Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by advanex1
Originally posted by Jmac0585
Here's a suggestion for option 5:
Stats to consider for Defense:
Tackles, Missed Tackles, Hurry, Sack, Tackles For Loss, Passes Defended,
Interceptions, Defensive TDs, Forced Fumbles, Fumble Recovery, Safety
The issue is the values for stats. For example, should the values for tackles be
different for Linebackers than it is for Corners? Ideally you don't want a CB with a
lot of tackles, but if your CB is making a lot of tackles, he might be the only
thing keeping the rest of the defense hanging themselves.
Or, should all of the numbers (i.e. a value for a sack) be the same and let the
numbers work themselves out? A pick is a pick, regardless of if the DE got it, or
the FS. I am more than fine with option number five.
I think they should vary. The issue here I think is the fact that lesser teams will have more tackles because they are forced to make those tackles. Nick Wilgis (a great linebacker) just happens/happened to be on one of those teams where he's making TONS of tackles because he's forced into more defensive plays.
I think they should vary with something like..
Linebackers
Tackles = 1 point
Missed Tackles - -2 points
Hurry - .5-1 point
Sack - 2-3 points
Tackles For Loss - .5 points
Passes Defended - 1 point
Interceptions - 2-3 points
Defensive TDs - 6 points
Forced Fumbles - 2 points
Fumble Recovery - 1 point
Safety - 2-3 points
DB's
Tackles = 1 point
Missed Tackles - -2 points
Hurry - 1-2 points
Sack - 2-4 points
Tackles For Loss - .5-1 points
Passes Defended - .5 points
Interceptions - 1-2 points
Defensive TDs - 6 points
Forced Fumbles - 2-3 points
Fumble Recovery - 1 point
Safety - 2-4 points
Just throwing numbers out there is all. Would be an interesting way to do it.
Not saying your numbers are bad for the DB but in this situation a DB that had 100 tackles and 0 pass defections would be ranked higher than someone with 50 pass defelctions, 0 tackles (Because they didn't have to), and 10 INT's
We could go back and forth all day on the 'formula'.
My opinion... whoever wants to take the time to do this, identify 5 to 10 top people in each position and everyone vote off of that. If you are not on the list, cry about it as it doesn't matter.
I feel most of the time that there are more pass deflections than tackles. On some of my other teams, I've seen 60-80 PD's and only 40-50 tackles.