User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Waltang
I think the real problem may be entirely being missed.

There was a HUGE variation to completion %.

Bort acknowledges that he intended to decrease the completion % by approximately 10%, which I would actually have agreed with. Where the real problem looks to me, is in the # of dropped passes. In most all of the games I have looked at, go and figure up the number of dropped passes as completions, and the complete % would be about what it should have. The real culprit looks to me as if it may be the stamina/chemistry issues affecting recievers.

If that is the case, then the change bort reversed to passing accuracy is not going to make a significant change.



I think he already stated this as being the main reason.
 
that_guy820
offline
Link
 
My teams tactits was set to run more than pass, with the setting so the computer couldn't override my play calling. We still threw was more than we ran. Something is definitely messed up here.
 
sbq80
offline
Link
 
Granted lower Lvl QB should not be completing passes in the 80s but we also dont need to turn this into a run & run only game. Where if you want to compete @ the higher divisions you need to just pound the rock.
If a team wants to build their team to be all pass than they should not be penalized for that.
Last edited May 2, 2008 18:47:55
 
CWickson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Originally posted by JoeRedneck

So were stuck with the sim result even though we game planned for what we though were known settings?



Probably. It is beta.


I don't care about the sim results, personally, since it effected everyone, and it's still a game in Beta, in season two, and it's one game.
 
B-T-A
offline
Link
 
Someone High Up had to fuck w/ the System or something cuz I just did my Power Rankings and all the QB's performances were WAY worse than what they were the previous weeks, I think this is a little fucked up.
 
treygreen13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by that_guy820
My teams tactits was set to run more than pass, with the setting so the computer couldn't override my play calling. We still threw was more than we ran. Something is definitely messed up here.


You lost by 30 points, your QB was trying to bring you back.
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
look there's no other explanation...it's simple...regardless if you are lvl 10 or your lvl 20...there should be no difference in completion percentage...your not playing yourself...your playing other defenses...so there is no pro...college or high school....just because you bought a team in the pro or in the asian or in the european...everyone is the same...the pro thing is over-rated...why because you were put in pro...lol the only ones that should be better are the ones that moved up for winning...everyone else was put there....and back to the qb issue...i could see if you had a lvl 11 qb...playing against lvl 16 cbs....then it's understandable your gonna miss more passes....but when you have a lvl 11 qb playing lvl 6 cb's there no way you should throw a 30% completion ratio...just not sound...as when you get higher level with your qb...so does the defenses.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Using Bort's logic that QBs are really very low level right now, should the same be true for running backs? We should all be running for 2 yards a carry if things are going to be equal.


Not really. Low-level QBs can still make more unforced errors that is not dependent on level of competition.
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Originally posted by wombat killer

Using Bort's logic that QBs are really very low level right now, should the same be true for running backs? We should all be running for 2 yards a carry if things are going to be equal.


Not really. Low-level QBs can still make more unforced errors that is not dependent on level of competition.


to an extent...but some plays today were ridiculous.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Originally posted by wombat killer

Using Bort's logic that QBs are really very low level right now, should the same be true for running backs? We should all be running for 2 yards a carry if things are going to be equal.


Not really. Low-level QBs can still make more unforced errors that is not dependent on level of competition.


So then we should all abandon the passing game as running will be much more effective right now. Great plan.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
What plan? I didn't say today's results should be the norm. But it also isn't true that a lvl 50 QB going against a lvl 50 D should necessarily have the same completion % as a level 5 QB going against a lvl 5 D. The level 5 QB should make more errant throws not tied to level of competition.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devin00
look there's no other explanation...it's simple...regardless if you are lvl 10 or your lvl 20...there should be no difference in completion percentage...your not playing yourself...your playing other defenses...so there is no pro...college or high school....just because you bought a team in the pro or in the asian or in the european...everyone is the same...the pro thing is over-rated...why because you were put in pro...lol the only ones that should be better are the ones that moved up for winning...everyone else was put there....and back to the qb issue...i could see if you had a lvl 11 qb...playing against lvl 16 cbs....then it's understandable your gonna miss more passes....but when you have a lvl 11 qb playing lvl 6 cb's there no way you should throw a 30% completion ratio...just not sound...as when you get higher level with your qb...so does the defenses.


Wrong!

Take a 14 year old QB and have him throw 100 passes, and i guarantee you his % will be lower than a college QBs %. The lower levels havent had the training, or the experience that they get at the college or pro level, plus his body and vision havent developed to the same level. You can totally take any defense out of this equation and it will still hold true, simply because at the higher level, their physical skills are better, their knowledge is better, and their handle on the concept of the QB position is superior. This directly relates to how a lvl 5 QB performs as compared to a lvl 15 QB. It doesnt matter that their receivers overmatch the defenders when the QB cant make the perfect throws, or anticipate exactly when to throw the ball so that it hits his receiver in the chest without altering his route.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
What plan? I didn't say today's results should be the norm. But it also isn't true that a lvl 50 QB going against a lvl 50 D should necessarily have the same completion % as a level 5 QB going against a lvl 5 D. The level 5 QB should make more errant throws not tied to level of competition.


I never said anything about a level 50 QB vs. a level 5 QB. I made a comment about QB vs RB.

 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Originally posted by Devin00

look there's no other explanation...it's simple...regardless if you are lvl 10 or your lvl 20...there should be no difference in completion percentage...your not playing yourself...your playing other defenses...so there is no pro...college or high school....just because you bought a team in the pro or in the asian or in the european...everyone is the same...the pro thing is over-rated...why because you were put in pro...lol the only ones that should be better are the ones that moved up for winning...everyone else was put there....and back to the qb issue...i could see if you had a lvl 11 qb...playing against lvl 16 cbs....then it's understandable your gonna miss more passes....but when you have a lvl 11 qb playing lvl 6 cb's there no way you should throw a 30% completion ratio...just not sound...as when you get higher level with your qb...so does the defenses.


Wrong!

Take a 14 year old QB and have him throw 100 passes, and i guarantee you his % will be lower than a college QBs %. The lower levels havent had the training, or the experience that they get at the college or pro level, plus his body and vision havent developed to the same level. You can totally take any defense out of this equation and it will still hold true, simply because at the higher level, their physical skills are better, their knowledge is better, and their handle on the concept of the QB position is superior. This directly relates to how a lvl 5 QB performs as compared to a lvl 15 QB. It doesnt matter that their receivers overmatch the defenders when the QB cant make the perfect throws, or anticipate exactly when to throw the ball so that it hits his receiver in the chest without altering his route.


yes to a point...but noone is a pro...and noone is a college qb here...we are all equally the same...
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by methomps

What plan? I didn't say today's results should be the norm. But it also isn't true that a lvl 50 QB going against a lvl 50 D should necessarily have the same completion % as a level 5 QB going against a lvl 5 D. The level 5 QB should make more errant throws not tied to level of competition.


I never said anything about a level 50 QB vs. a level 5 QB. I made a comment about QB vs RB.



And I said its not true that the RB should be running for less yards. Low-level QBs in real life make unforced errors that result in incompletions (for example, overthrowing a WR). That is a mistake that isn't dependent on the level of competition. Thus, a higher-level QB might have a higher completion % even if he is still facing competition that is at his same level.

Short of RBs tripping over their feet, what mechanism would you say would cause lvl 5 RBs to only have 2 ypc against lvl 5 defenses?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.