User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The_Kirk
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Madcow8me


again, his speed is 30ish



30 speed vs 70 speed is going to get abused like that.

blocking doesn't even come into play unless they lock up.


Maybe, but on a run, shouldn't that little DE be killed as well? Off tackle plays should be going for 10 yards a carry.


If you go back a few pages in the Bugs forum, you'll find the thread that talks about how unfair it is that off-tackle plays are so dominant.

EDIT: here it is: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1284027
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 15:06:47
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Warlock, those are good (and interesting) points. I'm not sure, however, that technique is completely separated out from attributes as GLB is currently designed. For example, I'm fairly certain that pass rushing techniques are available to players who don't have the points in their pass rushing SAs.

As for the value of speed to an OT, part of the issue is that it's very difficult (I imagine) to replicate in this game what goes into making a good OT in real life, as real life success isn't really just a confluence of a dozen discrete traits. I'd agree with you that in real life straight-line speed is of little value to an OT, but the ability to quickly move to keep your center of gravity in front of the DE is very important. In GLB, that ability seems to require a combination of speed, agility and vision (and, once the block is made, blocking to keep the DE engaged). At some level, I think vision, agility and blocking (and, maybe, some of the SAs) should be all that are needed to keep an OT in front of the faster DEs (there are very few successful OTs in real life that are not very agile, though sometimes their sheer enormity makes it hard to see), but the sim is designed so that speed plays a role in lateral quickness, and so it's necessary for OTs in this game.

I guess what I'm trying to say with all my babbling is that, while we might all want the attributes in this game to reflect perfectly what those words mean in real life (just ask any of the many agents of kickers who wonder why the hell "Jumping" is necessary for kicking), they don't and it would be hard to make them do so. "Speed" isn't really speed, "Agility" isn't really agility, etc. . .

In my view, so long as some combination of the attributes can make an OT successful against a speed DE (and it doesn't include jumping, kicking, throwing or punting), then I think it's ok, and just a function of figuring the game out. I just worry that large-scale nerfing of existing successful builds is a bad thing at this point in the game if there are other ways to solve the problem (like increasing morale/stamina degrading effects on low-strength DEs). While there's an argument that speed/agility DE builds are an exploit that should be nerfed, the OTs that were built to counter them weren't exploiting anything, and nerfing them would be a bad result.


Unfortunately, there is a problem with that out-look. I mentioned it previously, the issue is that OTs need more raw attributes to counter the successful speed rushing DEs, than the speed rushing DEs need to be successful. It's imbalanced currently.

Add in the fact that speed and agility for DEs, can easily compensate for a lack of strength. While the same doesn't hold true for OTs, speed and agility do not compensate for a lack of blocking and/or strength. Speed rushing DEs hardly ever get pancaked.

Either way, the system is broken and something needs to be done to balance it.
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Needs more vision IMO.
 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
Doesnt anyone have an example of a SPD/AGI OT. How do we know they need STR to work. I am building an entire O-line right now that will be AGI/BLK based. SPD will be high for the OT's and STR will be higher for the G's.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Doesnt anyone have an example of a SPD/AGI OT. How do we know they need STR to work. I am building an entire O-line right now that will be AGI/BLK based. SPD will be high for the OT's and STR will be higher for the G's.


They'll work about as well as a receiving TE. Unless you also mean having a decent amount of blocking and vision, in which case we're back at the problem of needing 4 attributes (5 if you want strength too), while DEs only need 3 (agility, speed and vision).
 
IrishEyes
offline
Link
 
Jesus, now i know what it's like to be fitted with cement shoes...that DE was enjoying a coke and a slice of pizza before the OT came outta his stance.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by Madcow8me


speed is 30ish


For a LOT that is low, you could get away with that with a C but not a LOT


It's ridiculous for that to be low. How many offensive linemen run as fast as the slower LB's in real life (the soft-capped speed that some think OT's should have to have)?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Welsh76

Originally posted by Madcow8me



speed is 30ish


For a LOT that is low, you could get away with that with a C but not a LOT


It's ridiculous for that to be low. How many offensive linemen run as fast as the slower LB's in real life (the soft-capped speed that some think OT's should have to have)?


It is no use comparing OT's to LB's. We all knew that was a flaw coming into this that DT's could be just as fast as WR's. Nothing we can do about that now.

That being said, you should be comparing the speed of of players who match up against OT's (DE's).

LB's match up to the skills of the HB. CB's match up to WR's. SS's with TE is passing game and HB's in running game.

Just because LB's are as fast as CB's doesn't mean that you shouldn't have your OT's equal to the speed of the guys they face (or at least near it).



So far, my team's OT's have allowed 0 sacks in 3 games. They are 100% in preventing a sack by a DE. The only sacks have come from LB overloads (3 of them in 3 games).

Personally, I think pass protecting is too easy right now. There is no way to get a sack with the new RB/TE being allowed to stay in.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Warlock, those are good (and interesting) points. I'm not sure, however, that technique is completely separated out from attributes as GLB is currently designed. For example, I'm fairly certain that pass rushing techniques are available to players who don't have the points in their pass rushing SAs.

As for the value of speed to an OT, part of the issue is that it's very difficult (I imagine) to replicate in this game what goes into making a good OT in real life, as real life success isn't really just a confluence of a dozen discrete traits. I'd agree with you that in real life straight-line speed is of little value to an OT, but the ability to quickly move to keep your center of gravity in front of the DE is very important. In GLB, that ability seems to require a combination of speed, agility and vision (and, once the block is made, blocking to keep the DE engaged). At some level, I think vision, agility and blocking (and, maybe, some of the SAs) should be all that are needed to keep an OT in front of the faster DEs (there are very few successful OTs in real life that are not very agile, though sometimes their sheer enormity makes it hard to see), but the sim is designed so that speed plays a role in lateral quickness, and so it's necessary for OTs in this game.

I guess what I'm trying to say with all my babbling is that, while we might all want the attributes in this game to reflect perfectly what those words mean in real life (just ask any of the many agents of kickers who wonder why the hell "Jumping" is necessary for kicking), they don't and it would be hard to make them do so. "Speed" isn't really speed, "Agility" isn't really agility, etc. . .

In my view, so long as some combination of the attributes can make an OT successful against a speed DE (and it doesn't include jumping, kicking, throwing or punting), then I think it's ok, and just a function of figuring the game out. I just worry that large-scale nerfing of existing successful builds is a bad thing at this point in the game if there are other ways to solve the problem (like increasing morale/stamina degrading effects on low-strength DEs). While there's an argument that speed/agility DE builds are an exploit that should be nerfed, the OTs that were built to counter them weren't exploiting anything, and nerfing them would be a bad result.


Unfortunately, there is a problem with that out-look. I mentioned it previously, the issue is that OTs need more raw attributes to counter the successful speed rushing DEs, than the speed rushing DEs need to be successful. It's imbalanced currently.

Add in the fact that speed and agility for DEs, can easily compensate for a lack of strength. While the same doesn't hold true for OTs, speed and agility do not compensate for a lack of blocking and/or strength. Speed rushing DEs hardly ever get pancaked.

Either way, the system is broken and something needs to be done to balance it.


speed DE's are getting pancaked alot more. Check the pancakes allowed by my team lately vs last year. Allowing 10 pancakes a game now instead of like 3 a game last year.
 
Porch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
By the way, I should add that if Bort made changes to the sim during the offseason that makes speed/agility rushers more effective, then disregard everything else I've written above. My argument is against nerfing what has been status quo for a long time (as there were ways to counter the fast speed rushers), but if things have changed making speed/agility DEs more overpowering, then I'm all for toning it back down to what it had been in the past. My OT and two higher-level DEs played against a terrible team today, so it's hard to decipher whether things have changed. The preseason games, however, made it look as if things hadn't changed much.


I think that is part of the problem here. This didn't happen last year at all and we played a lot of teams that had great pass rushers and great D's. We gave up a total of 9 sacks last year in the regular season. We played a lot of really good teams and good DE's while doing that and never got abused like this. It just seems like something changed.

I am stuck by two things in these. One our guy barely moved, ever. I mean it looks like he is on a different snap count. I don't mind getting beat but to get beat like that just looks stupid.

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
speed DE's are getting pancaked alot more. Check the pancakes allowed by my team lately vs last year. Allowing 10 pancakes a game now instead of like 3 a game last year.


If a DE is beating a slow OT consistently, a weak DE should be getting pancaked consistently.

I'm referring to the slow/strong OTs that should be mauling the weak DEs in the running game, yet aren't. Slow/strong OTs should give up the ability to pass block well, to gain powerful run blocking, but they only gain the advantage against poor builds... quick/fast DEs should give up the ability to stop the run, to gain great pass rushing, but they don't give up anything against poor builds.

Things need to be a two way street (i.e. balanced). You give up something to gain something else.

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
So, why not institute another factor in the calculations that takes into account the players height/weight so that bigger DE's although fast by DE standard, would be slow compared to a HB/WR with similar speed.

In this way, when being matched against OT's the problem won;t be as large and perhaps the OT's will be better able to react.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
My one plea in all of this, is that Bort decide sooner rather than later whether to do something about this during this season. I'd like to be able to boost my OT and DEs soon, but don't want the game to change on them after I boost and can no longer address the changes this season.
 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
i think that DEs and OTs should've been left alone, instead make it so if a D-linemen doesn't have strength (because all equipment is in speed/agility), he gets pancaked....a lot, even on pass plays. With the demoralizing effect pancakes have (or should have), that speed DE shouldn't be near as effective later on in the game due to low morale. There needs to be a trade-off or a downside if you go 100% speed rush.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Would be just fine if DEs don't get pancaked, but be pushed back a lot. I mean... if a 80 strength guy gets a hand on a punk of 40 strength, the punk should instantly be pushed back a yard or two. This would solve the problem i.m.h.o.: if the DE can manage to get around the OT without beeing touched - fine! Let him get the sack. But if the OT manages to get a block on him, he'd need to step back / change direction a lot and looses his momentum. And the DE will suck badly on runs if he's pushed back easily.

I also don't see the low strength DEs beeing tired enough during run plays. Maybe that's another way to solve the issue: let them tire very fast when going against strong blockers.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.