User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Bad Owners need to be NERFED
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Take that shit out of this thread please.


Excuse me?


Check your sarcasm detector.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lizrdgizrd
The obvious partial solution is to make contracts more complicated so that playing time, etc can be factored in.


Here's a solid suggestion.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Glenn Williams
then so do bad players -- only fair to consider both sides


I agree, arbitration.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by Glenn Williams

then so do bad players -- only fair to consider both sides


I agree, arbitration.


Here's a solution.

Don't piss your owner off to the degree that he is forced to bench, ban and block you. If you are the type of player that frequently gets in feuds with the owner, then don't sign contracts longer than one season so your development will not be harmed when such a situation arises. Know yourself and plan accordingly.
 
glaity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

Originally posted by Glenn Williams


then so do bad players -- only fair to consider both sides


I agree, arbitration.


Here's a solution.

Don't piss your owner off to the degree that he is forced to bench, ban and block you. If you are the type of player that frequently gets in feuds with the owner, then don't sign contracts longer than one season so your development will not be harmed when such a situation arises. Know yourself and plan accordingly.


Real question is --- who can tell what's going to piss someone off? by that time it's too late for either player/owner

and yes -- agree -- Agent/Owner know yourself before you sign/offer that contract

 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

Originally posted by Glenn Williams


then so do bad players -- only fair to consider both sides


I agree, arbitration.


Here's a solution.

Don't piss your owner off to the degree that he is forced to bench, ban and block you. If you are the type of player that frequently gets in feuds with the owner, then don't sign contracts longer than one season so your development will not be harmed when such a situation arises. Know yourself and plan accordingly.


I totally understand this. But what about the Jack ass owners that are just out for a vendetta? Please try to come up with a solution. I understand about jack ass players, believe me. I just trade them out, I also leave my PM's open for them no matter how much of a high maintenance person they are. Blocking them out is not helpful. Why lose out on daily salary and contribution from a player, trade him and move on, I am talking about really crappy people that screw good players out of what they have paid to do.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by Glenn Williams
then so do bad players -- only fair to consider both sides


I agree, arbitration.


Here's a solution.

Don't piss your owner off to the degree that he is forced to bench, ban and block you. If you are the type of player that frequently gets in feuds with the owner, then don't sign contracts longer than one season so your development will not be harmed when such a situation arises. Know yourself and plan accordingly.


As stated elsewhere, your "solution" is "Kiss ass in hopes it doesn't piss off Thy Holy Owner, and only sign one-year deals so even if you do piss him off he can only fuck you over for 40 days"?
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
GLB is still an RPG at heart. Owners need to do what's best for the team, and players need to do what's best for themselves, just like in real life. Owners (coaches) can bench players for detrimental conduct, and players can choose whether or not to engage in such conduct, just like in real life. Owners can be total douchebags, and players can't do anything about it, just like in real life (see Clay Bennett, owner of the Seat-oops, I mean Oklahoma City-based NBA team). Players can't bounce from contracts anytime they want in real life, so why should GLB be an exception?

My point of all this is that implementing far-reaching contract changes that will affect all the GOOD owner/player relationships is not worth satisfying the small % of the population that have BAD owner/player relationships.

I'm all for owner/agent ratings; it could be something like a "Reputation" meter. It would have to be heavily regulated though, and is still open for abuse.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
The best solution I've seen to date (and have supported elsewhere) is some type of 'buy-out' option that can be negotiated into a contract.

If done right, this would allow players to escape the so called 'bad-owner' (I know they are out there, but I don't think quite as prevalent as some would suggest)...but the same clause could be designed in such a way that the financial cost would protect reasonable owners.

There doesn't have to be a reason for a buy-out (i.e. depth chart position, playing time, etc.) just has to be a balance between the cost of the buy-out and the benefit. This way a player will only do a buy-out if they are really feeling trapped, and an owner will recover his funds.

My suggestions for such a clause would be

1) Make it optional, like the no trade clause is currently
2) Make the amount negotiable (I'd suggest that a good amount if it must be fixed would be 100% signing bonus (all bonuses given in last 40 days + 5 days salary)
3) NO Buy-outs between the trade deadline and end of season. This prevents the "I'm going to leave to go play for my buddies playoff team" or top level guys upsetting the balance of a playoff race
4) Pro-rate the buyout based on contract served
for a 1 season contract cut 20% off the amount for every 10 days played
Buyout original 100% of bonus + 5 days salary
Buyout after day 10 80% + 4 days salary
Buyout after day 20 60% + 3 days salary
Buyout after day 30 40% + 2 days salary

The contract buyout needs to be calculated off of all signing bonuses for the last 40 days so that the lv24 and higher bonuses can be calculated into the formula.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
The best solution I've seen to date (and have supported elsewhere) is some type of 'buy-out' option that can be negotiated into a contract.

If done right, this would allow players to escape the so called 'bad-owner' (I know they are out there, but I don't think quite as prevalent as some would suggest)...but the same clause could be designed in such a way that the financial cost would protect reasonable owners.

There doesn't have to be a reason for a buy-out (i.e. depth chart position, playing time, etc.) just has to be a balance between the cost of the buy-out and the benefit. This way a player will only do a buy-out if they are really feeling trapped, and an owner will recover his funds.

My suggestions for such a clause would be

1) Make it optional, like the no trade clause is currently
2) Make the amount negotiable (I'd suggest that a good amount if it must be fixed would be 100% signing bonus (all bonuses given in last 40 days + 5 days salary)
3) NO Buy-outs between the trade deadline and end of season. This prevents the "I'm going to leave to go play for my buddies playoff team" or top level guys upsetting the balance of a playoff race
4) Pro-rate the buyout based on contract served
for a 1 season contract cut 20% off the amount for every 10 days played
Buyout original 100% of bonus + 5 days salary
Buyout after day 10 80% + 4 days salary
Buyout after day 20 60% + 3 days salary
Buyout after day 30 40% + 2 days salary

The contract buyout needs to be calculated off of all signing bonuses for the last 40 days so that the lv24 and higher bonuses can be calculated into the formula.


Most intelligent thing I've read all day.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Buyout clause decent, but should be mandatory for all contracts.

It just seems like it would be too big of a sticking point otherwise; players feel like they're going to get screwed if the owner doesn't/won't offer it, owners feel like the players are going to be disloyal if they insist on having it offered.

Owners should have to treat every player fairly, not pick & choose which players 'can' get screwed because they don't have a clause to escape.
Last edited Aug 19, 2008 16:07:45
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
We're now officially an MMO, because my Drama meter's off the hook.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wallysmith
Originally posted by rbedgood

The best solution I've seen to date (and have supported elsewhere) is some type of 'buy-out' option that can be negotiated into a contract.

If done right, this would allow players to escape the so called 'bad-owner' (I know they are out there, but I don't think quite as prevalent as some would suggest)...but the same clause could be designed in such a way that the financial cost would protect reasonable owners.

There doesn't have to be a reason for a buy-out (i.e. depth chart position, playing time, etc.) just has to be a balance between the cost of the buy-out and the benefit. This way a player will only do a buy-out if they are really feeling trapped, and an owner will recover his funds.

My suggestions for such a clause would be

1) Make it optional, like the no trade clause is currently
2) Make the amount negotiable (I'd suggest that a good amount if it must be fixed would be 100% signing bonus (all bonuses given in last 40 days + 5 days salary)
3) NO Buy-outs between the trade deadline and end of season. This prevents the "I'm going to leave to go play for my buddies playoff team" or top level guys upsetting the balance of a playoff race
4) Pro-rate the buyout based on contract served
for a 1 season contract cut 20% off the amount for every 10 days played
Buyout original 100% of bonus + 5 days salary
Buyout after day 10 80% + 4 days salary
Buyout after day 20 60% + 3 days salary
Buyout after day 30 40% + 2 days salary

The contract buyout needs to be calculated off of all signing bonuses for the last 40 days so that the lv24 and higher bonuses can be calculated into the formula.


Most intelligent thing I've read all day.


I've been tweaking and pitching this idea for over a season. I am an owner...and I've had a couple immature players that weren't happy with 40+ snaps, because they weren't the starter. However I also have a number of players that are not on my own team. I've had generally good experiences, but I can see how others can get stuck with owners that are unreasonable.

With that being said, you need to have the restrictions I mentioned to protect abuse of the situation, but a 'buy-out' gets rid of the he said/she said crap. You have no reason to whine if you don't want to be where you are, train on relaxed for a few games, or train on NONE, and sell some equipment. All of a sudden you can buy-out of your contract.
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Buyout clause decent, but should be mandatory for all contracts.

It just seems like it would be too big of a sticking point otherwise; players feel like they're going to get screwed if the owner doesn't/won't offer it, owners feel like the players are going to be disloyal if they insist on having it offered.

Owners should have to treat every player fairly, not pick & choose which players 'can' get screwed because they don't have a clause to escape.


If mandatory, owners need protection too, so they don't get screwed without a starting HB a day before a big game. Maybe some kind of grace period between when a player exercises it, and when it actually happens? An alert can be sent to the owner so he could have, say, two days to try and convince the player to stay.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Buyout clause decent, but should be mandatory for all contracts.

It just seems like it would be too big of a sticking point otherwise; players feel like they're going to get screwed if the owner doesn't/won't offer it, owners feel like the players are going to be disloyal if they insist on having it offered.

Owners should have to treat every player fairly, not pick & choose which players 'can' get screwed because they don't have a clause to escape.


Fine with me...I'd offer it on all contracts anyhow as a 'security measure' that I am what I say I am. If you don't believe what you see on my team forums you have the extra security of a buy-out clause.

However I would insist that such a clause factors in all the bonuses that I've given a player over the past 40 days. This way when I pay for lv24 or lv32 (or eventually level 40) equipment the buy-out will include the amounts for all the bonuses to buy said equipment. It would still pro-rate through the life of the contract, but at minimum if they don't serve their contract out, they'll owe 40% of their bonus back.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.