User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
TesT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Originally posted by TesT

Looks great to me...build your lineman better.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78507&pbp_id=327023


that's just a horrible play by the DE and an even worse whiff by the CB moreso than a well-designed and executed play.

What is it that has some of these plays being run one way and others with the OT staying on the DE?


Kinda hard for a CB to make a play when he's being blocked by a RT.

I would say the SS made the worst play of them all..a level 27 SS.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TesT
Originally posted by griz

Originally posted by TesT


Looks great to me...build your lineman better.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78507&pbp_id=327023


that's just a horrible play by the DE and an even worse whiff by the CB moreso than a well-designed and executed play.

What is it that has some of these plays being run one way and others with the OT staying on the DE?


Kinda hard for a CB to make a play when he's being blocked by a RT.

I would say the SS made the worst play of them all..a level 27 SS.


okay the SS then. Either way the example you pulled up is far from the rule to how this play is working. It's also odd that one team would run this play every sweep and the other team would not run it once for all the sweeps they ran.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Its nothing to do with the linemen, its the TE...

Like this.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78329&pbp_id=287505

Works fine here.

This is not a bug its a build issue.


Again, the only reason this worked was you had a Level 19 DT playing out of position with a level 25 TE blocking him. Big difference man and in most scenarios not a realistic one to have.


Didnt say it wasnt unrealistic, just that it can work.

That level 25 TE is a balanced TE, so his blocking and strength are not that of a level 25 OT now are they?

In fact he has less Strength AND Blocking than some level 10 OLs on some of my teams.

A Blocking TE can execute this play, and Pass catching TE cannot.

 
Noaheli
offline
Link
 
Zone blocking schemes implemented? Watch my RT leave his DE and gun straight for the LB while RG steps over to dble the DE with the TE. It worked but I can't say I've ever seen such a thing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82717&pbp_id=53854




Here's my RT pulling on a sweep with the RG

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82717&pbp_id=54846



RT heading straight for the LB again, and RG comes over to the LDE

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82717&pbp_id=55688


Here the RT pancakes the LDE so he leaves him and moves to the next level... then the LDE makes the tackle. Linemen should stick with their blocks at least til the back is through the line of scrimmage.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82717&pbp_id=55788


And there are about another 10 plays where my RT leaves the End and goes straight for the backer. Ive sen RG pull to the next level but never heard of a tackle doing the same.


On an unrelated note but still GLB season 4 related, I noticed that DEs no longer take outside routes to the QB? Theyre trying to share the same gap as the DTs and are able to be picked up by tackle/guard double teams easier.


 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Yep, there were lots of complaints end of Season 3 that the RT was a spectator in most run games, and now he is more active.

This is a good thing not a bug.

Some people havent built the OLs to pull, so they will suffer, some dont have the HBs to get outside so they will suffer.
And some dont have TEs to block DEs so they will suffer.

Its not bad thing, as the benfits outweight the negatives.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by griz

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Its nothing to do with the linemen, its the TE...

Like this.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78329&pbp_id=287505

Works fine here.

This is not a bug its a build issue.


Again, the only reason this worked was you had a Level 19 DT playing out of position with a level 25 TE blocking him. Big difference man and in most scenarios not a realistic one to have.


Didnt say it wasnt unrealistic, just that it can work.

That level 25 TE is a balanced TE, so his blocking and strength are not that of a level 25 OT now are they?

In fact he has less Strength AND Blocking than some level 10 OLs on some of my teams.

A Blocking TE can execute this play, and Pass catching TE cannot.



There is still going to be a huge difference in how well this play is defended. STop focusing on YOUR guy. The defender is an out of position player 6 levels lower. That's how this play gets off here. Put a better DE in there and this play blows up 90% of the time in that exact same situation. You know where this play works best? The new leagues with a Level 13 cap. There isn't enough speed and vision on the field in most instances for this play to get rocked too often.

It also still doesn't answer why one team ran it a ton and the other never ran it for each teams respective sweeps.

I haven't checked all the games yet to see if it worked that way where the play was run exclusively by one team and not their opponent.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
I understand the fraustration, but really, the difference in Level doesnt matter nor does the fact its a DT not a DE.

I will conceed that its possible the Level 19 DT is a poor build and has no strength or agility or vision or shed Block SAs etc.

But really the point I was trying to make is that if the TE has similar Strength and adequate Blocking then the play will be a success. If not then the DE will win the fight and destroy the play.

Personally I dont like the idea of the QB pulling from the snap to the left then pitching back, as it leaves the HB in a very poor spot.

But it is one bad play out of a hell of a lot of good new plays that make the outside run a legitimate option again.

As to why some teams run more RT&RG pull and some run more RG only pull, well I have no idea.

But as the only variable is the human inputting, its almost got to be something to do with the settings, right?

So either the plays are slightly different depending on the defense thats faced.
or
the fact that there are three options for 'Outside Run' now means we will get different plays based on what we set.
or
Maybe its just some random element and we have not seen enough yet to be making assumptions?

We dont know yet, we all need to do some more research.
 
Link
 
The build of the DT playing DE is open, so it's not a huge mystery. I'm not exactly up to date on DE builds, so it may be good to check yourself to see if it's a good build or not. He looks more like a DT than a DE with relatively low agility for what you want in a standard DE IIRC.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Well he is slower than your average DE, but not exactly weak, stronger than my TE anyway

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78329&pbp_id=287599

Same game few plays later Vs a Level 25 DE

The CB is also Level 25, LOLB Level 24, SS Level 25.

Although this should really not be the issue here, we arent critiquing my teams TE build or my opponents DE/DT options.

The play can work, but doesnt always work.

It seems that the way to stop it is to have a well built DE, sounds fair enough to me.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griz
Originally posted by TesT

Originally posted by griz


Originally posted by TesT



Looks great to me...build your lineman better.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78507&pbp_id=327023


that's just a horrible play by the DE and an even worse whiff by the CB moreso than a well-designed and executed play.

What is it that has some of these plays being run one way and others with the OT staying on the DE?


Kinda hard for a CB to make a play when he's being blocked by a RT.

I would say the SS made the worst play of them all..a level 27 SS.


okay the SS then. Either way the example you pulled up is far from the rule to how this play is working. It's also odd that one team would run this play every sweep and the other team would not run it once for all the sweeps they ran.


Only reason i could think they were being run differently is maybe one team used the advanced O tactics and went with the specific outside pitch/sweep and the other team used the basic outside run? Probably totally off with that, but its the only thing i see that could have been different as far as sweeps are concerned.
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Well he is slower than your average DE, but not exactly weak, stronger than my TE anyway

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78329&pbp_id=287599

Same game few plays later Vs a Level 25 DE

The CB is also Level 25, LOLB Level 24, SS Level 25.

Although this should really not be the issue here, we arent critiquing my teams TE build or my opponents DE/DT options.

The play can work, but doesnt always work.

It seems that the way to stop it is to have a well built DE, sounds fair enough to me.


Okay, so did you watch the play you posted? Was that an example of good play execution? The RG and RT stood just beyond where the TE would be...and pretty much watched the play while the RB ran outside of them and got hit by the SS for squat. Not sure what the purpose of a pulling tackle is...nor am I sure why a team, any team, would run a play like this one you have here where the pitch is almost straight backwards while the onside G and T pull.

I get that the plays aren't always perfect in this game and that sometimes a bad player gets overwhelmed or a good player can take over a spot or a series in a game. I am going by just flat-out play design here, this is horrific design. Then to get saddled with this for every pitch we made for an entire game to boot. Seriously.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Oh damn we only got 5.5 yards on a play.

What are you expecting really?

The RG, RT and WR seal of the Edge against the LOLB and CB, and give the HB a corridor exactly as designed.

The SS comes up showing exceptional Vision and Closing speed, and makes a good tackle.

The play isolated a HB against a SS and gained 5.5 yards and the first down.

Please tell me exactly what was wrong with it again?

The RT and RG did exactly what they should in that situation, if they go off up the field the LOLB has a chance of getting the HB short of the first down.


And why are we still talking about this one team?

There are reasons in this thread for why the different calls could be made, no one knows for sure.

As you got the same play every time, you'll have more idea than most why it happened if you review your tactical inputs, make an adjustment for the next game, and compare notes.

but if your looking for a 25 yards Sweep every time you try it, well I have no answers for you I'm afraid.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 01:26:25
 
griz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Oh damn we only got 5.5 yards on a play.

What are you expecting really?

The RG, RT and WR seal of the Edge against the LOLB and CB, and give the HB a corridor exactly as designed.

The SS comes up showing exceptional Vision and Closing speed, and makes a good tackle.

The play isolated a HB against a SS and gained 5.5 yards and the first down.

Please tell me exactly what was wrong with it again?

The RT and RG did exactly what they should in that situation, if they go off up the field the LOLB has a chance of getting the HB short of the first down.


And why are we still talking about this one team?

There are reasons in this thread for why the different calls could be made, no one knows for sure.

As you got the same play every time, you'll have more idea than most why it happened if you review your tactical inputs, make an adjustment for the next game, and compare notes.

but if your looking for a 25 yards Sweep every time you try it, well I have no answers for you I'm afraid.


did you watch the play? Seriously watch the play. If you can't find a ton of flaws in just the overall design of the play, let alone that the only margin for success the play has was 2 of the LB's running backwards on the snap, the DE doing who knows what on the play side and essentially the both linemen allowing 1 guy to run into them while the other guy just stands there.

I am not expecting 25 yards a play. I have no problem with a dee blowing a play up. I do have a problem when I am forced to repeatedly run a majorly damaged and flawed play design over and over and the only way my team can stop running this f-ed up play is to stop running outside. That's all I'm after. That and apparently I feel like punishing myself by engaging in this discussion beyond my usual level of tolerance for idiots.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
No need for name calling.

Several times I have already said to you that its not a great play design.

but last season it would have been so much worse, as the TE, RG and RT were bystanders on outside runs, and any and all yardage relied on the WR.

This is one play design out of many, and it still works in the right situation.
The rest of the outside run plays work very well.

You caught a fluke if thats the only play you saw, as many other teams had a variety of play calls.
 
kingj0n
offline
Link
 
those plays would have been better if your TE wasn't a weakling... Don't let your TE get pancaked everytime he's "trying" to block. Otherwise, he's not doing his job.

The OT and RG seen your TE blocking the guy....
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.