User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Insane number of deflected passes being caught.
Page:
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
INSANE@!!
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
one other thing - bort said the majority of CB's are playing on aggressive...and when they miss the INT their chances of deflection = incomplete pass goes down, chance of WR catch goes up, because they took the risk, risk vs. reward.



I understand the risk Vs reward concept. I don't disagree. But having played alot of WR in my day, I can tell you that the slightest tip, even a near-miss at a tip, vastly increases the difficulty of making the catch. Even if an arm flys in front of your face, just before the ball gets to you, breaks the view that you have of the ball.

Not that it becomes any kind of impossible to catch it, but it makes it alot more difficult to.

A slightly tipped pass would be alot like a bad hop on the infield, in baseball, without the advantage of being able to pick the ball up, after you knock it down. A bad hop is very rarely fielded cleanly, and when it is, it's generally because the bad hop occured far enough in front of the infielder for him to adjust.

In basketball, when a defender is unable to block the shooters actual shot, they are instructed to "get a hand in his face". Because, even if it is only there briefly, it blocks the shooters view. Alot of good shooters though, know where they are on the court, and know exactly where the basket is. Therefore, the effects are far less than with a reciever in football.

You could try an experiment. Have a friend who can throw the football fast, throw you some rockets. And, have another friend, who throws like a girl, stand beside you and move his hand quickly in front of your eyes, as the football is coming. Do it a few times.

If you try this experiment, don't blame me for your broken nose.
Last edited Aug 14, 2008 04:33:16
 
G33
offline
Link
 
Deflected could mean something as simple as "fingertipped." Everything is categorized as a catch, drop, or pass deflection, no matter what happens in the replay. My WR had a "dropped" ball after catching it and running for two yards before the CB knocked it out of his hands.
 
GridironGuru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
But having played alot of WR in my day, I can tell you that the slightest tip, even a near-miss at a tip, vastly increases the difficulty of making the catch. Even if an arm flys in front of your face, just before the ball gets to you, breaks the view that you have of the ball.

Not that it becomes any kind of impossible to catch it, but it makes it alot more difficult to.


That's my point. If the ball is deflected at all, the WR should have a greatly increased difficulty catching the ball. It just seems that it's not having as much an effect as it should.
 
GridironGuru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G33
Deflected could mean something as simple as "fingertipped." Everything is categorized as a catch, drop, or pass deflection, no matter what happens in the replay. My WR had a "dropped" ball after catching it and running for two yards before the CB knocked it out of his hands.


That should be changed to be a fumble. I've seen that too, even on my own team.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
I agree with you. There is an exaggeratedly high number of tipped passes that wind-up being caught. And, as you said, the chances of dropping a football that has been nearly tipped are too low here.

This could probably be tweaked somewhere, but I doubt that it happens anytime soon, as there are bigger fish to fry right now.

It's pretty rare to even get a response to these kind of inquiries, as I don't think there is a big enough staff to address everything.
 
G33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GridironGuru
Originally posted by G33

Deflected could mean something as simple as "fingertipped." Everything is categorized as a catch, drop, or pass deflection, no matter what happens in the replay. My WR had a "dropped" ball after catching it and running for two yards before the CB knocked it out of his hands.


That should be changed to be a fumble. I've seen that too, even on my own team.


Agreed. That's either a fumble, or my WR has really long legs.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G33
Originally posted by GridironGuru

Originally posted by G33


Deflected could mean something as simple as "fingertipped." Everything is categorized as a catch, drop, or pass deflection, no matter what happens in the replay. My WR had a "dropped" ball after catching it and running for two yards before the CB knocked it out of his hands.


That should be changed to be a fumble. I've seen that too, even on my own team.


Agreed. That's either a fumble, or my WR has really long legs.


Could it be a bobbled catch attempt?

 
GridironGuru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by G33

Originally posted by GridironGuru


Originally posted by G33



Deflected could mean something as simple as "fingertipped." Everything is categorized as a catch, drop, or pass deflection, no matter what happens in the replay. My WR had a "dropped" ball after catching it and running for two yards before the CB knocked it out of his hands.


That should be changed to be a fumble. I've seen that too, even on my own team.


Agreed. That's either a fumble, or my WR has really long legs.


Could it be a bobbled catch attempt?



It usually looks like the ball stabilizes on the WR and then they go a couple yards. Almost like it's a catch and turn or "making a football move".
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GridironGuru


It usually looks like the ball stabilizes on the WR and then they go a couple yards. Almost like it's a catch and turn or "making a football move".


I agree. It definitely looks like that. In fact, I saw one where the receiver appears to have caught the ball, then there is a missed tackle mentioned, and then a deflected pass, for an incomplete pass.

But, if you think of it in terms of real football, that seems like the only logical explanation to me.

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.