I'd argue that, if a player leaves, he's not really all that dedicated.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Firenze
offline
offline
Whilst the game is more realistic (especially the replays), there's still plenty of work to be done.
My kicker has a good build, but he sucked in preseason...thankfully he hasn't sucked as much in the Regular Season.
And the people who complain about how everyone will end up with cookie cutter builds...should realise that not everyone is going to have exactly the same build.
It's impossible for that to happen. They may have similar builds, but most positions already have a suggested and tested way of developing a certain position...so what's the difference?
My kicker has a good build, but he sucked in preseason...thankfully he hasn't sucked as much in the Regular Season.
And the people who complain about how everyone will end up with cookie cutter builds...should realise that not everyone is going to have exactly the same build.
It's impossible for that to happen. They may have similar builds, but most positions already have a suggested and tested way of developing a certain position...so what's the difference?
glaity
offline
offline
Originally posted by Firenze
Whilst the game is more realistic (especially the replays), there's still plenty of work to be done.
My kicker has a good build, but he sucked in preseason...thankfully he hasn't sucked as much in the Regular Season.
And the people who complain about how everyone will end up with cookie cutter builds...should realise that not everyone is going to have exactly the same build.
It's impossible for that to happen. They may have similar builds, but most positions already have a suggested and tested way of developing a certain position...so what's the difference?
exactly --- and people are going to build however the hell the want anyway regardless of "cookie cutter" builds, everyone is looking for the player with the odd build that will somehow fool the sim --- not me of course, I like cookies
Whilst the game is more realistic (especially the replays), there's still plenty of work to be done.
My kicker has a good build, but he sucked in preseason...thankfully he hasn't sucked as much in the Regular Season.
And the people who complain about how everyone will end up with cookie cutter builds...should realise that not everyone is going to have exactly the same build.
It's impossible for that to happen. They may have similar builds, but most positions already have a suggested and tested way of developing a certain position...so what's the difference?
exactly --- and people are going to build however the hell the want anyway regardless of "cookie cutter" builds, everyone is looking for the player with the odd build that will somehow fool the sim --- not me of course, I like cookies
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
At the end of season 3, despite owning a team that made the playoffs in season 2 and got a home game in season 3, I was considering letting my ownership lapse at the end of season 4.
The constant barrage of bitching and moaning on the boards, combined with what was clearly a "broken" sim engine was taking the fun out of the game. Despite losing game 1, I saw how much better the changes had made the game. Yesterday, I extended my ownership another season.
Are there still bugs? Sure. Is there a lot to learn? You bet. Are some build broken? Yep. Are some builds fixed? Hell yeah.
That's the point of keeping the beta tag on the game...to warn people that they are working towards a moving target.
Keep up the good work.
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
At the end of season 3, despite owning a team that made the playoffs in season 2 and got a home game in season 3, I was considering letting my ownership lapse at the end of season 4.
The constant barrage of bitching and moaning on the boards, combined with what was clearly a "broken" sim engine was taking the fun out of the game. Despite losing game 1, I saw how much better the changes had made the game. Yesterday, I extended my ownership another season.
Are there still bugs? Sure. Is there a lot to learn? You bet. Are some build broken? Yep. Are some builds fixed? Hell yeah.
That's the point of keeping the beta tag on the game...to warn people that they are working towards a moving target.
Keep up the good work.
drkaraoke
offline
offline
Bort Rocks!!
Oops maybe you missed that thing at the begining when you logged in..the B word..what was it..OH YEA BETA!
Oops maybe you missed that thing at the begining when you logged in..the B word..what was it..OH YEA BETA!
randomguymike
offline
offline
Originally posted by drkaraoke
Bort Rocks!!
Oops maybe you missed that thing at the begining when you logged in..the B word..what was it..OH YEA BETA!
1. The Beta argument will never convince me it is OK something doesn't work when something is broken. So, saying that makes people like me want to just say 'F* this beta' and leave.
2. That being said, this is not something that is broken. It is a fix to something that was not broken. I'm all for fixes, even if it makes the game more challenging in the short-term. Roll with the fixes and be happy the product is getting better, not pissed because your team isn't winning. Adjust and adapt. Worst case scenario your team has a bad season and you learn from it. It's not like you have big money on the line based on the outcome of the season.
Bort Rocks!!
Oops maybe you missed that thing at the begining when you logged in..the B word..what was it..OH YEA BETA!
1. The Beta argument will never convince me it is OK something doesn't work when something is broken. So, saying that makes people like me want to just say 'F* this beta' and leave.
2. That being said, this is not something that is broken. It is a fix to something that was not broken. I'm all for fixes, even if it makes the game more challenging in the short-term. Roll with the fixes and be happy the product is getting better, not pissed because your team isn't winning. Adjust and adapt. Worst case scenario your team has a bad season and you learn from it. It's not like you have big money on the line based on the outcome of the season.
Minnsooner
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
Sorry Bort, but the game is broken. You keep trying to fix it. The game changes have messed a lot of players up. I pay 10300 flex points every season, but that is about to stop. Should have tested this more, and when all these problems started, you could have said to us all, hey there are to many bugs and we will work on them and release all of this at a later date. I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
Sorry Bort, but the game is broken. You keep trying to fix it. The game changes have messed a lot of players up. I pay 10300 flex points every season, but that is about to stop. Should have tested this more, and when all these problems started, you could have said to us all, hey there are to many bugs and we will work on them and release all of this at a later date. I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
RunningMn9
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
You aren't damned if you make bug fixes. But you will be damned if you just change the way the passing game works one morning - while GLARING bugs remain (LBs deciding to drop back in deep zones on almost every running play, blockers on the gunners on the punt return not doing ANYTHING to impede the progress of the gunners, etc).
Who doesn't want you to fix bugs during the season? The problem is that you aren't just fixing bugs. You're changing the way that the game works in the middle of the season.
And enough with the "Hey, it's a BETA" defense that some use (not you that I've seen). I've participated in over a dozen betas, including rapidly changing MMORPGs. None of them cost the $200 it takes to maintain my team every 45 days or so. When people are paying that kind of scratch, you can't just treat it like a regular BETA.
When you render builds of high-level players into garbage, you should probably do what professional game companies do - allow your beta players to respec their players according to the new set of rules. My team has forked over almost $1000 so far since we started playing. And someone's answer here is to retire our players and start over at Lvl 1 with the new rules?!? That's insane.
Changing the sim and fixing it will ultimately make the game better (which is good). But with the amount of money people are spending, you're under an obligation to not completely hump your customers randomly during the season like this.
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
You aren't damned if you make bug fixes. But you will be damned if you just change the way the passing game works one morning - while GLARING bugs remain (LBs deciding to drop back in deep zones on almost every running play, blockers on the gunners on the punt return not doing ANYTHING to impede the progress of the gunners, etc).
Who doesn't want you to fix bugs during the season? The problem is that you aren't just fixing bugs. You're changing the way that the game works in the middle of the season.
And enough with the "Hey, it's a BETA" defense that some use (not you that I've seen). I've participated in over a dozen betas, including rapidly changing MMORPGs. None of them cost the $200 it takes to maintain my team every 45 days or so. When people are paying that kind of scratch, you can't just treat it like a regular BETA.
When you render builds of high-level players into garbage, you should probably do what professional game companies do - allow your beta players to respec their players according to the new set of rules. My team has forked over almost $1000 so far since we started playing. And someone's answer here is to retire our players and start over at Lvl 1 with the new rules?!? That's insane.
Changing the sim and fixing it will ultimately make the game better (which is good). But with the amount of money people are spending, you're under an obligation to not completely hump your customers randomly during the season like this.
UCHI_MATA_MASTER
offline
offline
Can I buy his team if he leaves? Hah, I said it first!!
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 14:36:02
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by Minnsooner
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
Sorry Bort, but the game is broken. You keep trying to fix it. The game changes have messed a lot of players up. I pay 10300 flex points every season, but that is about to stop. Should have tested this more, and when all these problems started, you could have said to us all, hey there are to many bugs and we will work on them and release all of this at a later date. I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
There were changes that were made today that will benefit many of your players. Shouldn't you wait to see them first?
And when you say something is broken, you should be specific. What, exactly, is broken?
The running game change was needed and is constantly being fixed. The QB and DE tactics were an excellent addition. And today's passing changes were much needed, although it's too early to say whether or not they were successful.
What, in a thread talking about Season 4 changes, do you think is broken?
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
Sorry Bort, but the game is broken. You keep trying to fix it. The game changes have messed a lot of players up. I pay 10300 flex points every season, but that is about to stop. Should have tested this more, and when all these problems started, you could have said to us all, hey there are to many bugs and we will work on them and release all of this at a later date. I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
There were changes that were made today that will benefit many of your players. Shouldn't you wait to see them first?
And when you say something is broken, you should be specific. What, exactly, is broken?
The running game change was needed and is constantly being fixed. The QB and DE tactics were an excellent addition. And today's passing changes were much needed, although it's too early to say whether or not they were successful.
What, in a thread talking about Season 4 changes, do you think is broken?
howyadoin
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
I am in a similar situation Bort, I have sent 2 support forms,Pm'd Thorn and received NO response in 11 days. My support forms and PMs are NOT bug related, yet about something else. Sorry to hijack the thread folks!
If I quit, I screw over the people on my team and I lose all the money I have spent, which by the way is quite a large amount.
All of this and not even a simple "we are busy and will get to you as soon as we can" form letter PM...so Bort I at least understand the damned if I do...Damned if I don't mindset.
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
I am in a similar situation Bort, I have sent 2 support forms,Pm'd Thorn and received NO response in 11 days. My support forms and PMs are NOT bug related, yet about something else. Sorry to hijack the thread folks!
If I quit, I screw over the people on my team and I lose all the money I have spent, which by the way is quite a large amount.
All of this and not even a simple "we are busy and will get to you as soon as we can" form letter PM...so Bort I at least understand the damned if I do...Damned if I don't mindset.
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
You aren't damned if you make bug fixes. But you will be damned if you just change the way the passing game works one morning - while GLARING bugs remain (LBs deciding to drop back in deep zones on almost every running play, blockers on the gunners on the punt return not doing ANYTHING to impede the progress of the gunners, etc).
Who doesn't want you to fix bugs during the season? The problem is that you aren't just fixing bugs. You're changing the way that the game works in the middle of the season.
And enough with the "Hey, it's a BETA" defense that some use (not you that I've seen). I've participated in over a dozen betas, including rapidly changing MMORPGs. None of them cost the $200 it takes to maintain my team every 45 days or so. When people are paying that kind of scratch, you can't just treat it like a regular BETA.
When you render builds of high-level players into garbage, you should probably do what professional game companies do - allow your beta players to respec their players according to the new set of rules. My team has forked over almost $1000 so far since we started playing. And someone's answer here is to retire our players and start over at Lvl 1 with the new rules?!? That's insane.
Changing the sim and fixing it will ultimately make the game better (which is good). But with the amount of money people are spending, you're under an obligation to not completely hump your customers randomly during the season like this.
It doesn't look like you were following the whole passing game issue, because it was buggy. Extremely so.
Yes, you mention other bugs that need to be looked into, but the passing game issue took precedence because it was a huge situation. Half of every team's offense, in fact.
And please explain what type of build was "rendered into garbage"? I can't think of any type of player that is now useless, or even significantly changed.
Again, specifics.
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
You aren't damned if you make bug fixes. But you will be damned if you just change the way the passing game works one morning - while GLARING bugs remain (LBs deciding to drop back in deep zones on almost every running play, blockers on the gunners on the punt return not doing ANYTHING to impede the progress of the gunners, etc).
Who doesn't want you to fix bugs during the season? The problem is that you aren't just fixing bugs. You're changing the way that the game works in the middle of the season.
And enough with the "Hey, it's a BETA" defense that some use (not you that I've seen). I've participated in over a dozen betas, including rapidly changing MMORPGs. None of them cost the $200 it takes to maintain my team every 45 days or so. When people are paying that kind of scratch, you can't just treat it like a regular BETA.
When you render builds of high-level players into garbage, you should probably do what professional game companies do - allow your beta players to respec their players according to the new set of rules. My team has forked over almost $1000 so far since we started playing. And someone's answer here is to retire our players and start over at Lvl 1 with the new rules?!? That's insane.
Changing the sim and fixing it will ultimately make the game better (which is good). But with the amount of money people are spending, you're under an obligation to not completely hump your customers randomly during the season like this.
It doesn't look like you were following the whole passing game issue, because it was buggy. Extremely so.
Yes, you mention other bugs that need to be looked into, but the passing game issue took precedence because it was a huge situation. Half of every team's offense, in fact.
And please explain what type of build was "rendered into garbage"? I can't think of any type of player that is now useless, or even significantly changed.
Again, specifics.
Rexxor
offline
offline
First off - I love the idea of this game and have committed real world dollars to that end. I respect you Bort for your time and effort in doing this all and do not mean to add to the rant, but want to provide constructive - I hesitate to call it criticism - lets call it observations.
Not that I'm upset by the changes - those are to be expected as you need to continue to improve the game. What bothers me at this point is throwing cash into a game and then having, as someone has suggested, "retire and start over" but loose all the cash invested in doing so. Just a suggestion - if you want folks to "re-roll" you give them 100% fp back or something more substantial than existing % or alternatively and option to reallocate some amount of points.
That being said, I'll muddle on and adjust as is. What bothers me most atm is the pathing issues, blocking assignment errors, etc in the sim. But with changes comes troubleshooting, just hope we can get it done sooner than later. I know your working your ass off Bort - its just frustrating seeing stuff that you put into play last year and worked so well get messed up by changes that occur in the new season but have no way of finding out input X results in Z instead of Y this year with no explanation. Moreover, the AI itself can be difficult to decipher and even more so on what covers what in most instances without a lot of trial and error. If there was some kind of consolidated post about the basic coverage sets in a given formation for D it would be helpful. Additionally some graphical representations would be nice - I know Wiki has some and I've been using them, but something official from Dev end would be nice.
Additionally, vague notes on "this has changed" don't really give you a good idea of where things are going in some builds - example, we have continued to work on QBs with their "primary" skills, defined as (in no particular order) Passing, Strength and Vision with secondary skills in Agility and Confidence. A substantial and workable list - with a great variety available for individualization. However, now I'm seeing posts listing jumping? running? I'm kinda confused. Tie into that a decrease in accuracy across the board over last years performances, its a bit puzzling as to what changed versus what has been established as "areas to concentrate on". I'm sure its fun to find some of this out on your own - actually I'd say its more a preference of how far you train up X skill as being the fun part - individualization and all for players. But at some level its kinda feels like the devs are playing hide the ball with the players in regards to the function of attribs and SAs in developing their specific players.
Moreover, newcomers to the game are going to rely on old posts which - to my knowledge - have not been updated with regards to the changes made in the game this season. I know tpaterniti is working on revisions, but the FAQ is generally a bit weak on explanation of how the particular skill will work on the character. I guess I'm just making some observations here, feel free to take it or leave it.
I'm not going to threaten that "I won't play" or any stuff like that - I want to help you develop this as I believe its a good idea. Hell, I've even brought it up with some business development folks who are into fantasy football stuff, I work with startups a lot. I for one think you can really go places with this. Keep up the good work.
Rexx
Not that I'm upset by the changes - those are to be expected as you need to continue to improve the game. What bothers me at this point is throwing cash into a game and then having, as someone has suggested, "retire and start over" but loose all the cash invested in doing so. Just a suggestion - if you want folks to "re-roll" you give them 100% fp back or something more substantial than existing % or alternatively and option to reallocate some amount of points.
That being said, I'll muddle on and adjust as is. What bothers me most atm is the pathing issues, blocking assignment errors, etc in the sim. But with changes comes troubleshooting, just hope we can get it done sooner than later. I know your working your ass off Bort - its just frustrating seeing stuff that you put into play last year and worked so well get messed up by changes that occur in the new season but have no way of finding out input X results in Z instead of Y this year with no explanation. Moreover, the AI itself can be difficult to decipher and even more so on what covers what in most instances without a lot of trial and error. If there was some kind of consolidated post about the basic coverage sets in a given formation for D it would be helpful. Additionally some graphical representations would be nice - I know Wiki has some and I've been using them, but something official from Dev end would be nice.
Additionally, vague notes on "this has changed" don't really give you a good idea of where things are going in some builds - example, we have continued to work on QBs with their "primary" skills, defined as (in no particular order) Passing, Strength and Vision with secondary skills in Agility and Confidence. A substantial and workable list - with a great variety available for individualization. However, now I'm seeing posts listing jumping? running? I'm kinda confused. Tie into that a decrease in accuracy across the board over last years performances, its a bit puzzling as to what changed versus what has been established as "areas to concentrate on". I'm sure its fun to find some of this out on your own - actually I'd say its more a preference of how far you train up X skill as being the fun part - individualization and all for players. But at some level its kinda feels like the devs are playing hide the ball with the players in regards to the function of attribs and SAs in developing their specific players.
Moreover, newcomers to the game are going to rely on old posts which - to my knowledge - have not been updated with regards to the changes made in the game this season. I know tpaterniti is working on revisions, but the FAQ is generally a bit weak on explanation of how the particular skill will work on the character. I guess I'm just making some observations here, feel free to take it or leave it.
I'm not going to threaten that "I won't play" or any stuff like that - I want to help you develop this as I believe its a good idea. Hell, I've even brought it up with some business development folks who are into fantasy football stuff, I work with startups a lot. I for one think you can really go places with this. Keep up the good work.
Rexx
oldskool
offline
offline
Originally posted by Minnsooner
I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
Originally posted by What Minnsooner means
I spent 2 seasons of player builds exploiting the previous breaks & glitches in the sim and I am now upset that said exploits are closed and now my players are not uber-players.
I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.
Originally posted by What Minnsooner means
I spent 2 seasons of player builds exploiting the previous breaks & glitches in the sim and I am now upset that said exploits are closed and now my players are not uber-players.
Revel8
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
It doesn't have to be that way. If players were allowed to redistribute some points, albeit limited, to go along with these new changes I believe there would be fewer customers losing their will to put money into this game.
An analogy that may not be perfect, but close, is that the current updates are almost like buying a broken product at the store. Then when you go to return the product for one that actually works, you're not able to do so at all or without paying the store even more money. Most stores allow for a return policy just in case the customer is dissatisfied with their purchase. Without one, they would lose dedicated customers.
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.
If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.
Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
It doesn't have to be that way. If players were allowed to redistribute some points, albeit limited, to go along with these new changes I believe there would be fewer customers losing their will to put money into this game.
An analogy that may not be perfect, but close, is that the current updates are almost like buying a broken product at the store. Then when you go to return the product for one that actually works, you're not able to do so at all or without paying the store even more money. Most stores allow for a return policy just in case the customer is dissatisfied with their purchase. Without one, they would lose dedicated customers.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 14:46:18
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























