As owner of one of the four teams who submitted a ballot, I thought I'd share my two cents on some of the "controversy" mentioned here so far:
Originally posted by Greg Butler
Kind of suprised not to see Ure in there
While the quality of the team defense wasn't an intentional consideration in determining my votes, I'll admit it crossed my mind. I generally looked through our games to see if any players stood out in games against us, then looked across the conference leaders to see whose names appeared toward the top of multiple stat categories. One place where Ure doesn't come close to the top vote-getters is in Hurries. If I'd made a fourth pick at DT, it might've gone to Ure - who knows?
I was surprised to see your plays/game comparison, though. I didn't look that deeply into it, but wouldn't have guessed it'd be that close. Regardless of his "snub", I think you've got to be proud of Ure's season, especially considering he was regularly overmatched.
Originally posted by yomanpopo
Wow, no love for my QB. 3600 yrds, 358/507 for 70% (highest in the league), 20 TDs. Led the squad to 14-2 record, oh well.
Surprising only 2 of my teams players made it and we are the #2 team in the conference.
3rd in Yds.
1st in Comp %.
2nd in Yds/Att.
12th in Yds/Comp.
3rd in TDs.
7th in TD/INT ratio.A very respectable stat line, and certainly warrants consideration for Pro Bowl votes. It might be hard to make a case against any of the Top 3, though, too.
Originally posted by CarpeDeezNuts
http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=769008&playoffs=0
Really?
138 tackles, and 128 MISSED tackles? I thought I was missing something and this was a parody of some sort, but the other FS, cookie buchanon, actually has good stats.
Neither were on my ballot.
Originally posted by keith_dude
the tomato got screwed!
a level 19 FB with 66 carries for 250.5 yards....
He blocked for a dominant running game! Not my fault my lousy OCs didn't call a FB run.
11 pancakes? Come on!
I found it really hard to compare FBs without a ton of manual effort. If you look at rushing stats, it's nearly all HBs, if you look at blocking stats, it's nearly all OL, if you look at receiving stats, it's nearly all WR/TE. So if someone had assembled a list of all the FBs in the league with all their stats, I might've voted for you. As it was, all I had to go on was FB performances in games against us. You rushed 4 times for 12 yard and fumbled. 0 pancakes. Didn't scream "Pro Bowl" to me.
I'm sure I offended everyone I responded to, so I apologize. Just trying to shed some light on the rationale behind one ballot.

-HT