting exactly what you paid for", it's kind of a stupid thing to say... because this is the only beta ever that people have had to pay for, thus it's not really a beta. Plus, that was a rather abrupt way of putting it. Customer service obviously isn't your strong point.
4) You don't know what players are affected? I mean... you fixed the bug... the bug affects some players, you seem to know that much. What type of players does it affect? Random players? Minimum/maximum weight players? Tall players? Players created at exactly 4:20??? This goes along with #2, why the cryptic language??? Just tell us what's going on in your "beta".
5) No shit there's randomness, it's a football simulation. I'm talking about builds, x-factors, and speed bugs. You really didn't know what I meant there?
6) I find it kind of sad that the people who are paying you to use your beta are the ones finding bugs. Your job is to find issues, dig through the "sea of waaaah", and figure shit out. That makes you sound lazy and apathetic.
6a) Okay so you finally had to do something about it when proof was beating you over the head. Why do we have to create these gigantic threads and stir everybody up just to get answers such as "We just discovered the bug so we don't know exactly what it will do"???
Look, we realize that the game won't be perfect. We realize you guys hide behind the word "beta". Mistakes happen, code does some weird stuff. Just be forthcoming with information about something like this. If this is really the source of the X-factor, it is a pretty big deal... since the fix seems to have been rushed into the sim according to the info you've provided us with, it makes it seem even more so like a big deal.
So... does this fix delete the issue? Mitigate the issue? Are our players going to be moving at speeds determined by known factors now along with some in-game randomness, like we've all been assuming for 10 seasons?