User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Give standard XP for playoff players
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MEPT72
Instead of rich getting richer how about rewarding those who did well enough to make the playoffs?


Yeah, they could enter a tournament where they have a chance to win a trophy!!!

Great idea. Only the people who were good enough to make it to the playoffs get a chance in this tournament though. I think that's important.
 
naki
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by naki

You forget that the teams that will benefit most will also move up to a tougher league.


No, the top teams have to be considered the most here if we're talking about the consequence and result from giving regular playoff XP.

The top teams will still be the pro league. Even more, there's a possibility of a champion not being able to be brought down from the championship league.

The teams that are trying to make it up to the pro league? Not as much of an issue here. The issue has to be the few top teams in all the pro leagues that will make it almost impossible for anyone else to ever "crack" them and their impervious shell of extra levels gained from playoffs.


A salary cap would mean they couldnt have everyone on the team and still be able to afford to train. Then there is the fact that players will be forced to retire. Those players will be force to retired a lot sooner.
Perhaps have the forced retirement be based on amount of games played. Yeah those teams will be in it and be tough to beat but they will end up in retirement sooner.
Its a tough thing to balance.
 
Keith Wheeler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by k2skier

just doesn't make sense if one wants this to be competitive for the long run...


Yeah, but k2skier wins because he's shown he's actually able to think about consequence and probability of future events.


so if its about winning (and I can tell you are into that due to your avatar pic) then you lost since I have looked into the consequences of it. That is why there is a mechanism where the two top teams move up a league and the two bottome feeders drop down. But to go and say that someone has a better "winning" arguement is totally bogus. If the intent of this game is parity then it should be a human ran teams/GMs only and no human players. That way they can maintain parity and see who really has the skill to compete as an owner. But, the fact is that when they added human generated players to the mix the dynamic was set to have this kind of discussion. Humans want more, plain and simple. It is not competative balance when those that couldn't make the playoffs get better rewards than those that do make it to the playoffs. Heck, this is like NCLB for simulations.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
We aren't talking about gaining extra levels in the playoffs. We are talking about a token amount of XP. It takes 1,000 xp to level up.

4 games X 50 xp = 200 xp or 1/5 of a level for starters that play in a championship game.
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 13:38:50
 
Link
 
Originally posted by k2skier


why should the successful/rich get richer, or why would one want to create a larger separation in talent/xp levels?

just doesn't make sense if one wants this to be competitive for the long run...


That is pretty dumb
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Search first, add your comment to an existing thread.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.