User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #2 > Scrimmage game BS
Page:
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by BP

If you plan to stick with the basic offensive and defensive tactics tools we've been using so far, that's cool..but I do think there are alot of stinker plays in there..and you could at least use the AI to weed those out. That's the bare minimum use for the AI.

I'd be more then happy to play the Pain in a couple of friendlies this year once that option is available, just so you can see what the IED is up to this year...


I didn't say that I planned to stick with anything. I'm well aware of what the basic AI does well, and what it flubs, and I have my ideas on how to remove the flubs and maximize what it does well. Those ideas will be proven right or wrong in the sim I suppose.

Regardless, I'm not familiar with any NFL playbook or offensive philosophy that doesn't allow me to specify offensive formations, pass routes, etc. Until that's in this game, the most you can accomplish is a Basic AI that makes fewer mistakes than it currently makes.

You're deluding yourself if you think you're doing anything more.

And I have no desire to play the IED in a friendly matchup. If we play, it will be in the Championship game.


I know you don't have a desire to play us....and you are ABLE TO SPECIFY FORMATIONS AND LENGTH OF PASS ROUTES..I didn't want to be mean about it, but you need to become familiar with the AI. You can specify situation and formation and length of route and primary receiver, you can specify what type of run you'd like (there are multiple options). You keep saying that you aren't able to even install any type of offense or defense because

1) You can't specify formations based on game situation and YOU CAN
2) You can't specify route and primary receiver based on situation YOU CAN (you can't call a button hook instead of an out pattern...but that is your big complaint?)
3) You can't decide who's in each package...YOU CAN, with the new WR/CB depth chart you can specify your WR1..and guess what, if you make no backup he's in EVERY PLAY!

You started to argue with me and I didn't want to make this point so sharply, but you aren't familiar enough with the AI..you need to spend some time with it and use some imagination and you can actually build an OFFENSE and DEFENSE that isn't a cookie cutter GLB one!! lol...are you sure you aren't my son? he likes to argue alot too..
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 17:01:58
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by avwjase
Originally posted by BP


IMO this league has been totally watered down this season...I count 11 squads who are either in a rebuilding stage or just straight out don't have the personell to compete on this level. We should have been able to pick our own scrimmages...


Well, us gutted teams have to play someone. I'm sure a lot of us would prefer to not be in this league, too. I know my team took a vote on moving down so we could rebuild and most of us were in favor of it. Then we're told by support we have to stay here. So, we're building for next season now and pretty much understand this year isn't a playoff season and never was going to be after a total reboot of the franchise. I understand you'd like to face good teams but it's not really the fault of the people cleaning up the messes that this is what you're left to face. Play your backups in those games if you're so worried about crushing them 255-0. If your backups execute the game plans well then obviously your better players would do just as well, no?



Nothing against the rebuilding teams...I mean, you wanted a team..you got one and had to rebuild, I understand. I'm sure it can't be a fun process to get hammered every week while you are trying to recruit talent. It is what it is, I would just like to play non-gutted teams in scrimmages.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
you are ABLE TO SPECIFY FORMATIONS AND LENGTH OF PASS ROUTES..I didn't want to be mean about it, but you need to become familiar with the AI.


Apparently you need to become familiar with NFL offenses that are more complicated than the leather helmet era.

What formation is "Pass"? How many WRs are on the field? How many TEs? Is it shotgun? Is there a HB on the play? Can I specify a two-TE passing formation? How do I make sure that my slot WR runs more fly patterns than curls? How do I send my possession WR on an 8-yard square in? How do I call a post pattern?

What formation is "Run Inside"? I-formation? Power-I? Strong I? Weak I? Pro Set? Can I run inside out of a four-wide single back formation to encourage the defense to go nickel or dime and spread the defenders out and to get my best players on the field?

All I can do is make a slightly more complex and less (or more) error-prone version of what the basic AI is already doing. If you think you're doing more than that, you're wrong.

The defensive AI gives you more because you can tailor the defense to a specific formation and/or set of circumstances - but that is a lot less useful when the offense has no control over the formation being called. Or at least it puts the offense at a severe disadvantage. If I can't control when I go to a 4-wide set, or what kind of plays I'm calling out of that formation - I'm at the mercy of you discovering tendencies that I can't control or eliminate.

But the offensive AI is more or less completely useless as it is. All you are going to is spend 800 hours crafting a custom game plan that more or less approximates what you could do in 2 minutes with the basic AI settings and default football logic in the sim.
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 17:44:17
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Um, I think we've gone far enough..you are missing an entire piece to the whole thing. If we debate this any further I might actually HELP you figure out how to create an offense...so that's no good.

You are completely right about everything, k? the Offensive AI is completely useless and cannot be used to create any type of unique strategy, furthermore it's not specific enough to be of any use to anyone. The Defensive AI is a little better, but still almost completely useless....I see the light.

Hey, good luck in season 4!
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Preseason games are meaningless and waste of time. Bort should just have left the option for the owners who wants to work on their tactics schedule scrimmages.
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
The offensive AI is obviously far from perfect, and should be upgraded. however, the fact is that it will help, and it will help a LOT more than the basic AI settings and general football logic. Anyone that has football knowledge and doesnt use the offense AI settings is putting themselves at a clear disadvantage

The defense AI is actually quite good, imo. If it works as I think it will (or should) than it will do exactly as its supposed too. They just need to raise the offensive AI capabilities up to the standard that the defense sets. This year will probably be a very low scoring year all around

It is obviously more beneficial to play against good teams in scrimmages, so that you can test out the settings and find tendencies in good teams. As Runningmn mentioned, though, I think these scrimmages have been set up to be more basic user friendly, to make sure that people arent punting on 1st down and what not.

basically, BP is at a slight disadvantage in that theres only 1 game that he should even look at his plays.
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 18:42:21
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
I think the lot of you are insane. There is nothing in the offensive AI that wouldn't be countered by even simplistic use of the defensive AI. You can't build misdirection with the offensive AI, which is what you would need to combat the defensive AI.

The offensive AI will go through your 8000 rules, and determine your formation. It will then randomly determine a play from that formation - thus making most of your work completely moot. Except that instead of the defense being at the mercy of the same random number generator, the defense can now key on formation and personnel and blow up your random play. There is no way to force the offense to run out of a 4WR set. You can't force a pass out of the goal line formation. I can't call play-action. I can't call draws. I can't call screens. All I can do is set up 385 rules, which when executed, will telegraph to the defense the correct personnel that they need to have on the field to stop it.

Without letting me pick formations and plays to run from those formations, you cannot outsmart the defense. Unless it's an accident from the random formation and play selection.

Now - all of this is perfectly fine with me. I'm playing a football sim that runs on a remote server. Once you take real-time play-calling out my hands, there's little point to giving me 0.01% of it back. Set some percentages and go play. You can spend your time coming up with complicated formulas and scenarios to arrive at the same percentages - that's cool if that's your bag. How many times do you think that you're going to be in 4th and 2 with less than 27.3 seconds left in the third quarter, down by 21.6 points between the opponents 41 and the opponents 40 yard line that you think a custom rule for that is worth the time and effort to construct?

I've got about 25 rules with about 50 possible actions to take. Of those rules, I expect that I might see 5 or 6 of those situations actually crop up in a game. But I've seen them before and I'd like to try and make sure that they are handled the way I want. Other than that - will I gain any advantage in creating a custom rule to handle 2nd and 8 from my 42 yard line with 6:09 left in the first quarter?

Especially when the end result is going to be the random number generator choosing my action (which I at least have some control over), then my formation (which I have no control over), then my actual play (which I have no control over) - THEN it tells the defense my formation and personnel (which I had no control over) so that the defense can respond SPECIFICALLY to those random choices? Please.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
I like the sound of that..I am the Insane BP....or the Notorious B Dot P....

whatever, I think the AI can be worked if you use a little imagination...
Last edited Jul 28, 2008 22:02:54
 
hellbound201
offline
Link
 
I'm concerned about the new blocking changes for run blocking. there were a few teams last season who were run first teams that were brutal. it will be crazy to see these teams with a buff. That concerns me more than the AI changes or scrimmage games.
 
wsdp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hellbound201
I'm concerned about the new blocking changes for run blocking. there were a few teams last season who were run first teams that were brutal. it will be crazy to see these teams with a buff. That concerns me more than the AI changes or scrimmage games.


Oh come on hell.. you know the run game needed a boost... it wasn't working quite right...
 
Jaxx
offline
Link
 
Well BP you have me for your first game so it should help you out and be a good testing game. I doubt I can beat your team since you have me on levels by at least 3 or 4 perposition but hopefully I can hang with you a little.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaxx
Well BP you have me for your first game so it should help you out and be a good testing game. I doubt I can beat your team since you have me on levels by at least 3 or 4 perposition but hopefully I can hang with you a little.


I always like our Matchups Jaxx...Mcgurkin is my favorite RB in the league, so going up against him is always fun to watch.
 
paraflux
offline
Link
 
I think a lot of the fun/competitiveness of this league went out the door when the stalkers and paladins quit.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by paraflux
I think a lot of the fun/competitiveness of this league went out the door when the stalkers and paladins quit.


Yeah, with only 4 playoff teams returning from last year, it definitely doesn't feel as absurdly difficult as it did coming into last season.
 
nrobert151
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by paraflux
I think a lot of the fun/competitiveness of this league went out the door when the stalkers and paladins quit.


I wouldn't look past teams like the Dolphins,First Order,The Thunder ect...
If you think were some cupcake team's then maybe look again.
It's a new season everybody has the same record.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.