User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Pass defenders still have too quick reflexes...Bort was going to fix?
Page:
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Any update?
 
Analyst
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
I can think of only one professional team in the last 10 years to have more rushing yards than passing and that team went 7-9.


Atlanta Falcons?

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Still testing, along with the pass rushing update. I don't want defenders to NEVER make plays either. Tough balance.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the update Bort. I know there needs to be balance, but from the stats I've posted in this and a couple of other threads completion percentages are way down.

Are you looking at the CB interference issue as well? If we're to believe the dots they're still mugging WR's.
 
maitey
offline
Link
 
Last sim was much much better now that the jam WR bug was fixed and to me pass deflections didnt seem that much out of whack, or any change since last season.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the update maitey. In the games we were specifically linking to in another thread there were what appeared to be a lot of deflections where the WR broke back to the QB, had position to make the catch, and the CB dot just mugged him before the ball was even close to getting there. Then the CB got a deflection.
 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Thanks for the update maitey. In the games we were specifically linking to in another thread there were what appeared to be a lot of deflections where the WR broke back to the QB, had position to make the catch, and the CB dot just mugged him before the ball was even close to getting there. Then the CB got a deflection.


you can't really go by the dots as they only give you a general idea of what is happening. How many times have you seen a CB reach around a WR to get a deflection even though he was behind the WR and not get called for PI? It happens all the time.

In my team's games we haven't seen too much of a problem with massive PDs but The game is getting closer to being fairly realistic when it comes to the passing game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Still testing, along with the pass rushing update. I don't want defenders to NEVER make plays either. Tough balance.


True, just glad to hear it's at least still in the works. I agree with your caution to make sure defenders still make SOME plays.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
my level 21 QBs comp % has dropped to around 40% while the running game is still broken. this equals no offense at all. we have a great QB, dominant receivers and a great running game. yet, no offense!!!!!
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high. It seems like every pass is always right on target.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 13:06:08
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
its the speed nerf, a db can play tight coverage and almost never get beat, if he does get beat its because the play took a long time and the qb had tons of time
Most of the time the DB is on top of the wr, so to summarize catching in traffic = more drops and deflections and more passes to the TE, which a lot of people are complaining about

it doesn't make sense to nerf the db's, why not un nerf the wr's or un nerf speed all together, and if db’s play tight coverage 99% of the time, they get beat deep if they play off a bit they will not simple as that


the speed nerf was supposed to be for low agility players. our receivers already had high agility and added to that because of the "nerf". but their speed is still useless!!!!!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greenday4537
What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
I dont think the passing game is out of whack ...this last game out of 34 completions to wr's of both teams ..there were a total of 2 dropped balls combined.

The Qb for my team has yet to have a scrimmage game under 60% passing completion rate. Could be something to do with the High Confidence rate of all his recievers.

This last game we tested the passing game ..first was rushing..


Let the builds speak Bort...


I dont know if there is a big enough pool of data to pull from ..Lots of peeps still having trouble getting the Ai's set up to not expose there teams in coverage ect..I think any data at the moment is a bit skewed till peeps have a better handle on the new ai's.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 13:18:19
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sledge
I dont think the passing game is out of whack ...this last game out of 34 completions to wr's of both teams ..there were a total of 2 dropped balls combined.

The Qb for my team has yet to have a scrimmage game under 60% passing completion rate. Could be something to do with the High Confidence rate of all his recievers.

Let the builds speak Bort....


All you have to do is look around the leagues.

I know people are used to a sim where defenses stopped everything all the frigging time, but this is so obvious there shouldn't even be an argument.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Greenday4537

What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.


the running game has NOT been brought up to realistic levels!!! its worse, if anything. when a back with 73 speed and 50 agility cant get outside, there is a problem. you cant get caught by a LB with 50 or 60 speed. the numbers have to mean something!!! if you have 73 speed(and enough agility to support that)then you should be able to beat everyone to the corner. if the CB makes the tackle, so be it. but, no-one should stop him from getting to the outside.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.