Give a small XP award for holding a team to 3 downs?
Forum > Suggestions > XP For Defense: Bad D=Good XP
Randy03Texags
offline
offline
I have TE1 as WR5, though when I didnt assign WR 5 last game, CB1 came in because the computer felt that he was the most qualified person to play that position
Jed
offline
offline
^^Yup, I've had that happen, too. Which is a large reason of why I assigned a full depth chart 

Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Maybe instead of XP per play, XP for percentage of team's offensive plays and percentage of team's defensive plays.
I'm thinking that if a team came out and threw some early games by throwing 100% of the time to make game longer and get more total plays they could level players up faster. With no XP in playoffs, they could go 1 whole season with this strategy to make team much better for season 2.
I'm thinking that if a team came out and threw some early games by throwing 100% of the time to make game longer and get more total plays they could level players up faster. With no XP in playoffs, they could go 1 whole season with this strategy to make team much better for season 2.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Actually, the best solution all around may be to put a cap on number of plays you can get XP for in a game.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
Leroy Jenkins
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Actually, the best solution all around may be to put a cap on number of plays you can get XP for in a game.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
This is a bad idea on so many levels
Actually, the best solution all around may be to put a cap on number of plays you can get XP for in a game.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
This is a bad idea on so many levels
Randy03Texags
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
^^Yup, I've had that happen, too. Which is a large reason of why I assigned a full depth chart
Well he did catch an 11 yard pass, because it was the 5WR "broken play" lol
^^Yup, I've had that happen, too. Which is a large reason of why I assigned a full depth chart

Well he did catch an 11 yard pass, because it was the 5WR "broken play" lol
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Leroy Jenkins
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Actually, the best solution all around may be to put a cap on number of plays you can get XP for in a game.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
This is a bad idea on so many levels
Why?
1. It fights against owners building 30 players on the same team then starting them all the time and building up. While backups sit and get nothing.
2. It encourages human player depth on teams and getting backups in to keep non owner players happy.
3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)
4. It counters the penalty to good defenses or quick strike offenses.
5. It helps lower level players catch up to upper level players faster, because they get more XP per play and starters can't keep outgaining them by getting 50 more plays per game.
6. It retains importance of boosting, because it gets harder and harder to level up through XP as players get to higher levels.
edited to add 7. It stops players from leveling up as fast and contracts continually needing to be renegotiated because players can't afford to train.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Actually, the best solution all around may be to put a cap on number of plays you can get XP for in a game.
Set the cap at 40. Afte 40 plays in a game you get no more XP.
1. Defenses are pretty much going to play at least 40 plays a game, so starters on top defenses don't get penalized and fall behind starters on bad defenses. Backups may get hurt some, but it shouldn't effect team competitiveness very much.
2. It encourages teams to have more depth and play backups. If you can't get more XP for your starter by playing him 80 plays and it uses up more of his energy, there is incentive for having backups on the roster.
This is a bad idea on so many levels
Why?
1. It fights against owners building 30 players on the same team then starting them all the time and building up. While backups sit and get nothing.
2. It encourages human player depth on teams and getting backups in to keep non owner players happy.
3. It fights against gaming the system. (calling all pass plays in early games to level up players faster)
4. It counters the penalty to good defenses or quick strike offenses.
5. It helps lower level players catch up to upper level players faster, because they get more XP per play and starters can't keep outgaining them by getting 50 more plays per game.
6. It retains importance of boosting, because it gets harder and harder to level up through XP as players get to higher levels.
edited to add 7. It stops players from leveling up as fast and contracts continually needing to be renegotiated because players can't afford to train.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 13:10:27
Jed
offline
offline
^^I'm curious why this is a bad idea as well. I would love to have some depth on my team but don't cause it would screw us XP-wise. Just double the amount of exp you get per play, halve the amount of plays before the point where every additional play is basically 0.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
^^I'm curious why this is a bad idea as well. I would love to have some depth on my team but don't cause it would screw us XP-wise. Just double the amount of exp you get per play, halve the amount of plays before the point where every additional play is basically 0.
I wouldn't even double the amount of XP per play. Maybe a little more. But why not have players grow slower. Keep contracts from being outdated 1/2 through 1 season. Maybe increase the longevity of players to 12 or 15 season so they can grow more. Once there are salary caps this will be a concern.
^^I'm curious why this is a bad idea as well. I would love to have some depth on my team but don't cause it would screw us XP-wise. Just double the amount of exp you get per play, halve the amount of plays before the point where every additional play is basically 0.
I wouldn't even double the amount of XP per play. Maybe a little more. But why not have players grow slower. Keep contracts from being outdated 1/2 through 1 season. Maybe increase the longevity of players to 12 or 15 season so they can grow more. Once there are salary caps this will be a concern.
Jed
offline
offline
Wait till you're level 10+ and you're not leveling every game anymore. I'm expecting my FB (who's 15) will take over 2 games to level at this point.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.
Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.

Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Wait till you're level 10+ and you're not leveling every game anymore. I'm expecting my FB (who's 15) will take over 2 games to level at this point.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.
Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
But I'm looking right now and for deeper teams, less than 25% of starters are getting over 40 plays per game anyway. I can find games where not 1 defensive player on an entire team got to 40 plays.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=5373
Many players, even starters at certain positions are not going to be effected by a 40 play limit. HB is one example. Most teams use two HB interchangeably. While they primarily use 1 QB. QB's are leveling up much faster than HBs. OL are leveling up much faster than DL.
Edited to add: Your level 15 FB is evidence of the problem right now. There are only 44 level 13 or higher players. In reality, level 12 should be the highest any player has reached by this point and that is with a boost.
Wait till you're level 10+ and you're not leveling every game anymore. I'm expecting my FB (who's 15) will take over 2 games to level at this point.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.

Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
But I'm looking right now and for deeper teams, less than 25% of starters are getting over 40 plays per game anyway. I can find games where not 1 defensive player on an entire team got to 40 plays.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=5373
Many players, even starters at certain positions are not going to be effected by a 40 play limit. HB is one example. Most teams use two HB interchangeably. While they primarily use 1 QB. QB's are leveling up much faster than HBs. OL are leveling up much faster than DL.
Edited to add: Your level 15 FB is evidence of the problem right now. There are only 44 level 13 or higher players. In reality, level 12 should be the highest any player has reached by this point and that is with a boost.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 13:28:34
SnowShark
offline
offline
Another possibility to help the defense would be a defense that shuts out an opponent or gives up less than 10 points gets an immediate point or two of XP (starters and back-ups).
Just my 2 cents.
Just my 2 cents.
ThaOutlaw
offline
offline
Im a backup and i level every uhm....3 F#@W#%^ games. I mean that's ridiculous if your guy who is lower than a lvl 10 is leveling EVERY game. That's not fair...if we preach "the rich get richer" is what we want to avoid by not giving teams playoff EXP, we can't in good conscience keep screwing the back ups.
Urrymonster
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Wait till you're level 10+ and you're not leveling every game anymore. I'm expecting my FB (who's 15) will take over 2 games to level at this point.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.
Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
How on Earth are you still leveling so quick???? All my players have a higher stamina than what people recommend and yet they still get knackered and replaced. Generally though they are the highest snap players on my team (around the 50 mark). In six games I leveled up to level 3 and then boosted as the season finished. I am slightly baffled about the whole stamina thing at the moment and could do with some suggestions (my level 6 players have stamina around 30 at the moment but has been at that point most season).
Wait till you're level 10+ and you're not leveling every game anymore. I'm expecting my FB (who's 15) will take over 2 games to level at this point.
Fast forward 3 seasons, I don't want him to take over a season to level.

Leveling right now is at a good pace for starters, just not backups.
How on Earth are you still leveling so quick???? All my players have a higher stamina than what people recommend and yet they still get knackered and replaced. Generally though they are the highest snap players on my team (around the 50 mark). In six games I leveled up to level 3 and then boosted as the season finished. I am slightly baffled about the whole stamina thing at the moment and could do with some suggestions (my level 6 players have stamina around 30 at the moment but has been at that point most season).
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























