Originally posted by tpaterniti
I don't know what to tell you man. I told Bort I would be starting level 1s and asked him if the team could move down for those very reasons and he said no. The reason I made the team the way it is is because I am a Star Trek fan and wanted a Star Trek themed team. It wasn't to cheat the system. I pay for my team/s (will be only 2 after this season down from 6 last season) like every one else and I think that if I want to make a themed team and start a new roster I should be able to do that.
I don't think anyone should have a problem with your motives here.
This team obviously isn't being built to compete. It's a player mine, pure and simple; however, you've absolute got every right to build and run it that way.
While it irks people in the league that we have a fluff team, I can also see the logic in Bort's decision. With thousands of teams in the mix, you can't treat every situation that pops up on a case-by-case basis. Moving down is probably a good thing for this team, but moving it sets precedent for the next team that wants to cut bait and rebuild.
If Bsby and I chose to gut the Hitmen and stock up with LVL1 players, we could absolutely use the same argument to get our team moved to a lower league ... and for what purpose, really? You've got rosters stocked with LVL19 players now in the A leagues, so the water's not going to be any more inviting there, for the most part. 277-0 games likely become 199-0 games, perhaps, but the end result is the same. Once word gets out that this has been done for one team, forty others that can't compete will immediately change the agenda and follow suit.
Even if it stays intact, the slow-building team of LVL1s isn't going to be competitive anywhere for a few seasons, whatever the league, so he might as well stay here and get demoted naturally. Sure it's an eyesore to some of you, but there's not a perfect mandate to take care of things when we have a league full of different agendas.
Say Bort decides to take the time to swap TPat's team with a suitable replacement. It works for our league in the short-term and makes things nice and pretty, until next week when the Leopards decide to throw in the towel, trade all the players for cash and sell back the team.
New owner has a roster full of CPU guys, and decides to stock his pond with LVL1 players.
Rinse and repeat.
It's not the best decision for this league, in this situation, but it's the best course to take if you're going to push a uniform policy. If the team sucks, it won't be here next season. If another team wants to try and tank their way into AA, as well, more power to them.
Try as you might, there are always going to be one or two teams that, for one reason or another, get turned completely upside down and can't compete in a league.
I'd prefer his team was moved to another league, but I completely understand why he's here.
It boils down to a simple NIMBY argument.