Originally posted by j10er
Three things can happen on a pass, and two of them are bad.
That quote is only looking at a pass in terms of a given play. As GLB does not allow coaches to call individual offensive plays for specific situations (quite unlike RL football) it is necessary to look at "long passing" as a strategy and judge it's effectiveness that way.
In that perspective, an incomplete is not bad. An incomplete is neutral, it does nothing to decrease your chance of winning the game - heck, it even stops the clock for you. Only an incomplete on 3rd or 4th down is bad.
If a QB is getting 60% completion on any pass over 10 yards (the poster I was quoting originally maintained he gets 60% numbers and implied he is mostly a long passer) and is able to call those passes strategically going into a game (i.e. setting the AI to go 100% long passes on 1st, 2nd and 3rd down) then in my book, that is game breaking. It eliminates any reason to run the ball and the defense becomes solely about getting the sack or the INT. That game is not football.
Of course such a strategy would never work against a competitive team in RL because RL teams can adjust their game plans on any given play. However, we must accept that GLB defenses can not do this. Even if they could, what do they do about it? Call dime or quarters every play?
Since they can't lock their speed coverage guys on a speed WR, do they need 5 CBs all of whom have the necessary speed to keep up with a speed WR? If so, how do they ever defend against a possession guy?
A GLB defense can not possibly keep coverage on a competitively levelled offense that has both speed and possession guys - there's always a good chance someone gets "wide open". When you take that "get open past 10 yards" chance and modify it by the "wide open past 10 yards" completion chance, the end result needs to be around 50% or less, or there's just no reason to do anything but long passes - and it's hard to argue that's any more realistic than pro QBs missing wide open pro WRs with frequency. At least that does happen, where as 100% long passing has probably never been used at the pro level.
Three things can happen on a pass, and two of them are bad.
That quote is only looking at a pass in terms of a given play. As GLB does not allow coaches to call individual offensive plays for specific situations (quite unlike RL football) it is necessary to look at "long passing" as a strategy and judge it's effectiveness that way.
In that perspective, an incomplete is not bad. An incomplete is neutral, it does nothing to decrease your chance of winning the game - heck, it even stops the clock for you. Only an incomplete on 3rd or 4th down is bad.
If a QB is getting 60% completion on any pass over 10 yards (the poster I was quoting originally maintained he gets 60% numbers and implied he is mostly a long passer) and is able to call those passes strategically going into a game (i.e. setting the AI to go 100% long passes on 1st, 2nd and 3rd down) then in my book, that is game breaking. It eliminates any reason to run the ball and the defense becomes solely about getting the sack or the INT. That game is not football.
Of course such a strategy would never work against a competitive team in RL because RL teams can adjust their game plans on any given play. However, we must accept that GLB defenses can not do this. Even if they could, what do they do about it? Call dime or quarters every play?
Since they can't lock their speed coverage guys on a speed WR, do they need 5 CBs all of whom have the necessary speed to keep up with a speed WR? If so, how do they ever defend against a possession guy?
A GLB defense can not possibly keep coverage on a competitively levelled offense that has both speed and possession guys - there's always a good chance someone gets "wide open". When you take that "get open past 10 yards" chance and modify it by the "wide open past 10 yards" completion chance, the end result needs to be around 50% or less, or there's just no reason to do anything but long passes - and it's hard to argue that's any more realistic than pro QBs missing wide open pro WRs with frequency. At least that does happen, where as 100% long passing has probably never been used at the pro level.






























