User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tremele
Originally posted by Bort

Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on level 21 DTs, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Are you asking him why he is only posting to intelligent discussions?
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by tremele

Originally posted by Bort


Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on level 21 DTs, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Are you asking him why he is only posting to intelligent discussions?


Apparently, it's hard to read, but yeah. Why not post to plays showing huge bugs?
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 23:28:48
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tremele
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by tremele
Originally posted by Bort

Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on level 21 DTs, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Are you asking him why he is only posting to intelligent discussions?


Apparently, it's hard to read, but yeah. Why not post to plays showing huge bugs?


Because your argument was stupid? Come up with some reasons or something rather than "Game's broke!"
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tremele

Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Tremele,

The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Interesting, I would have expected the man to man coverage to handle the "don't let the guy get behind me". I figured it had a close man to man, a 5 yard cushion, and a 10 yard, never let the man pass you setting. Each having its own advantages and disadvantages in coverage.

OK, fair enough, I will drop AllDay down to Medium and see how he performs, and get you some of his stats. Thanks for replying. I know how busy and frustrated you have to be right about now.

PinTBC

 
tremele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by tremele

Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by tremele

Originally posted by Bort


Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on level 21 DTs, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Are you asking him why he is only posting to intelligent discussions?


Apparently, it's hard to read, but yeah. Why not post to plays showing huge bugs?


Because your argument was stupid? Come up with some reasons or something rather than "Game's broke!"


I didn't have an argument and there wasn't one at the thread I'm referring to, however I still haven't seen a Bort post on this.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=854606
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by tremele


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Tremele,

The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.

PinTBC


Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC

Originally posted by tremele



Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.


Tremele,

The problem with using a single play as an example of things wrong is that there are multiple random rolls on every play. It means that every once in a blue moon, a Level 1 HB can actually get lucky and break tackles due to a variety of reasons. If that same level 1 HB is breaking tackles right and left every game, then you have a statitcial method to point that something might be wrong.

PinTBC


Indeed. A man who plays the lottery once can still win.


Twice in the same day?
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 18:28:26
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Interesting data point.

My CB played on Medium in this game, agains assigned to their highest receiver and not a single pass was thrown in his direction...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104510

PinTBC
 
vt_dolfan
offline
Link
 
Hey Pin....great job with the line of questioning...bring this info back to A#8...or...I mean...I wont tell if you wont!!!
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Please don't let this thread become an emotional rant. I am trying to gather and present hard numbers specific to the WR and CB secondary problems.

*****************
OK Bort,

Some stats from our last game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104437

I am focusing on AllDay McRae who is probablly our best Corner. I matched him up generally against their best receiver.

AllDay looks like this (not saying he is all world, but he is a pretty decent 27th CB):

Strength: 16.08 Blocking: 8
Speed: 71.74 Tackling: 19.58
Agility: 55.69 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 30.01 Catching: 29.45
Stamina: 35.02 Carrying: 20.85
Vision: 44.07 Kicking: 10
Confidence: 27.63 Punting: 7

Specials are:
3 Swat Ball, 4 sticky Hands, 6 Super Vision, 2 Smooth Operator, and 3 shutdown coverage
1 First step, 2 change direction, 2 return spec, 1 Blitz, and 2 closing speed

The guys he covered were Tom Cruise Level 27 WR, and Jrue Holiday level 21 WR. There were 16 passes thrown to the guys he was covering, and 14 were completed, 2 were not. There were no PDs, nor interceptions.

AllDay was in Pass focus, Man to Man – Close coverage stick to your man like glue, and loose coverage style, play it safe and don’t get beat. Since you stated in a different thread that “Aggressive – go for interception even if you may get beat will give the defender a negative on the “catch” roll, I thought I’d try the loose hoping it might balance out. I expect that it doesn't.

The success rate for the offense when throwing the ball in his direction was 87.5%, a far cry from your 50-65% on even matchups. Remember please, he went against a good 27th WR, and a 21st WR, both caught most everything thrown to them.

This is the basis for my dissatisfaction with the current defensive secondary model. Even if the 27th WR is MUCH better trained, I’d be hard pressed to believe the level 21 is.

I’m willing to gather information in the next few games if you wish?

PinTBC


Completion % can be misleading, you would have to factor in the distance of the completions. For passes under 10 yards the completion rates are going to be high, 12-14 can be normal if all passes were in the 5 yard range. But as distance gets longer, the % should drop. If they are completing 12-14 for medium (10-20) and long passes (20+), then you are in trouble.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vt_dolfan
Hey Pin....great job with the line of questioning...bring this info back to A#8...or...I mean...I wont tell if you wont!!!


Heh!

Luckily for me, AllDay McRae is on a team in Africa!



AND with some of the defenses we've played against in A8, they pretty much know this stuff. That league has some killer teams in it.

PinTBC
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.