User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris

The second idea is probably the best I've seen. Also, why not let them chose the weakest league? Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Better than my Russian Roulette idea? never...
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by Galkuris

Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Yeah, random is really the best method to make sure there is eventual evening out of talent.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Anyway, another idea is that we do kinda like what we do with the Minor League teams now (or conferences when doing promotion): We send you down to the league you came from if we can, and a random one (maybe let teams rank them in order) if we can't.


EXACTLY what I've been trying to propose lol
Edited by ICRockets on Jul 27, 2009 19:38:12
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I will just adopt the league structure from BASEketball.

Anyway, another idea is that we do kinda like what we do with the Minor League teams now (or conferences when doing promotion): We send you down to the league you came from if we can, and a random one (maybe let teams rank them in order) if we can't.


BASEketball?
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by AirMcMVP


I have two ideas. Either or both may have been suggested. Both are based on the bottom 8 teams from each conference relegating from the WPL each season.

First, the bottom 16 teams relegate to their respective Pro Leagues. Where possible, they will also relegate into their old conference. The assumptions is that there will be enough CPU/gutted teams in each Pro league to handle whatever demotions come about. If there are insufficient CPU/gutted teams, the team(s) with the worst regular season record will drop down one level (based on inverse seeding). Enough teams will be demoted from the Pro league to ensure all league championship participants have room to promote. Extra demotions will work down the entire tree (Pro-->AAA-->AA-->Uncapped Minors) to make room in each tier (as needed).

Pros: Teams remain in their "home" region. Upper leagues get stronger due to bottom feeder teams relegating.
Cons: Number of teams relegating from Pro (and maybe AAA) unknown.

Second, participants in the WPL choose their preferred region for demotion (rated in order of preference 1-8). Based on current tie-breakers teams are demoted to their league of choice. If a team's first choice is not available, they will be put into the first available region.

Pros: Teams have a chance to choose their region. Upper leagues can become more diverse.
Cons: Teams not guaranteed to return "home".

In either case, if a WPL team goes CPU or guts, it drops as usual. If a WPL playoff team goes CPU or guts they are dropped to the appropiate level and the the top non-playoff team takes its place (reduce relegation from WPL and avoid any complaints about which Pro level team to promote).


I think second idea could work in some fashion if it was

Home region first if available, and then let them choose if it's not available. That way teams can't aim for the weakest league every time.


The second idea is probably the best I've seen. Also, why not let them chose the weakest league? Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


I agree. Giving total choice will diversify the game. If Cobra Kai (only using them because they are one of the most prominent teams in the game) goes 8-8 and finishes 9th, they earned the chance to move to USA if that's their choice. And the fact that teams region choice will be unknown makes the end of each season more interesting.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I will just adopt the league structure from BASEketball.

Anyway, another idea is that we do kinda like what we do with the Minor League teams now (or conferences when doing promotion): We send you down to the league you came from if we can, and a random one (maybe let teams rank them in order) if we can't.


Again, as I said before, owners should get the option to select if they care about regional placement or not. If they do, they get processed first when demotion occurs. Then the owners that select the option that they DON'T care about regional placement get placed in the leagues that need them the most according to whatever criteria are needed (better team goes to better league or whatever).
 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
I don't have time to read through all the threads, so I'm sure this has come up already. But honestly, this could not be simpler.

Create a World Pro League. Seed it initially with the top four teams from each Pro league, as determined by the S10 playoffs.

Have two conferences... maybe Eurasia (WE, EE, SEA, Africa) and Atlantica (USA, Canada, SA, Oceania). Or whatever.

Have four divisions in each conference. Name each one for a region. Keep each of the Pro teams that promoted initially together as part of that division.

At the end of the season, demote the lowest team in each division back to the Pro league from whence it came, and promote the league champion from that league. Yes, that means eight demotions. Remaining in the WPL should be an honor that has to be earned every single season. This will add even more spice to the intradivisional games, as they directly impact whether you get to continue playing in the WPL. If by some miracle all four teams from a division make the playoffs, use the opposite of the promotion rules to determine who goes back down (i.e. lowest seed from among those first eliminated from the playoffs).

In the event that a team which otherwise would not be demoted decides to fold, promote the next highest team from that Pro league to replace them, starting with the loser of the league finals and moving on to the two losers of the conference finals. Even if all four WPL teams from a given Pro league fold at once (highly unlikely), you're not going to be promoting any severely inferior teams to take their place.

I've promoted the idea of divisions a couple times before but never seen them gain much traction. You could use them to implement any number of cool things across ALL leagues:

1. Alter the scheduling process to approximate the NFL. Two games against each team in your division, one against each of two other divisions (one in your conference and one in the opposing conference), and one game each against the teams that finished last season at your relative division rank. Promotion and team folding make this an interesting exercise, but I guarantee I could have an algorithm for you to do this within a couple hours if you want it.

2. Hand out division titles based on regular season record. Bronze trophies all around. I think you see a lot of teams fold because it's just too damn hard to win a conference or league title, and teams who have great seasons often walk away with absolutely nothing to show for it, sometimes even getting promoted multiple times while never garnering any team awards. Make the division trophy only applicable to the team page rather than handing it out to all GMs like you do with the silver and gold ones, so agent pages don't get cluttered with them. Competition for a division trophy would intensify divisional rivalries and ensure that good teams are easily recognized on their team page. It's heartrending to go 14-2 or better and take an upset late in the playoffs... a divisional trophy would mitigate some of that sting. Every level of football has something like this (NFL division banners, college conference titles, high school state championships, etc.). Why not GLB?

3. Hand out endorsement equipment per division. The current endorsement system is lame. Some players on EVERY team get one, and then a TINY handful of players get a good one. You can create an intermediate step that would be meaningful and attainable, but not so exclusive.

And much much more. I'm sure others can add their own ideas.

Seriously, this is NOT a problem that should require the collective brainpower of GLB to solve. Throw out all the extra suggestions for now: all the initial implementation of this idea will take is another field in the database for each team, a little bit of UI rework to provide a page for each division and a way to alternately sort the league rankings into divisions instead of conferences. For everyone but the WPL, you can seed the initial divisions completely at random, right after the promotion script runs.

A few days is plenty of time to make this happen. Even if it's not, you can work on it for all of S11 and just look back at the S10 finals to retroactively determine who belongs to which division. Bort, you touted a WPL after S9 and said that it WOULD be happening... don't yank it away now over such a little thing.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Galkuris


Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Yeah, random is really the best method to make sure there is eventual evening out of talent.


Bort, how do you like my tourney idea??
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
Top 2 teams are in from each PRO conference for next season because those teams expected to be there based on announcements all season long and worked their butts of to accomplish what they have in their respective leagues. This should be the case irrespective of league strength, because this is how the idea was originally introduced.

That said, we do need a way to address stronger leagues and strong conferences so...Next season (season 11), along with world league games, you simultaneously run the 64-team tourney.

Best 32 teams are in the world league from that tourney the following season (S12) and the other teams that did not make the cut get put back in their respective PRO leagues as "demotion"

The tournament itself will take care of the "promotion" aspect of it.

Then every season you have a world league running simultaneously w/a 64-team pro tourney to decide the make-up of the WPL for the following season.

So MM and OFG might not be there the very first year but look...you have to start somewhere and build a model and sometimes that involves a little injustice. At least you have a base set up and a format teams can aspire to.

This also involves the most number of teams of any solution I've seen laid out thus far and incorporates promotion/relegation as well as changes in team chemistry, etc. throughout the season.

Your other solution is to have an extended off-season this season, run the 64-team tourney and then put the best 32 teams in WPL. This can work and it offers access to WPL for teams in strong conferences and strong leagues that will not have access to it come S11 because of the current set-up of entry into WPL (top 2 from each Pro conference are in).

Then next season, you can run another 64-team tourney concurrently w/WPL games or again in the off-season.

Why is there so much opposition to running both ideas at the same time instead of having to pick and chose one or the other?

As far as excess game-planning goes? Who cares?...Most of the top teams game plan to hell 24/7 anyway. If you want to get there bad enough, you'll GP to do it.
Originally posted by Crawly



Terrible. Just a basic world league is easier to handle. Why is a tournament also necessary?


1. to handle promotion/demotion to and from WPL
2. to handle all the teams that don't finish top 2 in their conference but belong in WPL


>>>>


I got a better idea.


WPL teams (32) get a first round bye. Then top 64 teams from other PLs enter the tourney.

That is 16 conferences each get 4 teams into the tournament.

First round: 64 pro league teams
Second Round: 32 round 1 survivors vs 32 WPL teams that get a first round bye


A. creates incentive to get to WPL
B. ensures no WPL team upsets in the first round...they will have their shot to be upset starting round 2
C. fair and equitable promotion/relegation among all regions and pro-teams


<<<<<>>>>>>> edit again to eliminate top 16 WPL teams from getting eliminated from WPL


In that case, further expand my idea.


1. top 4 teams from each pro conference get tourney invitation into WPL (this makes 64 teams that have access to WPL)
2. bottom 16 teams from WPL are also entered into tourney
3. round 1: top 64 pro teams play each other
4. round 2: top 32 teams play each other
5. round 3: 16 bottom WPL teams play 16 remaining pro teams for a shot at entering the WPL for the following season
6. teams that lose have the option of going back to same pro league from where they came or
7. randomly being assigned into another pro league in order to create GLB parity






quoted for edit

Edited by vrshah on Jul 27, 2009 19:40:16
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
I don't have time to read through all the threads, so I'm sure this has come up already. But honestly, this could not be simpler.

Create a World Pro League. Seed it initially with the top four teams from each Pro league, as determined by the S10 playoffs.

Have two conferences... maybe Eurasia (WE, EE, SEA, Africa) and Atlantica (USA, Canada, SA, Oceania). Or whatever.

Have four divisions in each conference. Name each one for a region. Keep each of the Pro teams that promoted initially together as part of that division.

At the end of the season, demote the lowest team in each division back to the Pro league from whence it came, and promote the league champion from that league. Yes, that means eight demotions. Remaining in the WPL should be an honor that has to be earned every single season. This will add even more spice to the intradivisional games, as they directly impact whether you get to continue playing in the WPL. If by some miracle all four teams from a division make the playoffs, use the opposite of the promotion rules to determine who goes back down (i.e. lowest seed from among those first eliminated from the playoffs).

In the event that a team which otherwise would not be demoted decides to fold, promote the next highest team from that Pro league to replace them, starting with the loser of the league finals and moving on to the two losers of the conference finals. Even if all four WPL teams from a given Pro league fold at once (highly unlikely), you're not going to be promoting any severely inferior teams to take their place.

I've promoted the idea of divisions a couple times before but never seen them gain much traction. You could use them to implement any number of cool things across ALL leagues:

1. Alter the scheduling process to approximate the NFL. Two games against each team in your division, one against each of two other divisions (one in your conference and one in the opposing conference), and one game each against the teams that finished last season at your relative division rank. Promotion and team folding make this an interesting exercise, but I guarantee I could have an algorithm for you to do this within a couple hours if you want it.

2. Hand out division titles based on regular season record. Bronze trophies all around. I think you see a lot of teams fold because it's just too damn hard to win a conference or league title, and teams who have great seasons often walk away with absolutely nothing to show for it, sometimes even getting promoted multiple times while never garnering any team awards. Make the division trophy only applicable to the team page rather than handing it out to all GMs like you do with the silver and gold ones, so agent pages don't get cluttered with them. Competition for a division trophy would intensify divisional rivalries and ensure that good teams are easily recognized on their team page. It's heartrending to go 14-2 or better and take an upset late in the playoffs... a divisional trophy would mitigate some of that sting. Every level of football has something like this (NFL division banners, college conference titles, high school state championships, etc.). Why not GLB?

3. Hand out endorsement equipment per division. The current endorsement system is lame. Some players on EVERY team get one, and then a TINY handful of players get a good one. You can create an intermediate step that would be meaningful and attainable, but not so exclusive.

And much much more. I'm sure others can add their own ideas.

Seriously, this is NOT a problem that should require the collective brainpower of GLB to solve. Throw out all the extra suggestions for now: all the initial implementation of this idea will take is another field in the database for each team, a little bit of UI rework to provide a page for each division and a way to alternately sort the league rankings into divisions instead of conferences. For everyone but the WPL, you can seed the initial divisions completely at random, right after the promotion script runs.

A few days is plenty of time to make this happen. Even if it's not, you can work on it for all of S11 and just look back at the S10 finals to retroactively determine who belongs to which division. Bort, you touted a WPL after S9 and said that it WOULD be happening... don't yank it away now over such a little thing.


Essentially what I am pulling for (and have been since Season 5): http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1164706

+1
Edited by lukin83 on Jul 27, 2009 19:42:54
Edited by lukin83 on Jul 27, 2009 19:42:24
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gabrosin
I don't have time to read through all the threads, so I'm sure this has come up already. But honestly, this could not be simpler.

Create a World Pro League. Seed it initially with the top four teams from each Pro league, as determined by the S10 playoffs.

Have two conferences... maybe Eurasia (WE, EE, SEA, Africa) and Atlantica (USA, Canada, SA, Oceania). Or whatever.

Have four divisions in each conference. Name each one for a region. Keep each of the Pro teams that promoted initially together as part of that division.

At the end of the season, demote the lowest team in each division back to the Pro league from whence it came, and promote the league champion from that league. Yes, that means eight demotions. Remaining in the WPL should be an honor that has to be earned every single season. This will add even more spice to the intradivisional games, as they directly impact whether you get to continue playing in the WPL. If by some miracle all four teams from a division make the playoffs, use the opposite of the promotion rules to determine who goes back down (i.e. lowest seed from among those first eliminated from the playoffs).

In the event that a team which otherwise would not be demoted decides to fold, promote the next highest team from that Pro league to replace them, starting with the loser of the league finals and moving on to the two losers of the conference finals. Even if all four WPL teams from a given Pro league fold at once (highly unlikely), you're not going to be promoting any severely inferior teams to take their place.

I've promoted the idea of divisions a couple times before but never seen them gain much traction. You could use them to implement any number of cool things across ALL leagues:

1. Alter the scheduling process to approximate the NFL. Two games against each team in your division, one against each of two other divisions (one in your conference and one in the opposing conference), and one game each against the teams that finished last season at your relative division rank. Promotion and team folding make this an interesting exercise, but I guarantee I could have an algorithm for you to do this within a couple hours if you want it.

2. Hand out division titles based on regular season record. Bronze trophies all around. I think you see a lot of teams fold because it's just too damn hard to win a conference or league title, and teams who have great seasons often walk away with absolutely nothing to show for it, sometimes even getting promoted multiple times while never garnering any team awards. Make the division trophy only applicable to the team page rather than handing it out to all GMs like you do with the silver and gold ones, so agent pages don't get cluttered with them. Competition for a division trophy would intensify divisional rivalries and ensure that good teams are easily recognized on their team page. It's heartrending to go 14-2 or better and take an upset late in the playoffs... a divisional trophy would mitigate some of that sting. Every level of football has something like this (NFL division banners, college conference titles, high school state championships, etc.). Why not GLB?

3. Hand out endorsement equipment per division. The current endorsement system is lame. Some players on EVERY team get one, and then a TINY handful of players get a good one. You can create an intermediate step that would be meaningful and attainable, but not so exclusive.

And much much more. I'm sure others can add their own ideas.

Seriously, this is NOT a problem that should require the collective brainpower of GLB to solve. Throw out all the extra suggestions for now: all the initial implementation of this idea will take is another field in the database for each team, a little bit of UI rework to provide a page for each division and a way to alternately sort the league rankings into divisions instead of conferences. For everyone but the WPL, you can seed the initial divisions completely at random, right after the promotion script runs.

A few days is plenty of time to make this happen. Even if it's not, you can work on it for all of S11 and just look back at the S10 finals to retroactively determine who belongs to which division. Bort, you touted a WPL after S9 and said that it WOULD be happening... don't yank it away now over such a little thing.


This is pretty much lukin's idea too.. some of it at least.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Galkuris


Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Yeah, random is really the best method to make sure there is eventual evening out of talent.


Random would be fine, but if you're giving the worst teams their first choice then we wouldn't have to set up the random part. The key is that the teams with the most choice are the ones that were least competitive in WPL. It allows a small amount of region shuffling, but is the least disruptive way of doing it as far as the competition of the league is concerned.
 
HULK
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I think you need to move the top teams around. Spread them out. Move teams from USA and Canada to leagues like Southeast Asia and Oceania. Otherwise, it will take like 8 season to even out.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by Galkuris


Wouldn't that bring parity quicker having the best demotion go to the worst league?


Not likely. If they're almost a playoff team in WPL, and they go to the worst Pro League, isn't it likely that their presence in said league would be fleeting? That's not a recipe for long-term parity. It's just a recipe for giving the best demotees the quickest and easiest path back to WPL.


Yeah, random is really the best method to make sure there is eventual evening out of talent.




Errrm. Random is best over the course of 100 seasons or so, but can be pretty fickle over the course of say, 2 or 3 seasons.....
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.