I was asked to weigh-in on this but I honestly can't say there was ever a hard and fast rule. From my prospective, I always wanted every game to count but there are some matchups (top team in 1 conf vs bottom feeder in the other) that just can't be considered viable to determine anything.
Last season, I believe Alpha won both comparisons:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=586608
However, what impressed me the most were the games between playoff-bound teams.
So I guess I am firmly on the fence here. Every team should compete to uphold their conference honor, but the games matching the haves vs the haves should provide the most telling result.
Last season, I believe Alpha won both comparisons:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=586608
However, what impressed me the most were the games between playoff-bound teams.
So I guess I am firmly on the fence here. Every team should compete to uphold their conference honor, but the games matching the haves vs the haves should provide the most telling result.






























