User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


Three things can happen on a pass, and two of them are bad.


That quote is only looking at a pass in terms of a given play. As GLB does not allow coaches to call individual offensive plays for specific situations (quite unlike RL football) it is necessary to look at "long passing" as a strategy and judge it's effectiveness that way.

In that perspective, an incomplete is not bad. An incomplete is neutral, it does nothing to decrease your chance of winning the game - heck, it even stops the clock for you. Only an incomplete on 3rd or 4th down is bad.

If a QB is getting 60% completion on any pass over 10 yards (the poster I was quoting originally maintained he gets 60% numbers and implied he is mostly a long passer) and is able to call those passes strategically going into a game (i.e. setting the AI to go 100% long passes on 1st, 2nd and 3rd down) then in my book, that is game breaking. It eliminates any reason to run the ball and the defense becomes solely about getting the sack or the INT. That game is not football.

Of course such a strategy would never work against a competitive team in RL because RL teams can adjust their game plans on any given play. However, we must accept that GLB defenses can not do this. Even if they could, what do they do about it? Call dime or quarters every play?

Since they can't lock their speed coverage guys on a speed WR, do they need 5 CBs all of whom have the necessary speed to keep up with a speed WR? If so, how do they ever defend against a possession guy?

A GLB defense can not possibly keep coverage on a competitively levelled offense that has both speed and possession guys - there's always a good chance someone gets "wide open". When you take that "get open past 10 yards" chance and modify it by the "wide open past 10 yards" completion chance, the end result needs to be around 50% or less, or there's just no reason to do anything but long passes - and it's hard to argue that's any more realistic than pro QBs missing wide open pro WRs with frequency. At least that does happen, where as 100% long passing has probably never been used at the pro level.

 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Very interesting points, and we're both in the same boat. I think the main difference is that you're saying long passes need to be about 50% completion rate and I'm saying 60% is fine (assuming equal competition, etc, etc) as long as interception chance is increased.

Although I would call an incomplete a bad thing as opposed to a completion of 2.5 yards or more. But that's reall a moot point
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er


Although I would call an incomplete a bad thing as opposed to a completion of 2.5 yards or more. But that's reall a moot point


Not at all, short/medium passing is critically relevant to a discussion on the power balance of long passing. However, the gain is only a positive in a traditional football strategy. If my gameplan is play the 60% chance for a 10+ yard gain so that I only need one play for the 1st down, then that 2.5-9.5 yard completion gets me nothing. I don't see it as a negative, because I still have two (or three) more "60% chances" to get the 1st down in one play - which is exactly the same chance I'd have with a 100% long pass strategy if I gained 9 yards on the play.

In fact, in such a strategy, you can make an argument that any sack that doesn't cost over 5 yards is also neutral, since long passes are 15+ yards.


Last edited Sep 30, 2008 12:01:29
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by j10er



Although I would call an incomplete a bad thing as opposed to a completion of 2.5 yards or more. But that's reall a moot point


Not at all, short/medium passing is critically relevant to a discussion on the power balance of long passing. However, the gain is only a positive in a traditional football strategy. If my gameplan is play the 60% chance for a 10+ yard gain so that I only need one play for the 1st down, then that 2.5-9.5 yard completion gets me nothing. I don't see it as a negative, because I still have two (or three) more "60% chances" to get the 1st down in one play - which is exactly the same chance I'd have with a 100% long pass strategy if I gained 9 yards on the play.

In fact, in such a strategy, you can make an argument that any sack that doesn't cost over 5 yards is also neutral, since long passes are 15+ yards.




The OP did not state he runs 100% (or even near 100%) long passing...we run a very balanced offense but it is aggressive with sufficient long passing thrown in to make DC play deep coverage. He was referencing deep throws as having a problem with open WRs.

Think of the play like this:
Covered - underneath
Covered - deep
Double covered - under and deep
Open - no coverage near
Assume each if for a deep pass. You would expect the open WR to catch the ball probably 2x the frequency of the covered. When open WRs are almost never catching the ball, it would seem something is wrong....that is what this thread is about, and Bort has found a fix and is still testing to make sure it doesn't over-compensate and increase the overall completion percentage too much.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
...

Not at all, short/medium passing is critically relevant to a discussion on the power balance of long passing. However, the gain is only a positive in a traditional football strategy. If my gameplan is play the 60% chance for a 10+ yard gain so that I only need one play for the 1st down, then that 2.5-9.5 yard completion gets me nothing. I don't see it as a negative, because I still have two (or three) more "60% chances" to get the 1st down in one play - which is exactly the same chance I'd have with a 100% long pass strategy if I gained 9 yards on the play.

In fact, in such a strategy, you can make an argument that any sack that doesn't cost over 5 yards is also neutral, since long passes are 15+ yards.


Totally right. But on the other hand, people keep talking about "wide open WRs". So that's a WR already beaten the CB as the pass is thrown.

In OP, all WRs were in GOOD coverage as the pass was thrown. They "gained separation" on their streak routes afterwards by some fake that made the defender freeze. Naturally, the QB didn't know if the fake would work out in the future (at least he shouldn't know: either he waits to see - but then the defender catches up or he throws away from the defender, this making it harder to catch).

While I agree that a (really) wide open WR pass should be completed 70%+, in the situation above the completion percentage should be somewhat below 30%. This making it a 34 % failure rate on three downs and a 24 % failure rate on 4 downs. That's not reliable anymore - but may get you a TD-pass once in a while.
 
Denman
offline
Link
 
More data from one of today's games.

Medium pass incompletion to wide open WR#2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=161916&pbp_id=4099932

Same http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=161916&pbp_id=4100058

One from our opponents http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=161916&pbp_id=4101234 (I guess fair is fair)
 
Link
 
If a pass is made to a wide open receiver-first look at the pass quality, then look at where the pass was actually thrown in relation to the WR's position on the field, then look at the WR's actual catching ability( and all related SA's). That's how I would figure it anyways... (as far as figuring out if that WIDE OPEN receiver should catch the ball)
 
mia1994
offline
Link
 
Here are mine:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=184226&pbp_id=4293733
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=184226&pbp_id=4294444
 
Link
 
Can someone tell me why these are incomplete? These are all wide open incompletions on the same play to the same guy. He caught 160 balls for 2000+ yards last year so don't tell me its the WR.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358182
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358468
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358748
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358763
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4359022

Talk about a glitch.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Can someone tell me why these are incomplete? These are all wide open incompletions on the same play to the same guy. He caught 160 balls for 2000+ yards last year so don't tell me its the WR.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358182
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358468
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358748
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358763
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4359022

Talk about a glitch.


It's actually the QB I'm guessing. The CB read the play and made the pass impossible as he had to space it over him towards the sideline.
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun

It's actually the QB I'm guessing. The CB read the play and made the pass impossible as he had to space it over him towards the sideline.


Read the thread.


Anyone noticing an improvement? Mine seem down, but they're still there.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
I have stripped them from my playbook, and re-equipped all my WRs where possible to avoid the problem.

Strangely all my teams then go on to have their best passing performances of the season.

 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Can someone tell me why these are incomplete? These are all wide open incompletions on the same play to the same guy. He caught 160 balls for 2000+ yards last year so don't tell me its the WR.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358182
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358200
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358468
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358667
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358748
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4358763
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=143225&pbp_id=4359022

Talk about a glitch.


It's actually the QB I'm guessing. The CB read the play and made the pass impossible as he had to space it over him towards the sideline.


Hmm...
 
Melancholy
offline
Link
 
So, was this fixed? There was an announcement about being close to a fix, but did that fix actually go out?
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Melancholy
So, was this fixed? There was an announcement about being close to a fix, but did that fix actually go out?


Unless there's one on the main page, assume no.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.