User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Tito716

If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Well, you forgot the players in the hihg USA leagues that got their money from gutting teams when they owned more than 1.

And, if that's true, then I truly am fortunate. I just got players to accept low wages for one season and built a slow build team. We are on pace to buy all equipment on time through level 32 for the entire roster. All I did was plow money back into my stadium.

 
Iktomi
offline
Link
 
Crushr

I didn't realize it was a debate. I was not debating. You assumed it was a debate, you were debating. When you said "I don't need any advice from you" I took it as an insult because I am the smartest man in the universe and anyone in their right mind would take advice from the smartest man in the universe. So you insulted me first

Arguement wise most players and owners will want revenue sharing. Most people want socialized health care and social security. If you want to give me free money, hey thats great, which line do I stand in... how much is the good old greenback worth now? I was just hoping that there were people out there that still had some pride in themselves and the work they put forth. "They cheated, we weren't boosted, Bort changed the game."
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 16:21:11
 
lafCowboy
offline
Link
 
I love how teams that make the top 4 are run by financial wizards carefully planning and earning their financial windfall while teams that are 5-8 are run by johnny-come-latelies who somehow managed to schlep their way into the playoffs despite horrible fiscal waste, general lack of planning, and terrible management.

No way the reality could be that generally the top 1-8 teams are all well run but guys in the 1-4 are looking to keep their 30x income bonus for being a little more successful than the guys just short of that. Couldn't possibly be that.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by Tito716



Originally posted by Crushr





You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



Blaming successful teams for making too much money is a gross oversimplification of facts.

A LOT of poor teams pissed their money away chasing victories they failed to achieve. They invested in Free Agents rather than their stadium. The playoff teams were able to make the investment pay off by winning. Then it snowballed.

Once upon a time, all teams were equal, now they are not. Don't assume that the wealthy teams are at fault.
If anything, the waelthy teams should be praised, and the poor teams should be scolded.


And now you are missing the point. You've seen the math done here today. The top 4 teams make over 25 times the amount that the lower 4 seeds do. How is that equitable? I am not blaming them for being successful. But part of their success in most cases can be attributed to having had home playoff games that infused enough cash into their budget so that they could then upgrade more sections in the offseason than the the other 12 teams in the league could. That problem just reinforces itself each season. Mostly the same teams in the playoffs because they can afford to make trades for higher level players that their opponents can touch because they haven't had the financial boom of a home playoff game. I just can't understand the opposition here. Sure you may get 200k less maybe 400k less.. but considering what you already get paid, is it really THAT big of a deal?


Because I took over a lousy resold team 3 seasons ago, and busted my ass to get in to the position to potentially host playoff games. No one gave me anything. I accomplished it all by myself. Now that I am here, I have to share my money with others. I may even have to share my revenues with the team that hosted playoff games last season that I replaced in the top4.



I get it.. This whole thing is about YOU! You obviously do not care about anyone else in this game and have no sympathy for others who are now enduring what you had to endure. Its great people like you that make this country great(sarcasm just in case you don't get that either). Its attitudes like yours that are so self centered that they really shouldn't be shared with others. Seriously, that is the best argument against rev sharing you have????


WTF are you talking about dude? What do these people have to endure? The fact that their team didn't make the top 4 seeds and thus no playoff money? Who are you? Son of Stalin? Get real.
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by wombat killer

I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.


That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.

A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.


so a gutted team should share in the playoff money or a slow build team... ya thats great
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr


You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



So luck is the reason behind people who are successful? If you work just as "hard" and struggle maybe you are 1) not working as hard as you think or 2) your ability is just not on par with others. So the people who work at McDonald should get paid just as much as doctors and lawyers because they "work just as hard"? Which world are you living in?
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tmoon
Crushr

I didn't realize it was a debate. I was not debating. You assumed it was a debate, you were debating. When you said "I don't need any advice from you" I took it as an insult because I am the smartest man in the universe and anyone in their right mind would take advice from the smartest man in the universe. So you insulted me first

Arguement wise most players and owners will want revenue sharing. Most people want socialized health care and social security. If you want to give me free money, hey thats great, which line do I stand in... how much is the good old greenback worth now? I was just hoping that there were people out there that still had some pride in themselves and the work they put forth. "They cheated, we weren't boosted, Bort changed the game."



Well, I have to disagree with at least one point. When you say that 'I was just hoping that there were people out there that still had some pride in themselves and the work they put forth' are you saying that any team that finishes below the top 4 should be ashamed of the effort they put forth? The league I am in is tough. Sure there are about 5 or 6 teams league wide that struggle. Last year I was one of them. I am now in the mid level tier of my league(at least I hope). If the end of the season comes and I miss the playoffs by 1 or 2 teams, I can assure its not because I haven't given it all I could to get into the playoffs and I will be proud of the effort I put forth. This issue has nothing to do with socialized healthcare or anything outside of GLB economics. Can you draw a correalation between them? Sure why not. But they have different issues and different consequences. 1 is real the other is a game so I think that is just a red herring to muddy the debate on the topic. Answer me this and I'll let it go. Do you really feel like its fair that the 1-4 teams get 30 times the cash that the 5-8 teams do? How can those teams be competitive when the top 4 are getting a huge financial advantage? Simple questions and eager to see your response. Thanks!
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toric
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by wombat killer


I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.


That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.

A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.


so a gutted team should share in the playoff money or a slow build team... ya thats great


Well, if it means 5-6 legitimate teams get a leg up as well, so be it. As the owner of a top level team, I'm willing to take that risk if it means making the whole league more competitive.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Crushr



You still aren't getting it are you? The current stadium disparity was CAUSED by the current inequities in playoff payouts yet you are determined that we continue that policy to create an even more lopsided advantage for the lucky teams? (easy I only say lucky because there are many owners who work just as hard but still struggle)

Thats what I find so hard to believe. How could anyone not understand the issues the current system has caused yet still be in favor of it?? OHHHH YEAHHH.. Because they benefited from it and want to continue their little cash cow policy.. NM I get it now.. For you this is about preserving your financial advantage regardless of how you got it or how it affects the game and others who play it.. No need to explain yourself any further. Thanks!



So luck is the reason behind people who are successful? If you work just as "hard" and struggle maybe you are 1) not working as hard as you think or 2) your ability is just not on par with others. So the people who work at McDonald should get paid just as much as doctors and lawyers because they "work just as hard"? Which world are you living in?


In a situation like the one being discussed, where 6-8 teams are extremely close in talent, etc., "luck" can play a significant role in where those teams end up.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by valakar

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by valakar



Tito I took over a team that was in poor shape myself halfway through a season. It had spent almost all the initial ticket sales money on signing new players. Oh the problem was they were giving out bonuses to CPU players thinking they were better then human players of lower level. To end my long story I too built my team up to now benefit from the system in place. As I have said many times I am still in support of what is best for the most teams yet not hurting those in top 4 seeds TOO much to do it. Sometimes you make individual sacrifices for the good of something larger and more important.


If you can set up a system to make sure that the teams receiving the money spend it on seats and not on players or equipment, I am all for it.

I don't need to send teams envelopes of money so they can give 250k to level 12 WRs.



I actually agree with you on that. Maybe like the equipment fund it is set up so can only be used when purchasing seats or stadium sections. Like when you upgrade equipment the equipment fund money shows up otherwise it does not. Could also be used to pay the daily salary as an emergency fund if low on money. Cannot be used in bonuses to free agents. Not exactly sure how to work that out but if that was in place would you agree some type of revenue sharing would be a good idea?


-1

I don't like the idea of telling a team how to spend their money for one thing. Second, what if they need that for lvl 24 or 32 equipment or a bonus for resigning a current player on the roster. We can't be in the business of managing what teams spend money on. If they don't get it, they will eventually fail and someone else will get a shot at it. Just make the payouts equitable and move on.



If they suck and they fail, let them fail with their own money, why the hell would us share the burden of their failure?
 
IamJack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Piemaster
But given there is no home advantage, what would be the point of finishing higher if it wasn't for increased revenue? A lot of the regular season would become pointless.


Penalizing the successful teams to benefit the lower teams...and ruining the desire to seed highly.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Tito716

If every team that missed the playoffs in the first season of every league put a full roster of level 1s on the field and spent all their revenue on stadium upgrades, would anyone in the league be poor?


Yes . . . because those teams would not reap the benefit of playoff revenue.

I'd be willing to bet that if you asked those owners who have maxed out stadiums "What is the #1 factor in completing your stadium build?" the overwhelming majority would not say "fielding a full roster of level ones." They would say, almost across the board . . . "Playoff Revenue."



Wrong. I GM'ed a gutted team, we have not made playoff in 3 seasons, the most we have won was 6 games in a season, but we still manage to build our stadium and are getting competitive without asking or receiving handouts. We are going to complete the level 2 at the beginning of next season. Playoff Revenue is nice, but not having it is not the end of the world. The #1 reason teams can't build their stadiums is because they pay insane amount of salaries to shitty players.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeauxTigahs
Originally posted by Piemaster

But given there is no home advantage, what would be the point of finishing higher if it wasn't for increased revenue? A lot of the regular season would become pointless.


Penalizing the successful teams to benefit the lower teams...and ruining the desire to seed highly.


The same thing goes with nerfing skills all the time. If you want all the teams to be the same level, the same skills, the same income, then what are we wasting our time trying to get better for anyway. It is going to be a coin flip game. I remember season one and two when it was basically a coin flip most of the times. The AI helped to change that, but nerfing skills means players will never be great.
 
Razor
offline
Link
 
What about a winner take more than the loser of a game.....

The home team determines the income based on their stadium, but money isn't distributed until after the game. The winner of the game gets a percentage (say 65%) and the loser gets (say 35%). The home team keeps concessions no matter what the outcome of the game. So the probable out come either way is that money is split but the higher seed (the one that is "supposed" to win the game) comes out ahead either way.

Right now the owner's money income situation sucks, especially for new teams. The amount of money required for level 40+ gear is outrageous. Their is few teams that can handle lvl 40 gear and if the current trend of money required for lvl 48+ gear continues. There isn't enough headroom in the game for any owner to afford it.

I think addressing the "bigger" money issue is more important, in the long run, than playoff revenue sharing.

IMHO
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeauxTigahs
Originally posted by Piemaster

But given there is no home advantage, what would be the point of finishing higher if it wasn't for increased revenue? A lot of the regular season would become pointless.


Penalizing the successful teams to benefit the lower teams...and ruining the desire to seed highly.


If we wer talking about a 50/50 split, you guys would have a valid point.

Since we are not . . . you don't. Home team would still get at least twice as much revenue as the visiting team. Is that not incentive enough?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.