User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rychyrd
You all are missing the point. The Point is that having a CB freeze while the WR blows by him for that large a margin is unrealistic.

I agree it as probably caused by a Pump Fake...My complaint is that a Pump Fake should allow the WR to get a step or 2 on the CB. 3 if the CB is not built well. But to have decently built CB's ( FYI none are mine ) get beaten by 6-7 yds due to a Pump Fake is wrong and should be addressed


Most CBs play on Aggressive too. Those CBs probably bite harder on a pumpfake than a CB playing on medium or loose coverage would. It's a trade off.
 
Rychyrd
offline
Link
 
I have another whole different argument concerning The PUMP FAKE theory. It shouldn't apply on a CB in Tight Coverage as he would not be looking into the Back Field to see the Pump. He would be playing the receiver. The Pump Fake is designed to Freeze LB's and Safeties to keep them from getting over to help on the Play. OR on a CB in loose coverage that is back pedaling and looking into the backfield on a Stop and Go route.

That was not the case in any of these.

And before you say Head Fake or Juke by the WR. Those are used on a up and out type route to fake the DB while the WR makes his cut. All a head fake would do on a GO route which all these were, is cause the DB to hesitate a split second to get the seperation needed to make the catch. It would not Freeze a DB in his tracks
 
honz
offline
Link
 
The thing is that this has never happened before this season and now it has happened to us in multiple games this season. We have tweaked our CBs settings and nothing really seems to help.

We are all dumbfounded by what is going on and I am sure that it has to do with the sim setting and not our players or their builds.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by honz
The thing is that this has never happened before this season and now it has happened to us in multiple games this season. We have tweaked our CBs settings and nothing really seems to help.

We are all dumbfounded by what is going on and I am sure that it has to do with the sim setting and not our players or their builds.


I've seen this going back to last season and it's because of pump fake. During the offseason I heard a lot of people talking about pump fake being the next "big thing" so it makes sense you are seeing it more now.
 
byrongame21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Rychyrd

You all are missing the point. The Point is that having a CB freeze while the WR blows by him for that large a margin is unrealistic.
would you argue that it freezes the CB for half a second? if so, and taking the WR to run a 4.5 40, the WR gets 4.44 yards in half a second.



That math is assuming the CB was mentally disabled and fell for a pump fake while his WR was running a streak (aka the maximum speed you are recommending). Talk about unrealistic.

 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by byrongame21
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Rychyrd


You all are missing the point. The Point is that having a CB freeze while the WR blows by him for that large a margin is unrealistic.
would you argue that it freezes the CB for half a second? if so, and taking the WR to run a 4.5 40, the WR gets 4.44 yards in half a second.



That math is assuming the CB was mentally disabled and fell for a pump fake while his WR was running a streak (aka the maximum speed you are recommending). Talk about unrealistic.



See my post about arguing visual semantics over end results
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 15:59:05
 
coach
offline
Link
 
We need the ptts emoticon here.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 16:27:15
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by honz
The thing is that this has never happened before this season and now it has happened to us in multiple games this season. We have tweaked our CBs settings and nothing really seems to help.

We are all dumbfounded by what is going on and I am sure that it has to do with the sim setting and not our players or their builds.


Maybe the Passing game is finally effective, so that running teams dont just dominate every league?

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Pump Fakes need to be re-examined. They cause a 'stun' essentially and the separation allowed in the stun is far to great and becomes near unrecoverable. Just like CB's aren;t supposed to be perfect neither are WR's and QB's. A few extra yards or even a nice break out is fair, but high pump fakes = much more than that.

If I were in charge:

C snaps ball to QB.
QB watches play develop.
QB makes 'pump fake' check, this causes a check against vision/super vision for Defensive Secondary. If fail - they bite and move in direction of play pump fake would send them, if Succeed they continue in current coverage.
QB makes determination who is open, throws ball. Secondary that bit on Pump fake may have made a receiver open, but instead of standing their drooling, they can still react. If they have adequate speed and agility they can course correct and if not make the play, limit the size of the gain.

Presently the 'frozen' CB/Secondary from a pump fake is just far too much.
 
Dope
offline
Link
 
Nevermind.

Last edited Aug 13, 2008 20:19:40
 
lawdawg95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by honz

The thing is that this has never happened before this season and now it has happened to us in multiple games this season. We have tweaked our CBs settings and nothing really seems to help.

We are all dumbfounded by what is going on and I am sure that it has to do with the sim setting and not our players or their builds.


Maybe the Passing game is finally effective, so that running teams dont just dominate every league?



Except for the fact that running is working VERY well right now. Defenses in general are REALLY under the gun. Our team went from a VERY solid defense to having all kinds of pass coverage issues.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdawg95
Originally posted by Yellow

Originally posted by honz


The thing is that this has never happened before this season and now it has happened to us in multiple games this season. We have tweaked our CBs settings and nothing really seems to help.

We are all dumbfounded by what is going on and I am sure that it has to do with the sim setting and not our players or their builds.


Maybe the Passing game is finally effective, so that running teams dont just dominate every league?



Except for the fact that running is working VERY well right now. Defenses in general are REALLY under the gun. Our team went from a VERY solid defense to having all kinds of pass coverage issues.



Same here lawdog95. Our secondary was nothing short of shutdown last season, right now they're slightly above average.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Yeah but that stuff happens in this game. Player builds are constantly in flux from season to season, as certain players max out certain stats and are able to focus on other stuff.

All i'm saying it this could just as easily be a product of that as it could be a product of a bug.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Unless your supervision is 11 with 60 vision, you don't have an excuse to biting on pumpfake. Most good QB's focus on one thing till it's very high, be it Tight Spiral, Pump fake, or Field general.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by byrongame21
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

Originally posted by Rychyrd


You all are missing the point. The Point is that having a CB freeze while the WR blows by him for that large a margin is unrealistic.
would you argue that it freezes the CB for half a second? if so, and taking the WR to run a 4.5 40, the WR gets 4.44 yards in half a second.



That math is assuming the CB was mentally disabled and fell for a pump fake while his WR was running a streak (aka the maximum speed you are recommending). Talk about unrealistic.



Uh, how is that unrealistic? The route was 10 yards deep when the pump fake occured. Perhaps the CB was going to jump a post, a curl, an out, an in, etc.

Have you ever played cornerback competitively?

Also, the assertion that close bump and run coverage means you don't look at the qb or the play developing after the snap is quite wrong.

edit:

Although, I do agree that pump fakes should be more and less effective, depending on the route and the timing of the pump fake.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 00:09:40
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.