User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by o5prey
This is an interesting discussion.

I think vision has really hurt my LBers actually. With vision they re-act to running plays sooner and run themselves right into the blockers. before they were more effective with high speed and cut down the ball carriers even for losses by not re-acting so quickly.


i've not had that problem with my LB.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Forbin


Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.



Well, then there are a whloe lot of retards playing in the NFL. When a CB is in coverage, they tend to be concentrating on the receiver that they are covering, and if the ball gets thrown another direction, they often don't get to see that for a few seconds after it is thrown, due to the fact that they have to keep an eye on their receiver.

Pass-rushers are often unable to see when the QB has thrown the ball, because they don't get to keep their eyes focused on the ball, when they are trying to avoid a 300 lb+ offensive lineman.

Remember the Kiwanuka/Vince Young play? Kiwanuka didn't realize that Young sstill had the ball, so he let him go.

Is Mathias Kiwnuka retarded, just because he couldn't see the ball?

If yes, then maybe VISION should make my D-League CB retarded.

If no, then maybe VISION should just make him unable to see the ball thrown most of the time.

How does a QB "pump-fake" work, if you would have to be retarded to be unable to see that the ball wasn't thrown?


Never go full retard boy.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by chief31

Here is my d-league player, CB, Emmitt Thomas HOF.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557580

Once the ball is in the air, he reacts immediately. His VISION is 13. He should be as lost as a Chicago Cubs playoff series, on about every single play.

My player isn't in on this play, but it is D-league players.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557946

Every defender on the feild is after the intended reciever, while the ball is in the air.


Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.


YOu think every defender on the field is watching the QB or the sky? Hell, at least a couple of them will have their backs to the line of scrimmage at any given moment.

The OP has a point.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 07:25:21
 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31


A player with 13 STRENGTH gets run over by stronger players regularly.

A player with 13 SPEED rarely gets anywhere.

But a player with 13 VISION reacts every bit as quickly as the players with 67+ VISION.

I am suggeting that low VISION should cause a slow reaction to the ball in the air, or even knowing when the QB has handed the ball off.


Have you ever seen 2 year old child running? When something all of a sudden falls in their path and a normal 12 would avoid it does the 2 year old avoid it? Is it because he didn't see it? No we aren't talking about a young Ray Charles. I think REACTION should be based on Agility/How fast you can get your body turned around or whatever you have to do Speed/How fast you get to where you need to be Confidence/How sure your player is on his read and yes Vision/ To jump routes etc. Vision shouldn't effect how fast a LB reacts when a QB hands the ball off because the defensive sideline is always yelling RUN or PASS when the offense runs a play. Guess you've never heard that.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 07:27:44
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by o5prey

This is an interesting discussion.

I think vision has really hurt my LBers actually. With vision they re-act to running plays sooner and run themselves right into the blockers. before they were more effective with high speed and cut down the ball carriers even for losses by not re-acting so quickly.


i've not had that problem with my LB.


Maybe it depends on position...a fast/high vision ROLB can make a disproproportionate number of tackles on the far side of the field because they are coming in after the blockers have all committed but before the back has turned upfield.

I've seen high level players in GLB overcommit and get blocked out as a result.

Might be something that will require tweaking.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SKADOODLE
Originally posted by chief31



A player with 13 STRENGTH gets run over by stronger players regularly.

A player with 13 SPEED rarely gets anywhere.

But a player with 13 VISION reacts every bit as quickly as the players with 67+ VISION.

I am suggeting that low VISION should cause a slow reaction to the ball in the air, or even knowing when the QB has handed the ball off.


Have you ever seen 2 year old child running? When something all of a sudden falls in their path and a normal 12 would avoid it does the 2 year old avoid it? Is it because he didn't see it? No we aren't talking about a young Ray Charles. I think REACTION should be based on Agility/How fast you can get your body turned around or whatever you have to do Speed/How fast you get to where you need to be Confidence/How sure your player is on his read and yes Vision/ To jump routes etc. Vision shouldn't effect how fast a LB reacts when a QB hands the ball off because the defensive sideline is always yelling RUN or PASS when the offense runs a play. Guess you've never heard that.


I think you're misinterpreting the meaning of "vision" in context of GLB. Basically, its awareness or football smarts. Not how good the guy's eyes are.
 
skibodragula
McFroggin
offline
Link
 
I have a rolb on my team that will cross the field to get to the runner...vision is reading the play....
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by skibodragula
I have a rolb on my team that will cross the field to get to the runner...vision is reading the play....


Every player on the field goes after the ball-carrier. Some happen to be able to see who has the ball sooner than others.

Originally posted by SKADOODLE
Have you ever seen 2 year old child running? When something all of a sudden falls in their path and a normal 12 would avoid it does the 2 year old avoid it? Is it because he didn't see it? No we aren't talking about a young Ray Charles. I think REACTION should be based on Agility/How fast you can get your body turned around or whatever you have to do Speed/How fast you get to where you need to be Confidence/How sure your player is on his read and yes Vision/ To jump routes etc. Vision shouldn't effect how fast a LB reacts when a QB hands the ball off because the defensive sideline is always yelling RUN or PASS when the offense runs a play. Guess you've never heard that.


Oh yeah. Because all that yelling is really effective in a stadium full of other people who are yelling all kinds of stuff. And I have never seen the sidelines yelling "pass" on a run play, where they missed the play-action.

Why do you figure that the sidelines are yelling? Do you think that maybe it is to try and let the players on the field know that it is a run/pass? Why would they do that? Obviously, according to you, there is no way for players on the feild to not see the football at all times. Why yell at them, if they already know?

As for the two year old, no. He didn't see it. Funny thing about a two year old. He can be running directly to you, and you can throw a ball directly at him, and watch it bounce off of his face.

Amazingly, he never knew it was coming. All agility aside. He didn't know that the ball was coming until it had long-since bounced off his face. He may not even know that it was the ball that hit him. He just knows that everything changed real quick. That's a mental developement issue, not a physical issue.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Obviously the effectiveness of vision does not increase linearly as vision increases. Any idiot can see when a ball is thrown. I believe raising vision is simply increasing the chance that your player will read something or react to something or do something above and beyond the normal call of duty.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 20:33:39
 
Xelstyle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Obviously the effectiveness of vision does not increase linearly as vision increases. Any idiot can see when a ball is thrown. I believe raising vision is simply increasing the chance that your player will read something or react to something or do something above and beyond the normal call of duty.


Basically it.
A player with low vision will be burned against any elusive backs or somebody trying to juke them.

Somebody with higher vision will not be so susceptible to tricks.
 
zack661199
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Forbin


Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.



Well, then there are a whloe lot of retards playing in the NFL. When a CB is in coverage, they tend to be concentrating on the receiver that they are covering, and if the ball gets thrown another direction, they often don't get to see that for a few seconds after it is thrown, due to the fact that they have to keep an eye on their receiver.

Pass-rushers are often unable to see when the QB has thrown the ball, because they don't get to keep their eyes focused on the ball, when they are trying to avoid a 300 lb+ offensive lineman.

Remember the Kiwanuka/Vince Young play? Kiwanuka didn't realize that Young sstill had the ball, so he let him go.

Is Mathias Kiwnuka retarded, just because he couldn't see the ball?

If yes, then maybe VISION should make my D-League CB retarded.

If no, then maybe VISION should just make him unable to see the ball thrown most of the time.

How does a QB "pump-fake" work, if you would have to be retarded to be unable to see that the ball wasn't thrown?




actually, i play corner right now in real life
your meant to keep your eyes on the QB and watch him and read him, its still easy to cover some1 just cause your not directly focusing on them



and pump fakes are just meant to throw the DB's off for a second, thats all the receiever should need,

you really dont know what your talking about
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 20:46:11
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
we all know vision is broken
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zack661199
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by Forbin



Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.



Well, then there are a whloe lot of retards playing in the NFL. When a CB is in coverage, they tend to be concentrating on the receiver that they are covering, and if the ball gets thrown another direction, they often don't get to see that for a few seconds after it is thrown, due to the fact that they have to keep an eye on their receiver.

Pass-rushers are often unable to see when the QB has thrown the ball, because they don't get to keep their eyes focused on the ball, when they are trying to avoid a 300 lb+ offensive lineman.

Remember the Kiwanuka/Vince Young play? Kiwanuka didn't realize that Young sstill had the ball, so he let him go.

Is Mathias Kiwnuka retarded, just because he couldn't see the ball?

If yes, then maybe VISION should make my D-League CB retarded.

If no, then maybe VISION should just make him unable to see the ball thrown most of the time.

How does a QB "pump-fake" work, if you would have to be retarded to be unable to see that the ball wasn't thrown?




actually, i play corner right now in real life
your meant to keep your eyes on the QB and watch him and read him, its still easy to cover some1 just cause your not directly focusing on them



and pump fakes are just meant to throw the DB's off for a second, thats all the receiever should need,

you really dont know what your talking about



Hey Jr, I played several years at both WR and CB. As a WR, you go ahead and watch the QB, and I will be wide open as you run down the field alone.

Seriously, you can't keep up with a WR who is running full speed ahead, while you are turning your head to look back at the QB.

If you want to argue, there are plenty of legit arguments that you can climb into around here. But suggesting that a player never takes his eyes off the ball isn't even stupid. It's a flat-out lie. Noone is so stupid as to believe that. You aren't fooling anyone with that approach.

The fact is that you have to be able to watch both, the QB and the WR (to the best of your ability, as it isn't always possible). That seems like it would take a considerable amount of VISION to me.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Yep, high vision compared to low doesn't show a significant difference so I agree. With 67 vision the SS in the play posted has 0 INTs on the season. If vision helps read something before or while it is happening then surely he would have more than 0.
 
Link
 
If you hate vision so much, I recommend putting points into kicking. That way, you can kick yourself in the ass when your guy doesn't quite make the plays. never forget that the entire play is determined before the graphics are put in. Those dots don't always tell the whole story.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.