User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by Savage Smurf

Originally posted by whotookmybowtie


But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


So if i blow up an orphanage but accept jesus i'm not a bad person?


The question is can you accept and love Jesus while knowingly and unrepetently(sp?) blowing up orphanages?


If after blowing up the orphanage you accept Jesus then yes, you are a born again Christian. However I don't believe in Hell so...
 
Booboo Laaug
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


without evil, there is no good because everything is good
if everything is good, there are no decisions for a person to make and thus no free will
with no free will, then how are you to test one's character?
and supposedly the whole reason we are here is to test our character and see where our soul will spend all eternity
that is why God is able to prevent evil, but chooses not to: so that he may test our true character
how can you grade an exam paper when all the multiple choice answers are correct?
without evil, there are no wrong choices.


So...God is "perfect", and he created us, and he wants to test us? If he is perfect, and he created us, shouldn't he already know what we are going to do, making the whole testing part useless?

And why does he want to test us, and punish us if we do the wrong thing?

If somehow there is a magic sky wizard, which I highly, highly doubt, he is one twisted individual. I mean fuck...he makes something that can do wrong, then tells it to not do wrong, then if it does something wrong, he punishes it for all eternity. That is some seriously fucked up shit...

If God cares that man does wrong, why make them able?
If God doesn't care that man does wrong, why punish them?




Just remember, this all started when women fucked us.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie

Originally posted by Savage Smurf


Originally posted by whotookmybowtie



But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


So if i blow up an orphanage but accept jesus i'm not a bad person?


The question is can you accept and love Jesus while knowingly and unrepetently(sp?) blowing up orphanages?


If after blowing up the orphanage you accept Jesus then yes, you are a born again Christian. However I don't believe in Hell so...


The answer is that if you planned on being sorry afterward, then I highly doubt that you would ever truly repent. Thus I would guess that God would never forgive such an act.

non-christians never understand this idea.
 
LoveGoose
offline
Link
 
tbqh I'm not sorry about masturbating, or drinking. And if I had sex I probably wouldn't be sorry about that either.

guess I'm going to Hell.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
If you're a Calvinist, whether you go to heaven or not is all pre-determined, so you might as well do what you want to do as it won't effect the outcome.

If you blow up orphanages, you were going to go to hell anyway, so you might as well do it. If you were going to go to heaven anyway, you might as well do it to because blowing up the orphanage won't get you kicked out.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
But the whole concept of Christianity is that you aren't sent to hell for what you do. It's thing is that you just have to accept Jesus, yadda yadda and that will cover the mistakes you make in life.


The whole concept of Christianity is that you are judged on who you are when you DIE. Not for who you used to be when you were younger.

The big problem though is that no one knows when they are going to die.

The other problem is that "saying" you are a changed man may fool a priest or your fellow humans, but God isn't going to judge you based on your words. He can see what your thoughts and intentions are and were, so the whole, "I'm just going to say I'm sorry on my deathbed" can easily be tossed out.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by MC Goose
tbqh I'm not sorry about masturbating, or drinking. And if I had sex I probably wouldn't be sorry about that either.

guess I'm going to Hell.


Nothing in the Bible about not masturbating. Drinking within moderation is in there somewhere, but this is just a suggestion that would lead to a healthier life. Like not eating pork. It also isn't clear whether those stories only applied for that era or for everyone in the next 400,000 years. If Jesus lived today, he might have mentioned something about not smoking, who knows.

Premarital sex is a sin and not a good idea (especially today with all the diseases going around like AIDS), but having premarital sex is a sin just like disobeying your parents, taking the lord's name in vain, etc etc. None of them mean you will go to hell. All of them will lead you towards an unhealthy lifestyle and away from God though.

Everyone on the planet has sinned and likely will sin again in the future. The key is to work on minimizing/eliminating it.

It is never too late to change. Even if you are currently an atheist. Give it a shot. It can bring you an inner peace that you have never felt before.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 12:34:02
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
lolreligion
 
Armaro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

The other problem is that "saying" you are a changed man may fool a priest or your fellow humans, but God isn't going to judge you based on your words. He can see what your thoughts and intentions are and were, so the whole, "I'm just going to say I'm sorry on my deathbed" can easily be tossed out.

Well, to be fair, someone who is on their death bed probably is truly repentant...if only because of fear.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by klaw19

God is all-powerful... yet won't stop all the fucked up things in the world.

I will not kneel for someone as evil as God.

Theodicy, the main issue theists have struggled with for centuries. Classical theists will deny (subtly) that evil actually exists, while admitting it exists (because it's mentioned in the Bible and is necessary for their world view) by calling it a "real privation of good". They also categorize types of evil, to account for natural disasters, etc. The whole reason they run into this problem, is because of their specific concept of God (as omnipotent, omnipresent and omniscient).

Basically, the Bible doesn't support the classical theist's God concept, and theodicy really arose out of the legacy of the church tradition (the Catholic church. But, really, theism often has little to do with the sacred texts of a religion). Over time, the classical theists conception of God became more and more centered on "coercive" power rather than "persuasive" power, which was all good and fine until the skeptics came along.

Neo-classical theists, or process theists, have a totally different conception of God, and thus a totally different answer to the theodicy problem. They'll say that God is not omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent (in the traditional sense), and claim ignorance to the limits/depths of God's power. Rather they focus on God's ability to persuade via love/compassion, and admit the presence of chaos, which accounts for "evil".

The process theist says, "understand that life is suffering, and philosophize from there".



In English, I think Asheme is trying to say that it isn't as clear as Deathblade and others are making it seem what role God plays in determining our life and personalities.

I think alot of the "God created your destiny" stuff that Deathblade talks about comes from a passage that says something to the effect of that "he knew us before we were in our mother's womb". Another passage talks about how he made is in his likeness. And other....that he created us from dust/ashes. I don't think any of those clearly states everything we want to know about what control he has over forming our souls.

Maybe all of our souls lived in a kind of purgatory whether there was no evil or any way to prove ourselves as good or bad. God may have known which souls were better than others, but he needed proof to show to those souls that given the opportunity, that they would turn bad. So he created a world of good and evil and plugged those souls into a human body. Then when then human body dies and the soul goes back for judgement, God has a body of work to say, "see all this stuff that you would do? This is why I don't want you with me in heaven". Then maybe they stay in purgatory and get another shot to prove themselves in the flesh. Maybe they were so bad, that they go to hell and never get another shot.

In this way, he still is the creator of their bodies and creator of the world, but he is not the creator of their soul. He just made this world as a place where they can show the quality of their character.


Now that is just my take on things. Everyone has their own theory, but in the end, we don't know.

Now in my vision of God, is he all powerful or not? I mean he can snap his fingers and change anything in the environment that he wants? So yes. But can he change someone's soul and character? I would say no. I think it is up to us to do that on our own. He gave us help in doing that with a book he inspired. But remember, the book isn't perfect because it was written by imperfect humans.

Last edited Oct 13, 2008 13:03:07
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
SI- Try using your brain.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
SI- Try using your brain.



Such intelligence coming from you all the time!

Way to pick apart my argument and theory of God.

You swayed me over to your side I think. o_O
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 13:04:54
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Now in my vision of God, is he all powerful or not? I mean he can snap his fingers and change anything in the environment that he wants? So yes. But can he change someone's soul and character? I would say no. I think it is up to us to do that on our own. He gave us help in doing that with a book he inspired. But remember, the book isn't perfect because it was written by imperfect humans.


If he can change anything in the environment, he can prevent all the evil things from happening to good people.

Earlier you mentioned he can read your thoughts/mind/soul/whatever. If that is the case, he is able to communicate perfectly and the Bible is worded exactly how he wanted it.
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by klaw19

SI- Try using your brain.



Such intelligence coming from you all the time!

Way to pick apart my argument and theory of God.

You swayed me over to your side I think. o_O


You recommended those non-believers to go to Church for a day... I suggested you use your brain for a day.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Armaro
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


The other problem is that "saying" you are a changed man may fool a priest or your fellow humans, but God isn't going to judge you based on your words. He can see what your thoughts and intentions are and were, so the whole, "I'm just going to say I'm sorry on my deathbed" can easily be tossed out.

Well, to be fair, someone who is on their death bed probably is truly repentant...if only because of fear.



Repentant isn't the only criteria.

Also have to believe in God.


Even then, personally, I don't think those souls get in. I think if you have a last minute change of heart, you might get a 2nd chance. If you don't give a shit at all, then you go to hell.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.