User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > WEEK 2 POWER RANKINGS
Page:
 
zero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Originally posted by Yellow

Ya know, i'm not really a big fan of these rankings...

Just the fact that the OFG are at 10, are enough to make me completely disregard these.


***O*** is our abbreviated name.


hahaha damn i don't want to type that instead....
 
Maik Jeaunz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Ya know, i'm not really a big fan of these rankings...

Just the fact that the OFG are at 10, are enough to make me completely disregard these.


after our nail biter against Brooklyn, I'm surprised we didn't drop a few spots...
 
MEbenhoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maik Jeaunz


after our nail biter against Brooklyn, I'm surprised we didn't drop a few spots...


You didn't cover the spread.
 
Maik Jeaunz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MEbenhoe
Originally posted by Maik Jeaunz



after our nail biter against Brooklyn, I'm surprised we didn't drop a few spots...


You didn't cover the spread.


exactly! AND we gave up a first down!!!
 
PP
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Maik Jeaunz
Originally posted by MEbenhoe

Originally posted by Maik Jeaunz




after our nail biter against Brooklyn, I'm surprised we didn't drop a few spots...


You didn't cover the spread.


exactly! AND we gave up a first down!!!


How can you guys even feel good about that?!...Not covering the spread, plus giving up a 1st down, I'm thinking it must be time for Duff to start considering a gut and sell. After all, 1st it's being ranked so low. Now it's a sub standard lvl of effort on the field. There really isn't anything left to play for...And your scrim games were nothing to write home about either. Just to be a nice guy, I'd be willing to look over your roster and give a few of the players a new home. You know, so they're not stuck on a gutted team with a crappy new owner.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 12:26:29
 
MEbenhoe
offline
Link
 
It's not a rip on OFG, but cmon, the team you were playing is like an A league scrub team. Any team that didn't beat them by that much has serious issues. Just give the rankings a few games. If your team is good they'll move up, if they're not they won't.
 
excalibur143
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nathbear
Kinda confused as to how the Vaqueros ranking could go down despite beating the team ranked directly above us, but still good to get the lists out there...

Thanks for the good work!


He has a point there. I was expecting the Generals to be like 40th after that loss. lol

Ken
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nathbear
Kinda confused as to how the Vaqueros ranking could go down despite beating the team ranked directly above us, but still good to get the lists out there...

Thanks for the good work!


I'm going to use this comment as an excuse to give a practical demonstration of how the rankings are calculated.

Here is how the Vaqueros offense ranked in the week 1 ratings:
First, I calculated the average level at each position.
QB: 28.0 (level 28 starter)
HB: 27.7 (a 28 and a 27, weighted 70-30)
FB: 25.0 (a 25)
WR: 26.1 (28, 27, 23, 21, weighted 37.5-35-20-7.5)
TE: 23.4 (24, 21, weighted 80-20)
OT: 25.4 (28, 24, 23, weighted 40-40-20)
OG: 25.8 (28, 26, 21, weighted 40-40-20)
C: 26.3 (27, 22, weighted 85-15)

Next, I did the same calculation for every other team in the league, and found the highest rating at each position, which was:
QB: 29.0 (2 teams)
HB: 27.7 (Vaqueros)
FB: 29.0 (***O***)
WR: 26.5 (NJ Generals)
TE: 27.2 (Grand Junction)
OT: 27.6 (Richmond)
OG: 27.2 (NJ Generals)
C: 28.3 (Las Vegas Aces)

Then I compared the Vaqueros ratings to those league maximums and converted the Vaqueros position ratings to a 100 point scale:
QB: 96.6 (28/29*100)
HB: 100
FB: 86.2
WR: 98.5
TE: 86.0
OT: 92.0
OG: 94.9
C: 92.9

Finally, I averaged these numbers together, with weights of 16.25% QB, 22.5% HB, 7.5% FB, 11.25% WR, 5% TE, 15% OT, 15% OG, 7.5% C. My logic for those numbers is that when passing, the QB and the collective receiving corps matter equally, so QB = WR+TE, whereas while when running, it's mostly the HB, less the FB. Overall, I give 37.5% credit to the O-Line, which is important on every play, 32.5% credit to the passing game skill players, and 30% credit to the running game skill players. Eventually, once I have enough data, I will run some multivariable regression analysis on rankings vs. results, and see if I'm overrating/underrating certain positions. Off the top of my head, HB should probably be worth less, and the O-Line probably worth more, but I'm not ready yet to mess with that portion of these rankings. Next season, perhaps. Anyway, averaging the numbers together with those weights, I calculated a rating of 95.0 for the Vaqueros offense.

Doing the same basic thing on defense, I got a rating of 94.7, and on special teams (kicker + punter) I got 84.4. Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.

Then they played a game against the New Jersey Generals, who were rated 93.6, so the Vaqueros were rated 0.7 lower, and thus were 2 point underdogs (actually 2.1282). They won by 3, so that means they overperformed their ranking by 5, which earned an adjustment of +0.26.

Now then, their week 2 rankings:
The only changes in level are that the backup TE went from 21 to 22, a DT went from 26 to 27, a LB went from 22 to 23, a CB went from 25 to 27, and the K went from 26 to 27. This did increase the weighted average level at those positions, but other teams also improved. Specifically, the best WR corps in the league jumped from 26.5 to 27.3, TE went from 27.2 to 27.8, and OT and OG went up as well, along of course with some increases to the defensive maximums.

In other words, the "league best" went up more than the Vaqueros did, therefore the Vaqueros rating dropped a bit in comparison, to an offense rating of 94.3, a defense rating of 93.0, and 86.2 on special teams. These, and a 91 chemistry, average together to 92.1, a drop from the 92.9 the were beforehand. The adjustment bonus for their upset win raises it to 92.3, but it's still lower than it was beforehand.

Is that a long enough answer to a short question?
 
zero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MEbenhoe
It's not a rip on OFG, but cmon, the team you were playing is like an A league scrub team. Any team that didn't beat them by that much has serious issues. Just give the rankings a few games. If your team is good they'll move up, if they're not they won't.


lol we were just playin mebenhoe, and careful cause the A teams in USA aren't scrubs at all. legacy is more like a sub-D team right now
and rofl PP that made me laugh out loud FO SERIOUS
 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by nathbear

Kinda confused as to how the Vaqueros ranking could go down despite beating the team ranked directly above us, but still good to get the lists out there...

Thanks for the good work!


I'm going to use this comment as an excuse to give a practical demonstration of how the rankings are calculated.

Here is how the Vaqueros offense ranked in the week 1 ratings:
First, I calculated the average level at each position.
QB: 28.0 (level 28 starter)
HB: 27.7 (a 28 and a 27, weighted 70-30)
FB: 25.0 (a 25)
WR: 26.1 (28, 27, 23, 21, weighted 37.5-35-20-7.5)
TE: 23.4 (24, 21, weighted 80-20)
OT: 25.4 (28, 24, 23, weighted 40-40-20)
OG: 25.8 (28, 26, 21, weighted 40-40-20)
C: 26.3 (27, 22, weighted 85-15)

Next, I did the same calculation for every other team in the league, and found the highest rating at each position, which was:
QB: 29.0 (2 teams)
HB: 27.7 (Vaqueros)
FB: 29.0 (***O***)
WR: 26.5 (NJ Generals)
TE: 27.2 (Grand Junction)
OT: 27.6 (Richmond)
OG: 27.2 (NJ Generals)
C: 28.3 (Las Vegas Aces)

Then I compared the Vaqueros ratings to those league maximums and converted the Vaqueros position ratings to a 100 point scale:
QB: 96.6 (28/29*100)
HB: 100
FB: 86.2
WR: 98.5
TE: 86.0
OT: 92.0
OG: 94.9
C: 92.9

Finally, I averaged these numbers together, with weights of 16.25% QB, 22.5% HB, 7.5% FB, 11.25% WR, 5% TE, 15% OT, 15% OG, 7.5% C. My logic for those numbers is that when passing, the QB and the collective receiving corps matter equally, so QB = WR+TE, whereas while when running, it's mostly the HB, less the FB. Overall, I give 37.5% credit to the O-Line, which is important on every play, 32.5% credit to the passing game skill players, and 30% credit to the running game skill players. Eventually, once I have enough data, I will run some multivariable regression analysis on rankings vs. results, and see if I'm overrating/underrating certain positions. Off the top of my head, HB should probably be worth less, and the O-Line probably worth more, but I'm not ready yet to mess with that portion of these rankings. Next season, perhaps. Anyway, averaging the numbers together with those weights, I calculated a rating of 95.0 for the Vaqueros offense.

Doing the same basic thing on defense, I got a rating of 94.7, and on special teams (kicker + punter) I got 84.4. Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.

Then they played a game against the New Jersey Generals, who were rated 93.6, so the Vaqueros were rated 0.7 lower, and thus were 2 point underdogs (actually 2.1282). They won by 3, so that means they overperformed their ranking by 5, which earned an adjustment of +0.26.

Now then, their week 2 rankings:
The only changes in level are that the backup TE went from 21 to 22, a DT went from 26 to 27, a LB went from 22 to 23, a CB went from 25 to 27, and the K went from 26 to 27. This did increase the weighted average level at those positions, but other teams also improved. Specifically, the best WR corps in the league jumped from 26.5 to 27.3, TE went from 27.2 to 27.8, and OT and OG went up as well, along of course with some increases to the defensive maximums.

In other words, the "league best" went up more than the Vaqueros did, therefore the Vaqueros rating dropped a bit in comparison, to an offense rating of 94.3, a defense rating of 93.0, and 86.2 on special teams. These, and a 91 chemistry, average together to 92.1, a drop from the 92.9 the were beforehand. The adjustment bonus for their upset win raises it to 92.3, but it's still lower than it was beforehand.

Is that a long enough answer to a short question?

you could of just said that beating a team doesnt necessarily put you ahead of them in the rankings. That would of sufficed.
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romeorr

you could of just said that beating a team doesnt necessarily put you ahead of them in the rankings. That would of sufficed.


I was interested in the long version, but then, I'm not making it my job to doink people all the time either.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tank Basterson
Originally posted by Romeorr


you could of just said that beating a team doesnt necessarily put you ahead of them in the rankings. That would of sufficed.


I was interested in the long version, but then, I'm not making it my job to doink people all the time either.


I could've said that, but I WANTED to explain how the system works, since I figured it could serve to make some people more interested. I'm glad to hear you liked it Tank
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
By the way, one other factor that should be considered is that the rankings are based on level AT THIS MOMENT. If one team boosts early, they could easily be ranked ahead of a "better" team, that waits until late to boost. Since the rankings are updated based on new levels each week, they will correct themselves for the current state of affairs as more teams boost. I have no idea who boosts early and late in this league, I didn't pay enough attention to what teams' rosters looked like during the offseason, but it's not out of the realm of possibility that the favorite to win the league championship is someone ranked well lower than the top 5 right now, if that team boosts late and others boost early.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I'm thinking it must be time for Duff to start considering a gut and sell. After all, 1st it's being ranked so low. Now it's a sub standard lvl of effort on the field. There really isn't anything left to play for...And your scrim games were nothing to write home about either. Just to be a nice guy, I'd be willing to look over your roster and give a few of the players a new home. You know, so they're not stuck on a gutted team with a crappy new owner.


You have no idea how close to the truth you are. It's like WWIII in our forum right now.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
phthalatemagic was actually threatening to join DDL...that is how bad it has gotten
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.