User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Field Goal Range (leave blank for "auto"):--Bug
Page:
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by cabrasher

Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?


Put in 47. If you put in 30, he will kick from the 13.


Ok, then "from the spot of the kick" is incorrect terminology. This implies the line of scrimmage or the spot of the placehold or something. I'm just confusing myself now. At least I know what I need to put in now. I hope everyone else understands as well.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:33:45
 
Kakseca
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Kakseca

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by czman



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by cabrasher





FG range was set to 30, but it was actually the 12.5 yd line that he punted from, so that should have even been within the range of 30 no matter the method you would use here. The FG input was setup before the Punt input in my AI, so either the AI is not checking through in the proper order or something's wrong with the FG range calculation.


It's - 17 yards. Maybe some sort of rounding problem (12.5 is close to 13)? I'll check it out.


Can we also get an official post (by an admin) that states how the FG distance needs to bet. We should not have to test this. Is it from the spot of the ball or the kick and does it take into account the ten yards for the end zone. If something official has been posted I am sorry I missed it but can it be linked here, please.


I should just put it on the tactics page to avoid confusion. It's from the spot of the kick.


Eh? So now on "Field Goal Range, from the spot of the kick (leave blank for "auto"): 50 yds". For my kicker to only attempt 50yd FG's? I thought you just said 33yds to attempt a 50yds FG?


I might have misunderstood or misread, etc. Been kinda tired lately.

It's from the spot of the kick. The LOS for that will be whatever your put - 17 yards.


Aww sorry...

Ok let me get this straight. To Only make my Kicker attempt 50yd FG Max. I would set that number to 67. Is this correct? Mahalo for taking the time to answer these questions Bort. We really appreciate it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by cabrasher


Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?


Put in 47. If you put in 30, he will kick from the 13.


Ok, then "from the spot of the kick" is incorrect terminology. This implies the line of scrimmage.


No... it's from the spot of the actual kick. It's the actual distance the ball travels from the kicker's foot to the uprights. You add 7 yards for the snap and 10 yards for the end zone...
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
The terminology is incorrect. "From the spot of the kick" means the spot where the ball is kicked from, which is entirely different from the line of scrimmage. The spot of the kick is the Line of scrimmage + about 7 yards. Putting in 47 would mean you would kick 57 yard field goals. (The spot of the kick + 10 yards)

The correct terminology would be to say "Field Goal Range(The maximum field goal length the kicker will attempt)" This is neither the "spot of the kick" or the line of scrimmage, but the line of scrimmage + 17.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:43:53
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg
Originally posted by cabrasher

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by cabrasher



Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?


Put in 47. If you put in 30, he will kick from the 13.


Ok, then "from the spot of the kick" is incorrect terminology. This implies the line of scrimmage.


No... it's from the spot of the actual kick. It's the actual distance the ball travels from the kicker's foot to the uprights. You add 7 yards for the snap and 10 yards for the end zone...


Wouldn't the spot of the kick then be the LOS + 7 then instead of 17? In the NFL, a missed FG results in the ball being marked at the "spot of the kick" or the yd-line that the ball was actually placed and kicked from. I believe this is correct. Not positive.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:44:16
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
The terminology is incorrect. "From the spot of the kick" means the spot where the ball is kicked from, which is entirely different from the line of scrimmage. The spot of the kick is the Line of scrimmage + about 7 yards. Putting in 47 would mean you would kick 57 yard field goals. (The spot of the kick + 10 yards)

The correct terminology would be to say "Field Goal Range(The maximum field goal length the kicker will attempt)" This is neither the "spot of the kick" or the line of scrimmage, but the line of scrimmage + 17.


Agreed with csull. I was wrong about the LOS the first time.
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg

Originally posted by cabrasher


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by cabrasher




Let me just ask it straight up so there's no confusion from here out. If I want my kicker's FG range to be 47 yds, in other words from the 30-yd line, should I put 30 or 47 in the FG range input?


Put in 47. If you put in 30, he will kick from the 13.


Ok, then "from the spot of the kick" is incorrect terminology. This implies the line of scrimmage.


No... it's from the spot of the actual kick. It's the actual distance the ball travels from the kicker's foot to the uprights. You add 7 yards for the snap and 10 yards for the end zone...


Wouldn't the spot of the kick then be the LOS + 7 then instead of 17? In the NFL, a missed FG results in the ball being marked at the "spot of the kick" or the yd-line that the ball was kicked from. I believe this is correct. Not positive.


You are correct, the spot of the kick is the yardline the ball is kicked from, and does not include the 10 yard length of the endzone.
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
It's a little frustrating to lose a game 21-24 and not take 2 FGs you wanted to (with 1 even being within the range regardless of methodology but caused by a "rounding error"). I understand you're really busy now with all the new updates, but maybe, Bort, you could delegate the writing of some sort of rules book compilation to one of the Mods, so owners and players don't have to sift through pages upon pages of random threads to find answers to basic questions.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:55:42
 
johnny005
offline
Link
 
This is what happen to me and these are the settings I set:

2:14 4th & 4.5 OPP 8.5 Punt by Tristan Five-0, 10 yds (touchback)

My (K) Merizo Majewski is level 18

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=393225

Offense AI settings:

Field Goal Range, from the spot of the kick (leave blank for "auto"): 40 yds

Input: 4th down, FG range

Ball Spot (yard line) Between: Any Spot and Any Spot

Down before 4 and 4

Special Circumstance: Within Field Goal Range

Pct Chance: 100%; Output: Field Goal; Play Type: Field Goal; Play Distance: Basic Settings

So where did I go wrong?
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 10:56:14
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johnny005
This is what happen to me and these are the settings I set:

2:14 4th & 4.5 OPP 8.5 Punt by Tristan Five-0, 10 yds (touchback)

My (K) Merizo Majewski is level 18

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=393225

Offense AI settings:

Field Goal Range, from the spot of the kick (leave blank for "auto"): 40 yds

Input: 4th down, FG range

Ball Spot (yard line) Between: Any Spot and Any Spot

Down before 4 and 4

Special Circumstance: Within Field Goal Range

Pct Chance: 100%; Output: Field Goal; Play Type: Field Goal; Play Distance: Basic Settings

So where did I go wrong?


Yikes, I dunno about that one. I would say check to see if your punt input is above your FG input first. If not that, then ?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, I posted this in another thread, but I wanted to make sure I'm not going crazy because all this +7 and + 17 stuff is making my eyes cross at the moment.



In feet, which is the real unit used in the sim:

You set your range to 40 yds from the goal post, which is at 0 ft.

To find the LOS from which to kick within, the formula is:

(40 * 3) - 21 = 99 feet = the 23 yd line + 30 ft for the endzone

Am I correct or am I losing my mind?
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
I'm just going to throw long passes every play...
 
cabrasher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I posted this in another thread, but I wanted to make sure I'm not going crazy because all this +7 and + 17 stuff is making my eyes cross at the moment.



In feet, which is the real unit used in the sim:

You set your range to 40 yds from the goal post, which is at 0 ft.

To find the LOS from which to kick within, the formula is:

(40 * 3) - 21 = 99 feet = the 23 yd line + 30 ft for the endzone

Am I correct or am I losing my mind?


Ok, so this means that the end zone begins at 30 ft (10 yds) or are we playing old school goal posts in front of the end zone?
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I posted this in another thread, but I wanted to make sure I'm not going crazy because all this +7 and + 17 stuff is making my eyes cross at the moment.



In feet, which is the real unit used in the sim:

You set your range to 40 yds from the goal post, which is at 0 ft.

To find the LOS from which to kick within, the formula is:

(40 * 3) - 21 = 99 feet = the 23 yd line + 30 ft for the endzone

Am I correct or am I losing my mind?


Okay, I suppose that makes sense, as long as we can define the FG range number not as the "spot of the ball" but as the "maximum field goal length" or "Distance from the spot of the ball to the uprights". Saying it is just the spot of the ball is too generic and implies that we are looking at the yardline, not the yardline plus 10 for the endzone.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cabrasher
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I posted this in another thread, but I wanted to make sure I'm not going crazy because all this +7 and + 17 stuff is making my eyes cross at the moment.



In feet, which is the real unit used in the sim:

You set your range to 40 yds from the goal post, which is at 0 ft.

To find the LOS from which to kick within, the formula is:

(40 * 3) - 21 = 99 feet = the 23 yd line + 30 ft for the endzone

Am I correct or am I losing my mind?


Ok, so this means that the end zone begins at 30 ft (10 yds) or are we playing old school goal posts in front of the end zone?


No, the endzone is 10 yds deep = 30 feet

10 yds + 23 yd line + 7 yd for the hold = 40 yds, correct?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.