User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


Well let's not "fix" that. Instead it would be interesting to find out how or why one WR is getting that many passes...look into the coverage settings and see how it happens.
 
Bountytaker
offline
Link
 
I'm looking at a lot of the team's involved depth charts. Both sides in most/all of these games were filling in the old WR/CB chart, as well as the new WR1,2,3/CB1,2,3 charts.


Wasn't that a no-no. I remember reading you had to choose one or the other, and, after a weird scrimmage result, we did.
 
DPGDawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by Bort

Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


Is this bad I am confused.


Yea
I dont get the problem
Would you rather have your QB throw it to the #1 guy whos doulble covered
instead of the #2 or #3 guys whos wide open just so the #1 guy gets a pass thrown his way
and doesnt run off the field cryin that you didnt throw him the ball ?
This sounds like a Liberal Football version of No Child Left Behind.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


While this seems reasonable at first, it does sort of put a damper on the more possession-oriented build.

Under this formula, the entire focus of a WR must be to "get open," with as few as possible actual catching skills as are necessary to catch the ball that is throw to you.

A WR with size, jumping, strength, a ton of catch, jump catching etc, will never have a chance to use those skills as they rarely get much separation.

If I have a 6'4" WR with 35 jumping, 60 points of catching and 5 points of jump catch vs a 6'0" CB with 15 points of jumping, I figure I am open even when he is standing right on top of me.

Just throw it high!

This does not seem to be a worthwhile strategy, at the moment.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


While this seems reasonable at first, it does sort of put a damper on the more possession-oriented build.

Under this formula, the entire focus of a WR must be to "get open," with as few as possible actual catching skills as are necessary to catch the ball that is throw to you.

A WR with size, jumping, strength, a ton of catch, jump catching etc, will never have a chance to use those skills as they rarely get much separation.

If I have a 6'4" WR with 35 jumping, 60 points of catching and 5 points of jump catch vs a 6'0" CB with 15 points of jumping, I figure I am open even when he is standing right on top of me.

Just throw it high!

This does not seem to be a worthwhile strategy, at the moment.


Yes, that makes some sense, but just think of all the complaints about the ball getting thrown into coverage. You generally want to keep the ball away from the defenders.

It also looks like this particular case had the same play called over and over again, which is going to lead to similar results over and over again. Perhaps we just need more offensive plays for variety.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
More offensive plays is definitely a good idea.

However, a more sophisticated targeting algorithm for QBs (perhaps based on vision?) might be a very good thing as well.

It would require a "mismatch" rating for each WR on each play...size, jumping and catching could figure in, and the QB could try to pinpoint a pass to the spot that the WR can catch it. The QB could look for open receivers first, mismatches second, or some combination of the two based on degree of separation or mismatch.

Just a thought.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
More offensive plays is definitely a good idea.

However, a more sophisticated targeting algorithm for QBs (perhaps based on vision?) might be a very good thing as well.

It would require a "mismatch" rating for each WR on each play...size, jumping and catching could figure in, and the QB could try to pinpoint a pass to the spot that the WR can catch it. The QB could look for open receivers first, mismatches second, or some combination of the two based on degree of separation or mismatch.

Just a thought.


That is how it works - each receiver has a "risk" value calculated based on the defenders near him. Being open just gives a bigger bonus to being less risky than being better than the receiver. I guess I could modify the variables a bit if it's causing problems, but it's been the same for 4 seasons now.
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
This didn't happen last year. It's obviously some type of bug. Whether the bug is with the QB, CB, or WR. There are to many #2 WRs that are getting 80% of the targets. We won today, but it almost beat us. Our 2nd WR is by far not our stud, but he is good.

Let's not assume that most #2 CBs had their settings on playing off instead of tight. B/c that is to much of a coincidence.

There might not be any changes with the passing, but something has changed. Nothing like this even came close to happening to us last season. 80% of the passes. We passed heavy this game. We outmatched (and I guarantee that has nothing to do with builds) our opponents DBs more then anything else on their team by far. The gameplan just didn't work b/c of this bug.
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 15:18:40
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
And it definitely wasnt the case in my situation (cb was playing tight).
 
Bountytaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CRich
This didn't happen last year. It's obviously some type of bug. Whether the bug is with the QB, CB, or WR. There are to many #2 WRs that are getting 80% of the targets. We won today, but it almost beat us. Our 2nd WR is by far not our stud, but he is good.

Let's not assume that most #2 CBs had their settings on playing off instead of tight. B/c that is to much of a coincidence.

There might not be any changes with the passing, but something has changed. Nothing like this even came close to happening to us last season. 80% of the passes. We passed heavy this game. We outmatched (and I guarantee that has nothing to do with builds) our opponents DBs more then anything else on their team by far. The gameplan just didn't work b/c of this bug.


The one common denominator I'm seeing is teams using both depth charts(new/old) for the CB's and WR's.

 
Link
 
My teams first preseason game I used the old WR depth chart only and the passes were spread out as normal. My last preseason game I used the new chart and my #2 WR was targeted like crazy even if my #1 was wide open.

Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761734
My #1 is wide open for the first down and the QB throws to the #2 that has 2 defenders right by him.


Also I noticed my CBs staying back from the WRs a lot and all of our CBs tactics were set to stay close.
Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761305
Last edited Aug 2, 2008 15:48:39
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joseph Trabell
My teams first preseason game I used the old WR depth chart only and the passes were spread out as normal. My last preseason game I used the new chart and my #2 WR was targeted like crazy even if my #1 was wide open.

Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761734
My #1 is wide open for the first down and the QB throws to the #2 that has 2 defenders right by him.


Also I noticed my CBs staying back from the WRs a lot and all of our CBs tactics were set to stay close.
Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761305


That second one is just a cover 3 - they're supposed to drop back like that into a deep zone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Joseph Trabell

My teams first preseason game I used the old WR depth chart only and the passes were spread out as normal. My last preseason game I used the new chart and my #2 WR was targeted like crazy even if my #1 was wide open.

Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761734
My #1 is wide open for the first down and the QB throws to the #2 that has 2 defenders right by him.


Also I noticed my CBs staying back from the WRs a lot and all of our CBs tactics were set to stay close.
Like in this play http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81074&pbp_id=761305


That second one is just a cover 3 - they're supposed to drop back like that into a deep zone.



Yea I see that now. Wasn't really paying attention to the cover type.
 
rogers2000
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


While this seems reasonable at first, it does sort of put a damper on the more possession-oriented build.

Under this formula, the entire focus of a WR must be to "get open," with as few as possible actual catching skills as are necessary to catch the ball that is throw to you.

A WR with size, jumping, strength, a ton of catch, jump catching etc, will never have a chance to use those skills as they rarely get much separation.

If I have a 6'4" WR with 35 jumping, 60 points of catching and 5 points of jump catch vs a 6'0" CB with 15 points of jumping, I figure I am open even when he is standing right on top of me.

Just throw it high!

This does not seem to be a worthwhile strategy, at the moment.


Yes, that makes some sense, but just think of all the complaints about the ball getting thrown into coverage. You generally want to keep the ball away from the defenders.

It also looks like this particular case had the same play called over and over again, which is going to lead to similar results over and over again. Perhaps we just need more offensive plays for variety.


This will be your answer! Let people choose what WR or RB on their advanced plays to target. Every play has a couple main targets & then secondary check & so on. If we had the ability to have a little more control in this area it would help a lot.

Overall things are working well & some people are just having trouble with new tactics in general.

 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Definitely looks to be a case of always passing to the most open guy. The CB in the OP's post is playing way off the receiver and leaving him open over and over. Maybe there needs to be more randomness in pass selection? Right now the QB will just look for the most open guy and send it his way.


While this seems reasonable at first, it does sort of put a damper on the more possession-oriented build.

Under this formula, the entire focus of a WR must be to "get open," with as few as possible actual catching skills as are necessary to catch the ball that is throw to you.

A WR with size, jumping, strength, a ton of catch, jump catching etc, will never have a chance to use those skills as they rarely get much separation.

If I have a 6'4" WR with 35 jumping, 60 points of catching and 5 points of jump catch vs a 6'0" CB with 15 points of jumping, I figure I am open even when he is standing right on top of me.

Just throw it high!

This does not seem to be a worthwhile strategy, at the moment.


Considering the average height of a CB is 5'10"-5'11" and WRs are in the 6'1"-6'2" area, then they would be open all the time. In general, CBs have better verticals than taller, heavier WRs. Real life talk anyways, so height advantage and being able to reach higher isn't everything. Even so, being able to reach the ball at it's highest point between you and the receiver will still win that battle.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.