People are just experimenting they spend their money to do what they want so why should they be punished for it?
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player goes up 8 levels in 4 games and 17 levels in 13 games
RIP Al Davis
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
who cares if there is a level 30 punter in 2 seasons? Have you ever seen a punter in GLB create a noticeable difference in a game? Also with kicking so messed up now level 30 kickers aren't that hot either.
What are you talking about? Their contributions may be less noticable, but they have huge effects on the outcomes of games. I doubt you see any playoff teams without one. I bet you'd care if someone had been doing this since season 1. Assuming they wern't banned, which of course they would be, they'd be level 50 or higher.
who cares if there is a level 30 punter in 2 seasons? Have you ever seen a punter in GLB create a noticeable difference in a game? Also with kicking so messed up now level 30 kickers aren't that hot either.
What are you talking about? Their contributions may be less noticable, but they have huge effects on the outcomes of games. I doubt you see any playoff teams without one. I bet you'd care if someone had been doing this since season 1. Assuming they wern't banned, which of course they would be, they'd be level 50 or higher.
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kira
Originally posted by Robbnva
who cares if there is a level 30 punter in 2 seasons? Have you ever seen a punter in GLB create a noticeable difference in a game? Also with kicking so messed up now level 30 kickers aren't that hot either.
What are you talking about? Their contributions may be less noticable, but they have huge effects on the outcomes of games. I doubt you see any playoff teams without one. I bet you'd care if someone had been doing this since season 1. Assuming they wern't banned, which of course they would be, they'd be level 50 or higher.
no they wouldn't because the floor is level 29 so once they hit that they can only earn 25 points per night and 100 points per game making it take them about 7 game sjust to level up 1 time.
I just think you are getting worked up over nothing as it is such a small population of people who are doing it (hell that could be the only one doing it)
nobody is getting banned because there is no rule against it and they really haevn't done anything wrong. A punter playing on a bad team getting a bunch of punts is normal. A team owner wanting to lose on purpose until he gets to a lower level league is understanadible because if I had a gutted team I would want to move down for easier competition since recruiting on GLB sucks ASS.
Originally posted by Robbnva
who cares if there is a level 30 punter in 2 seasons? Have you ever seen a punter in GLB create a noticeable difference in a game? Also with kicking so messed up now level 30 kickers aren't that hot either.
What are you talking about? Their contributions may be less noticable, but they have huge effects on the outcomes of games. I doubt you see any playoff teams without one. I bet you'd care if someone had been doing this since season 1. Assuming they wern't banned, which of course they would be, they'd be level 50 or higher.
no they wouldn't because the floor is level 29 so once they hit that they can only earn 25 points per night and 100 points per game making it take them about 7 game sjust to level up 1 time.
I just think you are getting worked up over nothing as it is such a small population of people who are doing it (hell that could be the only one doing it)
nobody is getting banned because there is no rule against it and they really haevn't done anything wrong. A punter playing on a bad team getting a bunch of punts is normal. A team owner wanting to lose on purpose until he gets to a lower level league is understanadible because if I had a gutted team I would want to move down for easier competition since recruiting on GLB sucks ASS.
Welsh76
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
People are just experimenting they spend their money to do what they want so why should they be punished for it?
If the team was competitive then you might have had a point, but the team is clearly being used this way to exploit a bug that hasn't capped the XP gains for certain positions.
Unfortunately I left school a long time ago and just wanted to participate in a friendly online game with like-minded people, maybe this isn't the game for me if things like this are allowed to continue.
I'm lucky to be in a competitive league but because I'm not directly affected does it mean that I shouldn't care about all the other users being affected who have also paid money?
People are just experimenting they spend their money to do what they want so why should they be punished for it?
If the team was competitive then you might have had a point, but the team is clearly being used this way to exploit a bug that hasn't capped the XP gains for certain positions.
Unfortunately I left school a long time ago and just wanted to participate in a friendly online game with like-minded people, maybe this isn't the game for me if things like this are allowed to continue.
I'm lucky to be in a competitive league but because I'm not directly affected does it mean that I shouldn't care about all the other users being affected who have also paid money?
RIP Al Davis
offline
offline
well, maybe not 50, but at least 40. The point is they'd be the highest level players in the game. THIS IS COLLUSION, just not the normal kind. Making your player better at the expense of the team. I can't think of a solution though as just about everyone does it to a much smaller extent.
EDIT - No, considering there was no 50 play cap for exp in the majority of season 1 level 50 sounds reasonable. Ray Finkle's level 35 for mostly playing normal other than the season 1 punting.
EDIT - No, considering there was no 50 play cap for exp in the majority of season 1 level 50 sounds reasonable. Ray Finkle's level 35 for mostly playing normal other than the season 1 punting.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 07:22:17
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by RandomBeast
just set a game XP cap at 500 and be done with it.
there you go but the complaint is punters, kickers, and I believe FBs have an extra XP gain because of the limited playing time they get and they are mad at the exploitation of it.
I think a Punter punting 200 times in a season should not be capped for all of the other punters who are on bad teams who are not trying to screw the system
just set a game XP cap at 500 and be done with it.
there you go but the complaint is punters, kickers, and I believe FBs have an extra XP gain because of the limited playing time they get and they are mad at the exploitation of it.
I think a Punter punting 200 times in a season should not be capped for all of the other punters who are on bad teams who are not trying to screw the system
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 08:19:21
Welsh76
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by RandomBeast
just set a game XP cap at 500 and be done with it.
there you go but the complaint is punters, kickers, and I believe FBs have an extra XP gain because of the limited playing time they get and they are mad at the exploitation of it.
I think a Punter punting 200 times in a season should not be capped for all of the other punters who are on bad teams who are not trying to screw the system
Every player should have the same cap depending on their level, but the number of plays needed to get the max XP should be varied depending on their position (like kickers).
All players should have the same XP cap to enable them to build their players at the same rate.
Originally posted by RandomBeast
just set a game XP cap at 500 and be done with it.
there you go but the complaint is punters, kickers, and I believe FBs have an extra XP gain because of the limited playing time they get and they are mad at the exploitation of it.
I think a Punter punting 200 times in a season should not be capped for all of the other punters who are on bad teams who are not trying to screw the system
Every player should have the same cap depending on their level, but the number of plays needed to get the max XP should be varied depending on their position (like kickers).
All players should have the same XP cap to enable them to build their players at the same rate.
RandomBeast
offline
offline
Yeah, punters would still get more XP per play, but they still hit the same cap. So if you only get in on 4 plays, you might still get 350XP or whatever, but if you punted 80 times a game, you max out at 500 instead of getting 1500 or more.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Yeah, punters would still get more XP per play, but they still hit the same cap. So if you only get in on 4 plays, you might still get 350XP or whatever, but if you punted 80 times a game, you max out at 500 instead of getting 1500 or more.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
Agreed. I don't think Bort had 18 levels in one season in mind when he built the game.
Yeah, punters would still get more XP per play, but they still hit the same cap. So if you only get in on 4 plays, you might still get 350XP or whatever, but if you punted 80 times a game, you max out at 500 instead of getting 1500 or more.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
Agreed. I don't think Bort had 18 levels in one season in mind when he built the game.
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Yeah, punters would still get more XP per play, but they still hit the same cap. So if you only get in on 4 plays, you might still get 350XP or whatever, but if you punted 80 times a game, you max out at 500 instead of getting 1500 or more.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
Agreed. I don't think Bort had 18 levels in one season in mind when he built the game.
Yeh, this seems not right to me, I'll go ahead and make sure Bort looks into it.
-Thorn
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Yeah, punters would still get more XP per play, but they still hit the same cap. So if you only get in on 4 plays, you might still get 350XP or whatever, but if you punted 80 times a game, you max out at 500 instead of getting 1500 or more.
Each position can scale XP differently based on number of plays, but still reach the same cap to limit exploitation.
Agreed. I don't think Bort had 18 levels in one season in mind when he built the game.
Yeh, this seems not right to me, I'll go ahead and make sure Bort looks into it.
-Thorn
mandyross
offline
offline
Maybe if you play more than 50 plays a game the amount of xp you receive should drop off slightly?
Would encourage squad management and prevent someone like this being a selfish .... and ruining the game for others.
Would encourage squad management and prevent someone like this being a selfish .... and ruining the game for others.
islander1
offline
offline
Although I've got to admit, punting exp is broken in more ways then this.
I've been on 2 very good teams in my two years with Elliott now, and in each case I've HAD to play special teams return coverage to get any experience.
If I hadn't, I'd be retiring my player at level 13 right now. The way punting experience is handled is simply improper.
Punters should get the maximum experience every game - punt total regardless. As long as they are the only punter in the game, they should get their level maximum.
I've been on 2 very good teams in my two years with Elliott now, and in each case I've HAD to play special teams return coverage to get any experience.
If I hadn't, I'd be retiring my player at level 13 right now. The way punting experience is handled is simply improper.
Punters should get the maximum experience every game - punt total regardless. As long as they are the only punter in the game, they should get their level maximum.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by mandyross
Maybe if you play more than 50 plays a game the amount of xp you receive should drop off slightly?
Would encourage squad management and prevent someone like this being a selfish .... and ruining the game for others.
the effective exp ceiling is between 30 and 40 now as it is. Actually, even lower then 30 I've observed of late.
Maybe if you play more than 50 plays a game the amount of xp you receive should drop off slightly?
Would encourage squad management and prevent someone like this being a selfish .... and ruining the game for others.
the effective exp ceiling is between 30 and 40 now as it is. Actually, even lower then 30 I've observed of late.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 09:28:04
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























