User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > *** OFFICIAL *** North Korea blows up a Nuke
Page:
 
Pithy Radish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ghost187
Originally posted by Jiggetty

Sheer numbers...

Our military might inflict alot more casualties, but eventually they would win because of the numbers game. Plus Russia would be with them. More numbers. The rest of our Allies would get out of the way. Less numbers for us.

There's alot of stuff on this all over the net. The ending always has China on top.


Sun Tzu's The Art of War

ever hear of it?


I've been meaning to read that book for the longest time.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
LMAO @ this whole post BUT mostly at Cybershot....

Originally posted by Cybershot

Hypocrites.

Say what you will about their crazy regime - and I implore you to do so - but condemning nuke tests when you have a stockpile of active warheads in the thousands is pretty funny.


LOL... so a Unstable regime that has since the 50's threaten the world is a better choice to have nukes vs a regime (up till the bush admin) has been seen by most of the world as a beacon of light and hope. USA has been condemning nuclear testing forever... its a way to stop a weapon from proliferating. There is no need for every country in the world to have nukes. if they did, it just increases the odds that the world will end in nuclear war.

BTW Had Stalin not acted like a nervous twit right after WW2, im sure the stockpiling of nukes would have been a lot different.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Then you said this about their crazy regime.....
Originally posted by Cybershot

And that has to be addressed. For sure.

How does one stop a country that didnt stop when it didnt have nukes and china's full backing.... that you now want to address when they do have Nukes and the full backing of China.

Seems to me you arent a man of history and just say how things "should" be.. this isnt lollipop land.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

You had the luxury of testing them for 40 years...


Yea forty years.. but the Usa hasnt tested them since 1992. Testing Nukes is for one thing only... Improving yields and yield to weight ratios. In other words... Multi nuclear warheads.

So let me get this straight.... a few quotes back you are saying NK needs to be stopped... then you are saying countries should all be testing nukes, cause the US had 40 years of testing? GG

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Honestly, they need to focus on the negatives of the regime in these stories, and not the fact that they have weapons that can hurt other countries. The point that should be pushed is they are a horrible regime, and are violating many human rights laws.

Edit: The world always takes notice when it's their asses on the firing line.


So... for 50 years, the world hasn't put sanctions on them for all the human right violations? The press never put of stories of all the human right violations? There arent any booked published about it? No people ever excaped from NK and told anyone anout it? No movies of teh week? you think this is something new? You really have no clue about history do you? This has been going on since the day the Korean war ended.. and has been addressed for decades from the world and the USA... but that lil sticking point of CHINA backing them... nothing was ever able to be done.

See lil one... history would show you that USA and SK had the Korean war won til China entered the war and pushed us both back and almost off the Korean peninsula.... we fought back and got it back to where the demilitarization zone is today. Had there been no china interference... there would be no NK today.

The reason the Nukes are such a big deal now is cause for almost 60 years NK has been insane.... now a insane person has a weapon that can kill millions in a second... that there is no defense against... that can destroy a area of the world for decades...

so keep assuming...

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Stop spewing your garbage. The US is the protector of its investments, and rarely anything else.


So has every one of your post been (garbage).... What country isn't protecting it's interests? even WW2 we were doing the same thing. but the US has done more non investment protections then canada ever has.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

I highly doubt his aids woul follow such an instruction.

BTW my stance it to aggressively dethrone that regime NOW, and not because of the damn nukes. But because of the starving people who are being brainwashed on a daily basis.


Again... no sense of history or why the Korean war happened in the first place.. Also many countries where people are being starved and brainwashed... where are you defending them? Canada, the worlds defender!!! with no army, air force or navy to worry about... talking about saving the world. easy to talk trash when your "big brother" has all the muscle, Eh? Would love to see Canada go into Dafur or Somalia solo and solve the worlds issues...

As for dethroning him now.... History, go read the North Korean war.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

I think his aids would not follow through on an order to start a nuclear war for a dying man. Just my opinion, and not based on anything but human nature.


Ah... the thoughts of one who knows nada. His "aides" are his military generals... they arent his aides btw... they are the North Korean ARMED FORCES GENERALS. they run the show there.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

a) no they can't be trusted, as proven by several bogus wars, lying to the people to get into such wars, and, until now, the only country to have used the nukes in an offensive manner.


You really need to learn history dude... cause the amount on talking out of your ass is insane.

1- USA warned Tokyo about the atomic weapons.
2- USA gave them multiple chances to surrender.
3- EVERYONE but you stated... people who have a clue... that dropping the bomb on japan saved lives.
4- those bombs were dropped more 60 years ago. wasn't you me or our parent who did that. so keep up with that arguement... you are winning.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Well...to my earlier point. They equipped the Afghans in order to fight the Russians, who needed control of the region in order to build a pipeline. This is what I mean by protecting their assets. Fighting covert wars and equipping highly dangerous people in order to maintain a dominant position is BS, if you ask me. Mind you own business on your own land, and things will work out. Start thrusting your peen into matters that don't need you, and you will engender hate and retaliation.


Ask the afghans who got stream rolled in the 80s who were the dangerous people.... BTW the Russians were the major world threat in the 80's... wars all over and had massive amounts of nukes and even threatened to use em... see Cuba.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Japan really wasn't a real threat tbh. Should have been on Germany imo, if anything.


LMAO..... LMAO.... LMAO.... LMAO

Again... HISTORY... read it.

You must be 16 and haven't studied history 101 yet. The atomic bomb was ready to be used AFTER Germany surrendered. A lil military thing called the Manhattan Project.

Ask anyone who was alive back then in the pacific theater on iwo jima or midway.... Oh yea ask the armys who were in Europe getting ready to be SHIPPED to japan who was the real threat was then.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

They won't be able to send them to NY from NK, ever.


Please learn to use facts... stop talking out of your... you know what.

Taepodong-2
http://www.missilethreat.com/missilesoftheworld/id.166/missile_detail.asp


I guess hawaii alaska and the west coast doesnt count as United states... so dont you worry guys.. they cant hit NY!!!!

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Prove it. Prove it that they were needlessly slaughtering people. Propaganda imo.
(He is talking about USSR going into Afghanistan and NOT killing their people.)

OMG HISTORY once again....

In 1979, the USSR took control of the Afghan capital, Kabul, and tried through the following decade to gain control over the whole country and its people. The invasion was a failure, costing thousands of lives and having serious consequences still felt today.

To better understand the reason for the Soviet invasion and failure, first one must understand the geography and culture in Afghanistan. The land is mountainous and arid. Jagged, impassable ranges divide the country and make travel difficult. Due to these physical divisions, the people are extremely provincial, with more loyalty to their specific clan or ethnic group than to a government or a country. The people are Muslims, and extremely religious and conservative. The majority ethnic group is the Pashtun, but there are over ten minority groups.

Starting in the 1950s, the USSR began giving aid to Afghanistan. The Soviets built roads, irrigation and even some oil pipelines. In the 1970s, a Communist party overthrew the monarchy and tried to institute social reforms. The rural populations saw land distribution and women's rights as alien to their traditional Islamic culture, a culture in which polygamy, covering of women, and blood for blood practices are accepted. The Communist governments in Kabul in the 1970s lacked the popular support of the rural population.

The Invasion

The Soviets sent troops into Afghanistan in 1979 for a number of reasons. First, they wished to expand their influence in Asia. They also wanted to preserve the Communist government that had been established in the 1970s, and was collapsing because of its lack of support other than in the military. Third, the Soviets wanted to protect their interests in Afghanistan from Iran and western nations.

The Soviets brought in over one hundred thousand soldiers, secured Kabul quickly and installed Babrak Karmal as their puppet leader. However, they were met with fierce resistance when they ventured out of their strongholds into the countryside. Resistance fighters, called mujahidin, saw the Christian or atheist Soviets controlling Afghanistan as a defilement of Islam as well as of their traditional culture. Proclaiming a "jihad"(holy war), they gained the support of the Islamic world. The US gave them weapons and money. The mujahidin employed guerrilla tactics against the Soviets. They would attack or raid quickly, then disappear into the mountains, causing great destruction without pitched battles. The fighters used whatever weapons they could take from the Soviets or were given by the US. Decentralized and scattered around Afghanistan, the mujahidin were like a poisonous snake without a head that could be cut off. There was no one strong central stronghold from which resistance operated.

Theres a quick history lesson for you... free of Propaganda. BTW im sure they took Kabul. without firing a single shot or killing anyone.
Your opinions as of yet... 1 out of 10 rating.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

If Germany had indeed surrendered at that point (fuzzy on the timeline), you guys could have focused entirely on Japan. = not a threat.


May 7, 1945 - Date Germany officially surrendered to the world (fighting mainly stopped before then)
August 6, 1945 - Date US drops atomic bomb on Hiroshima
August 9, 1945 - Date Atom bomb hits Nagasaki

Yay!!! history and dates... Fuzzy math for cybershot.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

I'm never in favour of bombing a city in order to send a message to the army. That's a massive and cowardly cop out.


Nope you are in favor of more brutal ways.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

I love Americans, I have family in the US.

I hate how ignorant the majority of you are about World politics.


Thank god you are here cyber... so i can show everyone TRUE examples of ignorance about world politics and history.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Yea I mean, part of the reason to dethrone the regime is to SAVE the people.

Again.. read history and see North Korean War

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot

Albert Einstein said "what have i done" or something like that after the creation of the atomic bomb, his advanced intellect doomed the world

Yep he did.

And most of the scientists involved in the Manhattan Project desperately tried to not have them dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki


And you realize Einstein Wrote the US government pushing them to CREATEnuclear bombs due to the fact Germany was making them. I know... HISTORY.. You really love to take things out of context and make your lil reality.

I will stop quoting the greatness know as Cybershot. It is obvious at how much he need to study history and learn what the past has taught us... mainly about NK china Russia and the USA.

Cyber, please stop posting about things you have a huge bias against and dont understand or never cared about learning. You didnt add one thing to this convo that was truthful.

Cybershot = 0 points.
How is this guy a mod???
 
0n1n3
offline
Link
 
Pragmatism.

Maybe it is hypocritical that the US preaches neutrality while having nuclear capability.

The USA has made difficult choices in it's history of nuclear warfare & development. One alternative to war with north korea was then to nuke their entire coastline and most of the country before sending in troops. Ultimately this did not happen and I feel that the next generation looks upon that in reflection.

Would the enemies of Israel ever hesitate to use a nuclear bomb on them if they had the capability?

No, that probably won't happen, but that doesn't give us an excuse to pull our pants down. Fundamentalism in this country may seem barbaric but it is far from the gray area of any fundamentalism in the east, religious or otherwise. There are more people there, the history is different, the culture is different and the only people that understand us are those who were once or are currently conquered by western nations. Draw up a political map and take a look around you. Sure, The British Empire is dead and gone but that doesn't mean imperialism no longer exists. The Queen of England is still the Queen of I-don't-know-how-many other countries, all of which still share strong relations with western nation builders, the same ones who go about and "accidentally" bomb their house on mission, "Oops, sorry. War is hell." And what are they supposed to say to that?

Nuclear weapons or not, violence simply begets more violence. Did we not learn this in Vietnam? Did we not learn this in Iraq?

If North Korea wants to toss around threats then let them talk. What are they going to do honestly? South Korea alone has one of the top 10 strongest armies AND navies in the entire world. North Korea is as backwards as it gets. They can throw as many parades and take as many pictures as they want, that won't change the weakness they themselves refuse to accept.

Look at the boys that these men arm with RPGs and take pictures, holding it over their shoulder proud, as if they were a monster... but they are not monsters, they are simply boys. If they spoke 1 word of english, our marines would put the fear of God into them quite literally.

I have read the Art of War.
That said, I feel you have 2 options; Politics or War. What else is there?
You can either play their games and feed into their diplomatic nonsense, likely giving them billions in resources and money, or you can take down the government and establish a democratic government.

To the latter, you can either go like Iraq or force through diplomacy, which has not been taken into account 1 bit whatsoever.
Everybody is afraid of the "New World Order" but the truth is that globalization is inevitable. Eventually there will be continental nationalism, be it 20 years from now or 200, and eventually there will be only 1. That will happen, 100 years from now or 1000.

If you want to avoid playing political games back and forth then that has to be established, the UN isn't good enough... everybody knows that. The UN is a joke.


Blahblahblah, I'm bored of the subject... but it's a worthy subject.
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Whatsdafus, the was the best owning of a single person that I have ever seen in my life.
Edited by bossinthe831 on May 28, 2009 01:11:22
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bossinthe831
Whatsdafus, the was the best owning of a single person that I have ever seen in my life.


ty ty, im sure i will be banned by him again for a week, so i will accept your kind words now, fast... and duck and cover the ban spray
 
0n1n3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by bossinthe831

Whatsdafus, the was the best owning of a single person that I have ever seen in my life.


ty ty, im sure i will be banned by him again for a week, so i will accept your kind words now, fast... and duck and cover the ban spray


You're quite scary.
Please be nice to me. <3
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Cricket Cricket
 
Wylker
offline
Link
 
this thread looks very official
 
Roughneck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Roughneck

Originally posted by Roughneck
US cannot afford to start another military campaign, and frankly, after watching their butchering of operations in the middle east, am unconvinced that they have the aggression necessary to efficiently defeat the much more psychotic NKs, than the Iraqi's. Even if the Koreans couldn't beat the US, they'd make a policy of smashing everything that stands, just on principle.


Iraq was a disaster because there was no plan to win the peace after the regime was toppled. Standing by and watching looting was pretty stupid. Disarming the army and police, sending them home without jobs, was pretty stupid.

Winning the peace in North Korea would be pretty simple, since, like in most dictatorships, he's not particularly well liked.

1) Defeat his army in the field.
2) Use his army and police, under US supervision, to protect law and order.
3) Bring and distribute food.


captobvious - How are you going to defeat his army in the field without him showering Seoul with rockets and arty just for kicks? There'd be high civilian losses, US morale is at a low right now. There is NO way that there would be an occupation in NK by the US, Iraq-style. Once again, too many fronts. What's great in America is not so good in the rest of the world. Tech weapons cost money and with defeat of NK, there is no real economic advantage, actually, disadvantage....... ignore and send black ops as needed.
Edited by Roughneck on May 28, 2009 11:37:59
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
LMAO @ this whole post BUT mostly at Cybershot....

Originally posted by Cybershot


Hypocrites.

Say what you will about their crazy regime - and I implore you to do so - but condemning nuke tests when you have a stockpile of active warheads in the thousands is pretty funny.


LOL... so a Unstable regime that has since the 50's threaten the world is a better choice to have nukes vs a regime (up till the bush admin) has been seen by most of the world as a beacon of light and hope. USA has been condemning nuclear testing forever... its a way to stop a weapon from proliferating. There is no need for every country in the world to have nukes. if they did, it just increases the odds that the world will end in nuclear war.

BTW Had Stalin not acted like a nervous twit right after WW2, im sure the stockpiling of nukes would have been a lot different.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Then you said this about their crazy regime.....
Originally posted by Cybershot


And that has to be addressed. For sure.

How does one stop a country that didnt stop when it didnt have nukes and china's full backing.... that you now want to address when they do have Nukes and the full backing of China.

Seems to me you arent a man of history and just say how things "should" be.. this isnt lollipop land.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


You had the luxury of testing them for 40 years...


Yea forty years.. but the Usa hasnt tested them since 1992. Testing Nukes is for one thing only... Improving yields and yield to weight ratios. In other words... Multi nuclear warheads.

So let me get this straight.... a few quotes back you are saying NK needs to be stopped... then you are saying countries should all be testing nukes, cause the US had 40 years of testing? GG

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Honestly, they need to focus on the negatives of the regime in these stories, and not the fact that they have weapons that can hurt other countries. The point that should be pushed is they are a horrible regime, and are violating many human rights laws.

Edit: The world always takes notice when it's their asses on the firing line.


So... for 50 years, the world hasn't put sanctions on them for all the human right violations? The press never put of stories of all the human right violations? There arent any booked published about it? No people ever excaped from NK and told anyone anout it? No movies of teh week? you think this is something new? You really have no clue about history do you? This has been going on since the day the Korean war ended.. and has been addressed for decades from the world and the USA... but that lil sticking point of CHINA backing them... nothing was ever able to be done.

See lil one... history would show you that USA and SK had the Korean war won til China entered the war and pushed us both back and almost off the Korean peninsula.... we fought back and got it back to where the demilitarization zone is today. Had there been no china interference... there would be no NK today.

The reason the Nukes are such a big deal now is cause for almost 60 years NK has been insane.... now a insane person has a weapon that can kill millions in a second... that there is no defense against... that can destroy a area of the world for decades...

so keep assuming...

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Stop spewing your garbage. The US is the protector of its investments, and rarely anything else.


So has every one of your post been (garbage).... What country isn't protecting it's interests? even WW2 we were doing the same thing. but the US has done more non investment protections then canada ever has.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


I highly doubt his aids woul follow such an instruction.

BTW my stance it to aggressively dethrone that regime NOW, and not because of the damn nukes. But because of the starving people who are being brainwashed on a daily basis.


Again... no sense of history or why the Korean war happened in the first place.. Also many countries where people are being starved and brainwashed... where are you defending them? Canada, the worlds defender!!! with no army, air force or navy to worry about... talking about saving the world. easy to talk trash when your "big brother" has all the muscle, Eh? Would love to see Canada go into Dafur or Somalia solo and solve the worlds issues...

As for dethroning him now.... History, go read the North Korean war.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


I think his aids would not follow through on an order to start a nuclear war for a dying man. Just my opinion, and not based on anything but human nature.


Ah... the thoughts of one who knows nada. His "aides" are his military generals... they arent his aides btw... they are the North Korean ARMED FORCES GENERALS. they run the show there.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


a) no they can't be trusted, as proven by several bogus wars, lying to the people to get into such wars, and, until now, the only country to have used the nukes in an offensive manner.


You really need to learn history dude... cause the amount on talking out of your ass is insane.

1- USA warned Tokyo about the atomic weapons.
2- USA gave them multiple chances to surrender.
3- EVERYONE but you stated... people who have a clue... that dropping the bomb on japan saved lives.
4- those bombs were dropped more 60 years ago. wasn't you me or our parent who did that. so keep up with that arguement... you are winning.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Well...to my earlier point. They equipped the Afghans in order to fight the Russians, who needed control of the region in order to build a pipeline. This is what I mean by protecting their assets. Fighting covert wars and equipping highly dangerous people in order to maintain a dominant position is BS, if you ask me. Mind you own business on your own land, and things will work out. Start thrusting your peen into matters that don't need you, and you will engender hate and retaliation.


Ask the afghans who got stream rolled in the 80s who were the dangerous people.... BTW the Russians were the major world threat in the 80's... wars all over and had massive amounts of nukes and even threatened to use em... see Cuba.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Japan really wasn't a real threat tbh. Should have been on Germany imo, if anything.


LMAO..... LMAO.... LMAO.... LMAO

Again... HISTORY... read it.

You must be 16 and haven't studied history 101 yet. The atomic bomb was ready to be used AFTER Germany surrendered. A lil military thing called the Manhattan Project.

Ask anyone who was alive back then in the pacific theater on iwo jima or midway.... Oh yea ask the armys who were in Europe getting ready to be SHIPPED to japan who was the real threat was then.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


They won't be able to send them to NY from NK, ever.


Please learn to use facts... stop talking out of your... you know what.

Taepodong-2
http://www.missilethreat.com/missilesoftheworld/id.166/missile_detail.asp


I guess hawaii alaska and the west coast doesnt count as United states... so dont you worry guys.. they cant hit NY!!!!

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Prove it. Prove it that they were needlessly slaughtering people. Propaganda imo.
(He is talking about USSR going into Afghanistan and NOT killing their people.)

OMG HISTORY once again....

In 1979, the USSR took control of the Afghan capital, Kabul, and tried through the following decade to gain control over the whole country and its people. The invasion was a failure, costing thousands of lives and having serious consequences still felt today.

To better understand the reason for the Soviet invasion and failure, first one must understand the geography and culture in Afghanistan. The land is mountainous and arid. Jagged, impassable ranges divide the country and make travel difficult. Due to these physical divisions, the people are extremely provincial, with more loyalty to their specific clan or ethnic group than to a government or a country. The people are Muslims, and extremely religious and conservative. The majority ethnic group is the Pashtun, but there are over ten minority groups.

Starting in the 1950s, the USSR began giving aid to Afghanistan. The Soviets built roads, irrigation and even some oil pipelines. In the 1970s, a Communist party overthrew the monarchy and tried to institute social reforms. The rural populations saw land distribution and women's rights as alien to their traditional Islamic culture, a culture in which polygamy, covering of women, and blood for blood practices are accepted. The Communist governments in Kabul in the 1970s lacked the popular support of the rural population.

The Invasion

The Soviets sent troops into Afghanistan in 1979 for a number of reasons. First, they wished to expand their influence in Asia. They also wanted to preserve the Communist government that had been established in the 1970s, and was collapsing because of its lack of support other than in the military. Third, the Soviets wanted to protect their interests in Afghanistan from Iran and western nations.

The Soviets brought in over one hundred thousand soldiers, secured Kabul quickly and installed Babrak Karmal as their puppet leader. However, they were met with fierce resistance when they ventured out of their strongholds into the countryside. Resistance fighters, called mujahidin, saw the Christian or atheist Soviets controlling Afghanistan as a defilement of Islam as well as of their traditional culture. Proclaiming a "jihad"(holy war), they gained the support of the Islamic world. The US gave them weapons and money. The mujahidin employed guerrilla tactics against the Soviets. They would attack or raid quickly, then disappear into the mountains, causing great destruction without pitched battles. The fighters used whatever weapons they could take from the Soviets or were given by the US. Decentralized and scattered around Afghanistan, the mujahidin were like a poisonous snake without a head that could be cut off. There was no one strong central stronghold from which resistance operated.

Theres a quick history lesson for you... free of Propaganda. BTW im sure they took Kabul. without firing a single shot or killing anyone.
Your opinions as of yet... 1 out of 10 rating.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


If Germany had indeed surrendered at that point (fuzzy on the timeline), you guys could have focused entirely on Japan. = not a threat.


May 7, 1945 - Date Germany officially surrendered to the world (fighting mainly stopped before then)
August 6, 1945 - Date US drops atomic bomb on Hiroshima
August 9, 1945 - Date Atom bomb hits Nagasaki

Yay!!! history and dates... Fuzzy math for cybershot.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


I'm never in favour of bombing a city in order to send a message to the army. That's a massive and cowardly cop out.


Nope you are in favor of more brutal ways.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


I love Americans, I have family in the US.

I hate how ignorant the majority of you are about World politics.


Thank god you are here cyber... so i can show everyone TRUE examples of ignorance about world politics and history.

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Yea I mean, part of the reason to dethrone the regime is to SAVE the people.

Again.. read history and see North Korean War

Cybershot = 0 points.

Originally posted by Cybershot


Albert Einstein said "what have i done" or something like that after the creation of the atomic bomb, his advanced intellect doomed the world

Yep he did.

And most of the scientists involved in the Manhattan Project desperately tried to not have them dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki


And you realize Einstein Wrote the US government pushing them to CREATEnuclear bombs due to the fact Germany was making them. I know... HISTORY.. You really love to take things out of context and make your lil reality.

I will stop quoting the greatness know as Cybershot. It is obvious at how much he need to study history and learn what the past has taught us... mainly about NK china Russia and the USA.

Cyber, please stop posting about things you have a huge bias against and dont understand or never cared about learning. You didnt add one thing to this convo that was truthful.

Cybershot = 0 points.
How is this guy a mod???


Wow man, relax. These are my opinions. They have nothing to do with being a mod.

As for most of my points, I think you failed to see them. I'm not saying it's good to test bombs, I'm not saying they should even have a right to do so. I don't support them in any way.

What I said - please go back and check - is that it is hypocritical for an nation with thousands of warheads to condemn another for actions and policies they themselves practiced for...what 50 years (1943'ish to 1993'ish)?

edit: oh hey you're the guy I had to suspend because you wanted to bomb mecca. No wonder you put this little piece together.
Edited by Cybershot on May 28, 2009 11:49:45
 
Wylker
offline
Link
 
God this thread is fucking awful.
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roughneck
Originally posted by captobvious

Originally posted by Roughneck


Originally posted by Roughneck
US cannot afford to start another military campaign, and frankly, after watching their butchering of operations in the middle east, am unconvinced that they have the aggression necessary to efficiently defeat the much more psychotic NKs, than the Iraqi's. Even if the Koreans couldn't beat the US, they'd make a policy of smashing everything that stands, just on principle.


Iraq was a disaster because there was no plan to win the peace after the regime was toppled. Standing by and watching looting was pretty stupid. Disarming the army and police, sending them home without jobs, was pretty stupid.

Winning the peace in North Korea would be pretty simple, since, like in most dictatorships, he's not particularly well liked.

1) Defeat his army in the field.
2) Use his army and police, under US supervision, to protect law and order.
3) Bring and distribute food.

captobvious - How are you going to defeat his army in the field without him showering Seoul with rockets and arty just for kicks?


I don't recall ever saying they wouldn't.

Originally posted by
There'd be high civilian losses, US morale is at a low right now.


I'm not seeing the relationship between the two.

Originally posted by
There is NO way that there would be an occupation in NK by the US, Iraq-style. Once again, too many fronts. What's great in America is not so good in the rest of the world. Tech weapons cost money and with defeat of NK, there is no real economic advantage, actually, disadvantage....... ignore and send black ops as needed.


Any invasion of NK would be preceeded by a pull-out from Iraq. One less front.

Anyway, I think you're setting up a straw man argument here. I am not advocating for an invasion of NK. I'm simply countering some of your arguments that an occupation of NK would turn out worse than Iraq.

North Koreans would not be "more psychotic" than Iraqis. They are not burdened by a poisonous religion. They are not divided into three different cultural factions.
 
Link
 
Well from day to night and night to day. No one can stop it. Same way poor becomes rich and rich becomes poor. the weak become powerful and the powerful becomes weak.
 
Roughneck
offline
Link
 
Why hit high-density civilian targets? - to make the enemy (US/SK) add the resources needed to stabilize, repair and occupy areas not close to the combat front.
"defeat his army in the field" - Jong WILL look for civvy targets - they are unavoidable in a dense country like SK.
1- There will be high civilian losses.
2- US morale is very low right now.
2 separate ideas, but both similiar in that neither strengthens an armies will to fight with valor.

Koreans have a major pride going on. It's not a war about religion. It's politically motivated and racially fueled, but on more of a basis of ideologies and ethical differences between the two ~ like Vietnam. Remember how Viets hated the French with passion. Sux to be US and have same skin color.
There is no pull-out from Iraq - we need that oil.
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Roughneck
Why hit high-density civilian targets? - to make the enemy (US/SK) add the resources needed to stabilize, repair and occupy areas not close to the combat front.
"defeat his army in the field" - Jong WILL look for civvy targets - they are unavoidable in a dense country like SK.
1- There will be high civilian losses.
2- US morale is very low right now.
2 separate ideas, but both similiar in that neither strengthens an armies will to fight with valor.


Attacks on civillians have, historically, hardened an army's resolve to fight. This has been proven time and time again.

Originally posted by
Koreans have a major pride going on. It's not a war about religion. It's politically motivated and racially fueled, but on more of a basis of ideologies and ethical differences between the two ~ like Vietnam. Remember how Viets hated the French with passion. Sux to be US and have same skin color.


Epic fail. South and North Koreans are the same race. We don't know the true ideology of the people, because all we hear is state propaganda.

And the Vietnam divide does not apply here... the South Vietnamese government was horribly corrupt and inept, while South Korea's government is stable and well respected. South Korea has a strong economy, and North Korea is starving. The leadership of the North had all the credibility in Vietnam. The opposite is true in Korea.

Originally posted by
There is no pull-out from Iraq - we need that oil.


Ever?

They have a government, and an army. They can take responsibility for themselves. Extracting the US troops would make Iraq less prone to violence... too many of the insurgents are jihadists specifically attracted to the idea of attacking American targets.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.