User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
level 1 isn't some random guy off the street with no football ability. It should be a rookie. Like a college player. Otherwise it defeats the purpose of these football sims. A rookie is already a footballer, an athlete. This includes the whole XP and trading thing too. Cannot have a team in pro-league signing a level 1 random guy off the street to suddenly be a back-up DT in a pro-league. If a level 1 player starts off with 10 speed, 10 tackling, 10 vision, etc. And a level 10 player is someone with 50 speed, 50 tackling, 50 vision, then it's literally like an NFL team playing a grade school team...which is resulting in these explanations of 20-50 pancakes per game and theoritically then 20-50 TDs to a WR in a game against a level 5 CB.

The entry point of a rookie should already start at 90 across a bunch of areas. And therefore a 10 season vet in GLB maximum attainable could be 100 across a bunch of areas. Not a perfect 100 in every category, but able to max out a couple of categories. But 100 speed vs 90 speed will therefore mean still fairly matched players and might result in only that one or two crucial mistake a game or something. This to also allow new people to GLB to actually sign up and create new players that can compete right away. But the current system of XP does not allow anyone to ever catch up with the rest of the GLB community and means the team owner will always keep them like 5th string OT behind the level 11, level 10, level 9, level 6 players in that depth chart.
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 19:46:15
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
You need to stop thinking of level 1s as a nfl rookie though. Start thinking more of high school player.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
so a guy should be able to be as good right away as someone who spent 6 seasons on their player?
um doesn't really sound fair to me...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I know that's what level 1's are in GLB at the moment. But im suggesting that is no longer tenable. Due to the on-going situation where many many games are gonna feature a level 15 Center vs a level 7 DT. And how that level/skill difference currently can/does/will result in 20-50 pancakes a game....or 20 TDs given up by a CB, etc.

Which THEN brings a collapse to the whole thing of getting people to sign up and/or create new level 1 players, on teams where they will just forever exist as 5th string DT and therefore will never get a game or game time. Etc.

Think long-term.
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
So, GG, what is the pint i nme spending cash on doign a level boost on my player if they'll play essentailly the same on level 1 as level 40?

There's a reason there are leagues from level BBB all the way up to pro. The idea is over your ten year career you try to progress up the ladder and eventually reach pro. You have to have something to strive for.
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Which THEN brings a collapse to the whole thing of getting people to sign up and/or create new level 1 players, on teams where they will just forever exist as 5th string DT and therefore will never get a game or game time. Etc.



No, the new person will go to a B or even C team and work their way up. The level 15 guys will be at or below low A six season from now. My CB should be at Pro, hopefully, but will be seven season old and almost on his way to forced retirement.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
so a guy should be able to be as good right away as someone who spent 6 seasons on their player?
um doesn't really sound fair to me...


Think bigger picture as explained in the post above. I'm STILL saying there should be a difference, but not 10 speed as a level 1 and 100 speed as a level 100. But more like all physical skills between level 1 and level 100 should be no greater than 90-100. And football skills maybe a little more, like 50 min and 100 max. Where that 50 difference ends up meaning a pancake or two a game. Or a few too many 35 yard receptions given up.
 
bibi
offline
Link
 
Have you ever played a MMORPG? People who spend more time are going to have an advantage. It's as simple as that.

You can go play your Barbie Playhouse Interactive Adventure if you want everything to be fair and even with springtime and flowers and lillies aplenty.

As they've said, there's gonna be level caps on leagues, so you won't get level 30s against level 1s.

If you make them even, then the level 30s would probably see no point in playing anymore and would quit, which would be much worse than some level 1 scrubs deciding they should be the best as soon as join quitting.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I own a team in pro-league....most of them are all level 2-8 players. Each season i play and we keep the same team roughly, they'll progress to level 8-15 now. But one day a bunch of them get traded, quit, etc. Or maybe i need a new OT asap and create one myself. Buy FPs and create a player from scratch. Happily pump money to boost him to level 4. But hang on, I cant play him because im up against level 20 players. So why did i create a player? If he sits on the bench for the rest of his life because i trade for and acquire level 15 back-ups. Each game the XP earned will always be the same so theres ZERO progress for that player. Always gonna be 10 levels behind everyone and therefore never gets to be starter.

And why did I create a player that I cannot play on my team? I have to have him go to the ZZZZZZ league? I want him on my team in the pro-league. I just pumped $10 into him. I want him. Or...maybe he's a friend of mine. I want him on my team. But I cant because he's level 1 and my team is in the pro-league with level 20 people?

Defeats the purpose.

Hence...why level 1 should be all 90 skill and level 10 max level 100 skill max. Something like that. But...per season boosting might mean you can only distribute 1-3 points per season, as opposed to 15 per 3 levels.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Well good luck convicning me (or most people to be honest) that you should be able to create a level 4 to be able to beat level 15s.
 
bibi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I own a team in pro-league....most of them are all level 2-8 players. Each season i play and we keep the same team roughly, they'll progress to level 8-15 now. But one day a bunch of them get traded, quit, etc. Or maybe i need a new OT asap and create one myself. Buy FPs and create a player from scratch. Happily pump money to boost him to level 4. But hang on, I cant play him because im up against level 20 players. So why did i create a player? If he sits on the bench for the rest of his life because i trade for and acquire level 15 back-ups. Each game the XP earned will always be the same so theres ZERO progress for that player. Always gonna be 10 levels behind everyone and therefore never gets to be starter.

And why did I create a player that I cannot play on my team? I have to have him go to the ZZZZZZ league? I want him on my team in the pro-league. I just pumped $10 into him. I want him. Or...maybe he's a friend of mine. I want him on my team. But I cant because he's level 1 and my team is in the pro-league with level 20 people?

Defeats the purpose.

Hence...why level 1 should be all 90 skill and level 10 max level 100 skill max. Something like that. But...per season boosting might mean you can only distribute 1-3 points per season, as opposed to 15 per 3 levels.


Stop bitching because people are better than you.

I own a team in pro league...we've been playing 8 seasons together spending hundreds of dollars boosting and whatnot. We're all level 60ish. Then along comes some asshole with his team full of level 1 and he beats my team. I'm thinking this game is retarded and I quit.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Bort is already saying that there's a 10 season maximum effectiveness to a player. The older he gets the less he gets better and actually degenerates.

So...if you make it 10 seasons max. Then a level 1 should be a 1st year (rookie) starting on something fairly equal like 90 skills. And each season you can skill them up that by season 10 (when they retire) they've gotten to like 100 skills across a range of skill-sets. That difference means they ARE good players, pro-bowl types, but they're not raking in 20 TDs a game, or 50 pancakes a game. They're just more effective players.

Im suggesting something like that.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bibi

Stop bitching because people are better than you.

I own a team in pro league...we've been playing 8 seasons together spending hundreds of dollars boosting and whatnot. We're all level 60ish. Then along comes some asshole with his team full of level 1 and he beats my team. I'm thinking this game is retarded and I quit.


Im not bitching. Im defending the integrity of something. I personally am not complaining because MY team had 21 pancakes put against it. My team got knocked out three games ago. I just noticed the championship game between two other owners and saw that absurd 21 pancakes in one game and got told about how these obscene types of things CAN happen due to level differences....SO i realized there's obviously a problem there.

 
bibi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by bibi


Stop bitching because people are better than you.

I own a team in pro league...we've been playing 8 seasons together spending hundreds of dollars boosting and whatnot. We're all level 60ish. Then along comes some asshole with his team full of level 1 and he beats my team. I'm thinking this game is retarded and I quit.


Im not bitching. Im defending the integrity of something. I personally am not complaining because MY team had 21 pancakes put against it. My team got knocked out three games ago. I just noticed the championship game between two other owners and saw that absurd 21 pancakes in one game and got told about how these obscene types of things CAN happen due to level differences....SO i realized there's obviously a problem there.



The leagues will balance themselves out. It's the first season, some people bought teams in USA Pro and filled them with computers, obviously they're gonna get dominated by the elite opposition. Eventually the crappy teams will fall to where they belong and the goods teams will rise to wher ethey belong.

You can't expect to make a team and instantly have them be competitive with people who have spent much more time here and worked much harder. That's extremely unfair to those people.

Suck it up, play against players your own level, and maybe you'll be at the top in the future when the current Pros retire.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well good luck convicning me (or most people to be honest) that you should be able to create a level 4 to be able to beat level 15s.


Long-term...do you see new people signing up, joining GLB, creating players and pumping $10 per season into them.....IF....they never get a starter job, never rise from 5th string on the depth chart?

The whole idea of GLB is to make money, make people sign, have a huge demand to join, etc. Instead the opposite is occuring AFTER they realize they're never getting any game time etc. They stop funding these players. They complain and demand a trade, release. Looking for places where they can start. Which they never will because the theory is that those who've been here for 5 seasons will all be level 30 and therefore always infinitely superior such that these level 1-5 guys never get game time so they never pump money into that players development.

But you cant make a rule like boxing weight classes either, because I as team owner or registrant, should be able to create a level 1 player, or 10 of them if i want, and have them play on my team in whatever league i may own a team in. Not told to give them up and play for some other team. Or, I could get my friend(s) to join GLB and play for my team if they start at level 1 but there's some league-level rule might forbid level 1 players joining a pro-league team etc.

DO you see the catch-22?
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 20:18:27
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.