User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > The newall powerfull CB's. Unless they are too much faster and more agile than the WR, then they suck.
Page:
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devolution
I guess your CB's aren't as perfect as you think they are LoL

Sorry to make a joke but I honestly don't care, Bort obviously knows about the "problem" so he'll get to it when he gets to it. I can only go from what I have seen on the 3 teams I DC for. We haven't had any problems, sure there has been a play here and a play there when I said, "what is my guy doing?", or "Is my CB playing close coverage or medium coverage?", but it hasn't happened to me enough to come on the forums and post.

Quick question...does your guy just not have high enough vision to pickup what the WR is doing? you are all talking about speed/agility, nobody has said, darn this level 22 CB only has 30 vision...should he have more?


In my case 65, 55 and 50 vision for starters.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devolution
I guess your CB's aren't as perfect as you think they are LoL

Sorry to make a joke but I honestly don't care, Bort obviously knows about the "problem" so he'll get to it when he gets to it. I can only go from what I have seen on the 3 teams I DC for. We haven't had any problems, sure there has been a play here and a play there when I said, "what is my guy doing?", or "Is my CB playing close coverage or medium coverage?", but it hasn't happened to me enough to come on the forums and post.

Quick question...does your guy just not have high enough vision to pickup what the WR is doing? you are all talking about speed/agility, nobody has said, darn this level 22 CB only has 30 vision...should he have more?


That's the thing - there's no real way to pinpoint the issue.

I've seen it happen to CBs with high vision and low vision. I've seen it happen with high level CBs/WRs and low level CBs/WRs. It's happened with fast WRs and slow WRs.

And it's not just this play here and this play there, otherwise it wouldn't be a big deal. Go look at some of the top 10 WRs in various leagues, and you'll see what we mean.

There's only one way I've discovered that seems to reproduce the effect everytime, and that's the depth chart. I'll try it tonight and let you know.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Just wanted to post letting everybody know I haven't been around posting much today because I've been running tons of tests and modifying stuff to try and address this. I did a dump of the whole live database, so I'm able to test with any currently live teams (well, at least as they existed a day ago).

I've found a few things so far:

Fast CB's back up too fast compared to slow WR's on streak routes, due to the fact their their acceleration is a constant. I've made them match acceleration in this case and it seems to work so far. I've put a 20 speed 20 agility guy against a 70 speed 50 agility CB and the CB is all over him in general.

Agile WR's don't have a way to fake out equally agile CB's and get open. I'm increasing the effect of the head fake and juke SA's, and adding some reduced reaction time for defenders based on vision and agility and coverage distance. The result is that on some plays the CB will stay with the WR and on others he will not make the turn with the receiver until a split second too late.

CB's were basically getting an immediate jump on the ball when thrown. I'm adding a delay on the jump based on vision agility and coverage distance. The result is that sometimes the CB gets a great jump on the ball and knocks it down while other times he waits a split second too long and doesn't get there in time. Combined with the above = botched coverage, basically.

Fast CB's with poor agility playing on close vs Fast WR's often dash forward at the snap to get within the "close" cushion and are then unable to turn around quick enough to keep up with the speedy WR. I've made them back up a little at the snap instead and wait for the WR to make his move.

QB's with decent vision hardly ever miss an open man on a checkdown, which means they will ALWAYS take advantage of the situation. I'm making them slightly more likely to miss the open guy unless they have really high vision.

Risk calculations did not take the catching ability of the receiver into account as a very big part of the calculation. Being open is the major part. I'm tweaking that a little to be willing to pass to a guy if he's just way better than his defender, even if he's not wide open.

Anyway, just an update because I know people are waiting on this and I wanted to let everybody know I'm working on it. I want to make sure it's right before pushing it out there, though!
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devolution
I guess your CB's aren't as perfect as you think they are LoL

Sorry to make a joke but I honestly don't care, Bort obviously knows about the "problem" so he'll get to it when he gets to it. I can only go from what I have seen on the 3 teams I DC for. We haven't had any problems, sure there has been a play here and a play there when I said, "what is my guy doing?", or "Is my CB playing close coverage or medium coverage?", but it hasn't happened to me enough to come on the forums and post.

Quick question...does your guy just not have high enough vision to pickup what the WR is doing? you are all talking about speed/agility, nobody has said, darn this level 22 CB only has 30 vision...should he have more?


We are talking about CB with vision > 50 in some cases. This is not an issue to brush off, and to his credit, Bort hasn't. Teams have lost games b/c a WR that shouldn't have given them problems goes off for 200, 300 yards. That's a little different than a running game that's a little slow, which is systematic and effects everyone equally.
 
seanjansen
offline
Link
 
I was just about to make a thread expressing my concern for this issue. I have a CB who played against a WR who was 20 speed slower and 15 points less agile (open stats) and it seemed he would do this peculiar bubble motion when the WR went to cut. I'll post a few examples but it seemed to happen just about every play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=111267&pbp_id=1666396
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=111267&pbp_id=1666455
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=111267&pbp_id=1667872

We have a big game next week and I was planning on boosting my player up for it but am a bit hesitant given that I'm not sure if my agility is actually hindering my player.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
Quoting bort,

Just wanted to post letting everybody know I haven't been around posting much today because I've been running tons of tests and modifying stuff to try and address this. I did a dump of the whole live database, so I'm able to test with any currently live teams (well, at least as they existed a day ago).

I've found a few things so far:

Fast CB's back up too fast compared to slow WR's on streak routes, due to the fact their their acceleration is a constant. I've made them match acceleration in this case and it seems to work so far. I've put a 20 speed 20 agility guy against a 70 speed 50 agility CB and the CB is all over him in general.

Agile WR's don't have a way to fake out equally agile CB's and get open. I'm increasing the effect of the head fake and juke SA's, and adding some reduced reaction time for defenders based on vision and agility and coverage distance. The result is that on some plays the CB will stay with the WR and on others he will not make the turn with the receiver until a split second too late.

CB's were basically getting an immediate jump on the ball when thrown. I'm adding a delay on the jump based on vision agility and coverage distance. The result is that sometimes the CB gets a great jump on the ball and knocks it down while other times he waits a split second too long and doesn't get there in time. Combined with the above = botched coverage, basically.

Fast CB's with poor agility playing on close vs Fast WR's often dash forward at the snap to get within the "close" cushion and are then unable to turn around quick enough to keep up with the speedy WR. I've made them back up a little at the snap instead and wait for the WR to make his move.

QB's with decent vision hardly ever miss an open man on a checkdown, which means they will ALWAYS take advantage of the situation. I'm making them slightly more likely to miss the open guy unless they have really high vision.

Risk calculations did not take the catching ability of the receiver into account as a very big part of the calculation. Being open is the major part. I'm tweaking that a little to be willing to pass to a guy if he's just way better than his defender, even if he's not wide open.

Anyway, just an update because I know people are waiting on this and I wanted to let everybody know I'm working on it. I want to make sure it's right before pushing it out there, though!
 
seanjansen
offline
Link
 
I was just about to edit my post because I saw Bort addressed it. Hopefully it will work better next game.
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanjansen
I was just about to edit my post because I saw Bort addressed it. Hopefully it will work better next game.


He hasnt said he was putting it in just yet.. he was testing it.

 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Devolution,

my CB was the one of the first to get hit with this or at least have it posted on the forums in the bug thread I started a few days ago.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=743444

Check out some of the replays. I don't mind spilling the beans on that CB's build. Not like we all dont know what makes a good CB

str 25
spd 70
agi 50
vis 40
sta 37
conf 19

8 in super vision, 4 in shutdown corner

The WR in all those replays catching all those 28 passes has this build:

Strength: 13
Speed: 55.51
Agility: 42.87
Jumping: 25.87 Catching: 46.44
Stamina: 31.87 Carrying: 20.38
Vision: 27.87
Confidence: 26.38

Special Abilities

Possession Receiver Abilities 33222
Speedster Abilities 44333


Does it make any sense for that WR to be doing that to that CB?

 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zable
Originally posted by seanjansen

I was just about to edit my post because I saw Bort addressed it. Hopefully it will work better next game.


He hasnt said he was putting it in just yet.. he was testing it.



Good enough, means he's worried about the problem and is fixing it.
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arteryman
Originally posted by Zable

Originally posted by seanjansen


I was just about to edit my post because I saw Bort addressed it. Hopefully it will work better next game.


He hasnt said he was putting it in just yet.. he was testing it.



Good enough, means he's worried about the problem and is fixing it.


Hehehe Id love to have it fixed before tomorrows sims.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
Poor bort, if only he could
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Great work Bort! Some of the tests and ideas you have to solve the problem sound great.
 
Perok
offline
Link
 
I'm glad to see a stronger move toward agility, vision and catching in wide receivers... it should help the possession WR become more of a viable target, especially on short routes where speed isn't as important.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143
Devolution,

my CB was the one of the first to get hit with this or at least have it posted on the forums in the bug thread I started a few days ago.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=743444

Check out some of the replays. I don't mind spilling the beans on that CB's build. Not like we all dont know what makes a good CB

str 25
spd 70
agi 50
vis 40
sta 37
conf 19

8 in super vision, 4 in shutdown corner

The WR in all those replays catching all those 28 passes has this build:

Strength: 13
Speed: 55.51
Agility: 42.87
Jumping: 25.87 Catching: 46.44
Stamina: 31.87 Carrying: 20.38
Vision: 27.87
Confidence: 26.38

Special Abilities

Possession Receiver Abilities 33222
Speedster Abilities 44333


Does it make any sense for that WR to be doing that to that CB?



So are you saying it should be impossible for that WR to get open in that matchup?

CB's aren't perfect, and they don't know the route the receiver will run. If CB's could completely shut down WR's, there'd be no passing offense. As it is, the passing offense works not as well as real life.

Oh, and there's CB's low Confidence. People can ignore Confidence all they want, but with that level he had tears streaming down his cheeks as soon as he allowed a few completions. Hard to play while crying.
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 23:54:29
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.