User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
tsimp93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Yea this should be done because 90 yard field goals just made me laguh
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


I think the punting restriction is good. The FG restriction i'm not sure about...I thought the max FG distance was 63 beforehand?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Both of those sound reasonable. Just make sure people can keep going for it on 4th down, if that's their choice (even though some people will screw that up and end up never kicking).
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Bort

I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Both of those sound reasonable. Just make sure people can keep going for it on 4th down, if that's their choice (even though some people will screw that up and end up never kicking).


The main thing I'm thinking about is the punt one - it's come up several times where somebody's punt on 4th down is entered wrong and they punt every time they get the ball (on 1st down).
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
I did it for the entire second quarter.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=82555

It did not follow the input correctly. The only input there was to attempt FG if "Near Field Goal Range (10 Yards)". I set this to only occur in the second quarter. I did have the Ball Spot set to Any Spot and Any Spot, but figured Near Field Goal Range (10 Yards) would be specific enough. Also, I didn't set the Time Remaining field properly, so it should have been kicking on 1st down once it got within range (oversight on my part), but it shouldn't attempted from so far back.


Bort, do you think this is a result of the special circumstances not working? If he had it set to near FG range then it should have worked correctly right?
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Yeah, in my case, I still think everything was setup properly. At least in terms of FG distance. "Near Field Goal Range (10 yards)" should never attempt 90 yard FGs.

The safeguards seem like a nice idea, but that makes it sound like we set it up wrong to start. I don't think that is the case with mine, but I guess I could be wrong...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Bort


I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Both of those sound reasonable. Just make sure people can keep going for it on 4th down, if that's their choice (even though some people will screw that up and end up never kicking).


The main thing I'm thinking about is the punt one - it's come up several times where somebody's punt on 4th down is entered wrong and they punt every time they get the ball (on 1st down).


Yeah, I can't see any downside to making it so you can only punt on 4th down.

I hope that "special circumstances" are working right. The other posts suggest "Outside FG range [10 yds]" and the like may not be.
 
32mewelde32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


i think its alot more fun if you leave it so people's AI does what they tell it to =P
 
brentlewis
offline
Link
 
Maybe the within 10 yards was incorrectly being applied to the other team's endzone? As in the 10 yard line on either side of the field in which case this is a programming error and not the user's fault.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brentlewis
Maybe the within 10 yards was incorrectly being applied to the other team's endzone? As in the 10 yard line on either side of the field in which case this is a programming error and not the user's fault.


I'm pretty sure it's a programming error with the "outside range [X yards]." But you're right, that it could be what you describe as well.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Yeah, perhaps Any Spot and Any Spot still needs to be further defined, although it seems redundant. Not sure.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Ehh, I have a setting to punt on 1st down in the 4th quarter as a mercy-rule sort of thing, because generally (unless the competition is extremely significantly overmatched), in a minor blowout the offense gets way more snaps than the defense.
 
MrNFL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Bort


I'm thinking of putting in some safeguards to help protect owners from shooting themselves in the foot on AI's. Maybe never attempt a FG outside of 60 yds?

The other one that's come up is people having an input that says punt when outside of FG range but on downs 1-4 instead of just 4th down. I'm thinking I should just not allow punts on anything but 4th down.


Both of those sound reasonable. Just make sure people can keep going for it on 4th down, if that's their choice (even though some people will screw that up and end up never kicking).


The main thing I'm thinking about is the punt one - it's come up several times where somebody's punt on 4th down is entered wrong and they punt every time they get the ball (on 1st down).


I would choose 65 yards as the max field goal attempt, since the NFL long is 63, and a 65 yarder was made in preseason once. (Although Janikowski kicked a 64, and had PLENTY of distance, but clunked it off the upright!)
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.