User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Whiners: STFU! This forum is for REAL bugs.
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.

The speed/agility DEs running directly at the offensive tackles has been largely fixed also, and I included it as an other example of people bringing up problems and seeing them get fixed quickly.

PinTBC
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
i agree, stfu you whiny little bitches
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.

The speed/agility DEs running directly at the offensive tackles has been largely fixed also, and I included it as an other example of people bringing up problems and seeing them get fixed quickly.

PinTBC


That definitely isn't what you said or insinuated but ok,

What other problems besides the coverage?
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
So whining about other people whining is the cool thing to do now? LOL
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.


Right. That's what belongs in this forum. What doesn't belong here is "My LB never missed a tackle in Season 3 and now he missed 5 in a game!"

I'm saying put Season 3 out of your mind. It was in no way reslistic. It wasn't football at all.

It's a good thing to point out actual bugs in Season 4 implementation, and a good thing (though it belongs in the Suggestions forum) to point out how we could keep the O/D balanced much, much more realistically but eliminate aspects of how it's done to be much more realistic (e.g. instead of triple covered receivers making catches, make it easier to beat tight coverage).
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 20:11:13
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Ken1

The Season 3 "sim" simulated nothing other than perhaps games played in blizzards. I'm sorry if you got used to games with no TD's and perfect CB's and guys making tackles even if their tackling was low (and no one even thniking of soft-capping tackling).

But this sim is better, more exciting, and more true to football, where even the losing team almost always scores TD's.

If you have tweaks to make it more realistic without draining out the offense, those go in "Suggestions."

If you wish for Season 3ish results again, then you don't want a football sim and should just STFU. They sure aren't BUGS, which is what this forum is for.


So, when you were whining about the problems you saw in season three, you would have had no problem with someone posting something like this? You never posted your dissatisfaction with the season 3 sims in the Bugs folder?

There are some serious issues with season 4, and categorizing everyone who is pointing them out as whiners doesn't exactly help get the issues out and fixed.

Just because YOU happen to like the changes, doesn't mean that everyone is as enamored with them as you are.

PinTBC


+1
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
sjmay,

I'm looking for a game that is fun to play, where neither the offense nor defense has the upper hand, and success is directly dependant on the player builds.

I've played since the mid point of season 1, I have 2 DEs, and even though everyone was saying the accepted build was to go high speed, and vision, I designed my guys with decent speed, agility, vision, and slightly lower strength and tackle. They were average players in season 3, and do fairly well now in season 4. I tell you that so you know the changes in season 4 are not killing me.

My CBs were designed the same way, and are not useless in season 4. What I don't like is the general idea that because the NFL manages a 70% completion rate overall, then GLB must do the same. I truly believe that player builds and tactics should decide the success or failure of plays.

Equal builds should stand a 50-50 chance of being successful, modified by tactics, and special abilities.

PinTBC
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
sjmay,

I'm looking for a game that is fun to play, where neither the offense nor defense has the upper hand, and success is directly dependant on the player builds.

I've played since the mid point of season 1, I have 2 DEs, and even though everyone was saying the accepted build was to go high speed, and vision, I designed my guys with decent speed, agility, vision, and slightly lower strength and tackle. They were average players in season 3, and do fairly well now in season 4. I tell you that so you know the changes in season 4 are not killing me.

My CBs were designed the same way, and are not useless in season 4. What I don't like is the general idea that because the NFL manages a 70% completion rate overall, then GLB must do the same. I truly believe that player builds and tactics should decide the success or failure of plays.

Equal builds should stand a 50-50 chance of being successful, modified by tactics, and special abilities.

PinTBC



I agree to a point, 70% completion shouldn't be a target, but a range, 60-75 etc and then let the builds and tactics compete.

But my question is, when most teams play against each other, the builds are closed, so how do you know what a similar or equal build is??
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by PinTBC

Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.


Right. That's what belongs in this forum. What doesn't belong here is "My LB never missed a tackle in Season 3 and now he missed 5 in a game!"

I'm saying put Season 3 out of your mind. It was in no way reslistic. It wasn't football at all.

It's a good thing to point out actual bugs in Season 4 implementation, and a good thing (though it belongs in the Suggestions forum) to point out how we could keep the O/D balanced much, much more realistically but eliminate aspects of how it's done to be much more realistic (e.g. instead of triple covered receivers making catches, make it easier to beat tight coverage).


You know Ken you say that season 3 was not realistic and many, many people are saying that about season 4, so you think the game is perfect now?
Season 3 was "in no way realistic" and In my opinion neither is season 4...I am just as right as you are!
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
it's way more realistic now then in season 3 slick, now i know ur an idiot
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NWWarrior
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by PinTBC


Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.


Right. That's what belongs in this forum. What doesn't belong here is "My LB never missed a tackle in Season 3 and now he missed 5 in a game!"

I'm saying put Season 3 out of your mind. It was in no way reslistic. It wasn't football at all.

It's a good thing to point out actual bugs in Season 4 implementation, and a good thing (though it belongs in the Suggestions forum) to point out how we could keep the O/D balanced much, much more realistically but eliminate aspects of how it's done to be much more realistic (e.g. instead of triple covered receivers making catches, make it easier to beat tight coverage).


You know Ken you say that season 3 was not realistic and many, many people are saying that about season 4, so you think the game is perfect now?
Season 3 was "in no way realistic" and In my opinion neither is season 4...I am just as right as you are!


Ok,

You have your opinion there, but tell me what exactly is not realistic about Season 4, that was realistic, in season 3.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
The DT's have been scaled way back and the DE's have been swung back up. C'est la vie.

 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by NWWarrior

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by PinTBC



Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.


Right. That's what belongs in this forum. What doesn't belong here is "My LB never missed a tackle in Season 3 and now he missed 5 in a game!"

I'm saying put Season 3 out of your mind. It was in no way reslistic. It wasn't football at all.

It's a good thing to point out actual bugs in Season 4 implementation, and a good thing (though it belongs in the Suggestions forum) to point out how we could keep the O/D balanced much, much more realistically but eliminate aspects of how it's done to be much more realistic (e.g. instead of triple covered receivers making catches, make it easier to beat tight coverage).


You know Ken you say that season 3 was not realistic and many, many people are saying that about season 4, so you think the game is perfect now?
Season 3 was "in no way realistic" and In my opinion neither is season 4...I am just as right as you are!


Ok,

You have your opinion there, but tell me what exactly is not realistic about Season 4, that was realistic, in season 3.


Pass coverage, linebacker behavior on running plays, and power backs are totally unrealistic and much worse than before.

The OL-DL aspect of the game is much better, making rushing relevant again.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
So whining about other people whining is the cool thing to do now? LOL


+1
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by NWWarrior


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by PinTBC




Actually, I only included the linebacker thing as an example of something someone pointed out that was fixed. It was actually a bug the Bort found and stomped on.


Right. That's what belongs in this forum. What doesn't belong here is "My LB never missed a tackle in Season 3 and now he missed 5 in a game!"

I'm saying put Season 3 out of your mind. It was in no way reslistic. It wasn't football at all.

It's a good thing to point out actual bugs in Season 4 implementation, and a good thing (though it belongs in the Suggestions forum) to point out how we could keep the O/D balanced much, much more realistically but eliminate aspects of how it's done to be much more realistic (e.g. instead of triple covered receivers making catches, make it easier to beat tight coverage).


You know Ken you say that season 3 was not realistic and many, many people are saying that about season 4, so you think the game is perfect now?
Season 3 was "in no way realistic" and In my opinion neither is season 4...I am just as right as you are!


Ok,

You have your opinion there, but tell me what exactly is not realistic about Season 4, that was realistic, in season 3.


Pass coverage, linebacker behavior on running plays, and power backs are totally unrealistic and much worse than before.

The OL-DL aspect of the game is much better, making rushing relevant again.


Lineback behavior - FIXED
Power backs - NEVER WAS A PROBLEM, running wasn't touched, TACKLING was, so anyone that complains about power backs, are probably the ones who didn't think tackling was necessary for defensive players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.