User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Revenue Sharing - why isnt it in the game?
Page:
 
Kutzy
Child Support
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by Kutzy

Teams do not LOSE anything. NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER should you be rewarded for losing.


No one is being rewarded for losing.

They are being rewarded for bringing their team to the stadium to play before the fans. If only the home team showed up, the fans would not come because there would be no game.

Its called sharing the gate. It's pretty common in sporting events for the reason set forth above.

And in the NFL they do it per a formula to improve competition.

If there was no revenue sharing Green Bay would not be able to field a competitive team, for instance. Or a team at all.

In GLB a little more balance would mean less teams lost to owners that quit, less inactive players.

You LIKE inactive players and sold teams, do ya?


Green Bay cant field a team without it? I cant think of another team who has a more dedicated fan base than them. They get their money without it, if you had used a team like Cleveland, it would allow your post to have more room to stand.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by littlebengal
Remember Revenue sharing is based on non ticket sales income. And since GLB only has ticket sales revenue it doesn't help.

Oh revenue sharing does include luxury suits... still doesn't help most. Need other ways for income, tv contracts, Endorsements and then have that shared.


NFL also shares ticket sales. Not league wide but between the two teams.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
What you are rightfully looking for is a huge economic overhaul of the game, I think. This would be a good start.


+1,000,000
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Originally posted by yello1

Originally posted by Kutzy


Teams do not LOSE anything. NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER should you be rewarded for losing.


No one is being rewarded for losing.

They are being rewarded for bringing their team to the stadium to play before the fans. If only the home team showed up, the fans would not come because there would be no game.

Its called sharing the gate. It's pretty common in sporting events for the reason set forth above.

And in the NFL they do it per a formula to improve competition.

If there was no revenue sharing Green Bay would not be able to field a competitive team, for instance. Or a team at all.

In GLB a little more balance would mean less teams lost to owners that quit, less inactive players.

You LIKE inactive players and sold teams, do ya?


Green Bay cant field a team without it? I cant think of another team who has a more dedicated fan base than them. They get their money without it, if you had used a team like Cleveland, it would allow your post to have more room to stand.


Green Bay has an extremely dedicated fan base, but they're still a small market. It takes a lot of money to operate a football team. Part of the money is ticket sales, but its also television and advertising market and the money that generates for the league, mechandise sales, etc.
Having a rabid fan base does not necessarily make them a fan base that is attractive to advertisers, or mean the fan base has a large disposable income, on average. It doesn't support the most luxurious facilities that bring in big money.
Its not a knock on anyone, least of all Green Bay fans, who are, indeed, some of the most dedicated anywhere to say that the New York or Dallas market is more attractive to advertising dollars, has a bigger overall market, etc. than Green Bay, WI.

Without revenue sharing, Green Bay and a number of other teams would have trouble staying as viable as they have been.

Revenue sharing is very much a part of most successful pro sports, and definitely should have a place here. While its not a big deal for supporting a team up through level 20-something, recruiting, retention, etc. becomes much, much harder as people start wanting their level 24 and 32 equipment and such if you don't make the top 4 to get a home playoff game with decent fan support.
 
josh2otter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


+1

I like this layout, at the least it keeps the playoffs on the forefront for non-playoff teams
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kutzy
Originally posted by yello1

Originally posted by Kutzy


Teams do not LOSE anything. NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER should you be rewarded for losing.


No one is being rewarded for losing.

They are being rewarded for bringing their team to the stadium to play before the fans. If only the home team showed up, the fans would not come because there would be no game.

Its called sharing the gate. It's pretty common in sporting events for the reason set forth above.

And in the NFL they do it per a formula to improve competition.

If there was no revenue sharing Green Bay would not be able to field a competitive team, for instance. Or a team at all.

In GLB a little more balance would mean less teams lost to owners that quit, less inactive players.

You LIKE inactive players and sold teams, do ya?


Green Bay cant field a team without it? I cant think of another team who has a more dedicated fan base than them. They get their money without it, if you had used a team like Cleveland, it would allow your post to have more room to stand.


In this instance I was referring to revenue sharing as a whole - TV revenue in particular.

TV revenues pay the majority of players salaries. And the players salaries are something like 85% of the cost of running an NFL team.

Without TV revenue sharing Green Bay would not exist as a team.

No matter how loyal their fan base. There just are not enough people there to pay the cost of the 100 million dollar salary cap for the team.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


I like it, but I would go more even handed, 25:20:55 or something like that.

Again, its not a reward for running your team poorly. Its a way to make the conference more balanced so that no one quits in disgust and ruins play for everyone in doing so.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
What you are rightfully looking for is a huge economic overhaul of the game, I think. This would be a good start.


Yes
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by rbedgood

I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


I like it, but I would go more even handed, 25:20:55 or something like that.

Again, its not a reward for running your team poorly. Its a way to make the conference more balanced so that no one quits in disgust and ruins play for everyone in doing so.



I can see changing the math slightly, but anything more than a 10% share for non-playoff teams is rewarding.

I could see 60-30-10 as an alternative to my proposal?! Or even 55-35-10...
Last edited Sep 10, 2008 13:39:35
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by rbedgood

I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


I like it, but I would go more even handed, 25:20:55 or something like that.

Again, its not a reward for running your team poorly. Its a way to make the conference more balanced so that no one quits in disgust and ruins play for everyone in doing so.


No, I'd strongly oppose that. There should be a big reward financially for running a team well.

RBed's numbers are good and fair ones. I especially think visiting playoff teams need their cut.

But you should not get a lot of money just by being in the league. Letting the whole league have a small cut, as RBed suggests, is fine. But just a small cut.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by yello1

Originally posted by rbedgood


I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


I like it, but I would go more even handed, 25:20:55 or something like that.

Again, its not a reward for running your team poorly. Its a way to make the conference more balanced so that no one quits in disgust and ruins play for everyone in doing so.


No, I'd strongly oppose that. There should be a big reward financially for running a team well.

RBed's numbers are good and fair ones. I especially think visiting playoff teams need their cut.

But you should not get a lot of money just by being in the league. Letting the whole league have a small cut, as RBed suggests, is fine. But just a small cut.


Getting alot of money just by being in the league is what makes the NFL the most successful sport in America.

And - again - WINNING is the reward for doing well and should be the only relevant reward.

Money in the game is just the medium by which we try to balance the teams so that everyone has fun.

It should NOT be the medium of IMbalance.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by yello1


Originally posted by rbedgood



I start by saying that I own a playoff team. In fact we even had a home game this year. However I would propose the following split during the playoffs for ticket revenue

65% Home team
30% Visiting team
5% Non-playoff teams

The 'non-playoff' team piece of the pie wouldn't add up to much, but it would be a small source of revenue
In round 1 there would be 16 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 8 games
In round 2 there would be 24 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 4 games
In round 3 there would be 28 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 2 games
In round 4 there would be 30 non playoff teams splitting 5% of 1 game

I would argue this split should be for ticket sales only and that concession sales stay with the home team. As teams get eliminated from the playoffs they'd then get a 'non-playoff' share for the next round, which would be significantly less than the 'playoff round bonus'.


So lets say in round 1 each of the 4 games generates $2,000,000...
The home team would get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would get $600,000
Each non playoff team would get $50,000 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 8 games, 16 teams)

In round 2 (assuming the same $2,000,000)
The home team would again get $1,300,000 + concessions
The visiting team would again get $600,000
And each non playoff team would get about $16,667 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 4 games, 24 teams)

In round 3 (assuming again the same $2,000,000 in ticket sales)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $7,142 (5% share of each game is $100,000, 2 games split by 28 teams)

In round 4 (same $2,000,000)
Home team $1,300,000 + concessions
Visiting team $600,000
Non playoff team $3333 (5% share of each game is $100,000 1 game split by 30 teams)

Yeah the non playoff piece is small, but there shouldn't really be much of a reward for running the team poorly. However the important piece of this is that in each round the gap between a top seeded playoff team and the lower seeded playoff teams is reduced to about a 3:1 ratio. That is much more reasonable.


I like it, but I would go more even handed, 25:20:55 or something like that.

Again, its not a reward for running your team poorly. Its a way to make the conference more balanced so that no one quits in disgust and ruins play for everyone in doing so.


No, I'd strongly oppose that. There should be a big reward financially for running a team well.

RBed's numbers are good and fair ones. I especially think visiting playoff teams need their cut.

But you should not get a lot of money just by being in the league. Letting the whole league have a small cut, as RBed suggests, is fine. But just a small cut.


Getting alot of money just by being in the league is what makes the NFL the most successful sport in America.

And - again - WINNING is the reward for doing well and should be the only relevant reward.

Money in the game is just the medium by which we try to balance the teams so that everyone has fun.

It should NOT be the medium of IMbalance.


This game is not the NFL, and Bort has designed it to have an economic aspect. Albeit there is no current penalty for fiscal irresponsibility, but it is supposed to be coming soon. As such, money is more than a medium to 'balance' the league in this game, but is actually currency and at some level a strategic commodity. You can use currency to build a dynasty, and even if you take a team that isn't very good (the team I GM won 2 games in season 2), you can turn it into a good team and eventually a playoff team within a few seasons (we went 8-8 last season missing the playoffs by 1/2 a game to an 8-7-1 team)...
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Here is my suggestion from last year. While I agree that losers should not be rewarded, there can not be a game if there isn't a loser. The current system is way to top heavy and needs to be spread out more. Money is tight for some teams and constricting their ability to improve, Seeds 1-4 get a monster payday where all others getting practically nothing.
________________________________________________________________________________________

Split playoff ticket sales 60/20/20 each game. 60% to the home team, 20% to the visitor, 20% to the conference pool. Any team not in the playoffs for that round shares equal in the pool. Round 1, there would be 8 teams getting 12.5% share of the pool, round 2 12 teams getting an 8.3% of the pool, round 3 14 teams with 7.1% each, round 4 15 teams with 6.7% each. Get rid of the playoff bonuses, and concessions stay with the home team. League championship, 50% of concessions to each team, 30% tickets to each team, 20% to each conference pool.

The visitor’s share is dependent on the opponents stadium size so it is possible for the 8th seed to make more than the 5th seed, but the 5th seed should have a greater chance to advance and thus make more. 5th plays the 4th so that is the game they should get a share of.

Using $3million in ticket sales a game, $300k in concessions and the favorites winning every game the playoff revenue would look like this:

Place Revenue
1____$7,350,000
2____$4,840,000
3____$2,782,857
4____$2,782,857
5____$782,857
6____$782,857
7____$782,857
8____$782,857
9____$482,857
10___$482,857
11___$482,857
12___$482,857
13___$482,857
14___$482,857
15___$482,857
16___$482,857

This is better than the current model using the same parameters of $3million in ticket sales a game, $300k in concessions and the favorites winning every game:

Place Revenue
1____$14,200,000 to $10,900,000
2____$7,200,000
3____$3,600,000
4____$3,600,000
5____$100,000
6____$100,000
7____$100,000
8____$100,000
9____$0
10___$0
11___$0
12___$0
13___$0
14___$0
15___$0
16___$0

Money is becoming more important as salaries and equipment bonuses increase. If the playoff revenue is not straightened out it becomes increasingly more difficult for teams to catch up. Teams should be rewarded for good performance but not to the level that others can not catchup. As players get past level 24, finances will and should play a part of recruiting.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.