User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Our #1 WR had 6 catches for 88 yards and a TD in our last game. I am happy with those numbers.


Your speed WR picked on a very slow CB.

I'd estimate the WR's speed is at least 65, probably over 70. And I'd guess the CB's speed is in the 40s. I'd say the speed difference is at least 25.

Also, I'd wager that CB has sub-30 vision.

It was a mismatch in levels and builds.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by czman

Our #1 WR had 6 catches for 88 yards and a TD in our last game. I am happy with those numbers.


It really seems to be hit or miss, depending on matchups. One game will have one guy get targeted 20 times because his defender is playing way off or can't keep up, while another game won't have the same problem because the two are well matched.


I do not think this is a bug. If a Wr is covered and you want your QB to throw to him there is an advanced tactic for that (favorite WR). I think many #1 WRs are not getting passes because they are usually going against the best CB and also have the FS over the top on most plays. I see a lot of cover 1 or 2 where the FS is helping out on the #1 WR making him a hard target to get the ball too. I have no problem.

In our first game our #3 had 8 catches. The #3 Cb was way off all game and gave us 8-10 yard completions. I am glad we took advantage and kept the chains moving.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by czman

Our #1 WR had 6 catches for 88 yards and a TD in our last game. I am happy with those numbers.


Your speed WR picked on a very slow CB.

I'd estimate the WR's speed is at least 65, probably over 70. And I'd guess the CB's speed is in the 40s. I'd say the speed difference is at least 25.

Also, I'd wager that CB has sub-30 vision.

It was a mismatch in levels and builds.


So when he got open he had the ball thrown towards him. I am not sure how this is a bug.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
I'm not saying that performance is a bug. It's a well-built WR kicking a sub-par CB's butt, which is how it should be.

Now, match that WR up against a decently built CB close to the same level and see what happens. That's the bug.

I do understand what you're saying about the most open WR. The problem is that many, many WR1s can't get open unless they severely outmatch the CB covering them.
 
missnlife
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by czman


Our #1 WR had 6 catches for 88 yards and a TD in our last game. I am happy with those numbers.


It really seems to be hit or miss, depending on matchups. One game will have one guy get targeted 20 times because his defender is playing way off or can't keep up, while another game won't have the same problem because the two are well matched.


I do not think this is a bug. If a Wr is covered and you want your QB to throw to him there is an advanced tactic for that (favorite WR)...


Put a lvl22 WR against a lvl16 CB today, made the WR the primary favorite target, and he got ONE TARGET. That's an issue.

We'll use this. Moss is Brady's favorite target. When the Patriots play Denver, Moss lines up against Champ Bailey the entire game. Does Brady not throw it to Moss the entire game because of a matchup? Hell no.

Now, in my game's case, it was like a #2 CB was lined up on Moss...and Brady didn't throw him the ball. See the problem?
 
MrMike
offline
Link
 
I think the best way to fix this may be to just use the "WR" list, instead of the WR#1, WR#2, etc. charts.
 
LSU
offline
Link
 
I think it's absolutely ridiculous how we have to pay money (Not cheap at that), in order to play a game competitively (That's not my argument) that just gets changed.

What is happening now is that people who once had great builds - Are now being punished.
While the ones who had bad builds - Are now getting the glory of an absolutely asinine change.


Bort - If you are going to charge people money... Don't change the game's basics. Keep it the same. You can improve... But you shouldn't fix something that isn't broken.
What you have done is made a game that was great into one that is now stupid - Because now what used to be a great build is a useless one.


It's complete and utter bull ****.
 
Link
 
does a wr who can only run vertical routes get stats in real life?
no, unless it JV.
 
LSU
offline
Link
 
Can a CB with average speed shut down a WR with great speed everytime?
Nope, unless it's JV because then they all suck.

That argument can go both ways.
 
wutango36o
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by czman

Our #1 WR had 6 catches for 88 yards and a TD in our last game. I am happy with those numbers.


It really seems to be hit or miss, depending on matchups. One game will have one guy get targeted 20 times because his defender is playing way off or can't keep up, while another game won't have the same problem because the two are well matched.


There is definitely an issue. Most #1 receivers aren't getting any catches at all. Either the #1 CB is bugged or the #1 WR is bugged. Our #1 had 0 catches in 68 plays, our #2 had 15 catches for 224 yards and 2 tds and we were playing a weaker opponent. How does the #1 WR get shutdown completely, I believe he was only targeted 3 times.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LSU
I think it's absolutely ridiculous how we have to pay money (Not cheap at that), in order to play a game competitively (That's not my argument) that just gets changed.

What is happening now is that people who once had great builds - Are now being punished.
While the ones who had bad builds - Are now getting the glory of an absolutely asinine change.


Bort - If you are going to charge people money... Don't change the game's basics. Keep it the same. You can improve... But you shouldn't fix something that isn't broken.
What you have done is made a game that was great into one that is now stupid - Because now what used to be a great build is a useless one.


It's complete and utter bull ****.


Bort doesn't "charge" anyone anything. People elect to put money into a beta game knowing full-well things will be tweaked and adjusted over time to create a better balance.

Anyways, all this is imo is a matter of routes. WR #2/#3 tend to run routes that have them open earlier than others. I think if the routes were just mixed up some more it'd be fine.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 18:35:24
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DLight03
Originally posted by LSU

I think it's absolutely ridiculous how we have to pay money (Not cheap at that), in order to play a game competitively (That's not my argument) that just gets changed.

What is happening now is that people who once had great builds - Are now being punished.
While the ones who had bad builds - Are now getting the glory of an absolutely asinine change.


Bort - If you are going to charge people money... Don't change the game's basics. Keep it the same. You can improve... But you shouldn't fix something that isn't broken.
What you have done is made a game that was great into one that is now stupid - Because now what used to be a great build is a useless one.


It's complete and utter bull ****.


Bort doesn't "charge" anyone anything. People elect to put money into a beta game knowing full-well things will be tweaked and adjusted over time to create a better balance.

Anyways, all this is imo is a matter of routes. WR #2/#3 tend to run routes that have them open earlier than others. I think if the routes were just mixed up some more it'd be fine.


I also think it is mainly the routes being run. I've charted every play on offense in GLB in each formation. It's not a lot, by the way. Anyway, if you look at the routes those WRs on the left side of the formation run... they're terrible! Half the time in 3-5 WR sets, those two on the left are running right next to each other, in almost the same space the entire sequence.

It's also terrible how the CBs cover those left-side WRs. Most of the time, it doesn't even matter what tactics they are playing, they will give those WRs cushion almost every play.
 
GiantBucs
offline
Link
 
After trying to get the ball to our #1 WR since the first game in preseason and having no luck I'm inclined to think it's a bug as well. We've done everything from setting favorite target to switching the depth order and creating a huge mismatch or at least what should've been with a level 2 CB on our level 13 WR. Yea that's right. Almost no targets. We also set the HB passes to a minimal and he got way more looks then the #1 WR. It's bugged and very frustrating.

I expect quirks in a beta but I've yet to see some of the supposed fixes actually be fixed. Things like speed and primary stat for positions still dominate over actual good builds that are more well rounded. We had our level 16 Center get pancaked numerous times by a level 7 NT and sack the QB 3x. That's totally borked code. Shouldn't happen.

 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
I think there are definitely some quirks to how the QB reads the play, but it's not isolated to WR1/WR2/etc position.

Our flanker (WR1) received 10 of 23 looks in game 2 and wound up with a lopsided distribution of PaYd/recepts/etc. He was lined up at SE (WR2) in game 1 and saw 14 of 38 looks. I think it's less a question of where he is, but whether he's able to beat the corner early and reduce the "risk" score when the QB scans him watching the play unfold.
 
xc0221
offline
Link
 
I have similar problem in my team my I am the #1 WR and we've tried everything and on 2 games He has 1 reception 6 yards that's it. We tried to put him on WR#2 still the same, my WR is the best on our team I don't know what's up.

Today 78 plays 0 catches. whats' up with that?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.