User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > League fix for player disparity
Page:
 
Bluejays4ws
offline
Link
 
For the purpose of the discussion:

This isn't just about you and me. Think about in general what people think about the "structure" and how it could be improved at the moment. I mean, what's the difference between "South America Pro" and "USA Pro". Is one of them considered "better" than the other?
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Well, with the whole CPU owner idea, and firing 'bad' GMs, Coaches, Advisers, etc per whatever system would be in place, whether it be a set value of whatever, or a voting system the players could be a part of, you'd almost be guaranteed to have a 'good' Coach or GM who would treat you right, or he/she would be replaced before too long.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bluejays4ws
For the purpose of the discussion:

This isn't just about you and me. Think about in general what people think about the "structure" and how it could be improved at the moment. I mean, what's the difference between "South America Pro" and "USA Pro". Is one of them considered "better" than the other?


the general consensus is overwhelming that the USA leagues are 'better' for the simple fact that they've been in place longer and it has nothing to do with talent.

With this idea, there would still be the various Regions (USA, Europe East/West, Africa, etc etc etc) just a H.S. level, College level, and pro level all intertwined within each region...

With the added idea of a relegation up/down due to performance and championship (or Bowl) wins/losses, etc within each level of play, it would still give teams that non-static aspect we have now.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I like the fact that the Pros are the Pros and there is no relegation there. Quite simply, if someone wants to be an ass and only hire his players or his buddies, its okay as long as they keep winning. Chances are, however, there will be better talent out there picked up by the best teams and they will lose.

I would say make the cost and structure for GMing look something like this (the numbers can be changed, of course)

-Pro team: base = 1000 FP
-College team: base = 500 FP
-HS: base = 250 FP

General Manager: base price
OC: base price x .75
DC: base price x .75
Special Teams Coordinator: base price x .25
Financial Advisor: base price x .50
Scout (Talent and Game Plan): base x .25

Of course, with these positions there would need to be clear distinctions/records kept. For example, a financial advisor should have a handful of stats such as team profit/ticket sales/concession sales total and trends, stadium progress, total salary paid out/average level of players, etc.

The way things are right now would still need to be reworked so that losing teams see a bigger hit to ticket sales. This way, everyone has to work together to net a profit. If the GM decides not to spend the money on a big time player, they will save some money but lose fan support and ultimately their job.

IDK, there are still a lot of holes in this system - the CPU-owned teams part, at least.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 14:35:50
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
I agree there are holes a-plenty, thanks for the good ideas right there. That's why I want as many opinions here to debate over as possible, so it can be refined a lot in the coming day(s), and when interest wanes from this thread, I'll compile it all together and post it up for final review, and maybe some new thoughts
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
BUMP
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
I just think a massive reshuffle of teams would fix this the best. I know a lot of people would be upset, but it's Beta. Just take all teams in the off season and throw caps on every league (that moves up a little every season) and reshuffle teams according to their current player level average and throw them into a league that best suits them. Then have teams that get gutted during a season get thrown into a "toilet" League where they start at the bottom and get hashed out the next season. This allows for 1 more team in the league below them to be promoted (maybe a random selector that pics one of the teams in one of the leagues below that lost their conferance title game). Then there would be no problems with this shit, a LVL cap keeps all of the other high level stat padders out.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I just think a massive reshuffle of teams would fix this the best. I know a lot of people would be upset, but it's Beta. Just take all teams in the off season and throw caps on every league (that moves up a little every season) and reshuffle teams according to their current player level average and throw them into a league that best suits them. Then have teams that get gutted during a season get thrown into a "toilet" League where they start at the bottom and get hashed out the next season. This allows for 1 more team in the league below them to be promoted (maybe a random selector that pics one of the teams in one of the leagues below that lost their conference title game). Then there would be no problems with this shit, a LVL cap keeps all of the other high level stat padders out.


All this would accomplish is nothing but the same exact thing we have now, it'd just take one singular season to get it back to the way it was before the shuffle.

I don't agree with a level cap, but a time frame cap. Hey, if you can manage to get a lvl 30 senior in H.S. with my idea's system, kudos. He'll be a College star before long and a Pro star after that most likely. That's how it should be, not everyone will 'make it' and some will just have to call it quits after College, or even H.S. in some extreme cases...
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 16:04:26
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
It wouldn't end up the same because if there is a cap it will keep parity within the leagues until they were allowed to move up. This would also give an extra incentive to move up so you can recruit higher level players. If there was a 3-5 level difference between each cap you will not have any major problems when you hit the next league. I wouldn't want to hop from team to team to team.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
It wouldn't end up the same because if there is a cap it will keep parity within the leagues until they were allowed to move up. This would also give an extra incentive to move up so you can recruit higher level players. If there was a 3-5 level difference between each cap you will not have any major problems when you hit the next league. I wouldn't want to hop from team to team to team.


TBH, this idea is not entirely aimed just at creating parity. It is also aimed at giving us a realistic career progression for our players. The way it is now, most people spend their time in a D-League, get signed and stick with that team (which basically will never make it to the pros) or move down to dominate a weaker league. It could be better, tbh.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05

It wouldn't end up the same because if there is a cap it will keep parity within the leagues until they were allowed to move up. This would also give an extra incentive to move up so you can recruit higher level players. If there was a 3-5 level difference between each cap you will not have any major problems when you hit the next league. I wouldn't want to hop from team to team to team.


TBH, this idea is not entirely aimed just at creating parity. It is also aimed at giving us a realistic career progression for our players. The way it is now, most people spend their time in a D-League, get signed and stick with that team (which basically will never make it to the pros) or move down to dominate a weaker league. It could be better, tbh.


It seems that every non boosting player will be forced to retire his player after 8 seasons, and boosting players would only get 2 seasons as a starter before the decline, and that's IF they're lucky enough to be one of the first players good enough to play in the pros their first season available.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
It seems that every non boosting player will be forced to retire his player after 8 seasons, and boosting players would only get 2 seasons as a starter before the decline, and that's IF they're lucky enough to be one of the first players good enough to play in the pros their first season available.


I hear you. I suggested a 12 season career before the decline (mimicking the average career in the Pros of 3.5 seasons). A player may go up as a junior, if a GM is interested enough. That would give them another year in the Pros, but they would be less likely to start.

A big issue is that we have no idea how the decline will work out, though. It would be nice to know the rate players decline...until they are all but forced to retire.

FYI - I am strongly in favor of having an "arena league" so that those that couldn't cut it can be retired and let the agents try again with a 70% FP return or they can keep him going in the arena leagues and hope a Pro Team eventually signs him. This would also make Special Teams less of a joke.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Schaffer05, please re-read my original post, because you obviously didn't do so.


I read your post... You think Bort would like to implement something that will make agents wary to boost their players? If I knew I may have to retire my guy after just a couple of seasons, there is no way I would boost all of my players (As I do now, spending 55$ a month on this game). Then after I play 8 seasons only to find out my guy won't be able to play in the pros, I'd be pretty pissed to have to retire him and start all over.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05

It seems that every non boosting player will be forced to retire his player after 8 seasons, and boosting players would only get 2 seasons as a starter before the decline, and that's IF they're lucky enough to be one of the first players good enough to play in the pros their first season available.


I hear you. I suggested a 12 season career before the decline (mimicking the average career in the Pros of 3.5 seasons). A player may go up as a junior, if a GM is interested enough. That would give them another year in the Pros, but they would be less likely to start.

A big issue is that we have no idea how the decline will work out, though. It would be nice to know the rate players decline...until they are all but forced to retire.

FYI - I am strongly in favor of having an "arena league" so that those that couldn't cut it can be retired and let the agents try again with a 70% FP return or they can keep him going in the arena leagues and hope a Pro Team eventually signs him. This would also make Special Teams less of a joke.



Arena league and a CFL league woudln't be bad at all... But just to have a Pros or nothing is kind of out there and would make players be more cautious of boosting players thus costing BORT money.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.