User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
dodgerdan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by powerwingman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123988&pbp_id=3962253


I wasn't going to post in this thread. But I find this play hilarious. Here that tard is posting a 4 yard pass on my guy that happened to be a TD and his guy was made to look a fool by a guy Speedy lined up against 17 times and he didn't catch a single pass on him. Now that's funny.

As for the team, I knew my guy wouldn't make it. The guy counting the votes despises me and half the owners hate me too. So, when I saw the All-Pro teams were being voted on I knew I had zero chance at making the roster and that's fine. It's a nice little honor outside of the game and I'm happy for the Ack players who did make the list. Although, like another poster, I can't help but notice a lot of Ron Mexico's own players made the team.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Well going by stats was the logical way to vote for defensive as people only really watch other teams games when they're scouting them. I doubt anyone still watches other teams games after they've played them, so they wouldn't truly know who the best players are.

Ronmexico's players made the team because they're good, not because he counted the votes. And I think only 7 teams bothered to vote.

Look at the last NFL Pro Bowl team, they were mainly players in the top 5 in the league for their important stats, or the famous players who've been playing quite well for years.
 
ronmexico7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dodgerdan
Originally posted by powerwingman

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123988&pbp_id=3962253


I wasn't going to post in this thread. But I find this play hilarious. Here that tard is posting a 4 yard pass on my guy that happened to be a TD and his guy was made to look a fool by a guy Speedy lined up against 17 times and he didn't catch a single pass on him. Now that's funny.

As for the team, I knew my guy wouldn't make it. The guy counting the votes despises me and half the owners hate me too. So, when I saw the All-Pro teams were being voted on I knew I had zero chance at making the roster and that's fine. It's a nice little honor outside of the game and I'm happy for the Ack players who did make the list. Although, like another poster, I can't help but notice a lot of Ron Mexico's own players made the team.


i dont despise you - i despise arrogance.

owners voted - and only 1 voted for you.

as for some of my players being in there, i didnt vote them in, so i have no say in the matter. owners voted for who they thought should make the team - there is no hidden agenda to diss speedy or you as a person.
 
dodgerdan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Ronmexico's players made the team because they're good, not because he counted the votes. And I think only 7 teams bothered to vote.


If you say so.

I'll throw Speedy out there vs El Nitro any day of the week and twice on Sunday. None of your Pro Bowl receivers did a thing vs Speedy. Not a one of them. I've always contended that the average NFL/Football fan was an idiot compared to other sports (giving a QB all the credit for a Superbowl win as if 50+ players don't touch the field per game for a team or the way fans and media, the first time a player struggles, claim he's washed up... you just don't see that idiocy in other sports and football is more of a team sport than any other game, too) and it's good to see people here continue to prove that correct. Basing CB's off tackles. I mean, get real. How does a CB get a ton of tackles? By playing piss poor coverage. If the ball is never thrown to or completed to the guy a CB is covering it's kinda hard to make tackles. Although, my guy does make tackles on runs to the other side of the field better than any CB in this league, I'm sure. Over half of my CB's tackles this year were on runs. Reason being, no one completed shit to the guys he was covering.

Last edited Sep 6, 2008 10:19:57
 
timbrock
offline
Link
 
They're just a bunch of haters. Granted I didn't watch everyone elses games so I'm probably no more qualified than anyone else here, I guess. But there's like a 100+ post thread about Speedy on our team boards and we all kept tabs of his play and stuff and the dude is freakin awesome. Him not being on an All-Pro team is absurd. My first and final post on the subject, though. Dan just posted a link to this thread and I figured I'd weigh in on what I saw. I find it hard to believe that 5 cornerbacks in this league were better than a guy who in a five game stretch gave up under 50 yards in the ground and air, combined. That's 10 yards or less per game. You'd have to be an outright fool to think that's not elite.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Well I'm not disputing how good or bad Speedy is as I have no idea, but he's not thrown to that much which you claim is because of his great coverage but what about when he is thrown to? You can't really take credit for drops or incompletes, you had 7 PDs whereas El Nitro had 20 PDs and 6 INT which is a good indicator of his coverage skills.

On a team I had a player on last season there was a very fast CB like Speedy who also rarely got thrown to and got average CB stats, and so teams always seemed to run and pass against our other CB who had a ridiculously good season with 57 PDs and 15 INTs.

The CB who was regularly thrown to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=126119&playoffs=0

The CB who was rarely thrown to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=136821&playoffs=0

So who would you say was the better CB last season?
 
Veraze
offline
Link
 
You want to test out a CB's coverage skills put him on the strong side. Claiming a CB is great and seeing him on the weak side is just smack talk.
 
loadediwc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Veraze
You want to test out a CB's coverage skills put him on the strong side. Claiming a CB is great and seeing him on the weak side is just smack talk.


You must play a different game than the rest of us. In the passing game the QB AI strongly favors WR1, who the CB1 lines up against. It also favors the WR3 heavily. Although, I guess all of the people bitching about WR2 getting no looks this year are just making shit up. The only thing putting him on the strong side would affect would be run coverage since most runs go to the right.

The idiocy in this division never ceases to amaze me. Glad I'm getting out of it this year when I retire my punter. Bunch of fucking rubes. It's like Bort tried to combine every dipshit owner into one league.


Edit: Hrmm, all of the Pro Bowl WR's were WR 1's too. Something is amiss here in your logic that a CB2 has it tougher when all of the best WR's are on the CB1's side. Add that to the fact that people have bitched non-stop this season about the QB-AI logic where it totally ignores the WR2 at times because it's locked in on WR1 and well, I can now safely add you to the list of people that don't know what the fuck they're talking about.
Last edited Sep 6, 2008 14:33:19
 
loadediwc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Well I'm not disputing how good or bad Speedy is as I have no idea, but he's not thrown to that much which you claim is because of his great coverage but what about when he is thrown to? You can't really take credit for drops or incompletes, you had 7 PDs whereas El Nitro had 20 PDs and 6 INT which is a good indicator of his coverage skills.

On a team I had a player on last season there was a very fast CB like Speedy who also rarely got thrown to and got average CB stats, and so teams always seemed to run and pass against our other CB who had a ridiculously good season with 57 PDs and 15 INTs.

The CB who was regularly thrown to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=126119&playoffs=0

The CB who was rarely thrown to:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=136821&playoffs=0

So who would you say was the better CB last season?


Easy answer. I take the CB rarely thrown at. "SHUTDOWN corner" is a term lost on you guys, isn't it? A shutdown corner totally shuts down a WR. That's more valuable to a team than INT's or tackles for a corner. You basically take one of 3-4 offense weapons totally off the table and make the other team work with fewer options. Any defensive coach worth his salt would take that over all else. Get two shutdown corners and you've effectively thwarted the entire passing game.
 
Veraze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by loadediwc
You must play a different game than the rest of us. In the passing game the QB AI strongly favors WR1, who the CB1 lines up against. It also favors the WR3 heavily. Although, I guess all of the people bitching about WR2 getting no looks this year are just making shit up. The only thing putting him on the strong side would affect would be run coverage since most runs go to the right.


Yeah I don't have a clue about football, and my record reflects this. Seems to me like you're a Speedy fanatic, and that's cool everyone needs admirers. But just like the real pro-bowl selections they base voting on stats so getting worked up because your favorite CB didn't make the list is a little too dramatic.

Originally posted by loadediwc
Edit: Hrmm, all of the Pro Bowl WR's were WR 1's too. Something is amiss here in your logic that a CB2 has it tougher when all of the best WR's are on the CB1's side. Add that to the fact that people have bitched non-stop this season about the QB-AI logic where it totally ignores the WR2 at times because it's locked in on WR1 and well, I can now safely add you to the list of people that don't know what the fuck they're talking about.


You must be reading a different pro-bowl list than the rest of us. The only WR1 to make the list is Blades. The others were either clearly WR2 or on a WR list rotation. There really isn't anything I have done to prove this because there is a lot to take into consideration (such as QB preference, CB matchups, route selection in known passing situation, etc.), but that's fine with me, the more asshats that think the way you do the more games we'll continue to win despite our talent. Maybe if you did some research on this subject rather than regurgitate some other fucking noob's whine you wouldn't look like such a dumbass right about now. And please go retire your silly punter just like all your other players, maybe the teams you will have played for will benefit.

Originally posted by loadediwc
Easy answer. I take the CB rarely thrown at. "SHUTDOWN corner" is a term lost on you guys, isn't it? A shutdown corner totally shuts down a WR. That's more valuable to a team than INT's or tackles for a corner. You basically take one of 3-4 offense weapons totally off the table and make the other team work with fewer options. Any defensive coach worth his salt would take that over all else. Get two shutdown corners and you've effectively thwarted the entire passing game.


Matter of opinion. If you get two shutdown corners you have to read twice as many posts.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Only Alpha Males play in the Alpha conference...
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by loadediwc
Easy answer. I take the CB rarely thrown at. "SHUTDOWN corner" is a term lost on you guys, isn't it? A shutdown corner totally shuts down a WR. That's more valuable to a team than INT's or tackles for a corner. You basically take one of 3-4 offense weapons totally off the table and make the other team work with fewer options. Any defensive coach worth his salt would take that over all else. Get two shutdown corners and you've effectively thwarted the entire passing game.


So the CB who's thrown at and deflects or intercepts most passes isn't shutting down that side?

Originally posted by loadediwc

You must play a different game than the rest of us. In the passing game the QB AI strongly favors WR1, who the CB1 lines up against. It also favors the WR3 heavily. Although, I guess all of the people bitching about WR2 getting no looks this year are just making shit up. The only thing putting him on the strong side would affect would be run coverage since most runs go to the right.


Well actually my WR in another league plays at WR2 is the leading WR on the team, followed by the WR3 then the WR1. He had +1000 yards in the regular season and is the leading WR in the league in the playoffs.

Originally posted by dodgerdan
I wasn't going to post in this thread. But I find this play hilarious. Here that tard is posting a 4 yard pass on my guy that happened to be a TD and his guy was made to look a fool by a guy Speedy lined up against 17 times and he didn't catch a single pass on him. Now that's funny.


Yes but he hasn't gone on about how great his CB is. Also, out of those 17 times when you played him he was only thrown to 3 times. One he dropped, one he was underthrown (probably due to your shutdown coverage) and a 14yard pass where the FS made the tackle.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123878&pbp_id=4470912

Originally posted by dodgerdan
Basing CB's off tackles. I mean, get real. How does a CB get a ton of tackles? By playing piss poor coverage. If the ball is never thrown to or completed to the guy a CB is covering it's kinda hard to make tackles. Although, my guy does make tackles on runs to the other side of the field better than any CB in this league, I'm sure. Over half of my CB's tackles this year were on runs. Reason being, no one completed shit to the guys he was covering.


I just thought I'd look at your last few games, 4 out of your 9 tackles were from passes to the WR you were covering. Speedy is a very good CB, but he's not the greatest.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=124124&pbp_id=8279917
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123885&pbp_id=7814023
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123885&pbp_id=7815338
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123884&pbp_id=7353866
Last edited Sep 6, 2008 16:25:19
 
dodgerdan
offline
Link
 
Ummm, my guy has played CB2 this year as well. The results were the same.
 
dodgerdan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount

I just thought I'd look at your last few games, 4 out of your 9 tackles were from passes to the WR you were covering. Speedy is a very good CB, but he's not the greatest.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=124124&pbp_id=8279917
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123885&pbp_id=7814023
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123885&pbp_id=7815338
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=123884&pbp_id=7353866


So, three games and FOUR catches, only one of which was over 10 yards (the 18 yarder) and you think that's not great coverage? Are you serious? Four completions in three games against my guy. I give up... arguing with people that believe that's anything short of a remarkable job is too daft for my tastes.

You also proved my point on my tackles. I said over 50% were in run support and that's not a lie. I have a thread independent of this board where I keep track of Speedy's stats. I watch each game and track him. As the season progressed he got WAY better, too. Some of the earlier completions against him you can't get on him now. When he had lower agility and vision he'd play erratic at times in pass coverage. It's of no consequence now. You guys are going to back your decisions and to be honest I didn't want to aruge this to begin with. You guys are welcome to your opinion and I'll respectfully agree to disagree.


Originally posted by
Also, out of those 17 times when you played him he was only thrown to 3 times.


As for this, isn't that the objective? And you pretty much make my case for me. How can I get an assload of PD's and INT's when the ball comes my way three times a game? If I had it my way I'd put Speedy in at CB2 for this Rage game just to show you this weakside/strongside bullshit is ridiculous. That has nothing to do with it. Either side my guy lines up on he's going to cover one WR so what's the difference? Strongside affects NOTHING since the TE isn't my guy's responsibility.
Last edited Sep 6, 2008 16:50:19
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
I'm not arguing. You said "no one completed shit to the guys you were covering", so I just put up a few examples where they did.
I do agree that the strongside/weakside point is rubbish though.

Anyway I guess tonight is the battle of the CBs then, El Nitro vs Speedy Gonzales Jr, I'm honestly wondering who's gonna perform better?!
Last edited Sep 6, 2008 16:57:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.