User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
can't you just set the CB deoth chart the same way and resolve the issue?
 
Link
 
The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Does this even work?

I was under the impression that WR1 and 2 would fill with the top guy in the basic WR chart first. So assuming energy was fine the WR1 and WR2 spots on 5 WR plays would still be the top 2 guys in the basic WR depth chart. Then since the starters are already in the top slots, the sim would pick the next likely candidate to fill the WR3-5 spots (likely the remaining WRs on the basic chart). Correct me if I'm wrong. I assume it would happen some of the time, but certainly not all, if my understanding is correct.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 12:06:43
 
P1_Gimpy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


The thing is, in real life, if an offense comes out and has their #1 WR in a different spot, the defense can adjust. In GLB, that adjustment isn't possible with the current system. You would need to be able to assign specific players to cover specific players. Unfortunately, I have a feeling the interface to do that would be very clunky. You would also have to consider letting the safeties and linebackers do the same thing which would make the interface that much worse. I would love to be able to assign players to cover players, but I'm not sure it would work without serious work to the interface.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
The reason it is an exploit is because it's intentionally using the inability of the AI to dynamically determine best CB vs best WR matchup as a human could easily do in real life.

Last season, if you put the #1 3rd at the depth chart, you were sacrificing his ability to play the majority of the snaps in his proper position - a fair tradeoff


Yeah, I wish we just had this...
 
uofi316
offline
Link
 
The depth chart should only be used to determine what WR/CB will see the field on a particular play. Once the WR are on the field, the CB should matchup accordingly based somehow on the "overall" rating (like any regular college/pro/HS team would do).

There is no way that the Carolina Panthers can "sneak" Steve Smith onto the field and have him line up across from the #3 CB.

To go along with that the WR should have a tactic called "Route Type" or something where you can pick between long, medium and short (or go route, crossing route, underneath route). That way you can set up the WR based on their individual skills.

Another option would be to be able to set a CB to always cover a WR. Although it would have to be name specific, or some other option that could not exploited.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
can't you just set the CB deoth chart the same way and resolve the issue?


You can, but then they can change there depth chart right before the game in reaction. The admins have tried to avoid situations where you had to be online right around game time in order to be effective (ie halftime adjustments), so this solution doesn't necessarily work.
 
ste
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.


That would be a decent solution, realistically the defence reacts to the offence and sets up to match it. The only problem would be the time zones of different users would mean not all teams could alter in time.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Does this even work?

I was under the impression that WR1 and 2 would fill with the top guy in the basic WR chart first. So assuming energy was fine the WR1 and WR2 spots on 5 WR plays would still be the top 2 guys in the basic WR depth chart. Correct me if I'm wrong.


To tell you the truth, I am not sure.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ste
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.


That would be a decent solution, realistically the defence reacts to the offence and sets up to match it. The only problem would be the time zones of different users would mean not all teams could alter in time.


Yeah that's true, but that was the reason for my GM comment, I mean right now, with this and other DC issues, the Awake Owner/GM already has an advantage over those that are asleep at gametime, so might as well attempt a fix.
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy


I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.


But that's not the issue. Find a mismatch? Go ahead and have your QB attack it, but having a design "flaw" that allows teams to wait until near gametime and pick WR charts, while the defense is left no time to react is obviously an issue.

In the NFL they had a similar issue with the Colts and changed the rules to fix this because it's obviously not fair.


That's the only complaint that holds weight, but even that lends to shoring up your secondary so that it is capable enough to cover most of the threats, most of the time. If you only have one or two good coverage guys, then your secondary is just going to get beat.

I did however say that to avoid ping ponging up untill game time, it wouldn't be unreasonable to ask that there is a lock on the DCs for a certain period prior to the game being played. BUT in the context of the original post that wouldn't matter because the DC will get adjusted up to the lock, and even if the D has additional time to adjust past that it would still be considered by the OP as an exploit.

My position though is that you can't call something an exploit if it is well within the scope of the gameplay. As it stands, it is working as intended. Doesn't mean that it couldn't be adjusted, does mean that calling it an exploit is stretching it.

 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by P1_Gimpy
Originally posted by Rezlov

Even if the above is true, regular college/pro/HS teams would do the same. You don't HAVE to stick your best WRs in the #1 spot. Go cry because your CBs can't cover their shade.


The thing is, in real life, if an offense comes out and has their #1 WR in a different spot, the defense can adjust. In GLB, that adjustment isn't possible with the current system. You would need to be able to assign specific players to cover specific players. Unfortunately, I have a feeling the interface to do that would be very clunky. You would also have to consider letting the safeties and linebackers do the same thing which would make the interface that much worse. I would love to be able to assign players to cover players, but I'm not sure it would work without serious work to the interface.


Not really. What Bort could do is create an interface in which the DC can assign different CBs to a certain WR. So instead of CB1, CB2, CB3 like we have right now, it should be WR1, WR2, WR3.

Whichever CB you put in the WR1 depth chart on defense will always line up against WR1 whenever WR1 comes into the game. Now of course the offense can try to change it right before gametime, so they should also lock offensive DCs 30min to an hour before the game and lock the defensive DC 30 min before or something.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
If you have players that get assigned to a certain WR whenever he's on the field, then you are basically at the mercy of the opposing team's energy settings and not your own, no? That would be an issue.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
If you have players that get assigned to a certain WR whenever he's on the field, then you are basically at the mercy of the opposing team's energy settings and not your own, no? That would be an issue.


Not really, because you can set a second CB for WR1 on the defense. So when CB1 is tired, CB2 will come in and cover WR1.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by somecut8
Originally posted by Sigmaforce

If you have players that get assigned to a certain WR whenever he's on the field, then you are basically at the mercy of the opposing team's energy settings and not your own, no? That would be an issue.


Not really, because you can set a second CB for WR1 on the defense. So when CB1 is tired, CB2 will come in and cover WR1.


I think he means that once WR1 gets tired your CB 1 is off the field. There would be a fix for this as well though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.