User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sjostrom7
offline
Link
 
Same thing happened to my team.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=105387&mode=pbp

Look at last play of game and where we were on the field. He should of at least attempted the kick. That is complete BS. That would of been to tie the game.

We had it set so he kicked field goals within the 35. Its problems like these that screw my team over.
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Methinks it's something you did, because:
a) It's routinely been somebody screwing up the AI settings when last-second FGs don't get attempted, and
b) you also went for it on 4th and 6.5 from their 33.5 within the last two minutes of the game. That would've been ~52yd FG, which is something you "should" have attempted.

I'm guessing you didn't fix your Down Late tactic. I can't actually see your tactics, obviously, but that's been the most common screw-up thus far.


Bzzzt! Wrong
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Methinks it's something you did, because:
a) It's routinely been somebody screwing up the AI settings when last-second FGs don't get attempted, and
b) you also went for it on 4th and 6.5 from their 33.5 within the last two minutes of the game. That would've been ~52yd FG, which is something you "should" have attempted.

I'm guessing you didn't fix your Down Late tactic. I can't actually see your tactics, obviously, but that's been the most common screw-up thus far.


Not sure what you mean by fix the Down Late tatic. But it looks fine to me. Plus the FG kick Input is first on the list. The SIM never should have gone any further, since it searches for a match from top down.

What should have happened is the SIM should have checked th 4th quarter tactics saw that we were down 2, in field goal range and under 40 seconds. It should have stopped right there as that is a 100% match to the situation.

I'm not sure why we went for it on the other posession either? Again, that looks to be a bug. That FG would have been 50 yards.

The tactics look to be fine, I have no idea why we are attempting FG's.

Domer
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
what is your script in the last second field goal play exactly?
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
what is your script in the last second field goal play exactly?


INPUT

Time Remaining - Less then 40 seconds.
Ball Spot - Between - Any Yardline and AnyYardling
Down - Between 1 and 4
Yards to First Down - left blank
Score Difference - Between -3 and 0
Special Situations- Within FG Range

OUTPUT
Percent Chance - 100%
Play Type - FG

All other output options are use basic settings (Primary Receiver, Runner, Play Distance).

We left the FG range at the top blank so it is autodetermined.

We kicked a 55 Yard FG earlier in the game that the sim felt was within range.

Domer
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
removed because it answered OP question.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 06:43:29
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
the part that jumps out is 'within field goal range'. I have basically the same set up but defined it a lot better to take away guess work.

INPUT:
20 seconds or less
Ball spot Opp40-Opp goal(max 57 yard fg)
down 1-4
yards to first left blank
score difference -3 and 0
***no special circumstance***

output:
100% field goal

This will take make the team kick when you deem fit not with an artificial number crated by a formula you do not know like 'within FG range'


I will change it for sure now. But I'd still like to know why it wasn't followed. I beleive Bort is looking into it as he has replied with some questions in another thread. If it is indeed the SIM calculating a differnece FG range at that time, I'd like to know why the range got reduced so drastically at that time and not earlier in the game. If it is indeed a Stamina issue, then we can fix that. I don't see how it can be, since he last made a play 9 minutes prior to that moment and finsihed the game with 97 energy.

Thanks for your help. Hopefully we get an answer on this so it doesn't happen again.

Domer
 
eaglesfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domer
Here is what we have set up in advanced offensive AI.

Under 4th quarter overrides

First Input.

Less then 40 seconds in the quarter and down by 3 or less. Kick the FG 100% of the time in FG range.

We had the ball on the 35 yard line (within our FG range) with 27 seconds left run a play gain 7-8 yards. With 7 seconds to go we have the ball on the 27 yard line. We run it up the gut DOWN by 2. Why didn't we kick the FG here?

We had Offensive AI enabled and the Input was he first on the list for 4th quarter overrides. I don't get it. We should have had a chance to win that game. We had a 52 yard FG try and then a 45 yard FG try and the SIM pass on them both to run out the clock.

Any ideas?

EDIT MORE INFO: Our FG kicker did attempt a 55 yard FG and a 44 yard FG in the game. He missed both, but the SIM should have kicked the 52 Yard FG with 27 seconds left in the game according your our AI settings.

Domer



we had teh same issue today last play of game its 4th down and we are down by 2 on the 16 yard line

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91389&pbp_id=1272003

4th quarter advanced AI setting
less than 40 seconds remaining in 4th quarter
between opponent 30 and opponent goal
between downs 1-4
score difference of -3 and 0
special circumstances within field goal range

100% kick field goal

why didnt we kick it we should have won this game
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Define the "within field goal range" setting that the system uses. You can't because the code is unknown.

Maybe the code to determine 'within field goal range' expects a 50% or higher make probability before it is called. With it being late in game and kicker lower on stamina and confidence maybe he would not satisfy the 50% make chance until you were at the 20. Thus your team was not in range. No one knows.

Just take away all the decisions the sim will make and you won't have to post alot of 'bug' reports
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5STAR
Define the "within field goal range" setting that the system uses. You can't because the code is unknown.

Maybe the code to determine 'within field goal range' expects a 50% or higher make probability before it is called. With it being late in game and kicker lower on stamina and confidence maybe he would not satisfy the 50% make chance until you were at the 20. Thus your team was not in range. No one knows.

Just take away all the decisions the sim will make and you won't have to post alot of 'bug' reports


This is a smart approach. And one I will follow for sure from this point forward. But even with this work around, the problem needs to be fixed or at the least what happended needs to be explained ( I beleive it will when Bort figures it out). If things don't work as they are supposed to, they need to be fixed.

Also, our specfic situation borders on a FG range issue perhaps, but others reporting similiar problems where much closer and still didn't have the FG kicked...

Domer
 
jazzedpap1028
offline
Link
 
I just posted something as well, didn't see this thread. This same thing happen to me about 30 mins ago, please provide an answer. Though the FG may have been missed, sure would have liked to attempt and win the game.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
I believe that the problem is that the auto range is out of whack. I would like some confirmation from the powers above though before changing my AI to compensate.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.