User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams with no backups have to be penalized
Page:
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
after about 50 plays xp gain goes down sharply already

But from what I've seen:
1) It doesn't stop entirely until play #90,
2) Owners are more than willing to let their players play all the snaps because the penalties for doing so are so miniscule (two days of relaxed training and they're back to 100), and the rewards for XP are better served inching their level 10 OT towards level 11 than handing the full XP to a low-level backup.

They don't have backups right now, and the point killertoad and I are bringing to light is this: Why should they PLAY the backups they're forced to have by the soon-to-be-imposed roster minimums?

The XP is cut but it's not cut sharply enough. The abilities when fatigued are cut but they aren't cut sharply enough. Energy takes a hit but it doesn't take a big enough hit. Owners aren't going to change this strategy if they don't have to, and making the XP gain next to nothing, the player's ability on the field next to nothing and their energy loss considerable (i.e. something that can't be completely undone by the next game) would MAKE them change the strategy. Adding an extra 18 CPU players to the bench doesn't make them.

big makes a good point in that many positions do play close to every snap. It's sort of a balance between avoiding having every team having one layer of high-leveled depth and a bunch of disgruntled players quitting GLB because they had no chance of starting and there was no bench to speak of, but you don't want to force teams to go 80 deep and play five quarterbacks, three kickers and a dozen defensive tackles a game.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 20:52:41
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
In the USA pro...all of those teams are already beat out of the playoffs. All that reamain are teams with depth.


I don't believe that it is the competition element that bothers people, at least that isn't the case for me.

A. It is un-realistic
B. It wastes roster spots when there are so many paying (and freebie) players looking for a spot.

I would never suggest that a pro level team should include low level players just to give people a chance. But if all teams were forced either by minimum depth charts or more realistic in-game impact for over-usage to carry a realistic roster they would pick up additional decent players. That would create room below and filter it's way down. By having so many of the upper teams employing this un-realistic type of roster, it ultimately squeezes out the bottom rung players who have no where to go.

Adding more teams will likely always be a need, but if this particular issue is not addressed it seems to me that there will always be a lack of slots at the bottom which ultimately hurts the viability of the whole thing.

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
But "realistic" rosters will have at least 5 backup OL...most of whom will only play on FG team....or an extra TE on a goal line play. These teams will have a 3rd QB who holds a clip board 100% of the time. They will have 3 or 4 backup LB's and the last couple will only play in emergency or special teams. Same with a 3rd string HB...and bottom of every depth chart are special team only players.

Those types of players aren't going to be included in this game...and teams that do have them are going to use cpu players anyway.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
But "realistic" rosters will have at least 5 backup OL...most of whom will only play on FG team....or an extra TE on a goal line play. These teams will have a 3rd QB who holds a clip board 100% of the time. They will have 3 or 4 backup LB's and the last couple will only play in emergency or special teams. Same with a 3rd string HB...and bottom of every depth chart are special team only players.

Those types of players aren't going to be included in this game...and teams that do have them are going to use cpu players anyway.


There has to be a reasonable balance somewhere between absolute realism and a team that has 1 HB, 1 SS, et cetera. Forcing depth might well cause the game to evolve into having more specialization which could be a lot of fun.

While I agree with you that the extreme is plain silly in a sim, one player at each pos. except WR can't be resonably called a realistic team.

Last edited Apr 17, 2008 21:03:14
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
But "realistic" rosters will have at least 5 backup OL...most of whom will only play on FG team....or an extra TE on a goal line play. These teams will have a 3rd QB who holds a clip board 100% of the time. They will have 3 or 4 backup LB's and the last couple will only play in emergency or special teams. Same with a 3rd string HB...and bottom of every depth chart are special team only players.

Those types of players aren't going to be included in this game...and teams that do have them are going to use cpu players anyway.

I'm afraid those are already being included for the backup-free teams, they'll just moved up a slot on the depth chart when roster minimums gets added. If you play your starters all game, every game, the 2nd string QB is really just the 3rd stringer from your example. A guy who doesn't do anything but fill a roster slot.

Football realism would be one quarterback who plays every play unless he's hurt or something, and then the backup comes in. Installing that in GLB would be god-awful because so many people (myself included) would love to have a starting QB, and realism means backups hardly ever play and backups never playing means backups never being able to start.

What it needs is either stiff energy penalties and a low plays-to-max-XP cap to encourage backups playing, and a Starting Competition feature that gives the lower-leveled players on the depth chart occasional advantages in order to give them a chance to earn a starting position.
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.


You show me any NFL team that doesn't sub FB, TE, OL, LB or DB. You're nuts.

Just like Conn Chris so eloquently put it. If this continues, all of us owners will just purge our teams of human players. Start 22 plus 2 kickers. And keep the rest on CPU. This game will lose steam and live a very short life as a result.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??

You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.

We're convinced otherwise because the game itself blatantly calls you a liar on this point.

You say you need more than 22 + 2 kickers. Unless you're referring to KR and PR, there are several teams out there that are getting by with just those 24, and some of those are making do with even less than that. (And if you're referring to mandatory roster minimums, the point's already been raised that a bunch of CPU backups that never play doesn't fix the problem.) A bunch of them made the playoffs, even. How can you honestly say you NEED more than the core 24 (a witty rhyme, if I do say so myself) when there's so much in-game evidence that points to that statement being wrong?
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
I know your a Mod. Do you really want us playing the minimum? Wouldn't you rather us get as many human players as we can for our teams? Human players that will each spend money to boost their players. Human players that will tell their friends, hey Im on this great game why don't you join.

It would seem to me the logical argument for you is to increase the player base. Not diminish it.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
oldskool i think if you look at the USA pro playoffs the teams with depth are the ones that have won so far.

Also those teams that went without depth have a couple of backups (at least 1 LB, 1 DB, 1 WR (3rd), 1 TE). I think going less than 28 players puts your team at a huge disadvantage no matter what.

killertoad...yes i am a mod. Yes i would love to see this game grow as big as possible. But i speak on these forums as a player, team owner, and a mod.

If you look in some other threads i have said they should drop the "max" from 90 to 60 plays therefor making a roster of 35 players gain just as much EXP as a roster of 25. I do see an issue with this balance. But i think you have to try to balance realism, game experience, business ($$$), and the admins are trying to find exactly where that balance is.
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??

You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.


Would you like me to go down the list starting with USA Pro league? How many teams left have 1 guy playing at each position?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by killertoad


Would you like me to go down the list starting with USA Pro league? How many teams left have 1 guy playing at each position?


haha no i can see who has what depth. I think this is an issue over how EXP is given out more so than the depth thing though.

B/c other than DDT...the teams that won last game were a little deeper. Gators has a little more depth than philly did. Spartans had alot more depth than did the gangsters.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Did it for you, toad.

Of the four teams left in the USA Pro playoffs, shockingly enough, only the Mustangs have a depth chart that has multiple positions with more than one human player at a reasonable level (I took reasonable as above 5, that's starting at level 4 and gaining enough XP to level once during the season). San Jose had mostly CPU backups and from what I saw Detroit & Jacksonville were running as empty as possible. (Side note, Detroit's 6 better 'overall' than Jacksonville, and they run the more barebones roster)

USA AAA looked good, though they were running barebones (i.e. 3 OLB, two start and one's the substitute)

USA AA has the Demon Lions running next-to-nobody, the Cougars are respectable, Fresno's thin but not empty, and the tBus Window Lickers (not a typo, search for them!) have somehow assembled the 'best' roster (as far as full depth chart goes) yet.

USA A, Richmond repeats the designated substitutes (though they've got 4 OLBs) and the Detroit Football Guys are running next-to-nobody.

In summary:
USA Pro: 2/4 run as few as possible, 1/4 runs CPU backups, 1/4 has a full backup set.
USA AAA: Both teams in the championship run barebones, with one backup for two similar positions being common (one OLB is the same backup at ROLB and LOLB, the same guy is the LDE and RDE backup, etc.)
USA AA: 1/4 runs as few as possible, 2/4 are respectable and 1/4 runs the barebones.
USA A: One runs barebones and one runs as few as possible.

Conclusion: A LOT of teams are running next to nobody onto the field (9/12 run with one backup or less at many positions), and they seem to be having quite a bit of success.
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
Lol well done Old Skool. Well done. By the way...I play on the San Antonio Shortbus Window Lickers. And yes, we are trying to win the "right" way.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.