User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Originally posted by stahu miguel

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=97305&pbp_id=3776592

Fix the damn game bort. Passes to a shorter TE or WR over players who are supposedly taller with better jumping?

This is stupid. Keep this crap up, and I'm out. I'm sick of it.


Ever hear of David Tyree?


I'm sorry, but this game is only a best guess graphical representation of the game, not what actually happens.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Originally posted by CHA5E

It went through their hands, so you need to settle down Mr. Miguel.


It doesn't go through their hands on every play.


That TE had 3 catches for 21 yards in that game! OMG! That's just crazy!
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Bort

I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.


It happens sometimes. That TE had 3 catches in that game. What's the problem?
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DWinsRespect
I don't know how many times people need to say that the replays you see are merely a best guess graphical representation of the play, not of what actually happened.


Word. People need to stop putting so much stock in the dots.
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Shouldn't multiple defenders reduce the WR's catching roll as well? I mean, 2 or 3 "average" defenders should be able to shut down one "very good" WR, but if it is just their individually 3 rolls vs the WRs 1 roll, obviously 55, 60, 65 vs 80+ is not gonna win..
 
DWinsRespect
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
The problem is you're adding in SA's for the offensive player; the defense has SA's too.

Maybe the defense SA's weren't activated for the particular play? There are so many variables that go into a players production that you can't rely on a graphical representation to judge a play.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TreMetal
Originally posted by Bort

I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Shouldn't multiple defenders reduce the WR's catching roll as well? I mean, 2 or 3 "average" defenders should be able to shut down one "very good" WR, but if it is just their individually 3 rolls vs the WRs 1 roll, obviously 55, 60, 65 vs 80+ is not gonna win..


It does...but they can still catch the ball if the rolls go their way.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Is the sim a zero sum game? I didn't ask to go back to another broken aspect of the game. There are other changes you can make to correct this.

1. Triple coverage should not result in a completed pass.

2. Triple coverage should not result in a qb with good vision attempting the pass.

If there are that many rolls, it shouldn't result in a completion most of the time, and if the rolls result in a tipped ball, less than 10% should result in completions. It just doesn't happen in real life, but it's almost 50% in the game right now.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gator93
The play you showed had a TE catching it in double coverage of what looks like the SS tipped it. Nothing wrong with that, good catch. Calm down


The problem is it happens ALL THE TIME since the latest WR/CB tweaks. In an even fight the passing defenses now suck . . . and I'm an offensive guy!
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


Its Beta, and that's cool. I think we need to find a middle ground, not simply "go back."
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I feel their pain. It is aggravating to have a guy in double coverage on a long pass and have him covered so that you can't even see the blue dot anymore and he makes the catch. It is frustrating.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The only reason multiple coverage now results in a QB being able to attempt the pass is because people bitched about certain players never getting targeted, even if he's a better catcher than his defenders. If the receiver has a good chance of catching the ball vs his defenders' tipping abilities, he can still get the ball thrown his way.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
We get it. You're mad because you lost.

The sim is fine. First of all, it wasn't triple coverage. The CB was covering the WR.

Second, you want it to NEVER be able to make a catch in triple or double coverage? Then what's the point of even trying? A defense can just double team a team's best WR all game and keep him at 0 yds.

What if 2 lvl 2 CBs were double teaming a lvl 15 WR? The WR shouldn't be able to make the catch?

Just because the sim didn't go your way, doesn't mean it's broken.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.