User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Guys in all fairness...it looks like those two guys gang tackled him to the ground in that play.

If you get him tackled what is the problem?


LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
It's going to take a DT more time to regain energy than a RB. Voltron and biqtisme both have it correct.


That is the simple, and wrong answer. Way to jump on the wrong bandwagon on this one.
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
This only proves to me that there is a bug in this game. A level 1 HB should never break a tackle with a level 10+ let alone a level 20+. I have no problems with this game, just some things need to be fixed like this. That's why there is a bugs forum for a beta game.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE


LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.


but they did tackle him right?

He didn't blow through them for a 85 yard return!

This might be the perfect example for people who dont think players "lose momentum" and dont believe in gang tackling.
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
You have your opinion and I have mine.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tremele
Originally posted by Voltron

I know right! You guys should never ever miss a tackle once you have high tackling/strength. That way there's never a reason to make a powerback because they'll never be able to break tackles.


Level 1 HB smartass.


It happens.
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by SCACE



LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.


but they did tackle him right?

He didn't blow through them for a 85 yard return!

This might be the perfect example for people who dont think players "lose momentum" and dont believe in gang tackling.


So is it better to wait for them to miss the tackle twice where it could effect the game big time then to have it fixed before that happens? I guess I don't agree with that.
 
catspaw27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by bigtisme

Guys in all fairness...it looks like those two guys gang tackled him to the ground in that play.

If you get him tackled what is the problem?


LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.


What's the problem?

OK, level 21 defender, level 1 HB. Consider it a NFL player up against my 3-year-old son. And he whiffs.

What if it happens every game? 16 missed tackles more at the end of teh season.

What's the problem?
 
dkgojackets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by catspaw27
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by bigtisme


Guys in all fairness...it looks like those two guys gang tackled him to the ground in that play.

If you get him tackled what is the problem?


LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.


What's the problem?

OK, level 21 defender, level 1 HB. Consider it a NFL player up against my 3-year-old son. And he whiffs.

What if it happens every game? 16 missed tackles more at the end of teh season.

What's the problem?


If an NFL player couldnt tackle a three-year old then there is an obvious problem ducy
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
For all those people that don't think missed tackle is not a problem, check this out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88550&pbp_id=4424198

The two DT's that missed the tackle both had strength over 70, tackling and agility over 50, vision over 30. How would a level 1 HB broke those two tackles I have no idea.

I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed. Not whining here, so please don't post "stop whining" or "get higher tackling" replies.


So you'd rather have there be a 0% chance of breaking the tackle instead of a 0.0001% chance or the equivalent?
The game doesn't work without random chance. Learn to live with it.
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
I see it more as a Division I Football team playing a Division II Football team. Missed tackles shouldn't happen but do happen. The problem is that people keep comparing this to the NFL when it's not.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Guys in all fairness...it looks like those two guys gang tackled him to the ground in that play.

If you get him tackled what is the problem?


I'm complaining or whining. The problem is that something is obviously not "right" here. I love this game and I would like to see this game get better, so when I see a potential problem, I bring it up. If I only bring up problems when we lose, I'll be labeled a whiner. I am already been labeled a whiner by some as it is already.

It doesn't really matter if he eventually got tackled or not, it doesn't even matter if we win or lose this game. What matters is that something extremely abnormal happened here and should be investigated.

If this is by design, level 1 HBs breaking tackles by level 21 DTs, then there is "no issue" here.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by bigtisme

Guys in all fairness...it looks like those two guys gang tackled him to the ground in that play.

If you get him tackled what is the problem?


I'm complaining or whining. The problem is that something is obviously not "right" here. I love this game and I would like to see this game get better, so when I see a potential problem, I bring it up. If I only bring up problems when we lose, I'll be labeled a whiner. I am already been labeled a whiner by some as it is already.

It doesn't really matter if he eventually got tackled or not, it doesn't even matter if we win or lose this game. What matters is that something extremely abnormal happened here and should be investigated.

If this is by design, level 1 HBs breaking tackles by level 21 DTs, then there is "no issue" here.


Well it feels like you're treating it like a pandemic when it's really just a rare occurrence. Do you have any examples of this happening? I mean even if you could come up with 10 and post them here, realize that hundreds of thousands of plays are simmed every week.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by SCACE



LVL 21's vs. LVL 1...come on big

I'm not usually a defender of these posts, but this one seems to have something behind it imho.


but they did tackle him right?

He didn't blow through them for a 85 yard return!

This might be the perfect example for people who dont think players "lose momentum" and dont believe in gang tackling.


Do we really need to see him break loose for an 85 yard TD return before we say "geez, there might be a problem here"?

Is there really a need to "gang tackle" a level 1 HB by a bunch of level 20+ DTs? What would it take to tackle a level 20 HB then? "Gang tackling" by the whole roster?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Originally posted by datongw

For all those people that don't think missed tackle is not a problem, check this out:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=88550&pbp_id=4424198

The two DT's that missed the tackle both had strength over 70, tackling and agility over 50, vision over 30. How would a level 1 HB broke those two tackles I have no idea.

I'm simply pointing out a flaw in the game that is obviously need to be addressed. Not whining here, so please don't post "stop whining" or "get higher tackling" replies.


So you'd rather have there be a 0% chance of breaking the tackle instead of a 0.0001% chance or the equivalent?
The game doesn't work without random chance. Learn to live with it.


So 0.0001% chance happened twice in a row? This is my lucky day, maybe I should go out and buy some lottery tickets.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.