User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Blitzing is BROKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Page:
 
Shorteous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theboatist
Originally posted by Shorteous


On another note I thought bort posted that the substitution for the 34 would go like this:

Base- LOLB,LILB,RILB,ROLB
Nickle - LILB,RILB,ROLB
Dime - LILB,RILB
Quarter - I'm not sure but i'll go RILB

Instead the Sub goes
Nickle LOLB,MLB,ROLB - One (MLB) WTF, I have two there LILB RILB, So that's not filled in. The AI autofills a DE fort hat spot
Dime - MLB,ROLB,
Quarter - MLB

The only problem is redoing all my non base formations, not big but some FYI would have been nice.

But the blitzing is broken for sure.


if you have three line backers what do you call the middle one?
3-4 you always pull the inside backer first


the problem you raise is a valid symantic one. but when my base defense is 3-4

with LDE,NT,RDE
LOLB, LILB, RILB, ROLB

and I then swich to a 3-3-5

LDE,NT,RDE
it's fine if they call it the LOLB,MLB,ROLB as long as they don't pull the players from that spot. I didn't have anything in the MLB spot because my defense doesn't have a MLB it has a TED and MIKE. Call it MLB if you must but pull the player out of the RILB DC spot... not some DE because all my other DE's are used...

I've gone back and fixed it, I know have MLB and RILB that are the same person and they both show up on the profile page.. it's kinda funny.

NT Jason McGrumpy (Lv. 27)
LDE Travis Cook (Lv. 23)
RDE Ivan Affale (Lv. 24)
MLB Frank Urlacher (Lv. 27)
LOLB Sausage Mahoney (Lv. 24)
ROLB Sans Testicles (Lv. 24)
LILB uri heiman (Lv. 25)
RILB Frank Urlacher (Lv. 27)
CB1 Harry Chinko (Lv. 24)
CB2 Boris Yeltsin (Lv. 24)
FS Jiggle Tooth (Lv. 24)
SS jack mill (Lv. 23)

haha, sweatness 5 starting LB's.

You are right on the inside linbacker spot getting pulled, i concede that. but it should be the LOLB,RILB,ROLB DC wise - call the RILB MLB for all I car, I just want the players from that column.... i was just mostly saying for FYI benefit.
 
chrome
offline
Link
 
If the AI put the DE in there, that's GLB's way of telling you he's probably a better pass defender than your MLBs.

A couple of seasons ago I let the Auto-Sort pick our Kick and Punt Returners. Instead of the CB we'd been using, or any of the other positions you'd think it'd use, it put in a DE who was both fast and agile. Damned if he didn't get +10 yards/return.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Ive found the same problem. Im running 3-4 and all my settings are correct and fine, just trust me on that. Anyway, the new "play recognition" feature has broken blitzing. I'm telling certain LBs to blitz 100% of the time on various inputs that are 100%, and they never blitz, especially on pass plays (play recognition).

See, the inputs are working all fine. The formations and alignments I called are all working. But the blitzes are not. As soon as they see it's a pass, all the LBs/SS called to blitz stop and drop back. So always end up with only the 3 DL ever rushing the passer.

I dont care if theres a man loose, I want that player to blitz! If i want them to pick up the player I will tell the settings to NOT blitz.

The whole "play recognition" thing needs to be fixed in order to fix the blitzing problem.


It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.
 
theboatist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shorteous
Originally posted by theboatist

Originally posted by Shorteous



On another note I thought bort posted that the substitution for the 34 would go like this:

Base- LOLB,LILB,RILB,ROLB
Nickle - LILB,RILB,ROLB
Dime - LILB,RILB
Quarter - I'm not sure but i'll go RILB

Instead the Sub goes
Nickle LOLB,MLB,ROLB - One (MLB) WTF, I have two there LILB RILB, So that's not filled in. The AI autofills a DE fort hat spot
Dime - MLB,ROLB,
Quarter - MLB

The only problem is redoing all my non base formations, not big but some FYI would have been nice.

But the blitzing is broken for sure.


if you have three line backers what do you call the middle one?
3-4 you always pull the inside backer first


the problem you raise is a valid symantic one. but when my base defense is 3-4

with LDE,NT,RDE
LOLB, LILB, RILB, ROLB

and I then swich to a 3-3-5

LDE,NT,RDE
it's fine if they call it the LOLB,MLB,ROLB as long as they don't pull the players from that spot. I didn't have anything in the MLB spot because my defense doesn't have a MLB it has a TED and MIKE. Call it MLB if you must but pull the player out of the RILB DC spot... not some DE because all my other DE's are used...

I've gone back and fixed it, I know have MLB and RILB that are the same person and they both show up on the profile page.. it's kinda funny.

NT Jason McGrumpy (Lv. 27)
LDE Travis Cook (Lv. 23)
RDE Ivan Affale (Lv. 24)
MLB Frank Urlacher (Lv. 27)
LOLB Sausage Mahoney (Lv. 24)
ROLB Sans Testicles (Lv. 24)
LILB uri heiman (Lv. 25)
RILB Frank Urlacher (Lv. 27)
CB1 Harry Chinko (Lv. 24)
CB2 Boris Yeltsin (Lv. 24)
FS Jiggle Tooth (Lv. 24)
SS jack mill (Lv. 23)

haha, sweatness 5 starting LB's.

You are right on the inside linbacker spot getting pulled, i concede that. but it should be the LOLB,RILB,ROLB DC wise - call the RILB MLB for all I car, I just want the players from that column.... i was just mostly saying for FYI benefit.


i want it to go lolb lilb rolb
thankfuly bort lets us both win by using the mlb slot


i wish you could have a d-chart for each formation so i could have a rolb in 4-3 and a 3-4
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 11:40:24
 
Shorteous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by theboatist
Originally posted by Shorteous






i want it to go lolb lilb rolb
thankfuly bort lets us both win by using the mlb slot


i wish you could have a d-chart for each formation so i could have a rolb in 4-3 and a 3-4


hahaha yah!! for both winning, thanks bort..

I defenintly agree with your separate depth charts, but I want bort to take it a step further by allowing us to make as many depth charts as we want and save them. then in the ai screen you can have a drop down menu where you can select which depth chart you want to use for that output!!!! that'd be the greatest ever bort.


back on subject... bort the blitzing is broken.
 
theboatist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shorteous
Originally posted by theboatist

Originally posted by Shorteous







i want it to go lolb lilb rolb
thankfuly bort lets us both win by using the mlb slot


i wish you could have a d-chart for each formation so i could have a rolb in 4-3 and a 3-4


hahaha yah!! for both winning, thanks bort..

I defenintly agree with your separate depth charts, but I want bort to take it a step further by allowing us to make as many depth charts as we want and save them. then in the ai screen you can have a drop down menu where you can select which depth chart you want to use for that output!!!! that'd be the greatest ever bort.


back on subject... bort the blitzing is broken.


qft
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.


No, actually, it only changes the play call based on play recognition when it's a run and they player is set to go into coverage.

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.


No, actually, it only changes the play call based on play recognition when it's a run and they player is set to go into coverage.

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.


Well, they're talking about passing plays where they set people to blitz and they don't blitz. Those wouldn't be runs where they'd be looking to cut off the runner.
 
Shorteous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.


No, actually, it only changes the play call based on play recognition when it's a run and they player is set to go into coverage.

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=246384

my defense ran this play 70 % of the time in our base formation... I do not have this play anywhere. I also don't know why the LILB and RILB go towards the middle, it just makes huge running lanes for the RB. But once again I do not have a base play that doesn't blitz somebody. Also my output percent rarely get over 35% so I don't know why this pay was ran soo much.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 11:59:30
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shorteous
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Ken1


It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.


No, actually, it only changes the play call based on play recognition when it's a run and they player is set to go into coverage.

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=246384

my defense ran this play 70 % of the time in our base formation... I do not have this play anywhere. I also don't know why the LILB and RILB go towards the middle, it just makes huge running lanes for the RB. But once again I do not have a base play that doesn't blitz somebody. Also my output percent rarely get over 35% so I don't know why this pay was ran soo much.


I do not know what play that is but it is a very poorly designed cover 2 zone where they leave middle relatively unprotected.
 
Shorteous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Shorteous

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Ken1



It sounds like the sim is automatically assuming that if it's a pass play they don't want to blitz, when some blitzes are called intentionally as pass blitzes.

If a blitzer recognizes a pass play when he's blitzing, he should only stop blitzing if it's man coverage and his assigned man goes out for a pass. Otherwise, the sim should realize that maybe you wanted the guy to blitz as part of a pass rush.


No, actually, it only changes the play call based on play recognition when it's a run and they player is set to go into coverage.

I've been testing this recently and it seems to work on my test machine, but sometimes it looks as though players aren't blitzing (even though they are trying to) on run plays because they are positioning themselves to cut off the runner.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78565&pbp_id=246384

my defense ran this play 70 % of the time in our base formation... I do not have this play anywhere. I also don't know why the LILB and RILB go towards the middle, it just makes huge running lanes for the RB. But once again I do not have a base play that doesn't blitz somebody. Also my output percent rarely get over 35% so I don't know why this pay was ran soo much.


I do not know what play that is but it is a very poorly designed cover 2 zone where they leave middle relatively unprotected.


Interesting pickup on the zone, I think your right... but I don't have any zone plays except for my quarter output and prevent output
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I went with 50% zone and 50% man, inputs at 100%, certain LBs/SS blitzing 100%. None of them did. Maybe 1 or 2 plays out of the 90 in the game. Every pass play, no one blitzed as they were asssigned to.

Bottom line....there should be NO play recognition and all this type of thing. People's settings should live-die by their settings. If people want to blitz 100% at a certain position or whatever, let the code let them. If they're not being told to blitz then the play recognition can be used to allow them to man up or go into zone coverage or hunt down the RB.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:20:48
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I went with 50% zone and 50% man, inputs at 100%, certain LBs/SS blitzing 100%. None of them did. Maybe 1 or 2 plays out of the 90 in the game. Every pass play, no one blitzed as they were asssigned to.

Bottom line....there should be NO play recognition and all this type of thing. People's settings should live-die by their settings. If people want to blitz 100% at a certain position or whatever, let the code let them. If they're not being told to blitz then the play recognition can be used to allow them to man up or go into zone coverage or hunt down the RB.


I just looked through your inputs and I see what the problem most likely is - On 3-3-5 nickel, there's no ILB's, just OLB's and a MLB. It can't match 100% blitzing for a LILB if there isn't a LILB on the field. There's a reason I changed the formation names from 3-4 nickel, etc - because they didn't really make sense as to a what real formation would be.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
What about the OLBs and SS being asked to blitz 100% not doing so on pass plays?

What about base 3-4 where the ILBs are there and being told to blitz 100%, not blitzing.

There's still something broken with blitzing.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:44:39
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
What about the OLBs and SS being asked to blitz 100% not doing so on pass plays?


That should work assuming the inputs match the situation, as far as I can tell. For instance, I just set up an input/output on the test server to blitz all the CB's and the SS 100% on a quarter play against every offensive formation, anywhere on the field, and they blitzed every single time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.