User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > What's with all the CPUs on the Punishers?!?!?!?!?!?!
Page:
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Reggie Smash
I mean - I thought the whole point of this game was to get on a team that could reach USA Pro & challenge the best of the best. Extremely disheartening to see just how selfish & shortsighted most people are.

(snip)

Pathetic.

So it's "pathetic" to want your player to be able to actually make a real difference on a team, as opposed to being a replaceable part?

Not to mention how disgustingly hubristic it is of you to write off every non-USA league. Honestly, the main feature of USA Pro that I've detected so far is that it manages to rival Canada Pro for sheer density of garbage on the forums. If it weren't for the ability to laugh at the tears of the Galaxy Aces and TSE (and the fact that it will keep me far away from Canada Pro), I'd have never come to the Rebel Yell.

*rolls eyes*

But you're right, there is absolutely something pathetic.
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
Oh no! I've put on a disgusting display of hubris by suggesting that in a tiered-league game, the goal should be to reach the top tier. Nice zinger at the end too lol. Spare me.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by Reggie Smash

I mean - I thought the whole point of this game was to get on a team that could reach USA Pro & challenge the best of the best. Extremely disheartening to see just how selfish & shortsighted most people are.

(snip)

Pathetic.

So it's "pathetic" to want your player to be able to actually make a real difference on a team, as opposed to being a replaceable part?

Not to mention how disgustingly hubristic it is of you to write off every non-USA league. Honestly, the main feature of USA Pro that I've detected so far is that it manages to rival Canada Pro for sheer density of garbage on the forums. If it weren't for the ability to laugh at the tears of the Galaxy Aces and TSE (and the fact that it will keep me far away from Canada Pro), I'd have never come to the Rebel Yell.

*rolls eyes*

But you're right, there is absolutely something pathetic.


I think the point is you can make a difference as a backup just as much as a starter on a lot of teams. I use rotations at most positions so that backups get almost as many plays as starters. Really the only difference is their name doesn't show up on the starter list. It's just pathetic how many lvl 20s went down to Canada A once the cap was lifted. So every Canada A team had to get rid of all their lvl 13 players so they could make room for the stat padders who would rather look like studs against less competition than come play in a higher league where they would have less stats, but play against better competition. To me it's the equivalent of playing football in High School and the coach tells you that you will be playing a lot on the varsity team, but you say "nah I'll stay on JV and beat up younger kids".
Just the way I look at it.
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah


I think the point is you can make a difference as a backup just as much as a starter on a lot of teams. I use rotations at most positions so that backups get almost as many plays as starters. Really the only difference is their name doesn't show up on the starter list. It's just pathetic how many lvl 20s went down to Canada A once the cap was lifted. So every Canada A team had to get rid of all their lvl 13 players so they could make room for the stat padders who would rather look like studs against less competition than come play in a higher league where they would have less stats, but play against better competition. To me it's the equivalent of playing football in High School and the coach tells you that you will be playing a lot on the varsity team, but you say "nah I'll stay on JV and beat up younger kids".
Just the way I look at it.


+1
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by Reggie Smash

I mean - I thought the whole point of this game was to get on a team that could reach USA Pro & challenge the best of the best. Extremely disheartening to see just how selfish & shortsighted most people are.

(snip)

Pathetic.

So it's "pathetic" to want your player to be able to actually make a real difference on a team, as opposed to being a replaceable part?

Not to mention how disgustingly hubristic it is of you to write off every non-USA league. Honestly, the main feature of USA Pro that I've detected so far is that it manages to rival Canada Pro for sheer density of garbage on the forums. If it weren't for the ability to laugh at the tears of the Galaxy Aces and TSE (and the fact that it will keep me far away from Canada Pro), I'd have never come to the Rebel Yell.

*rolls eyes*

But you're right, there is absolutely something pathetic.


Backup players make a huge difference on teams. We have a ton of non-starters who i consider to be integral to our team's success, and we do our best to get good playing time for everybody on our team. Last season, one of our most important players was our backup FS, who got max XP every game. He ended up leaving this season, to be a starter elsewhere, but he sucked it up and played as a backup last season and made a huge impact.

I dont know why you're taking such offense to what was a pretty good post. Something personal you're not sharing with us?
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
I dont know why you're taking such offense to what was a pretty good post. Something personal you're not sharing with us?

I just think that anyone who believe that a lv18 should want to come into this league as a backup, rather than play in a league where they actually can compete with the other good players, or anyone who thinks that USA is in any way better than not-USA, should die in a fire.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by Yellow

I dont know why you're taking such offense to what was a pretty good post. Something personal you're not sharing with us?

I just think that anyone who believe that a lv18 should want to come into this league as a backup, rather than play in a league where they actually can compete with the other good players, or anyone who thinks that USA is in any way better than not-USA, should die in a fire.


I agree with the lvl 18, but a lvl 23 + has no business in Canada A or other low leagues. Unless of course they started their career there.
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by Yellow

I dont know why you're taking such offense to what was a pretty good post. Something personal you're not sharing with us?

I just think that anyone who believe that a lv18 should want to come into this league as a backup, rather than play in a league where they actually can compete with the other good players, or anyone who thinks that USA is in any way better than not-USA, should die in a fire.


I don't think I like you very much either.
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah
I agree with the lvl 18, but a lvl 23 + has no business in Canada A or other low leagues. Unless of course they started their career there.

Yes, 23+ is probably too high for an A league. But he said 18. Also, I was objecting just as much to his suggestion that USA Pro is supposed to be some kind of destination as to the rest of it.


Originally posted by Reggie Smash
I don't think I like you very much either.

Good.
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 00:07:23
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
I joined my team as a backup, remain a backup & nickel/dime DB, and have built a very good build on the advice/help of my higher-levelled teammates. I know my role on the team is valuable, and I see my contribution reflected in the game film - and in the game plans. I'm not talking from the position of some alpha-tester looking down on the scrubs, I'm talking as a scrub myself.

I've found it much more enjoyable & worthwhile to be an active participant on a good team in a challenging league like USA AAA #2 than it was being one of the only reliable players on any number of shaky, roster-turnover-prone teams in shitty leagues (such as the 4-12 one from Southeast Asia AA #3). And yes, I think it's pathetic the amount of talented players I saw electing to enter situations where they could dominate instead of embracing an opportunity to play in a good league like the one we have here.

And for the record, USA Pro is the best league (according to the avg level list), but you're irked by the fact that I think it's GLB's ultimate destination... seriously, WTF is your problem guy?
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
I think Usa Pro is definitely one of the best leagues out there, but Canada Pro is pretty close and I am sure the other Pro leagues are good as well.

As far as being a backup, I was lucky to start this game early and have not had to do much as a backup, but when i have I embraced the role. As long as I am getting plays and helping the team I am happy. The way this game is set up I think backups are just as important as starters. They get roughly the same amount of plays and without quality backups you give up 200 yards rushing to the razorbacks.
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
You are confusing a quantitative measure (higher levels) with a qualitative measure ("better").

I do like how you are claiming a team focus (players should be happy to be backups for teams much higher-level than them!) while simultaneously putting the lie to that (every single player should be trying to get accepted into USA Pro!).

I will offer my actual, honest opinion and see if we can just all agree that it is correct: players should seek a team on which they can be credible, valid contributors, and which hopefully meets their other needs (playtime, level of commitment, fun teammates, etc). If the team does meet those needs, players should then work over the long term to make that team as successful as they can. (The obvious corollary to this is that owners must similarly exercise long-term effort and responsibility.)
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
You are confusing a quantitative measure (higher levels) with a qualitative measure ("better").

I do like how you are claiming a team focus (players should be happy to be backups for teams much higher-level than them!) while simultaneously putting the lie to that (every single player should be trying to get accepted into USA Pro!).

I will offer my actual, honest opinion and see if we can just all agree that it is correct: players should seek a team on which they can be credible, valid contributors, and which hopefully meets their other needs (playtime, level of commitment, fun teammates, etc). If the team does meet those needs, players should then work over the long term to make that team as successful as they can. (The obvious corollary to this is that owners must similarly exercise long-term effort and responsibility.)



I can get behind that
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
I will offer my actual, honest opinion and see if we can just all agree that it is correct: players should seek a team on which they can be credible, valid contributors, and which hopefully meets their other needs (playtime, level of commitment, fun teammates, etc). If the team does meet those needs, players should then work over the long term to make that team as successful as they can. (The obvious corollary to this is that owners must similarly exercise long-term effort and responsibility.)


No one has any issue with your opinion. It's no different from anything the rest of us were saying -- except that we were also expressing our frustration over how few agents seemed to realize they could find all of the above and more by joining a team in our league instead of entering an iffy situation in a beginning league with a number of weakened or uncompetitive teams as opponents.

The only real issues here are that I'd add "competing against the best competition possible" to your list, and the fact that you find me disgustingly hubristic for equating the quantitative measure of "higher player levels" to the qualitative measure of "a better league" (and I still maintain that correlation holds true).

But whatever. This one's just about done. You can get your last word in next, and by that point this conversation will likely have run its course. Thanks for the headache.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
I have been very fortunate with OFBG. It would be near impossible to bring in equal level players. We lost our RB1, WR2 and CBs 1,2 and 3 at the end of season 1 but apart from that the group has been together thru seasons 2,3 and hopefully 4+.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.