Originally posted by Gyuri1
Warlock, those are good (and interesting) points. I'm not sure, however, that technique is completely separated out from attributes as GLB is currently designed. For example, I'm fairly certain that pass rushing techniques are available to players who don't have the points in their pass rushing SAs.
As for the value of speed to an OT, part of the issue is that it's very difficult (I imagine) to replicate in this game what goes into making a good OT in real life, as real life success isn't really just a confluence of a dozen discrete traits. I'd agree with you that in real life straight-line speed is of little value to an OT, but the ability to quickly move to keep your center of gravity in front of the DE is very important. In GLB, that ability seems to require a combination of speed, agility and vision (and, once the block is made, blocking to keep the DE engaged). At some level, I think vision, agility and blocking (and, maybe, some of the SAs) should be all that are needed to keep an OT in front of the faster DEs (there are very few successful OTs in real life that are not very agile, though sometimes their sheer enormity makes it hard to see), but the sim is designed so that speed plays a role in lateral quickness, and so it's necessary for OTs in this game.
I guess what I'm trying to say with all my babbling is that, while we might all want the attributes in this game to reflect perfectly what those words mean in real life (just ask any of the many agents of kickers who wonder why the hell "Jumping" is necessary for kicking), they don't and it would be hard to make them do so. "Speed" isn't really speed, "Agility" isn't really agility, etc. . .
In my view, so long as some combination of the attributes can make an OT successful against a speed DE (and it doesn't include jumping, kicking, throwing or punting), then I think it's ok, and just a function of figuring the game out. I just worry that large-scale nerfing of existing successful builds is a bad thing at this point in the game if there are other ways to solve the problem (like increasing morale/stamina degrading effects on low-strength DEs). While there's an argument that speed/agility DE builds are an exploit that should be nerfed, the OTs that were built to counter them weren't exploiting anything, and nerfing them would be a bad result.
Unfortunately, there is a problem with that out-look. I mentioned it previously, the issue is that OTs need more raw attributes to counter the successful speed rushing DEs, than the speed rushing DEs need to be successful. It's imbalanced currently.
Add in the fact that speed and agility for DEs, can easily compensate for a lack of strength. While the same doesn't hold true for OTs, speed and agility do not compensate for a lack of blocking and/or strength. Speed rushing DEs hardly ever get pancaked.
Either way, the system is broken and something needs to be done to balance it.