Originally posted by mpowell
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by sbuck143
shameless bump. This is still upsetting to me. Somehow my CB goes from playing uber tight the first half to giving his WR a 5 yd cushion the entire second half. What happened to my CB's tactics? He was on close coverage but obviously wasnt like that for the entire 2nd half.
There's some stuff in the code (that I decided to remove today) that keeps track of risk based on how badly a guy has burned you, and makes players try to stay behind him more to keep from getting beat. I think that's probably what happened with your CB after he got thrown on over and over. I haven't had a chance to check recent leagues, but the last couple hours of sims today were running without that bit.
Well, that's not a bad idea, in general. But the threat level shouldn't be elevated b/c he catches a ball in front of the CB. The CB should only increase his cushion if he's getting beat deep. Otherwise, yes, this is what we would call a positive feedback loop (and a really bad situation). 
Please keep such stuff!
"Intelligent" CBs realizing what "their" WR does to them are very important for a more realistic sim.
The "behavior" of giving more cushion when getting beaten deep is just right i.m.h.o. What needs to be looked at is the behavior of
keeping the SAME cushion all the time.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=91913&pbp_id=911441Starting out with that cushion, the CB should "use it up" to about 1 - 1.5 yard(s) at 7 yards deep and 0.5 - 1 yard at 10 yards deep. So he'd still have a little in case the WR goes deep but is able to defend the medium routes too.
This a
general problem of using cushion by CBs. Either they keep it all the time or they loose it right from the start:
Watch CBs Hanford Dixon (#1) and DaShawn Glovinyo (#3) in the play above: starting out with a little cushion, they
head towards the WR right from the start (to play close coverage).
Now that makes no sense. IF a defender wants to play that close, he'd line up press. But if he starts out with 2 yards cushion, he'd let the WR come his way and pick him up there. So - if possible - a little change to the CB movement:
- (right from the start

never move towards the WR, but let the WR come your way (if playing close)
- use cushion up during the play; whatever cushion the CB starts out with, have it half at 7 yards deep and cut it down to 0.5 - 1 at 10-12 yards deep.
And of course, the "remembering" should go both ways. So if the CB gives cushion because of getting beaten deep, he'd need to give less when getting beaten on shorter routes in front of him (if he's ordered to play close; at "medium" he's ordered to play it saver and give up short passes - so he shouldn't mind passes >5 yd., at "far" not even passes >9 yd).