Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
What about Patrick Willis? He would more reflect the first guy you mentioned...
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
What about Patrick Willis? He would more reflect the first guy you mentioned...
Skanker irl
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
I agree with this
I agree.
I don't think there is a problem with Power Backs. People just build their defensive players with lots of speed and agility.
The flaw is in how players are building their defenders. Much like how people were incorrectly building their linemen against DEs. I'd hate to see another nerf because of that.
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
I agree with this
I agree.
I don't think there is a problem with Power Backs. People just build their defensive players with lots of speed and agility.
The flaw is in how players are building their defenders. Much like how people were incorrectly building their linemen against DEs. I'd hate to see another nerf because of that.
norseman
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Korwin
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Yeah, each player has a balance attribute that is lowered when they run into other players, etc, and refills when they move around not running into stuff. If it reaches zero, they fall down. Breaking a tackle reduces balance, and then if another comes along right away it's likely to be a tackle. That's the current GLB method of "gang tackles."
Something about that sentence does not sit right with me, and the reason for that is this one particular play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213421&pbp_id=5400377
Not your usual cupcake routing or anything like that, this was just a regular season game between two division rivals. A pretty low scoring affair with this play giving the scoring team the winning edge. Is this just an anomaly? Or is there a realistic explanation out there for what happened on this play?
I'm interested to see if Bort has a response to this, genuine curiosity is making me post this - there is no ill intent or any background meaning to this post. I'd be happier asking this if I was not involved in the team it happened against but sure thats the only reason I saw the play anyway!
Originally posted by Korwin
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Yeah, each player has a balance attribute that is lowered when they run into other players, etc, and refills when they move around not running into stuff. If it reaches zero, they fall down. Breaking a tackle reduces balance, and then if another comes along right away it's likely to be a tackle. That's the current GLB method of "gang tackles."
Something about that sentence does not sit right with me, and the reason for that is this one particular play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213421&pbp_id=5400377
Not your usual cupcake routing or anything like that, this was just a regular season game between two division rivals. A pretty low scoring affair with this play giving the scoring team the winning edge. Is this just an anomaly? Or is there a realistic explanation out there for what happened on this play?
I'm interested to see if Bort has a response to this, genuine curiosity is making me post this - there is no ill intent or any background meaning to this post. I'd be happier asking this if I was not involved in the team it happened against but sure thats the only reason I saw the play anyway!
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
EastBayFunk
offline
offline
Originally posted by Octowned
Putting a break tackle penalty on going slow is a troublesome thing, especially for the PeeWee leagues and expansion leagues. Going fast, and being strong, is simply impossible until you're like level 30, just b/c of SP available.
I think elusive backs should be much much easier to tackle without strength as well. Too many backs have 25 strength, which is just absurd. They should get launched 5 yards back when tackled and lose a ton of energy with that sort of mismatch. Though, this isn't about elusive backs... (my powerback answer was a few pages back)
Well speed is all relative. You could make it relative to the defender.
A fast defender will be able to unload on a big, slow player if the gap in speed is too wide.
Putting a break tackle penalty on going slow is a troublesome thing, especially for the PeeWee leagues and expansion leagues. Going fast, and being strong, is simply impossible until you're like level 30, just b/c of SP available.
I think elusive backs should be much much easier to tackle without strength as well. Too many backs have 25 strength, which is just absurd. They should get launched 5 yards back when tackled and lose a ton of energy with that sort of mismatch. Though, this isn't about elusive backs... (my powerback answer was a few pages back)
Well speed is all relative. You could make it relative to the defender.
A fast defender will be able to unload on a big, slow player if the gap in speed is too wide.
Robbnva
offline
offline
I built my LB to be a power tackler and I already posted a few pages back, he had 10 tackles and no missed tackles today
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by Iceman16
Yeah Bort, Brandon Jacobs runs in the mid-4.5s. Do you really think 50 speed and 60 agility is 4.5 territory?
Yeah Bort, Brandon Jacobs runs in the mid-4.5s. Do you really think 50 speed and 60 agility is 4.5 territory?
Originally posted by norseman
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Korwin
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Yeah, each player has a balance attribute that is lowered when they run into other players, etc, and refills when they move around not running into stuff. If it reaches zero, they fall down. Breaking a tackle reduces balance, and then if another comes along right away it's likely to be a tackle. That's the current GLB method of "gang tackles."
Something about that sentence does not sit right with me, and the reason for that is this one particular play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213421&pbp_id=5400377
Not your usual cupcake routing or anything like that, this was just a regular season game between two division rivals. A pretty low scoring affair with this play giving the scoring team the winning edge. Is this just an anomaly? Or is there a realistic explanation out there for what happened on this play?
I'm interested to see if Bort has a response to this, genuine curiosity is making me post this - there is no ill intent or any background meaning to this post. I'd be happier asking this if I was not involved in the team it happened against but sure thats the only reason I saw the play anyway!
I would lean towards anomaly more than anything. That doesn't happen often at all.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Korwin
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Yeah, each player has a balance attribute that is lowered when they run into other players, etc, and refills when they move around not running into stuff. If it reaches zero, they fall down. Breaking a tackle reduces balance, and then if another comes along right away it's likely to be a tackle. That's the current GLB method of "gang tackles."
Something about that sentence does not sit right with me, and the reason for that is this one particular play:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=213421&pbp_id=5400377
Not your usual cupcake routing or anything like that, this was just a regular season game between two division rivals. A pretty low scoring affair with this play giving the scoring team the winning edge. Is this just an anomaly? Or is there a realistic explanation out there for what happened on this play?
I'm interested to see if Bort has a response to this, genuine curiosity is making me post this - there is no ill intent or any background meaning to this post. I'd be happier asking this if I was not involved in the team it happened against but sure thats the only reason I saw the play anyway!
I would lean towards anomaly more than anything. That doesn't happen often at all.
Knicksfan20
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
I agree with this
I agree.
I don't think there is a problem with Power Backs. People just build their defensive players with lots of speed and agility.
The flaw is in how players are building their defenders. Much like how people were incorrectly building their linemen against DEs. I'd hate to see another nerf because of that.
And then we are back where we started...Speed offensive players kill all...
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW
The problem, essentially, is how players have been built thus far. This game is all about speed and agility, where in reality the other attributes should have more of an influence.
Here is a typical LB (around level 40) build:
Strength: 50
Tackling: 50
Vision: 60
Agility: 70
Speed: 90
Why in the world is the LB having 80+ speed? In real life, a LB would have stats more on par with:
Strength: 65
Tackling: 70
Vision: 60
Agility: 65
Speed: 60
A LBs job is to blow up the run game. You know, punish those RBs that get past the LoS. They don't miss many tackles, and are usually the best tacklers on the field. They don't need lights out speed because they are covering TEs (Balanced/Blocking TEs...If you have a Receiving TE you treat him as a WR IMO and put a CB on him).
I agree with this
I agree.
I don't think there is a problem with Power Backs. People just build their defensive players with lots of speed and agility.
The flaw is in how players are building their defenders. Much like how people were incorrectly building their linemen against DEs. I'd hate to see another nerf because of that.
And then we are back where we started...Speed offensive players kill all...
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
norseman
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
I would lean towards anomaly more than anything. That doesn't happen often at all.
Thats what I was thinking/hoping for - at least now I know that player is not superman!
Thanks for the feedback.
I would lean towards anomaly more than anything. That doesn't happen often at all.
Thats what I was thinking/hoping for - at least now I know that player is not superman!
Thanks for the feedback.
Nuge20
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
I say you make an announcement that tackling is now more important, everyone will add it and problem solved??????????????/
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
I say you make an announcement that tackling is now more important, everyone will add it and problem solved??????????????/
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
I say you make an announcement that tackling is now more important, everyone will add it and problem solved??????????????/
Not at ALL.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, dragging people isn't all you'll do. Breaking a tackle and getting 3 yards is about the same as dragging a tackler 3 yards.
Yes, but if you are dragged instead of flattened, you don't get the ugly "missed tackle" stat.
good? because that isnt a missed tackle
if you dragged him and he let go, then its a missed tackle..if you drag him and he brings you down...it is a tackle
That's what I'm getting at - people generally aren't upset when the make the tackle and the guy gains an additional couple of yards at the end. They are upset when they see "I missed 5 tackles!!! WTF"
I say you make an announcement that tackling is now more important, everyone will add it and problem solved??????????????/
Not at ALL.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























