User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Getting coverage more realistic
Page:
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
i just want my CB who is soft capped in speed and agi to stop giving WRs a cushion. looks like your suggestion will do the trick.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Ad to this my suggestions on how DB's 'bite' on fakes. Instead of being 'frozen' and standing there like a drooling idiot for a number of ticks because they were faked out, instead, the DB will move in the direction of where they think the ball is going to be (due to the fake) and begin moving in that direction.

This opens up the coverage and allows more receivers to possibly be open for the real throw.

When 'faked out'.. the DB has a chance each time slice/tick to recognise they've gone off in the wrong direction and course correct to return to their coverage. This would be based on their Vision (Supervision should provide a very reliable boost) and their ability to resume coverage would be based on their agility and speed. The more agile/faster they are, he better their chances of getting back into coverage if they recognise they have been faked.

Once the ball is thrown, DB 'recovery' rolls are given a bonus because the ball is now in the air and if they haven't already recovered from the fake, they can now trace its trajectory and begin moving in the proper direction. It's still not 100% but it should be very high percentage chance so that they will recover.

In this way, DB's will behave more realistically. They will constantly be moving (although sometimes in the wrong direction) and will have a chance to actually stop the receiver who previously was blowing by them with no coverage at all for long yardage/TD's because the code called for the DB to freeze which meant they were motionless for a significant amount of time.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 07:02:59
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Ad to this my suggestions on how DB's 'bite' on fakes. Instead of being 'frozen' and standing there like a drooling idiot for a number of ticks because they were faked out, instead, the DB will move in the direction of where they think the ball is going to be (due to the fake) and begin moving in that direction.

This opens up the coverage and allows more receivers to possibly be open for the real throw.

When 'faked out'.. the DB has a chance each time slice/tick to recognise they've gone off in the wrong direction and course correct to return to their coverage. This would be based on their Vision (Supervision should provide a very reliable boost) and their ability to resume coverage would be based on their agility and speed. The more agile/faster they are, he better their chances of getting back into coverage if they recognise they have been faked.

Once the ball is thrown, DB 'recovery' rolls are given a bonus because the ball is now in the air and if they haven't already recovered from the fake, they can now trace its trajectory and begin moving in the proper direction. It's still not 100% but it should be very high percentage chance so that they will recover.

In this way, DB's will behave more realistically. They will constantly be moving (although sometimes in the wrong direction) and will have a chance to actually stop the receiver who previously was blowing by them with no coverage at all for long yardage/TD's because the code called for the DB to freeze which meant they were motionless for a significant amount of time.


Good idea in general, but a fake can also result in the DB slowing down (besides him going the wrong way).

"Freezing" sure isn't a good idea; keep going in the former or a wrong direction and/or slowing down / over accelerating is.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by RAPB

- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?


People would need to get used to the better possession receivers making great catches, even when the defender is right on top of them. Maybe the PbP could say "Great catch by Receiver Name!" to indicate that it was a catch based on catching ability despite very good coverage.

All receivers would have some chance at the "Great catch..."es, as it would compare the relevant stats (and just how well covered) to a random number, and anyone would win at times. But someone with 60 Catching should get many more "great" catches than someone with 30 Catching; and not only double, but many more than double.


... another way: possession guys require more accurate throws - so the QBs needs to be build in order to do so. A well covered guy should be harder to hit i.m.h.o.; at the same time, you could provide a bonus to his further movement. I see WRs stop A LOT to catch the ball. Maybe possession guys could just pick up the ball while maintaining full speed? So even a little separation (which they get unless the CB is set on "bite on everything") will result in a complete pass and even some extra yards after catch?

I generally disagree with receivers making the majority of catches even in "perfect" coverage. If the defender is all over the receiver, he can not only deflect the ball before the receiver even gets a chance to catch. He can also swat the ball out of the hands before the pass is complete. So high jumping/catching should not guarantee a completed pass - for you sure got a hand on the ball, but you need to hold on afterwards.


Well, in real life, the possession receiver is seen as the sure way to get the catch made-- not as the YAC threat, and (as is already true in any suggestion) not as the burner.

Basically, the completion percentage to him should be higher, but the yards per completion lower. Giving him a YAC advantage doesn't achieve this. It would need to be achieved by letting high enough Catching, Vision, and Jumping catch the ball in traffic very well, even as other types don't do it as well as they do now if they're covered well.

And he actually needs a less precise throw. The greatest possession receivers are the ones who always seem to come up with the ball-- hence in the possession tree Jumping Catch, Diving Catch, and even One-Hand Catch.

One way or another, he needs to win ball fights a good amount of the time.
 
uofi316
offline
Link
 
Another thing I think should be included is to have the CB recognize the route. In our last game the offense ran the same play 4 times in a row, and the same WR caught the ball each time for a 5-10 yard gain. Each time the play was run the CB reacted the same way. In real life if a WR keeps making the same move, the CB will catch on and will try to jump the route. Obviously in real life the WR can break the route and make changes on the fly which is something that can't happen in the game.

Maybe the CB can have something related to its vision that will allow them to notice it is the exact same play and alter their coverage appropriately. Each time the play is called the chances of the CB reading it correctly increases.

I am not sure how many plays Bort has designed for each formation, but maybe the next version of the offensive AI can have something where you can set a max % that each play can be called. So if you have a route that you think will really work you can try to take advantage of it, but also slowly increase the chance of it not working (does that make sense to anyone else?).
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uofi316
Another thing I think should be included is to have the CB recognize the route. In our last game the offense ran the same play 4 times in a row, and the same WR caught the ball each time for a 5-10 yard gain. Each time the play was run the CB reacted the same way. In real life if a WR keeps making the same move, the CB will catch on and will try to jump the route. Obviously in real life the WR can break the route and make changes on the fly which is something that can't happen in the game.

Maybe the CB can have something related to its vision that will allow them to notice it is the exact same play and alter their coverage appropriately. Each time the play is called the chances of the CB reading it correctly increases.

I am not sure how many plays Bort has designed for each formation, but maybe the next version of the offensive AI can have something where you can set a max % that each play can be called. So if you have a route that you think will really work you can try to take advantage of it, but also slowly increase the chance of it not working (does that make sense to anyone else?).


That's more of a symptom of just not that many offensive plays in the playbook. There was a thread floating around a while ago where we were talking about getting some plays submitted from the community into the playbook.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uofi316
Another thing I think should be included is to have the CB recognize the route. In our last game the offense ran the same play 4 times in a row, and the same WR caught the ball each time for a 5-10 yard gain. Each time the play was run the CB reacted the same way. In real life if a WR keeps making the same move, the CB will catch on and will try to jump the route. Obviously in real life the WR can break the route and make changes on the fly which is something that can't happen in the game.

Maybe the CB can have something related to its vision that will allow them to notice it is the exact same play and alter their coverage appropriately. Each time the play is called the chances of the CB reading it correctly increases.

I am not sure how many plays Bort has designed for each formation, but maybe the next version of the offensive AI can have something where you can set a max % that each play can be called. So if you have a route that you think will really work you can try to take advantage of it, but also slowly increase the chance of it not working (does that make sense to anyone else?).


I think there need to be more plays before CB's can be allowed to recognize the routes-- because there aren't right now all that many plays.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by uofi316

Another thing I think should be included is to have the CB recognize the route. In our last game the offense ran the same play 4 times in a row, and the same WR caught the ball each time for a 5-10 yard gain. Each time the play was run the CB reacted the same way. In real life if a WR keeps making the same move, the CB will catch on and will try to jump the route. Obviously in real life the WR can break the route and make changes on the fly which is something that can't happen in the game.

Maybe the CB can have something related to its vision that will allow them to notice it is the exact same play and alter their coverage appropriately. Each time the play is called the chances of the CB reading it correctly increases.

I am not sure how many plays Bort has designed for each formation, but maybe the next version of the offensive AI can have something where you can set a max % that each play can be called. So if you have a route that you think will really work you can try to take advantage of it, but also slowly increase the chance of it not working (does that make sense to anyone else?).


That's more of a symptom of just not that many offensive plays in the playbook. There was a thread floating around a while ago where we were talking about getting some plays submitted from the community into the playbook.


I think that's a very good idea, with somehow some testing (hopefully not requiring your time-- could DD do it?) to filter out both truly bad plays and plays that defeat everything.

People would enjoy getting to create plays, even if they'd be reviewed for "not too bad, and not too good" before they could get into the game.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
...
Well, in real life, the possession receiver is seen as the sure way to get the catch made-- not as the YAC threat, and (as is already true in any suggestion) not as the burner.

Basically, the completion percentage to him should be higher, but the yards per completion lower. Giving him a YAC advantage doesn't achieve this. It would need to be achieved by letting high enough Catching, Vision, and Jumping catch the ball in traffic very well, even as other types don't do it as well as they do now if they're covered well.

And he actually needs a less precise throw. The greatest possession receivers are the ones who always seem to come up with the ball-- hence in the possession tree Jumping Catch, Diving Catch, and even One-Hand Catch.

One way or another, he needs to win ball fights a good amount of the time.


We are talking about an WR not beeing able to get any separation at all, right?

In this case my thought was like:

- a less precise throw can be caught by this WR for sure - but since he'll be in close coverage almost all the time: this pass will be swatted down by the defender more likely (naturally it's hard to make a catch while the defender gets his arm or even his body in front of the receiver - besides that, the defender can perfectly time the attack on the ball and man after the first touch)

- so that WR needs either a pass...

...perfectly overthrown - so only that (great) jumping will enable to get a hand on it; if thrown too high - uncatchable and might get picked up by another defender... if thrown within "normal range" - the defender will be able to get a hand on it

... perfectly thrown away from the defender / underthrown - so only that catching abilities and some fine jumping make that pass catchable. Of course: after a diving catch there shouldn't be any chance to advance the ball too: the WR will immediatly be down after the catch (no tackle needed!)

... a bullet thrown so fast that there isn't time for the defender to react and just fingertips won't do.

That's why I suggested even more "precise" throws.

I see this as kind of balance: A QB able to throw 40+ yard bombs in a row shouldn't be able to throw that "precision throws" too often. No player should "have it all". Besides that: there's less chance of any pass rushing on shorter passes, because it takes less time to get rid of the ball.

Maybe catching a pass in close coverage could get harder based on distance too - but I'm not sure if there needs to be extra formulas. As the ball travels for a longer time, the additional agility and speed of the defender should show effects.

Generally - as SA Route Run shows - Possession WRs should be interested in getting separation too. They just do it in a different way and they don't need as much distance. While speedsters try to outsprint the CB and beat him deep on straight or slightly turned routes (i.e. go or post routes), the possession guy is great at short cuts (i.e. comeback routes; quick in/out routes). He just makes a turn or comeback move so quick that the defender just stays a few inches away for a split second. And he catches so fast that this is enough for a completion.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uofi316
Another thing I think should be included is to have the CB recognize the route. In our last game the offense ran the same play 4 times in a row, and the same WR caught the ball each time for a 5-10 yard gain. Each time the play was run the CB reacted the same way. In real life if a WR keeps making the same move, the CB will catch on and will try to jump the route. Obviously in real life the WR can break the route and make changes on the fly which is something that can't happen in the game.
...


Not really about coverages, but in general:

Right now a game can get pretty stupid and unrealistic if one team just calls the same play over and over (this might be their only chance for only this play works well - but still unrealistic). There were already some games with goalline-offense all plays. And we had a scrimmage with like 80% outside runs and not a single inside rush.

A solution would be to give the defenders an increasing bonus on this play, maybe starting at 20 times and getting huge at like 35 times. A "normal" game has about 70-80 offensive snaps (QB plays). So if a team calls the same play 1/4 of the time, the defenders will react. Since the SIM can't do so, a increasing bonus might help.
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 13:00:34
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by Ken1

...
Well, in real life, the possession receiver is seen as the sure way to get the catch made-- not as the YAC threat, and (as is already true in any suggestion) not as the burner.

Basically, the completion percentage to him should be higher, but the yards per completion lower. Giving him a YAC advantage doesn't achieve this. It would need to be achieved by letting high enough Catching, Vision, and Jumping catch the ball in traffic very well, even as other types don't do it as well as they do now if they're covered well.

And he actually needs a less precise throw. The greatest possession receivers are the ones who always seem to come up with the ball-- hence in the possession tree Jumping Catch, Diving Catch, and even One-Hand Catch.

One way or another, he needs to win ball fights a good amount of the time.


We are talking about an WR not beeing able to get any separation at all, right?

In this case my thought was like:

- a less precise throw can be caught by this WR for sure - but since he'll be in close coverage almost all the time: this pass will be swatted down by the defender more likely (naturally it's hard to make a catch while the defender gets his arm or even his body in front of the receiver - besides that, the defender can perfectly time the attack on the ball and man after the first touch)

- so that WR needs either a pass...

...perfectly overthrown - so only that (great) jumping will enable to get a hand on it; if thrown too high - uncatchable and might get picked up by another defender... if thrown within "normal range" - the defender will be able to get a hand on it

... perfectly thrown away from the defender / underthrown - so only that catching abilities and some fine jumping make that pass catchable. Of course: after a diving catch there shouldn't be any chance to advance the ball too: the WR will immediatly be down after the catch (no tackle needed!)

... a bullet thrown so fast that there isn't time for the defender to react and just fingertips won't do.

That's why I suggested even more "precise" throws.

I see this as kind of balance: A QB able to throw 40+ yard bombs in a row shouldn't be able to throw that "precision throws" too often. No player should "have it all". Besides that: there's less chance of any pass rushing on shorter passes, because it takes less time to get rid of the ball.

Maybe catching a pass in close coverage could get harder based on distance too - but I'm not sure if there needs to be extra formulas. As the ball travels for a longer time, the additional agility and speed of the defender should show effects.

Generally - as SA Route Run shows - Possession WRs should be interested in getting separation too. They just do it in a different way and they don't need as much distance. While speedsters try to outsprint the CB and beat him deep on straight or slightly turned routes (i.e. go or post routes), the possession guy is great at short cuts (i.e. comeback routes; quick in/out routes). He just makes a turn or comeback move so quick that the defender just stays a few inches away for a split second. And he catches so fast that this is enough for a completion.


I can agree with you on that, especially on bullets. I QB who has possession receivers and wants to best use them should be on "Bullet" for throw type, while one who wants to best utilize speedsters should be on "Lofty."

Or maybe receivers should be allowed to specify preference (to give them something more to set and help offset the CB coverage options) and the QB could set the default as he does, but with a Yes/No box of "defer to the receiver's preferred pass type when possible."
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.