User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Does GLB almost necessitate farm teams (discussion)?
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Fandom

So, If you want your TEAM to advance most quickly, you'll play a lot of players.



Yeah... exactly. And if you're smart then most of your players will play on FARM TEAMS!!


It gets worse, what if you had two teams and through a creative series of trade, got an extra two full games of xp out of it?
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
There are, but there seems to be a pretty good contingent that supports collusion, for some reason.

I understand gaining advantage from boosting, it's a legitimate business model. Farm teams and collusion go above and beyond with no benefit to the developers. If they allow stuff like this to continue I know I and others would keep our money in our wallets in the future. Why own a team why you can't compete without 3?
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
It gets worse, what if you had two teams and through a creative series of trade, got an extra two full games of xp out of it?



Yeah, I didn't start at the very beginning or play for a team that tried to give everyone at least 90 plays... but I did make sure that I got 2 extra games in on one of my players.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

It gets worse, what if you had two teams and through a creative series of trade, got an extra two full games of xp out of it?



Yeah, I didn't start at the very beginning or play for a team that tried to give everyone at least 90 plays... but I did make sure that I got 2 extra games in on one of my players.



Right, it's hard to fault you as it seems almost accepted as long as farm teams are around.
 
ewinter43
offline
Link
 
maybe im a minority here, but i don't like farm teams. i enjoy this game. trying to get playing time is a challenge sometimes. one of my players has been seeing less and less pt since we made a playoff run. sucks, but adversity is part of the game experience. my other player is getting a ton of pt but his contract is pretty small. they are both situations that i will have to try to fix on my own.

i don't know, i guess im just old school. i would rather earn everything than gain an advantage by spending a ridiculous amount of money on a game. it seems like there is a small minority who participate in the majority of this farming. you know, the kids with 5 teams and 30 players. its just silly in my opinion.
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
you mean collusion. you said farm teams, but you meant collusion.

and yes, competition fuels a desire to do it.

no, GLB does not necessitate it.

and the lack of high level players to fill rosters will be gone as the player pool's avg level increases.

jkocurek is right, some colluding owners have inflated the highest player level.

GLB is (will be?) set up to hurt teams that max play time at the cost of depth and adequate personnel. teams that try to max out their players for a sseason will not be competitive. it will be like tanking for a higher draft pick.

we can stop arguiing about colluding cause it is wrong, obviously, and we can argue about tanking for exp later ( it won't matter as much when the level of player barking on the team wanted forum gets high).
 
cajik
offline
Link
 
What if a farm team is a legitimate team that is trying to win and develop players for a higher level team at the same time?

Let's say you have a team full of level 8-12's with a 2 or 3 deep depth chart at most positions. At some point that team will want insurance in case a player goes inactive or leaves the team for whatever reason. The most cost effective way to plan for this is to have a farm team.

That farm team will be fully stocked with humans, just like the main team, but with lower level players. They will be 2 or 3 deep at every position. When someone from the main team needs to be replaced, a promising player from the farm team can be called up to be the replacement. This is much more cost effective than trying to find one on the trading block or free agency. Of course there is the CPU fair trade enforcement, so the main team sends cash down to the farm team. This will help the farm team sign new promising players.

This is not the type of farm team where every player plays 2-way and 90+ snaps a game, but a legitimate, realistic, feeder team.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
If you have two teams that is virtually impossible (hell, even with 3) because of the 10 day no trade back (going to be expanded to 20).

I started out with two farm teams and three main teams because I thought I would need to do that in order to keep up with the Jones' so to speak... I moved players between teams as I saw a need develop and had a "long term" goal in mind. With forced player decline in 10 seasons starting to replace players will become important and I wanted to have something in place to take care of it. Not worth the hassle though... too many people think of it as "cheating" so I'll just run 3 teams the right way and if I need to develop a backup or player I'll do it myself if I can't find the right build/type in the free agent market. Of course people will still think 3 teams and 40+ players is "cheating" but I don't really care... it's my money and I can spend it how I want to.

Dealing with inactive players, selfish players, and bad build players I fully understand and support a farm team type system, but I don't need it to win so I've moved away from it.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 21:19:19
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cajik
What if a farm team is a legitimate team that is trying to win and develop players for a higher level team at the same time?

This is not the type of farm team where every player plays 2-way and 90+ snaps a game, but a legitimate, realistic, feeder team.


All of GLB performs the needed functions of a real world farm system in that the larger number of lower leagues develop players faster than the USA pro league could without them. Player experience is, after all, a limited commodity.

There is, however, no need to have "farm teams" collude with another team.
The lower leagues in GLB are not owned by a corporate association for the purpose of producing a marketable, televisable product like MLB or D-league NBA.

The lower leagues are their own marketable product. Independent owners of lower teams are participating in leagues just as competitively as independent owners in the higher leagues.

The sifting of two teams up and down each season will produce the hierarchy which gives competitive substance to the league ranking structure.

The term "farm team" as used in this debate is really referring to collusion between two teams which should be independent competitive agents in their respective leagues.

Instead of having players on teams competing to win championships and get promoted to the next league, or even having players trying to stand out and get bigger contracts in better programs, we have leagues of half-teams playing for maximum PT instead of playing to win.

Those teams are then gutted, destroying any identity they had within their own conference. Regular season stats, awards, championships, season records, ratings, standings, competition, fun, etc... The all become devalued.

The more collusive teams there are, the worse the problems become.

The less collusion there is, the better GLB will play.

No collusion would be the best.
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
What if a farm team is a legitimate team that is trying to win and develop players for a higher level team at the same time?


It's fine, but the problem is legislation. It would be so hard to really regulate between who is trying to win with two legit teams, and who is just planning to undermine one. It's a headache we don't need, and no matter how many rules are written, people are going to try it.

That's what happens on internet games.
 
ewinter43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
. Of course people will still think 3 teams and 40+ players is "cheating" but I don't really care... it's my money and I can spend it how I want to.




yes you can argue that. it is your money- a ridiculous amount, but yours nonetheless. i liken that response to a kid on the playground screaming, "im taking my ball and going home!". just a little childish.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Whatever.
The simple fact is that the regular season dictates giving players as much playing time as possible.

However, the best teams actually will have depth.
If the game wasn't set up so that depth was desirable then we wouldn't need farm teams.

The reason the best teams will want farm teams is because you DO want depth. You just don't want it during the regular season because you lose experience for your players.

So... yeah.
If you want to be a great team then the game is set up so that you will get as much experience as possible for both starters and backups. And then the playoffs come and you just want to win.

...that's Farm Teams.


Just because you choose to not give your backups any playing time, why would you suddenly change that method of operating during the playoffs? There are no injuries, and players will play for 10 seasons before topping out, so why would a team that only plays its starters ever need more players?

Ahhhh, perhaps a few players decide they don't want to play you ask? Well, then that team had the chance to develop good backups behind their starters, but chose not to... Perhaps they can find someone in the free agent pool, or in trade, but it doesn't necessitate a "Farm" team.

PinTBC

 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
Not to mention the books of rules telling owners of NFL teams how they can spend their money is inches thick.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 21:26:04
 
ewinter43
offline
Link
 
having your own team and having players on it is one thing. you're getting all the playing time you want. having 3 teams and moving the top players and money to the top team only tells me that you are unable to succeed at the game the way it was meant to be played.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ewinter43
Originally posted by thehazyone

. Of course people will still think 3 teams and 40+ players is "cheating" but I don't really care... it's my money and I can spend it how I want to.




yes you can argue that. it is your money- a ridiculous amount, but yours nonetheless. i liken that response to a kid on the playground screaming, "im taking my ball and going home!". just a little childish.


The game is bigger then you. Your money is spent playing a game that only exists so long as competitive balance is maintained. I'm not interested in your personal feelings about whether or not you should be able to buy "+5 Ring of speed" for all your players or not, it's all about being competitive.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.